Comments
Transcript
C。ncentrati。ns 。f G。 - GODAC Data Site -NUUNKUI
Concentrations of Gold and other Ore Metals in Volcanics Hosting the Pacmanus Seafloor Sulfide Deposit Roger MOSS*1 The sulfide deposit is the subject of an ongoing cite melt, whereas Zinc, appears to behave cobalt behaves compatibly, with Si02 in the dacites. A single sample lower Sb 0.17 ppm, and shows metal contents, suggesting similar metal contents as the dacites could produce hydrothermal Co 7 ppm, enriched in the da- a significant negative of basaltic andesite shows the volcan- metal contents of Zn 84 ppm, incompatibly, becoming S, As, Zn, Sb and Ba contents than the dacites. PACMANUS similar primitive mantle normalized whether precipitates. Average dacitic volcanics include Ba 318 ppm, Au 3 ppb. As 3 ppm, Key seafloor volcanogenic to the iimited data set of metals in seafloor volcanics, and to determine 18 ppm, and S 0.02%. A. BINNS*2 investigation with two principal aims : to ics could provide the metals found in the hydrothermal Cu Raymond metal content of volcanic rocks in the vicinity of the PACMANUS massive add Steven D. SCOTT*1 correaltion higher Au, Co and Cu and sulfides and dacites show that leaching of a source with the relative metal contents seen in the precipitates. words :PACMANUS, metal content,volcanics,dacite,volatiles ・ ■ * I Marine Geology Research Laboratory. Department * 2 CSIRO Division JAMSTEC J. Deep Sea Res・,13 i 1997! ■ ㎜ ㎜ ■ o f Geology, University o f Toronto o fExplol・ation and Milling 25 1. Introduction The PACMANUS Manus Basin (Fig. deposit cruise (Binns Binns et aI., 1996), & Flux volcanogenic PACMANUS ; Scott & massive venting, et al., 1996a, edifice known each with (up and and lower minimum Ridge, and is (Auzende was there has been much the likelihood of magmatic all of the metals to VMS ; Urabe & convincing discussion concerning fluids contributing some hydrothermal Murumo, 1995 ; Yang it remains et al.,1996). 1991 systems arguments ; de there are for such a process in some necessary to evaluate whether tent of the host (Urabe, ; Stanton, 1991 & Scott, 1996). Although or volcanic sequence cases, the metal con- is sufficient to resultant differences in tirely discarded. To date, there have been few studies etal. 1996). associated high with (45-63 °C) vent- observed et Both during al., 1996a). the The sulfides, iron-manganese oxide mounds (Binns et al., 1996). The and bacterial mat comprising Pual Ridge are dominated by da- Fig. 1 Simplified tectonic and bathymetric map of the Manus (modified from Benes et al.,1994). 2 58 the two produce crusts, volcanics between of precipitates include both zinc-rich and cop- massive levels, generally & Scott, 1993 ; Waters Recently, 1987 of a at deeper basaltic andesite is of the ridge, and to the north and south of the ridge Ronde, as Pual temperature water), cruise Manus- b). to 262 °C) venting (shimmering hydrothermal the lobate andesite and to the northeast. character precipitates (Binns ManusFlux active and occurring a different hydrothermal per-rich 6500" arms (Binns of at least four distinct sites activity and with smokers 1995; sulfide deposit. Since hydrothermal ing Binns, "Shinkai to be comprised temperature present I is a currently "Yokosuka" volcanic known mainland the PACMANUS lies near the bathymetric Y-shaped black Guinea Pillowed several cruises have visited the site, in- the 1995 of active 1993 PACMANUS cruise (Auzende now New in 1991, during Scott, initial discovery, cluding is situated in the eastern east of the Papua 1). Discovered seafloor cite with lesser rhyodacite a deposit before a leaching process can be en- the metal content of modern of seafloor volcanics (Keays & Fryer, 1994 Scott, 1976 Terashima examined modern ; Cawood and ; Doe, 1994 ; et al.,1994), and none of these studies have felsic volcanics. The attraction of studying seafloor volcanics lies in the fact that, if proper ly selected, they can represent the most pristine rocks as sociated with massive sulfide deposits, and give valuabl< information regarding hydrothermal Basin region, showing the evolution system. An of a magmatic investigation of the ore meta the location of the PACMANUS JAMSTEC deposit J. Deep Sea Res., 13 (1997) content of volcanic samples MANUS from the vicinity of the PAC- deposit was therefore undertaken limited a total acid digestion at Activation Laboratories Ltd, Ancaster, Ontario. data set of metals in seafloor volcanics, but in par- ticular, to investigate the concentration canics associated This to add to the lowing ongoing MANUS with a seafloor massive investigation an extensive of metals in volsulfide deposit. has included collection of dredged the analysis of samples from and other areas of eastern Manus et al.,1996a, b, 1997). ples collected during 2. Sample All samples "Shinkai we Basin (Moss report results for sam- the Manusflux Collection and Analysis submersible 6500" All but one of the samples lected Basin, as part used in this study were col in the vicinity of the four vent sites comprising the PACMANUS of Pual mafic deposit on the crest and eastern flank Ridge. The remaining basaltic andesite sample, from 299-R-01, lobate flows with is a glassy on the floor of a valley immediately east of Pual ridge, at 2134 m depth. A description of the samples 1. is given Dacite collected by the during the 1995 "Yokosu- cruise to the Manus Description rinds, outcropping cruise. used in this study were 6500" ka" "Shinkai Here PAC- 3. Sample in Table observed in outcrop consists of blocky that are lightly to moderately sedimented Large in some blocks of dacite observed flows (Photo 1). areas, appear to et al.,1996b). A series of five dives (297, 299, 301, 304 along on the top of the flow. In rafts that were carried hand specimen, the dacite is typically very fresh, has a & glassy of the Japan/France 305) were NUS New performed Starmer Program (Auzende in the vicinity of the PACMA- vent sites,of which three resulted in the collection of volcanic samples. In order changes cles appearance tend to minimize the effect of post-eruption in the gold content of the volcanics, used for analysis (cf. Connors et al.,1993). Gold al., 1996). sured free are neutron activation analysis (INAA) using 200 milligram ability, samples following of Stix (1992). Major cence the technique & sulfur by the LECO infrared spec- trometric technique, and Cu, Ag and Pb by ICP-MS JAMSTEC J. Deep Sea Res・, 13 (1997) variable vesicularity. Vesia result of flow, and Examination rare (Photo was 2). Such is essential to be used to draw either in magmas (Waters et of thin sections of dacite en- glass to be analyzed were are unaltered and glass, if results of the analyses conclusions or unaltered, regarding metal avail- in volcanic products. Gorton elements were analyzed by X-ray fluores- spectroscopy, elongated, of phenocrysts, and other trace elements were analyzed by instrumental shows distributed in the samples that the phenocrysts and to be homogeneously unaltered glassy volcanic rocks, selected by visual examination, were be fol 4. Results A totalof twelve samples of Pual Ridge volcanics from the vicinityof the PACMANUS vent siteshave 2 59 Table 2 Whole rock and selected trace element analyses of glassy volcanic rocks. been analyzed for gold and other ore metals (Table 2 With only one exception, ). a sample of basaltic andesite ゛alues that are similar to andesites (mean rhyolites (mean 2.7 ppm) 2.0 ppm) given by Stanton (1994). from the southern flank of Pual Ridge, the samples are Similarly・ antimony varies from 0.12 to 0.24 ppm and dacitic in composition. The barium content of the PAC- averages 0.17 ppm close to the average abundance in an- MANUS dacites ranges from 299 (basaltic andesite) 333 parts per million (ppm) and averages 318 ppm. This average is at the low end of the wide range of to 798 ppm (average 1994). desite of 0.2 ppm (Stanton, 8 0 t 23 PPm and averages 260 = 421) for dacitic lavas from modern island arcs (Stanton, varies from to Gold in the dacites 2 to 7 ppb (Fig. 2).No significant correla- tions are observed between gold and other trace metals less than the average of Stanton shows (1994). 1994). and Copper ranges from 18 ppm (Fig. 2 ) ・significantly 30 ppm for arc dacites given by Copper in the PACMANUS dacites a strong・ significant negative correlation with zinc (Table 3j。 The samples have an average zinc content of 84 ppm・ considered here・ nor are there any significant correla- greater than the mean zinc content o f arc dacites (59 tions between gold and the major elements Si, Fe and ppm), of MORB and arc Mg basalts of 84 ppm and 77 ppm respectively (Stanton, 26θ f Table 3). The dacites contain 2 t 0 3 ppm As. and closer to the mean values JAMSTEC J. Deep Sea Res., 13 (1997) Fig. 2 Frequency distributions of selected metals in PACMANUS volcanics.Shaded sample is basaltic andesite, the remain- der are dacite. 1994). The zinc content of the dacites is positively cor- related with Si(>2 (Fig. 3), but shows tive correlations with Fe2C>3, MgO, showing significant nega- Co and Cu. Besides a negative correlation with zinc, cobalt shows a significant negative correlation with SiO? (Fig. 3). and JAMSTEC J. Deep Sea Res., 13 (1997^ positive correlations with respect, the behaviour to that of zinc. The NUS arc dacites of 12 ppm and MgO. In this of cobalt in the dacites is opposite mean dacites is 7 ppm, FegO^ cobalt content approximately given by Stanton of the PACMA- half the mean (1994). for Sulfur in 261 Fig. 3 Scatter the dacites varies from average of 0.02%. served between here (Table No 0.01 to 0.04%, and gives an significant correlations are ob- sulfur and any of the metals considered 3). ent trace metal concentrations Au (15 ppb) and Cu (406) are significantly enriched in the basaltic andesite compared to the PACMANUS da- quite differ- than the dacite (see Fig. higher Au, Co and Cu and lower S, As, Zn, Sb and Ba contents. For this reason, and because it is only- one sample, the basaltic andesite was not included in cor262 relation calculations, nor in plots of metal content. Both cites. As expected, the basaltic andesite shows 2) having plots of selected metals against Si02. 5. Discussion Magmatic and hydrothermal processes known to affect the metal content of volcanic rocks include the following (Connors et al., 1993 JAMSTEC ; Doe, 1994 ; Togashi & J. Deep Sea Res., 13 (1997") Terashima, 1997) : concentration the degree magma of metal in the source of partial melting ; and crustal assimilc degassing of magma, hydrothermal and seawater this study of the original metal content could be lost Primitive mantle in press). Such alteration glassy volcanic rocks i: content of the volcanics, and allows an esti mate to be made With the exception here do of the metal content normalized S1O2, Fe2C>3 or MgO significant correlations (Table 3), suggesting plots of metal content potential source witl that, at leas plots for PACMANUS similar "negative" a relative enrichment Au, whereas rocks and should difference however of silver compared to Pb and a relative depletion (Fig. in the normalized Ag content be treated with caution, as the Ag value for PACMANUS The sulfides and da- slopes, but the dacites the sulfides show 4A). This of the magma of zinc and cobalt, the metals consi not show cites show show limits the effect of the post eruption processe on the metal for the dacite deposits from different districts(Barrie & Hannington, both pre- and syn-eruption; use of fresh unaltered dered melt, as much are useful for comparing tion; The be considered a minimum by pre-eruptive degassing. ; differentiation, mixing canics, should dacites is based on only one analysis. broadly parallel patterns of the dacites and the for these metals, there is littleeffect from differentiatioi sulfides are consistent with leaching of metals from processes. source ing Zinc, appears to behave incompatibly, show a significant positive correlation with Si02, and nega tive correlations with Fe203 and MgO. trast to the findings of Stanton the Solomon (1994) This (1994) is in con for felsic lavas o: Islands, but agrees with the findings of Dot for the behaviour of zinc in MORB. The strong positive correlations of cobalt with Fe2C>3 and MgO, strong negative anc correlations with Si02 and Zn indicate that cobalt is behaving compatibly None significant correlations with sul of the metals show fur, suggesting by that metal distribution is not controlled possible submicroscopic It has been deposits volcanic that the metal rocks (Franklin ; Barrie & Hannington, possible contributions the hydrothermal tions of melt Pual Ridge et al., 1981 inclusions andesite, and that a volatile phase the magma, and that the volatiles degassed of the magma (Yang has produced similar results (Yang, served among the metals Gold J. Deep precipitates (Moss et al., 1996b, 1997). In terms of ore metal content, dacites from the PACMANUS mon area are similar to arc volcanics from the SoloIslands (Fig. 4B), which previously is in agreement with the noted arc-like signature of Pual Ridge volcan- ics (Binns & Scott, 1993 ; Scott & Binns, 1995 ; Binns et Back arc basalts from the Japan Sea both show the Lau Basin and depletions in Zn relative by the PACMANUS and Solomon is a depletion in Cu relative to Zn, whereas canic suites considered show patIsland dacites the other vol- a general enrichment in Cu relative to zinc (Fig. 4B). from in on eruption of dacites Zn, in the obto partition here for the PACMANUS Sea Res., 13 (1997) in the hydrothermal volcanics. A distinctive feature of PACMANUS pers. comm.). is also known to provide the metal concentrations this is present reported previous tern showed into the volatile phase, and so concentrations metals, presented JAMSTEC was & Scott, 1996). Analysis volatile phase. strongly these were mechanism observed 6. Conclusions of vesicles in the andesitic shown and Fe calculations indicating the viability of a leaching with ; Doe, investiga- phenocrysts glass, have Cu mass balance is consistent to Au and Cu, in contrast to relatively flatAu-Zn-Cu volcanic fluid to are ignored. Recent in pyroxene conclusion in the those volcanics, and of a metal-rich system dacites. This from content of VMS in press). However, true only if metals are leached from with a similar metal content as the PACMANUS al., 1996b). sulfides. should reflect the metal content observed associated 1994 suggested in the dacite melt a of vol- The ore metal concentrations determined in unaltered glassy volcanic rocks from the vicinity of the PACMANUS deposit are considered to reflect minimum metal contents of the dacitic melt, due to the partitioning of many of these metals into a volatile phase. Only zinc and cobalt show any significant correlations with indices of differentiation Zinc behaves richment incompatibly, showing en- in the glass with increasing silicacontent in the 263 in the dacite glass. Primitive mantle normalized contents PACMANUS dacites show broadly similar patterns, although three to four orders of magnitude canics. The and metal hydrothermal of the precipitates the sulfides are enriched over the vol- similarity of the patterns indicates that leach- ing of a substrate with a metal the content similar to the da- cites, would provide right sulfides. The ore metal content of the dacite is most lar to that in arc volcanics although metal from the PACMANUS ratios the Solomon volcanics show for the simi- Islands, a distinct Cu depletion. Acknowledgments Co-Chief Urabe Scientists Jean-Marie are thanked Auzende for providing opportunity to participate cruise. We thank "Yokosuka" and RAB in the the captain and RM crew 6500" for their contribution to the success This research by grants Sciences and funded and Engineering the Bank of Toronto of Nova Doctoral Research Scotia to SDS, Fellowship 1995 of the R/V chief pilot and his team was with the ManusFlux and the "Shinkai and Tetsuro of the cruise. from the Natural Council of Canada and by University to RM. References Allan, J. F. and Gorton, Igneous In: M. P. (1992) rocks from Tamaki, liams, oi legs 127 and 128, Sea of Japan. K., Suyehiro, K., Allan, M., et al.,Proceedings Program, : Geochemistry J., McWil- of the Ocean Drilling Scientific Results, Vol. 127/128, pt. 2, 905. Auzende, Fig. 4 Plots of primitive mantle normalized metal content for (A) PACMANUS sulfides and dacites, and (B) PACMANUS dacites and other arc and back arc volcanics. Sources of data : PACMANUS sulfides Scott & Binns, 1995, Ag in PACMANUS dacites Binns & Scott, 1993, PACMANUS suite, decreasing any gests whereas cobalt as the silica content correlation ty (1996a) magmatic Basin : Submersible and (Papua Geophysics T. and Shipboard observation hydrothermal New of tectonic activity in the Manus Guinea). Meeting, Scientific Par Abst. Brisbane Western 1996, Pacific W115. dacites this study, Japan Sea Allan & Gorton, 1992, Lau Basin Cawood mon Islands Stanton, 1994. dacite J-M., Urabe, between & Fryer, 1994, Solo- behaves increases. sulfur and compatibly, The lack of the ore metals no sulfide or sulfate control on metal sug- distribution Auzende, J-M., Urabe, T. and Shipboard ty (1996b) : Cruise explores the Manus Basin. EOS, Barrie, C. T. and sification of VMS hydrothermal Trans, Hannington, M. D. : in press, Clas- deposits based : Processes JAMSTEC and Examples J. Deep vents of v. 77, 244. positions. In : Volcanic-Associated Deposits Scientific Par- on host rock comMassive Sulfide in Modern Sea Res., 13 ( and Ancient Settings, Reviews in Economic Geology. Benes, V., Scott, S. D. and Binns, R. A. (1994) : Tector ics of rift propagation western Woodlark into a continental margin Basin, Papua New Guinea. J. Ge Binns, R. A. and Scott, S. D. (1993) : Actively forminj polymetallic sulfide deposits associated with felsii volcanic rocks in the eastern Manus Econ, back-arc basin Geol., 88(8), 2226- Binns, R. A., Parr, J. M., Waters, J. C., Gemmell, J. B. Moss, R. M., Scott, S. D., Naka, J., Charlou, J-L Gena, K. and Herzig, P. M. (1996a) : Actively-form ing sulfide deposits at the PACMANUS mal field, Eastern Manus Guinea. Abst. Western Brisbane 1996, W115 hydrother Basin, Papua Pacific Geophysics New Meeting : A submarine andesite-rhyodacite line- age of arc affinity,Pual Ridge, eastern Manus arc basin, Papua New Pacific Geophysics Meeting, P. A. and abundances Guinea. Southwest Connors, back Westerr Brisbane 1996, W119. : Noble metal basin basalts (Lau Keays, R. R. and Scott, R. B. (1976) : Precious metals source rocks for gold mineralization.Economic Basin. ology. v. 71. 705-720. Moss, R., Scott, S. D. and Binns, R. A. (1996a) : Gold content of volcanic rocks around the PACMANUS Guinea. Abst. GAC/MAC gram Basin, Papua Annual with abstracts volume 21, A67. Moss, R., Scott, S. D. and Binns, R. A. (1996b) : Submarine volcanics of eastern Manus Basin : An enriched source of gold. Abst. Western Pacific Geophysics Meeting, Brisbane 1996, W-116. metal concentrations in PACMANUS hydrothermal precipitates and in the host volcanics : Implications for metal sources. Abst. GAC/MAC ing, abstract volume Scott, S. D. and Annual Meet- 22, A105. Binns, R. (1995) : Hydrothermal processes and contrasting styles of mineralization in the western Woodlark and eastern Manus basins Processes, L. M. Parson, C. L. Walker and D. R. Dixon : bearing on the behaviour of gold in magmat- (eds.), Geol. Soc. Spec. Publ. No. 87, 191- 207. Stanton, R. L. (1991) : Understanding volcanic massive sulfides-past,present and future. In :Hutchinson, v. 21, 937-940. R. W. and Grauch, R. I. (eds.) Historical Perspec- C. E. J. (1995) : Fluid chemistry and isotopic tives of Genetic Concepts and Case Histories of Fa- ic systems. Geology, characteristics of seafloor hydrothermal and associated VMS systems deposits : Potential for mag- mous Discoveries, Econ. Geol. Mono. J. F. H. (ed.) ford Monographs Magmas, Mineralogical 29, Oxford University Press, 391. Fluids Association and Ore Deposits, of Canada, Short Course Volume 23, on Geology and Geophysics No. Stix, J. and Gorton, M. P. (1992) : Trace element analysis of ten U. S. Geological Survey rock standards by 479 -510. Doe, B. R. (1994) : Zinc, copper, and lead in mid-ocean ridge basalts and the source rock control on Zn/Pb in deposits. Geochim. ocean-ridge hydrothermal Cosmochim. Acta, vol. 58, 2215 -2223. Frankiin, J., M.. 8, 82-95. Stanton, R. L. (1994) : Ore elements in Arc Lavas. Ox- matic contributions. In : Thompson, JAMSTEC Meeting, Pro- of the Ocean Drilling Pro- S. I. (1993) : Initialgold contents of silicicvolcanic (1981) New Vents and K. A., Noble, D. C., Bussey, S. D. and Weiss, de Ronde, deposit, eastern Manus of the western Pacific.In : Hydrothermal Scientific Results, vol. 135, 595-602. rocks Ge- J.,Parson, L., Al- Pacific). In : Hawkins, lan, J.,et al.,Proceedings gram, Abst. Fryer, B. J. (1994) in backarc Geology Publishing Company, Moss, R., Scott, S. D. and Binns, R. A. (1997) : Ore W-116. Binns, R. A., Waters, J. C., Carr, G. R. and Whitford, D J. (1996b) Economic Lancaster, 485-627. vms 2236. Cawood, Volume, Geology 75th Anniversary- in ocean ridge basalts: Implications for basalts as ophys. Res. v. 99, 4439-4455. Papua-New-Guinea, deposits. In : Economic Sangster, D. M. and : Volcanic-associated massive J. Deep Sea Res., 13 (1997) Lydon, J.W. sulfide neutron activation using a low flux reactor. Geostandards Newsletter, 16, 21-26. Terashima, S., Yuasa, M. and Nohara, M. (1994) : Gold content of submarine Ogasawara volcanic rocks from the Izu- (Bonin) Arc. Resource Geology, v. 44, 241 -247. 265 Togashi, S. and Terashima, S. (1997) : The behaviour submarine felsic volcanic rocks on Pual of gold in unaltered island arc tholeiitic rocks from Eastern Manus Izu-Oshima, Western Fuji, and Osoreyama Japan. Geochim. Cosmochim. volcanic areas, Acta, vol. 61, 543- 554. magmatic deposit modeling based on hydrothermal theory, Mining Geol. v. 37, Pacific Geophysics New Guinea. Abst. Meeting, Brisbane 1996, W-120. Yang, Urabe, T. (1987) : Kuroko Basin, Papua Ridge, K. and Scott, S. D. (1996) : Possible contribution of a metal-rich magmatic hydrothermal fluid to a sea-floor system. Nature, v. 383, 420-423. 159-176. Urabe, T. and Marumo, Kuroko-type K. (1991) : A new model for received 4, July 1997) deposits of Japan. Episodes, v. 14, 246-251. Waters, J. C., Binns, R. A. and Naka, J.: Morphology 266 (Manuscript (Notice) Photos are given on the following page. of JAMSTEC J. Deep Sea Res・, 13 (1997) Photo 1 PACMANUS Photo 2 Thin dacitein outcrop to the northwest of Roman Ruins, Dive 304. section of PACMANUS claciteshowing unaltered phenocrysts. Field of View 200 //M. JAMSTEC J. Deep Sea Res.,13<L997> nature of glass,and the presence of microlites,and 267