Comments
Transcript
1 2009.06.22 G・E・ムアとブルームズベリー・グループ:第一次大戦期へ
2009.06.22 đdĐdZ5$U_eZEW^eĒ=_eVĎãfË·Ä)'¯ä3¹0& Ù£xĈ¢¡ĉ [email protected] 'Éî U_eZEW^eĒ=_eV'ãfËgÛ·)'¯'±³ÞÓø3 GdEdZ5t Ö~Ö'$ðÑ/¿/&1$$-&ãfË·)'¯ä3¹0 $"U_eZEW^eĒ=_eVÞ%Z5tÖ~Öñý'»ÍÞYJbB\_3 ¿/&1 àßÑĈČĉ>bU^ICpn'Î×Ò$"'U_eZEW^ed=_eV àßÑĈčĉZ5tÖ'Õ)'üØ$"'U_eZEW^eĒ=_eV ČĊĆ'¸^W]_% Detachment ď ċĉ ÿâā&1 l½'lāÞjÏ$é÷'k(·¥ '±³3× +z1ď pnÞĆò ČĉU_eZEW^eĒ=_eVďĈÙ£ 2007ĉ U_eZEW^ed=_eV '«¶Ĉp $DJ6ecb$'znĉ U_eZEW^ed=_eV'Ü×(`E^eĒDJ6ecbi%0þc4PI @þÚKSeËc4eCN5ËÚ:7L^5b'l'v©abLb'U _eZEW^|?eLbĒD<:5&¨ ù 1904 ¦'y#1K8Se(>bU ^ICK^NJ6ed;`IC'pn[bRe ^IKbdDK`7He`M eLd9_T<]7cdW_$ïj0ÌúÁ¾Ð&Ą* "Ê%óĆ&! "öô1Ðn 3æ¶"1905 ¦'măKSe'Ðn 3Å Án $"ê#Āu1.&%02&c4PI@c4eCN5:7L^5 b{1.&% '=_eV'*0#1 >7bE(^IKbĒDK`7He/ XIUQ9D3/2Gb;bd =]bKĈ^IKb'$ĉ$!,ą#U_eZEW^e|&Ç" ç- "=]bK$w&ÅÁn&z¤1.&% ĈoGb;b( 1910 ¦čÃÆ&:7L^5bdDJ6ecb$²&ì $>7bE&Ý"1ĉ >7bE(U_eZEW^eĒ=_eV'±³Þå lāÞ%jÏ'°È$é ÷'k $´õ'Ôµ &Âć'qs3èđdĐdZ5'¼ $³"1 aC\edT]7c4PI@dW_3h®$"T]bDéíÓ&ë¬$«µ' ÀûÞ%«§ '3ár1FAbO/YDK}÷Î &ªĂ®3º 1 " ń`QWoDm^jTOfYQW/kPdpŎ\gD.ĸĬŅ kPdpŎ\gD/` QWijû.VNDm@ú#HbI¿Û.Ę©-7Ŀ?&(# ]ipaR_h p.VNDm/kpgoBOejp-9&(qļ§£=(< ĕqð°Úé-/Ê»=¯.ãµĝ8čIJzÔ«Ë@¦<u2 3®,ĠËĊÆÝ¢@ąİ}æ-Éx#ńÄå°ĢČ-(#M DmR-'(7QJViQJpZkTXįMDmR/ĠËĊÆÝ¢@ąİ (,Į;)<*@·ĩ(<Ņ 23¤þ?!(#88,ØĈ *ÚapX/Ô«Ë-ý%#Úwīzi[pXo]iTKŌÈ 247ō8ŋoŊo EFiR8ʼnoŋokjmQ@ÿÍ!#ń_i 1972:52f Ņ ï8PfmQWmď¥(<9-Lip^è(#Úõ*âø´ Ñ/Lip^.q¤$&#\GpQSp.Ē.ê ń1939Ņ-Ĥė=(<9Î?=< Ē/Ě¹Ċê@, Ē/Đ9Ē/4!A+Ĩ #4@cTWp*< "=)7Ē/ê.å}-Ą,?-/ , Ē/".tć.u)ğ.Ĕ@¶:,(/,:,.)< +: Ĝ<*-9 4 ç/zĊ,zľĿ)< ŇŇ),,; ň7ň),,< ĞÏ&(7yz.zľ.ľ-/ā*(Ô*ĭ·*; <.$ Ą(#6-/zìĎ·,7.);·¬<.$**- ("=-¹<ĩ/qĀĦ,=0,:,.)< zĊzľĿ/ {ä)/Ķġ=(< ]iPflĊ,Ĵ÷);)-ĺ-,&#Áđ,å}. ĻĂ$*ĥ:=("A,7./à((4"=9;7~âøĊ,Ĺ*věĵ@ß>*!&'=< Ē/.vě*.´)«¸@ģ<@ģ <*ķ:=#*-/«¸@ģ<õ@Þ%#*Î ·@ħ*ă}.ôv vě/Ö?Ðz,+)/,ºë7",<*/,$> $ă}.|.â øÅÕ-ó1=0"=2+×517.)/,*ēÂ-/áÞ- <.)< *?)ôvvě-/yÂŌ'4;s.y$ōrñ@9 qÂċ/ ¯î@Ĩ:);yÂċ/Ü@Ĩ:)< #$yÂ) sÂ7 ¨Ľ<ÌĤ/, ń\GpQSpĪıŁ¾ùãÃ110-114 łŅ ĕqð°Úé:Lip^*(.úü¼1920 À-ªÓ.#6.bclpiŎ Kg]ęÙ=# ņŅv,zĂ.ĄöÀ*Ĝ QUCpnm¸ James Fitzjames Stephen (1829-1894)[Leslie .][È 118 James Kenneth Stephen (1859-1892)[Fitzjames .ðĆĖĐĉŀ)ÝŃòíÂ.± Ï´Ñ Jack the Ripper ĈÒ][È 197 Leslie Stephen (1832-1904)[² Harriet .³ Anne ¡½ Harriet .òÇJulia 2 %|¯/] Vanessa Bell (nee Stephen, 1879-1961)[Julia ( Clive %íR.FryD.Grant] Thoby Stephen (1880-1906)[26 Ë(%öISF$Íl] Adeline Virginia Woolf (nee Stephen, 1882-1941) Adrian Stephen (1883-1948)[ædʺh)ċÒ&¦iòĊ '] T]cWGV\cb@]cU(i&X`Qc Roger Eliot Fry (1866-1934)[:X<¤»(ìç'¢´][s° 214] Desmond MacCarthy (1877-1952)[Ēą(d%#S[`Fºï(đĆČºÜ ď'][s° 231] Edward Morgan Forster (1879-1970)[Ēą(ëð'y2ºj$(úÀfÁó½ é(.9EUM(6^?C`N\6+][s° 237] Leonard Sidney Woolf (1880-1969)[Virginia %ív¬e(ÖØ$z®xĐĒÉ È(®'"#(âä5ÝûgÚ¿©5 1916 §'Ýû1918 §'8>\F áĒĉàÿå'"#(¸üÂ5r¹3Ē'ĄÕ][s° 241] Giles Lytton Strachey (1880-1932)[v¬e(ÖØ$z®5xĐßõ'Ñ a7? M\6Åo$ODZO\GW'}0Î5Ð*3][s° 239] Arthur Clive Heward Bell (1881-1964)[×÷êqª(Ï(ÆVanessa %í º,3%«',¦5 Ĕ1915ĕ5ú_`N`¥č1Ýã~5 1ø²Þz®¼5ÙăĈ$mÃw'±k] John Maynard Keynes (1883-1946)[L.StracheyD.Grant ùáćô5ý¶$ø²Þ z®¼5Ùă H`;`b@[`M%L7a7JNĜ<cPJM(ø²Þz®¼Ùă( ā(.'£][s° 243] Duncan James Corrowr Grant (1885-1978)[D.GarnettVanessa A8`G(£$ø ²Þz®¼āĈ$mÃw] David Garnett (1892-1981)[A8`G(£$ø²Þz®¼āĈ$mÃw] ęĕ¨"(Û Ô^G\c(a7?M\6ÅÞY[\GW1(þ¾%ĂÁ(f FK7ca`¡/Ď4!#A`T\JEs°n%(Ďt0qě W6[s° 229]uÖÖ(ē%)ě ĚĕÇ$Ā-3%T]cWGV\c(µ·5ĸ& $|ȹ3Ā- A`T\JEs°n(oî%(Ďĉ$T]cWGV\(ÌÞpñ5½3% ædʺ+(³è%(Ďĉ$W6uÖÖ(8`R?M({ 5½3% ĘĖs°n(Ì%T]cWGV\cĜ@]cU ĔLevy 1981L7cB` 1988F=L]F=c1987 5Óĕ ėĕs°nĔCambridge Apostles or Cambridge Conversazione Societyĕ 3 1820 º*Im^iRM©PmVMgmOpCkRM'ĉÉ:!ÿ³Gh^dmZq ,PmVMgmOEmHOViYT>+s$+CkRM7ÑoÙ*ë9ÈĴ)´Þ <Ĉ&IJ-:! çĮ§ÖÔ+¨+°Õ*z·Ķ+ij¸*ĺ18eUkqQq łŃy3v 7:!¤Ŀ*$&ĦÒ<ĥ2}+dmZq'é3:7!ľô'Âïù *öěؽ*¢'Ġé<(8å+Į+¤Ŀ<é3&7ĚÐ9(Êľ' Ė);:!Jq[qąĕ(Ł łKqU>m+(Ń<+ !VqNV9 (&õèĂ+ñó)8ä¹,Ģ37:)#!{ºø7'»Ĭ ª (&č<Ë$ $18ćĩ¢(&+ĺ18*)(* 9Ĩß<Ë$(Ģ37:9 ¾*)89ėď,Ē łembryosŃ(¡-:âÿ+´Þ(¢rē'+IJĎ <Ĉ!½*65¾+Ĩß<¿9łģò Ńí (¡-:9½Ę|$ +ĝĵ5İ*ĥ2t7:!ĦÒ,.&Đã łArkŃ(ÛÜ+VhmG* ®:!Ć«&94+4¶))ł¾ úā+Ø©+ĻķŃ ńŃ¾+æ þļ×+Ï+ĤÓ*$&ĜĦ9!3* 12 |+ĐđďÃÚď'ĺ1#!+' ¾ (Ā~7:!jZ?fqV+ČğďBWlqWp]>RSMAhj W(Edward Marlborough FitzGerald, 1809-1883)+¥Æ*6:-¾(ĭĀ, ©¯ĸò+dmZq'¯á+')ď 12 |& ¾(¡-:!(*óÝ&9 (ī.&9łU>qJm 1988:17Ń ıÀ£¯+ęì7|9,ü+k_j'ăý+ò <Ħ9Ċ<û¦! 94+*!+,½*EiNVÏüxċď*&Im^iRM*ñ£¯ÏÍ() 9eqiNłJohn Frederick Denison Maurice, 1805-1872, ¾ 30Ń'#!1!Î ê5ü*$&+¾'+ħĦ*¼Ľ<0!ÄƲ(&,KmLem(Jq jiRMÌ7:9KmLemxċ+¼Ľłî*"7)¬ÅķŃ*µ&, ¾ij'4ö#!±Ĺ*?FiN*9KmLemxċ+į*9 ¾4ð:!łMgqMphmDc¾ 57Ń üxċ*4Ç÷'8]A\=mx ċ*Ī%¾4!/ð'4!(-BiRGp`^Oaqc,¾'9 (U>qJm*6#&ûĢ:&9ł)U>qJm+iNV*6:-ÄƲ (&ŀNT>qnmpV@qjbm5GAmT>mpNEXq4¾'9Ń ÒĔî*ġ*µ9ķÁ4 19 wĄ-*,Ę7:96*)8ł1830 º*LA iq+ġ*,uıÀ+ 9 (ФĦ7:&9Ń1829 º*!4 ++ĦÒ×)(ñó' 30 º*Ĭ!TYNmłAlfred Tennyson, 1809-1892, ¾ 70, 1850 º*àġ|Ń,ġ|(&©É!½1855 º*<Ģ37: 4 À-¨ *,%(> [_So.ı-/Åã. É.í°Ü?(= É"$/nr]SAʼn6> "$nr]S.µAʼn6(æŀ.óÛ$AË?!.¤-*+7=",%(7 %"1*"$ŌH\hZUFDō-<?(>ëÁ-öğ?" ijIJ." 8.ijIJ-3>ī<? Ńý-×A"= ėēÿÓv²´-,> É9ă ? ]dSqPoXrjo^Ō É 53ō/ċĀ(ñB#*9<?(> ÍÒ./ 1830 À<ī<?" §/bj]_ZL,9.) µĨ*SKg oXlA%"./ ß°-×A(ĥĹ? ±éł.ĤA6(ĸ"GEk DfqRioVoŌ É 112 È GEkDfqOkr-Þō.ã* 19 wĘç < 20 wĘ.8#)%"Èģ-(ä9<7-ŊĚ,V^erAµķ "./kZ]oqS]mFYrŌ239ō*NFoTŌ243ō) jZUlŌ224ō-;? 0.{.yºîAÝ%(è ľØ.¥ù/ĐČ,ėēČ,ĵĶ <¶¬.Ėŋ-ĔĨ ÍÒ/"=7.**,%" ÍÒČ,Ļ½Ä7>sá) ©Í¯ÎŌeVR_rō.9Ēµ-ī<? !. ëĖ,ı.x)B,©/ò?(=7?(97@,*"%"œqŔq S[ErpoŌ É 197 œqŒqS[Erpoő118 .ðĈŐŕqS[Erpo.ĆŐp C`ZP:pCrR_D.*ō)%"Ç/ 1892 À-ėēĊŅ)Ùʼn.ç-}, %(> =ĪRgZL.ĉÏ<?(>s)9> ).Į·,.Mlrb-;>üÑ*Ăč-¥'ďĄ.ĺô ŌQRGE ZLō*â¿ą÷*.7=.Ľ< 19 wĘ<Ō!<Io] ±.ÆŇ)ō -ł@>9.Aµ£ ŌRealityō*2 !?-¸.¦ĿAăĴČ ŌPhenomenalō *4ġÔą7?""*0 dLWJr]/Ĝ®>*AăĴČ,«A> *B)" ú·,ÌÃ*~.kDl*w.ăĴČâ¿.łA+Ģ >/ É-*%(ä9ø,¡ň)%"ŌQRGEZLĄ±.áõ.å ,µķĄÍ.{ÍĄČ¼yĠ*yĠ*{&.Ď|-āĕ "àČ,Ą±ĄIJČ-Õ=ĕ$>**9!<.¡ň.ÂŁĞ t->*Ģ<?>ō ŏŎ»ÚalrfTckr.āĦÍ ĝ-;>ę.ïª÷.Ħć ¹.đ É/ NoakZR§.þ´.ImZR.ìÕń´ ļ¢áõ9s´ ĝ¦.¾Č,ěfD.³ß ņÖŌÖō Ĭĭħĩ5.łÊ É/fD-¸(9Öz-¸(9īį/í Ĭĭħĩ5.ûłÊ u *= fD*ņÖŌÖō*.łĻAxÊ- BB .ÌÐAêİ 5 ʼnņ\B}ð¢&ĀfÞÄ1+»āJDbO+ľ¯Ðr@Å;) ŇŅdetachment?JDbO8NT`DQe+\Bðė)#$+]RP_+¾ JbV^RM)$JDbO&^RTbdNT`DQe, )ú+kr9;7Ąá h+kr)$<+¯ĵ)ăù+Ł,łõö)?"?=?=+kr wê&$cCHT^BÖ+pĵ "+)©µ:,FUaeUÖ+pĵ%< ?=?=+kr,Êã8čó(ĚĞ)9<û°<īà@{$č{=- đ+ƪČ)(<&@ÕA 7=(+l+ĝ.&;&$đ :¡þ<&@Õ57+,("JDbO&^RTb+kr,Y^LSpz î&+Ė¨(Ķ?;@«7ÕA%(5>µ:,¹9Ïķ%#>( :ĻĬñå@ĩ<&@Õ4ńthe goodŅ&,·@ĆA ö)ě6& ċ7+ F^eTn@½ë &ċ$+ËĜ@µ:,3"i²)7ŋdŊd\B &ċč!\B+± %<&ĘJDbO,¾IJď Ï+{Ù%²Ð+µ:\B@Ģĉ$&)/=:),\B+ðĞ+ İ@éĕ!%"&7ħ2$<\B,Į¸)<2è@$ ÔÝöćf+ðĞ@ò<&%@øs:ĭĽfĪ+½ëö(÷ĵ)9"$Ü Ã=<&ċ<ĔÎ@Ĩ$\B+± @čü$Č!,µ+ Ë++~Ŀ@ĔĐ&µ+}ð¢@7"0"¢Û+ÁmĊ)ġ6$ 3"+%<ńRosenbaum 1975: 403Ņ ňŅJDbO+¾ úJbV^RM¢)¢+, 1902 ¯+[GF_ZN¢×10 Ó 1 ÏŌ% ;+Āf¢¯+ą?;),\B+}ð¢ð í=$<?=?= )&"$+Ñî+j´ŀ&í+¶)Ē(?=ĠĞ&,â¤ö)ıē(7 +%"²Ð³Ã=7++ÁÎ?=?=+İ)´ŀ +H]VV_e\OX^edI_eW)ļ¼@j?=?=@İ:ĹĈ $²+7+%"?=?=\B:Å)=7+,µ?=?=+ )®7++v%,("µ,ìģ@Í+̬+g)+$, 7fÎ+ģ,LMECRH8XbK\æ+ęĂ(?!ßĒ)Ķ<fĎä +()ý"ĥA%}ð¢ð +(),?=?=+Ķ¹@7¿( fÿĀoÿ"?=?=,?-\B+£ËĀÿ+öx| Ğ@§=µ+Į¸Āoÿ+¥ĤöĮ¸@Ç$+%<='> ¥ĺ?=?=+ÀĔ%,µ+£Ë+Òè+.&#,£ËĮ¸@ºē&(& <& À >)"ù,?=?=+Ĵijö(kô+İ)uA% ğ+ïÂ&@Ē(&¥Ĥ}ð&+ĵ),3;¨È(Ķy,(" ?=?=+Á%,¥ĺ,¶ČČ@¦<ĸ:"ØÚ+£Ë &7+,Ħr+øsöq@<Ét£Ë&,į#*)Ńç(7+ 6 )&##2@>=>=.uWcFS©)&(w7_fp7`.+ .1*'-x(6Ô~?®!WÍÀ(#**"=?tW-®( < Û¾.TGXF¨.f¿¦112-115 ÖBAV§s-< k-' (.|* k*-'(.lÊ©±.IÕ-'(.ÚÜ ÝÜG. E. Moore, Principia Ethica (1903) ähttp://fair-use.org/g-e-moore/principia-ethica/å { Preface .ª©V§s´<3J'.j.y] +.9,°Ù.6."=½O.#5-rm 3,.ßÛYm©, “being good”Ü «Ä©ÞÆ6cÆ6),½,°Ù.V§©¬§ >=>=/+.9,°Ù.Á¤?Á,3,.ßÛ¢©, “doing good”Ü ¯s©±-9&(Æ*cÆd¼,Á¤.·-'(.,l©¬§ ³D² V§s.HØ à ¯s©,V§s/<HÈ-'(.k goodnessÛ</ badnessÜ ?5<V§©\?±.xÌ* < á KV§s/V§©\.ÎÈ)<k goodness k good*/P *jØ6±.xÌ*(<$·Ê:0.k good*,P ?v¹ <*/Ed¼)<*.6v¹*/Â.ö)=#ºxÌ .[.*?g(<k/".bµ8-[Ed¼)<:v¹ <*6Ed¼$**-,< Û=-x-.ÎÈ?L=(<k6 . the good/ v¹Þ[d¼)<Ü.9-k/v¹Ed¼)<-6Ô >:!00k?K.P-9&(v¹9*Ç4Á,>=(# .9-K.P?%Z *-9&(k?v¹9* <É;?½¥H¹© ÉËÛthe naturalistic fallacyÜ*h2 â PV§©-k*\=<./ .J'.oe)<1*'/".P "=½O)koe);61*'/".P K."=½O)k P.ª©.#5.¢*(lÊ©-koe)<}»/¢*(k -Ñ,^»/"=½O.#5-k "=½O-(k*g)Y m©RU intrinsic value?'Ym©RU/K.iØ:Ê <*6Æ 6Ed¼$*£-(«Ä©,6.)<=-x¢©RU/ lÊ©-ÆCcÆd¼)<Å =0/k.·?NÁ¤.lÊ© Ò *¯s©,±d¼,×n)< ã V§s.xÌ*,<6./Â.k6.¸4e&#© organicWO );"-/Ym©RU*¢©RU.l©ÏÓ¸4e&(< ³J² ½¥H¹©V§sÛ½¥H¹©ÉË".DÜ Mq.½¥©¡z,P-Q(k?v¹ 7 <ÐaÊV§s ÇEÆ «KÐøÕ´Kмáã(Bù Õ´¼¼&>¨$"v>Ð:«KмfeKÐ ÇwÆ ÒF¼\· çÛ¼~z(Ð'X"v>Ð:?DA\· ÇOÆ ×³$(ñê':\·ø®¼Y[(y§â¼ÁÄúè¼\·ù %(7&׳>&.$u)v̧>483(®$" nÔ&9v׳)V$u$ÈY#9®'!"(y§â¼&u >T4(#:®¼Y['!"(!(Ìâ׳(Ðg)Õ &4( #)&øÌ'!"(y§â¼Ñ '7 ";:ù(#¾ÜKÐ)á9# :86:{o'"ì,:."(׳(J#%(׳_U(̧>¢v' :$$>ß :$) 8'HnÔ#: "j&s#( =;=;(Ðg>Úc$)#&&8=;=;ì,&׳ (J#%;¢v(̧>48$$>Â$)nÔ4;&\· &"$&:$)μ&Ðg>¯:$#)&:µ° (G#ì,:!(ìÓ(J#%;¢4v̧>48>Â$ #: ÇaÆ ·øbz¼Y[(ÁÄv$)V>uC@\·ù Ù(v4(Í1o £¬¼ organic_U(J8®¼Y[(y§¼ êî$éZ¼&\·>l9òËÊ&bz¼Y[>c:μÅh( ±¼&¶å¼Iº(ÝU$WS$z¼Iº(õ¶û "(μÅhøabsolute isolationù$±>¸"á9>x í:&8*ÝÉ.uô)\·'!"(âM8L¤;:794): '¡#:7'=;:=;=;(Àä$^(k-9'"ö& ¢÷(Y[> ":4():ä(µøcertain states of consciousnessù# 9} 0& Þ > ;* ; )Rð ¼& P²( «$ Ï å (Qm øthe pleasures of human intercourse and the enjoyment of beautiful objectsù'/&8& (u>Õ8'q$(:+$&8*8;+$9$"R©¼& øaffectionù$ÖØ5Õ´':Ï4((ïæ$;ÕU#v$$' »>2$)&<0VËÊ';ÕU(3(Y[>!$ $>j'Ñ{o'&'d(4((N!'r0;:4($pÈ']}&Y[ >!&%$$$>Ñ:+$:$4&ó(iË&¿·) IºJ#à38;":$Þ "7;0#à38;"& ();ë t(Ī¼!¨¥¼&¿·$$#:&=`¼:)ü&Ðg >×&$$;:()8;;8N!(3'¦#: |(R©¼&$Ï(Qm~z:$>½¼$"×&=;:{o'8 ;:$$(N!(~z·¹#:$$;8N!(ÙoU( 8 àÀĝč=ó¸+1.8/x#qľ0Ĝð0öû.ąßüá,āu0 ĵä0f0ğîD²À*A,,B?0þö1ĞĶB&+'$ >/¼CBA ŇChapter 6, 113ň ŋňÌyû.8,; ö 1Úû.¢ēDÆ:0 û}/(*0ýġDü û.ö ,¢ēĕ.<00Âæû}DÛĩû/ÿą!Aö 0n( /BA Đ¥ûĆ/)ýġ/>B2ĎŅû.Ò«jø0ÛĩûĴļ/çBA ,0.ČĊ/*Õņ0 û}1qľûoë,Ē¥Ĭ0p+A Ōʼn\F,ćfâÁ40»ĉ ŊňKGcO0ę¹û´Æ÷Ĩ,Ī0Ďíûªď VbQT 1967(1951)Ħ/¥!ANJR`NJe1992(1983)0Ä dVbQTōę¹û´Æ÷Ĩ0m£DĤ ĚÒ0¼¾²À, DİĠ dNJR`NJeōĪ0Ďíûªď/ėA 1910 ¬s0¼¾²ÀDĺĠ NJR`NJeĦō¼,£Į0\FûÑDÄû/đÅ$KGcO Ze`daWe1µ0Ô$\F0vģ\F,KcY_QMz·u 0k+¶¬0 KGcO0\FÄõ£jø?0ijķDã±!Aìě.īĩ%/¥* \Fö 0āuûŁD°ħ!A^QP`=aUeTdH`X>@<<',Ķï.ĩ īD§Ľ$z·$&ö ö?µ?0ĘD®ĸ%#B1è *#0×Ë|!A!5*+1.'$D¤B$,m£1µ0ĞĢ/>B 2\Fµ?/7$³Ń<'$3'$ Ħû.<0+1.qÞû. <0+'$,DĀ*A\Flē1 /AqÞ¨Ç0{%'$ KGcO0ĚÒ0Ø1ö ö0 û ¤0ܹ,16,E-C @DÊ'*.aWe1KGcO\F0l¯0ĩöŁ+0¿ē/êü. '$,IJ5Óú.ĥ@Dô*AKGcOĖį~Ö*$ö ö1 ĻĈ/>AÔı9+fÙ+@#B?1l,*0¢ēhĕ½D;AŀĢ .ù/Ŀ!A<0%'$aWe18$[eL]`d^GY^_e/åB$0 ń=©lē0ń= ö öËĭ$#0r0 ûńDÃ'$KGc O0ĩÐ,ÂĄDĞ*.^QP`H`X#*YaGNHIGS1\F0 ö !.C&¡Ïāu/CAĜðDºòû/w,DĦ>,$0 +@#0ÉĢĹ/>@KGcO¶¬ĎíÍł/¦¹$ÝÈDËĀ$ 0Ĕ1\Fög0,Îéû.ĎíûăĂ,0ľ/ĩöû(.@Di *.'$,è¢û.ܹDñĠ*8'*A$,2ĎíûăĂ1Ó? /ög0, +1.#*\F0l¯/1ĎíûăĂög00ºĝ Øt+A,DĀ!>. ¤1.0n(DĿĴ"A,1\F0xċ 9 .¡<.ęíwµ,;&(È<?-0+<+iTPk*Ek^/¿xAĢ $=×ÙwüA97!#=>*ďĨ,ãº,Á%Ę6*)#* =,(ì8+ĕÏ,8ě¹ĉ,ħ&(#.*ªĖ ě¹,(4)8°Ēí+ě¹,¸&#*·<AdB£þ,v¡?# zä,#.)>LDmO/°,<:>öA>*+í AęÚ#*½)dBí )=ú#·Āė/Û(í ęÚ.qÎ)°Ēí+ªĖé,¸dBwüþ)+&#,8ġ@< īNHWk NHp: 236-239Ĭ ĥ²LDmO,>dBªĖéī;=ïª+ÍAr3°ĒAĝćĬ.« oFYcmYo[pJ.ÉÜ¥Ď ī1904Ĭı *?>³ñ .Ò¢* ĉà2.Ī".åÝr)r>Ò8ĠĜ.®+Í*(.}ù9°Ē oé¥ģý ī190507_09Ĭı»´é¥*/,ąá.ÖÄ *+>[ï< probability AªĖé¥AÇ oïçĐ ī1906-141921ĬıĨĠ.ăâíġ.ĊÏ ¶ČåÝr)>ąáăâí,~øÔ,'(.ïª+îĒ ođ.÷ßí¯øī1919ĬıYDU.ÈÂÿAý¾+)Ĕğĩī1320 c kJ ¶Ð.YDU. GNP20 ²ĬA©7#\jđÓö,¬>÷ߥíĉà<. à İĭ61,(_kpdOajpoKkp`,>lpVCíĨ ĮĬlpVCíĨıjSfpYolpVCĥ²Ð{,Ă¼#Ğê.Ą ī¦¨í+ û2.ġºĬ*XlUHp īð|íØü.ªèĬ.ĐéíġlpVCĀė/uþ. ġĚA©í,Å ò Ħ ,>të.ēóAč>#7.nGHf]gijp. ÆÚībNXeRZOdĬ* Ħ ,>ÉÜío÷ßí+Øü.ęÚA=Ĥ bNXeRmo_kMhBojaijOd A> įĬLDmOĆ#dBé¥,>§Ê *ě¹ .sĚú _kpdOajpí±Đ.Õº/^GpNQp.zí+éLDmO.÷ß Éô ÌæqĈ Bell, Quentin 1968. Bloomsbury, Weidenfeld & Nicolson.īÞˤċ_kpdOaj poKkp`ytõDIjNÌ.îíāº5 ÑÀ, 1972Ĭ. Rosenbaum, S.P., ed. 1983. Bloomsbury Group Reader, Blackwell. Johnstone, 1963. The Bloomsbury Group, 1963. Lang, Berel 1964. Intuition in Bloomsbury, Journal of the History of Ideas,25. Levy, Paul 1981. G. E. Moore and the Cambridge Apostles. 10 Regan, Tom 1986. Bloomsbury's Prophet: G.E. Moore and the Development of His Moral Philosophy, Temple University Press. Rosenbaum, ed., The Bloomsbury Group, Croom Helm, D[FA; 2007#-2'%,21-2$?d5ePU,>C8c ,>C1KL6;^a_ -2*/1( 21/ f<TJ 1883-1920iI1IIj VYbZO@_ 2//#,,2QN_ W=` 1989#-2'%,21-2$4B:g_ H79h 2007/ /#,]3\&!-0RM .2,%+-1)2" GSEXRI 11