...

1 2009.06.22 G・E・ムアとブルームズベリー・グループ:第一次大戦期へ

by user

on
Category: Documents
9

views

Report

Comments

Transcript

1 2009.06.22 G・E・ムアとブルームズベリー・グループ:第一次大戦期へ
2009.06.22
đdĐdZ5$U_eZEW^eĒ=_eVĎãfˏ·Ä)'¯ä3¹0&
ŸÙ£xĈ¢¡–ĉ
[email protected]
Œ„'Éî
U_eZEW^eĒ=_eV'ãfËgۏ·)'ž¯'±³ÞÓø3 GdEdZ5t
֖~Ö'‚œ$ðÑ/¿/&1$$-&ãfˏ·)'¯ä3¹0
$"U_eZEW^eĒ=_eVÞ%Z5t֖~Öñý'»ÍÞYJbB\_3
¿/&1
àßÑĈČĉ>bU^ICp­n'Î×Ò$"'U_eZEW^ed=_eV
àßÑĈčĉZ5t֖'՚)'üØ$"'U_eZEW^eĒ=_eV
ČĊ†Ć'¸Š^W]_% Detachment ď
ċĉ
ÿâā&1 l½'lāÞjÏ$éž÷'k‚(€·¥…'±³3×
+z1ď
p­nކĆò™
ČĉU_eZEW^eĒ=_eVďĈŸÙ£ 2007ĉ
U_eZEW^ed=_eV
'«¶Ĉp­
$DJ6ecb›$”'znĉ
U_eZEW^ed=_eV'Ü×(`E^eĒDJ6ecbi%0þc4PI
@þÚKSeːc4eCN5ËÚ:7L^5b'‡l'’‘v©abLb'U
_eZEW^‹|?eLbĒD<:5&¨
ù 1904 ¦'y#1K8Se(>bU
^ICK^NJ6ed;`IC'p­n[bRe
^IKbdDK`7He`M
eLd9_T<]7cdW_$ïj0Ìú‰Á¾ÐŽ&Ą*
"Ê%óĆ&!
"öô1Ўn
3æ¶"1905 ¦'măKSe'Ўn
3Å
Án
$"ê—#Āu1.&%02&c4PI@c4eCN5:7L^5
b{1.&%
'=_eV'“*0#1
>7bE(^IKbĒDK`7He/
XIUQ9D3/2Gb;bd
=]bKĈ^IKb'$ĉ$!“,ą#U_eZEW^e‹|&ƒÇ"
ç-
"=]bK$w&ÅÁn&z¤1.&%
ĈoGb;b( 1910
¦čÃÆ&:7L^5bdDJ6ecb$²&ì
$>7bE&„Ý"1ĉ
>7bE(U_eZEW^eĒ=_eV'±³Þå
lāÞ%jÏ'°È$é
ž÷'k‚
$´õ'Ôµ
&Âć'qs3èđdĐdZ5'˜¼
$ˆ³"1
aC\edT]7c4PI@dW_3h®$"T]bDéíÓ&ë¬$«µ'
ÀûÞ%«§
'•Š3ár1FAbO/YDK}÷Î
&ªĂ®3º
1
"
ń`QWoDm^jTOfYQW/kPdpŎ\gD.ĸĬŅ
kPdpŎ\gD/`
QWšijû.VNDm@ú#HbI¿Û.Ę©-7Ŀ?&(#
]ipaR_h
p.VNDm/kpgoBOejp-9&(qļ§£™=(<
ĕqð°Úé-/ʍ“»Š=¯.ãµĝ8čIJzÔ«Ë@¦<u2
3€®,ĠËĊÆÝ¢@ąİ}攇-Éx#ńÄå°ĢČ-˜—(#M
DmR-'(7QJViQJpZkTXįMDmR/ĠËĊÆÝ¢@ąİ
(,Į;)<*@·ĩ(<Ņ
23‹¤þ?!(#Ž88,ØĈ
*›ÚapX/Ô«Ë-ý%#Úwīzi[pXo]iTKŌÈ 247ō8ŋoŊo
EFiR8ʼnoŋokjmQ@ÿÍ!#ń_i 1972:52f Ņ
ïŸ8PfmQWmď¥(<9-Lip^Œè(#›Úõ*âø´
Ñ/Lip^.q¤$&#\GpQSp.Ē.ƒê
ń1939Ņ-Ĥė=(<9Î?=<
Ē/Ě¹Ċƒê@ƒ,
Ē/Đ9Ē/ƒ4!A+Ĩ
#4@cTWp*<
"=)7Ē/ƒê.å}-Ą,?-/
,
Ē/".tć.u)ğ.Ĕ­@¶:,(/,:,.)<
+:
Ĝ<*-9
4
ç‘/„zĊ,zľĿ‚)<
ŇŇ),,;
ň7ň),,< ĞÏ&(7yz.zľ.ľ-/ā*(Ô*ĭ·*;
<.$
Ą(#6-/zìĎ·,7.);·¬<.$**-
("=-¹<žĩ/qĀĦ,=0,:,.)<
„zĊzľĿ‚/
{ä)/Ķġ=(<
]iPflĊ,Ĵ÷);)-ĺœ-,&#Áđ,å}.
ĻĂ$*ĥ:=("A,7./à((4"=9;7~âøĊ,Ŗ*věĵ@ß>*!&'=<
Ē/.vě*.´)«¸@ģ<@ģ
<*ķ:=#*-/«¸@ģ<•õ@Þ%#*Î
·@ħ*ă}.ôv
vě/Ö?Ðz,+)/,ºë7",<*/,$>
$ă}.|.â
øÅÕ-ó1=0"=2+×517.)/,*ēÂ-/áÞ-…<.)<
*?)ôvvě-/yÂŌ'4;s.y$ōrñ@9
qÂċ/
¯î“@Ĩ:);yÂċ/ܒ@Ĩ:)<
#$yÂ)‰
sÂ7
¨Ľ<ÌĤ/,
ń\GpQSpĪıŁ¾ùãÃ110-114 łŅ
ĕqð°Úé:Lip^*(.ú–ü¼1920 À-ªÓ.#6.bclpiŎ
Kg]ęÙ=#
ņŅv,zĂ.ĄöÀ*†Ĝ
QUCpnm¸
James Fitzjames Stephen (1829-1894)[Leslie .ˆ][È 118
James Kenneth Stephen (1859-1892)[Fitzjames .ðĆĖĐĉŀ)ÝŃòíÂ.±
Ï´Ñ
Jack the Ripper ĈÒ][È 197
Leslie Stephen (1832-1904)[‘² Harriet .³ Anne ¡½
Harriet .òÇJulia
2
%|¯/]
Vanessa Bell (nee Stephen, 1879-1961)[Julia (œ Clive %íR.FryD.Grant]
Thoby Stephen (1880-1906)[26 Ë(%öISF$Íl]
Adeline Virginia Woolf (nee Stephen, 1882-1941)
Adrian Stephen (1883-1948)[ædʙºh)ċÒ&¦iòĊ…'Šƒ]
T]cWGV\cb@]cU(i&X`Qc
Roger Eliot Fry (1866-1934)[:X<¤»(ì“ç'¢´][s° 214]
Desmond MacCarthy (1877-1952)[”Ēą‡ž(d‘%#S[`Fºï(đĆČºÜ
ď'][s° 231]
Edward Morgan Forster (1879-1970)[”Ēą‡ž(ëð'y2ºj$(úÀfÁó½
é(.9EUM(6^?C`N\6+][s° 237]
Leonard Sidney Woolf (1880-1969)[Virginia %ív¬e(ÖØ$z®xДĒÉ
È(®'"#(âä5ÝûgÚ¿©5 1916 §'Ýû1918 §'8>\F˜†
á”Ēĉàÿå'"#(¸üÂ5r¹3Ē'ĄÕ][s° 241]
Giles Lytton Strachey (1880-1932)[v¬e(ÖØ$z®5xĐßõ'Ñ
a7?
M\6ō—o$ODZO\GW'}0Î5Ð*3][s° 239]
Arthur Clive Heward Bell (1881-1964)[×÷ê—qª(ϝ(ÆVanessa %í
™º›,3%ˆ«',¦5
Ĕ1915ĕ5€ú_`N`¥č1Ýã~5
1ø²Þz®¼Ž5ÙăĈ–$mÄw'±k]
John Maynard Keynes (1883-1946)[L.StracheyD.Grant ™ùáćô5ý¶$ø²Þ
z®¼Ž5Ùă H`;`b@[`M%L7a7JNĜ<cPJM(ø²Þz®¼ŽÙă(
ā‹(.'£‚][s° 243]
Duncan James Corrowr Grant (1885-1978)[D.GarnettVanessa A8`G(£‚$ø
²Þz®¼Žā‹Ĉ–$mÄw]
David Garnett (1892-1981)[A8`G(£‚$ø²Þz®¼Žā‹Ĉ–$mÄw]
ęĕ¨"(ے
Ô^G\c(a7?M\6ÅÞY[\GW1(þ¾%ĂÁ(f‡
FK7ca`¡/Ď4!#A`T\JEs°n%(Ďt0šqě
W6[s° 229]u֟‰Ö(­ē%)ě
ĚĕǕ$Ā-3%T]cWGV\c(µ·5ĸ&
$|ȹ3Ā-
A`T\JEs°n(oî%(Ďĉ$T]cWGV\(̌Þpñ5½3%
ædʙº+(³è%(Ďĉ$W6u֟‰Ö(8`R?M({ 5½3%
ĘĖs°n(̌%T]cWGV\cĜ@]cU
ĔLevy 1981L7cB` 1988F=L]F=c1987 5ŠÓĕ
ėĕs°nĔCambridge Apostles or Cambridge Conversazione Societyĕ
3
1820 º*Im^iRM©PmVMgmOpCkRM'ĉÉ:!ÿ³Gh^dmZq
,PmVMgmOEmHOViYT>+s$+CkRM7ÑoÙ*ë9ÈĴ)´Þ
<Ĉ&IJ-:!
çĮ§ÖÔ+¨+°Õ*z”·Ķ+ij¸*ĺ18eUkqQq
łœ€Ńy3v
7:!¤Ŀ*$&ĦÒ<ĥ2}+dmZq'é3:7!ľô'Âïù
*öěؽ*Œ¢'Ġé<(8å+Į+¤Ŀ<é3&7ĚÐ9(Êľ'€
Ė);:!Jq[qąĕ(Ł
łKqU>m+(Ń<+
!VqNV9
–‘(&õèĂ+ñó)8ä¹,Ģ37:)#!{ºø7'»Ĭ
ªƒ
(&č<Ë$
$18ćĩ€¢(&€+ĺ18*­)(*˜’
9Ĩß<Ë$(Ģ37:9
ƒ¾*)89‡ėď,ĒŠ
łembryosŃ(¡-:âÿ+´Þ(Œ¢rē'+IJĎ
<Ĉ!½*65ƒ¾+Ĩß<¿9łģò
Ńí
(¡-:9½Ę|$
€+ĝĵ5İ—*ĥ2t7:!ĦÒ,.&Đã
łArkŃ(ÛÜ+VhmG*
…®:!‚Ć«&94+4¶))łƒ¾€
úā+Ø©+ĻķŃ
ńу¾€+æ›
þļ×+Ï+ĤÓ*$&ĜĦ9!3* 12 |+ĐđďÃÚď'ĺ1#!+'ƒ
¾
€(ŸĀ~7:!jZ?fqV+ČğďBWlqWp]>RSMAhj
W(Edward Marlborough FitzGerald, 1809-1883)+¥Æ*6:-ƒ¾€(ĭĀ,
©¯ĸò+dmZq'¯á+')ď 12 |&
ƒ¾(¡-:!(*óÝ&9
(ī.&9łU>qJm 1988:17Ń
ıÀ£¯+ęì7†|9,ü€+k_j'ăý+Žò
<Ħ9Ċ<û¦!
94+*!+,½*EiNVÏü€xċď*&Im^iRM*ˆñ£¯ÏÍ()
9eqiNłJohn Frederick Denison Maurice, 1805-1872, ƒ¾ 30Ń'#!1!Î
ê5ü€*$&+ƒ¾€'+ħĦ*¼Ľ<™0!ÄƲ(&,KmLem(Jq
jiRMÌ7:9KmLemxċ+¼Ľłî*"7)¬Åķ„Ń*µ&,ƒ
¾€ij'4šö#!±Ĺ*?FiN*9KmLemxċ+į“*˜’9
ƒ¾4ð:!łMgqMphmDcƒ¾ 57Ń
ü€xċ*4­Ç÷'8]A\=mx
ċ*Ī%ƒ¾4!/ð'4!(-BiRGp`^Oaqc,ƒ¾'9
(U>qJm*6#&ûĢ:&9ł)U>qJm+iNV*6:-Äƛ²
(&ŸŀNT>qnmpV@qjbm5GAmT>mpNEXq4ƒ¾'9Ń
ÒĔî*ġ*µ9ķÁ4 19 wĄ•-*,Ę7:96*)8ł1830 º*LA
iq+ġ*,uıÀ+‰ 9
(ФĦ7:&9Ń1829 º*‹€!4
++ĦÒ×)(ñó' 30 º*Ĭ€!TYNmłAlfred Tennyson, 1809-1892,
ƒ¾ 70, 1850 º*àġ|Ń,ġ|(&©É!½1855 º*Ž‹€<Ģ37:ž
4
À-¨…*,%(>
[_So.ı-/Åã.…É‚.í°Ü?(=
…É"$/nr]SAʼn6>
"$nr]S.µAʼn6(æŀ.óÛ$AË?!.¤-*+7=",%(7
%"1*"$ŌH\hZUFDō-†<?(>ëÁ-öğ?"
ijIJ."
8.ijIJ-3>Šœī<?
Ńý-×AŽ"=
ėēÿÓv²´-,>…É9ă
?
]dSqPoXrjo^Ō…É 53ō/ċĀ(ñB#*9ƒ<?(>
šÍÒ.Šœ/ 1830 À€<ī<?"
§–/bj]_ZL,9.)
µĨ*SKg
oXlA„%"./
ß°-×AŽ(ĥĹ?
±éł‡.ĤA6(ĸ"GEk
DfqRioVoŌ…É 112
È
GEkDfqOkr-ޛō.ã€*
19 wĘç
< 20 wĘ.8#)%"Èģ-(ä9<7-ŊĚ,V^erAµķ
"./kZ]oqS]mFYrŌ239ō*NFoTŌ243ō)
jZUlŌ224ō-;?
0.{‚.yºîAÝ%(è
‚ŸľØ.¥ù/ĐČ,ėēČ,ĵĶ
<¶¬.Ėŋ-ĔĨ
šÍÒ/"=7.**,%"
šÍÒČ,Ļ½Ä7>sá)
©Í¯ÎŌeVR_rō.Šœ9Ēµ-ī<?
!.
ëĖ,†ı.x)B,©/ò?(=“7?(97@,*"%"œqŔq
S[ErpoŌ…É 197
œqŒqS[Erpoő118 .ðĈŐŕqS[Erpo.ĆŐp
C`ZP:pCrR_D.*ō)%"Ç/ 1892 À-ėēĊŅ)Ùʼn.ç-},
%(>
=ĪRgZL.ĉÏ<?(>s)9>
‚).Į·,—.Mlrb-;>ŒüÑ*Ăč-¥'ďĄ.ĺô
ŌQRGE
ZLō*â¿ą÷*.7=.Ľ<
19 wĘ<Ō!<Io] ±.ÆŇ)ō
‚-ł@>9.Aµ£
ŌRealityō*2
!?-¸‚.¦ĿAăĴČ
ŌPhenomenalō
*4ġÔą7?""*0
dLWJr]/Ĝ®>*AăĴČ,«A­>
*B)"
ú·,ÌÃ*~—.kDl*wˆ.ăĴČâ¿.ł‡A+Ģ
>/…É‚-*%(ä9ø“,¡ň)%"ŌQRGEZL‰Ą±.áõ.å›
,µķĄÍ.{‹Í™ĄČ‘¼yĠ*”‘yĠ*{&.Ď|-āĕ
"à™Č,‰Ą±ĄIJČ-Õ=ĕ$>**9!<.¡ň.ÂŁĞ
t->*Ģ<?>ō
ŏŎ»ÚalrfTckr.āĦÍ
ƒĝ-;>’ę.ïª÷•.Ħć
¹ž.đ
…É‚/
NoakZR§.þ´.ImZR.ì՟ń´ ļ¢áõ9s´
ƒĝ¦.¾Č,ěfD.³ß
ņÖŌ˜Öō
Ĭĭħĩ5.łÊ
…É‚/fD-¸(9Öz-¸(9īį/í Ĭĭħĩ5.ûłÊ
u
*=
fD*ņÖŌ˜Öō*.łĻAxÊ- BB .ÌÐAêİ
5
ʼnņ\B}ð¢&ĀfޛÄ1+»āJDbO+ľ¯Ðr@Å;)
ŇŅdetachment?JDbO8NT`DQe+\Bðė)#$+]RP_+”¾
JbV^RM)$JDbO&^RTbdNT`DQe,…)ú+kr9;7ĄŽá
h+kr)­$<+Ž¯ĵ)ăù+Ł–,łõö)™?"?=?=+kr
wê&$cCHT^BÖ+pĵ
"+)©µ:,FUaeUÖ+pĵ%<
?=?=+kr,Êã8čó(ĚĞ)9<û°<īà@{$č{=-
›đ+ƪČ)(<&@ÕA
7=(+l+ĝ.&;&$›đ
:¡þ<&@Õ57+,("JDbO&^RTb+kr,Y^LSpz
î&+Ė¨(Ķ?;@«7ÕA%(5>µ:,¹˜9Ïķ%#>(
:ĻĬñå@ĩ<&@Õ4“ńthe goodŅ&,·€@ĆA
ö)ě6&
ċ‡7+
F^eTn@½ë
&ċ$+ËĜ@µ:,3"i²)7ŋdŊd\B
&ċčˆ!\B+± %<&ƒĘJDbO,”¾IJď
Ï+{Ù%²Ð+µ:\B@Ģĉ$&)/=:),\B+ðĞ+›
݈@éĕ!%"&7ħ2$<\B,Į¸)<2Œè@$
ÔÝöćf+ðĞ@ò<&%“@øs:ĭĽfĪ+½ëö(÷ĵ)9"$Ü
Ã=<&ċ<ĔÎ@Ĩ$\B+± @čü$Č!,µ+
Ë++~Ŀ@ĔĐ&µ+}ð¢@7"0"ž¢Û+ÁmĊ)ġ6$
3"+%<ńRosenbaum 1975: 403Ņ
ňŅJDbO+”¾
úJbV^RM›¢)¢+, 1902 ¯+[GF_ZN¢×10 Ó 1 ÏŌ%
;+Āf¢¯+ą?;),\B+}ð¢ð
‡í=$<?=?=
)&"$+Ñî+j´ŀ&‡í+‹¶)Ē(?=ĠĞ&,â¤ö)ıē(7
+%"²Ð³Ã=7++ÁÎ?=?=+›İˆ)´ŀ
+H]VV_e\OX^edI_eW)ļ•¼@j?=?=@šİ:ĹĈ
$²+7+%"?=?=\B:Å)=7+,µ?=?=+‹
)®‡7++‚v%,("µ,ìģ@͜˜+̬+g)+$,
7fÎ+ģ,LMECRH8XbK\æ+ęĂ(?!ßĒ)Ķ<fĎäŠ
+()ý"ĥA%}ð¢ð
+(),?=?=+Ķ¹@7¿(
fÿĀoÿ"?=?=,?-\B+£ËĀ„ÿ+†—öx|
Ğ@‘§=µ+Į¸Āoÿ+¥ĤöĮ¸@Ç$+%<='>
¥ĺ?=?=+ÀĔ%,µ+£Ë+қ‰è+.&#,£ËĮ¸@ºē&(&
“<&
À
>)"ù,?=?=+Ĵijö(kô+†İ)uA%
ğ+ïÂ&“@Ē(&¥Ĥ}ð&+ĵ),3;¨È(Ķy,("
?=?=+Á%,¥ĺ,¶Č‹Č@Ÿ¦<ĸ:"ØÚ+£Ë
&7+,Ħr+øsöq@’<Ét£Ë&,‚į#*)Ńç(7+
6
)&##2@>=>=.uŒWcFS©)&(w7ž_fp7ƒ`.+
.1*'-x(6Ô~?®!WÍÀ(#**"=?tW-®(
<
Û¾’.T˜GXF¨.f¿¦112-115 ÖBAV§s-<
k-'
(.€|*
k*-'(.lšÊ©­±.IÕ-'(.ˆ‹ÚÜ
ÝÜG. E. Moore, Principia Ethica (1903) ähttp://fair-use.org/g-e-moore/principia-ethica/å
{Ž Preface
—”.ª©V§s´<3J'.j.y]
+.9,°Ù.6."=½O.#5-rm
3,.ßÛYm©, “being good”Ü
«Ä©ÞƓ6cÆ6),½“,°Ù.V§©¬§
>=>=/+.9,°Ù.Á¤?Á,3,.ßۄ¢©, “doing good”Ü
¯s©­±-9&(Ɠ*cÆd¼,Á¤.·š-'(.,lš©¬§
³D² V§s.HØ
à ¯s©,V§s/<HÈ-'(.k goodnessÛ</ badnessÜ
?5<V§©\?­±.xÌ*
<
á KV§s/V§©\.ÎÈ)<k goodness
k good*/P
*jØ6­±.xÌ*(<$·Ê:0.k good*,P
?v¹
<*/Ed¼)<*.6v¹*/.ö)œƒ=#€ºxÌ
.[™.*?‚g(<k/".bµ8-[™Ed¼)<:v¹
<*6Ed¼$**-,<
Û=-x‘-.ÎÈ?L=(<k6
. the good/
v¹Þ[™d¼)<Ü.9-k/v¹Ed¼)<-6Ô
>:!00k?K.P-9&(v¹9*Ç4Á,>=(#
.9-K.P?‡%Z
*-9&(k?v¹9*
<É;?½¥H¹©
ÉËÛthe naturalistic fallacyÜ*h2
â PV§©-k*\=<./ .J'.oe)<1*'/".P
"=½O)koe);61*'/".P
K."=½O)k
P.ª©.#5.„¢*(lšÊ©-koe)<}»/„¢*(k
-Ñ,^»/"=½O.#5-k
"=½O-(k*‚g)Y
m©RU intrinsic value?‡'Ym©RU/K.iØ:‰Ê
<*6Æ
“6Ed¼$*£-(«Ä©,6.)<=-x„¢©RU/
lšÊ©-›ÆCcÆd¼)<ŠÅ
=0/•k.·š?NÁ¤.lšÊ©
҅*¯s©,­±d¼,×n)<
ã V§s.xÌ*,<6./.k6.¸4e&#–Ÿ© organicWO
);"-/Ym©RU*„¢©RU.lš©ÏÓ¸4e&(<
³J² ½¥H¹©V§sÛ½¥H¹©ÉË".DÜ
Mq.½¥©¡z,P-Q†(k?v¹
7
<ÐaÊV§s
ÇEÆ «KÐøÕ´Kмáã(Bù
Õ´¼¼&>¨š$"v>Ð:«KмfeKÐ
ÇwÆ ÒF€¼\·€
ç•Û¼~z(Ð'Xš"v>Ð:?DA\·€
ÇOÆ ×³$(ñê':\·€ø—®¼Y[(y§â¼ÁÄú‚è¼\·€ù
%(7&׳>&.$u)v̧>483(—®$"
nÔ&9v׳)V$u$ÈY#9—®'!"(y§â¼&u
>T4(#:—®¼Y['!"(Œ!(Ìâ׳(Ðg)Õ &4(
#)&øŠÌ'!"(y§â¼Ñ…'7
"‰;:ù(#¾ÜKÐ)á9#
:86:{o'"ì,:."(׳(J#%(׳_U(̧>¢v'
:$$>ß :$) 8'HnÔ#:
"j„&”s#(
=;=;(Ðg>Úc$)#&&8=;=;ì,&׳
(J#%;¢v(̧>48$$>Â$)nÔ4;&\·
€&"$&:$)Ά¼&Ðg>¯:$#)&:µ°
(G#ì,:Œ!(ì˜Ó(J#%;¢4v̧>48>Â$
#:
ÇaÆ ·“øbz¼Y[(ÁÄv$)V>uC@\·€ù
ٝ(v4(Í1o
£¬¼ organic_U(J8—®¼Y[(y§¼
êî$éZ¼&\·>l9òËÊ&bz¼Y[>™c:Ά¼Åh(ž
±Ÿ‹¼&¶å¼Iº(ÝU$WŽS$‚z¼Iº(õ¶û
"(Ά¼Åhøabsolute isolationù$ž±>¸"á9>x
í:&8*ÝÉ.uô)\·€'!"(âM8L¤;:794):
'ƒ¡#:7'‘=;:=;=;(Àä$“^(k-9'"ö&
¢÷(Y[>›
":4():”ä(µ–øcertain states of consciousnessù#
9} 0& ޞ > ;* ; )Rð ¼& P²( «$ Ï †å (Qm øthe
pleasures of human intercourse and the enjoyment of beautiful objectsù'/&8&
(u>Õ8'q$(:+$&8*8;+$9$"R©¼&’
øaffectionù$ÖØ5Õ´':Ï4((ïæ$;ÕU#v$$'
»>œ2$)&<0VËÊ';ÕU(3(Y[>›!$
$>j„'Ñ{o'&'d(4((N!'r0;:4($pÈ']}&Y[
>›!&%$$$>Ñ:+$:$4‘&‚ó(iË&¿·)
IºJ#à38;":$Þ
"7;0#à38;"&
();ë
t€(Ī¼!¨¥¼&¿·$$#:&=`¼:)ü&Ðg
>×&$­$;:()‡8;;8N!(3'ˆ¦#:
|(R©¼&’$Ï(Qm~z:$>½¼$"×&=;:{o'8
;:$$(N!(~z·¹#:$$;8N!(ÙoU(
8
àÀĝč=ó¸+1.8/ƒx#qľ0Ĝð0’öû.ąßüá,āu0
ĵä0˜f0ğîD²À*A,,B?0þö1ĞĶB&+'$
>/¼CBA
ŇChapter 6, 113ň
ŋňÌyû.8,;
ö 1†Úû.¢ēDÆ:š0…œû}€/(*0ýġDü­
û.ö ,¢ē‘ĕ.š<00Âæû}€D›Ûĩû/ÿą!Aö 0n(
/‰BA
Đ¥ûŸĆŒ/)ýġ/>B2ĎŅû.Ò«jø0›ÛĩûĴļ/çBA
,0.ČĊ/*Õņ0…œû}€1qľûoë,Ē¥Ĭ0p+A
Ōʼn\F,ćfâžÁ40»ĉ
ŊňKGcO0ę¹û„´Æ”÷Ĩ,Ī–0Ďíûªď
VbQT 1967(1951)Ħ/¥!ANJR`NJe1992(1983)0Ĉ
dVbQTōę¹û„´Æ”÷Ĩ0m£D”Ĥ ĚÒ0¼¾²À,— DİĠ
dNJR`NJeōĪ–0Ďíûªď/ėA 1910 ¬s0¼¾²ÀDĺĠ
NJR`NJeĦō¼­,£Į0\Fû‡ÑDĈû/đÅ$KGcO
Ze`daWe1µ0Ô$\F0vģ\F,KcY_QMz·u
0k+¶¬0
KGcO0\FĈõ£jø?0ijķD㱌!Aìě.īĩ%/¥*
\Fö 0āuû‚ŁD°ħ!A^QP`=aUeTdH`X>@<<',Ķï.ĩ
īD§Ľ$z·$&ö Žö?µ?0ʕD®ĸ†%#B1è
*#0×Ë|!A!5*+1.'$D¤B$,m£1µ0ĞĢ/>B
2\Fµ?/7$³Ń<'$3'$ Ħû.<0+1ƒ.qÞû.
<0+'$,DĀ*A\Flē1— /AqÞ¨Ç0{%'$
KGcO0ĚÒ0Ø1ö Žö0— û…¤0ܹ,16,E-C
@DÊ'*.aWe1KGcO\F0l¯0ĩöŁ+0¿ē/êü.
'$,IJ5Óú.ĥ@Dô*AKGcOĖį~Ö*$ö Žö1
ĻĈ/>AÔı9+fÙ+@#B?1l,*š0¢ēh‘ĕ½D;AŀĢ
.ù™/Ŀ!A<0%'$aWe18$[eL]`d^GY^_e/åB$0
™ń=Š©lē0™ń=
ö ŽöËĭ$#0r0— û™ńDÃ'$KGc
O0ĩÐ,ÂĄDĞ*.^QP`H`X#*YaGNHIGS1\F0
ö !.C&¡Ïāu/CAĜðDºòû/w,D‹Ħ>,$0
+@#0ɞĢĹ/>@KGcO¶¬ĎíÍł/¦¹$ÝÈDËĀ$
0Ĕ1\Fög0š,Îéû.ĎíûăĂ,0ľ/ĩöû(.@Di
*.'$,è¢û.ܹDñĠ*8'*A$,2ĎíûăĂ1Ó?
/ög0š,“
+1.#*\F0l¯/1ĎíûăÁög0š0ºĝ
Øt+A,DĀ!>.…¤1ƒ.0n(DĿĴ"A,1\F0xċ
9
.¡<.ę‘íwµ,;&(È<?-0+<+iTPk*Ek^/¿xAĢ
$=×ٟwüA97!#=>*ďĨ,ãº,Á%Ę6*)#*
=,(ì8+ĕÏ,8–ě¹ĉ,ħ&(#.*ªĖ
ě¹,(4)8°Ēí+ě¹,¸&#*·<AdB£þ,v¡?#
zä,#.)>LDmO/°,<:>öA•>*+‰žíƒ
AęÚ#*½˜)dBí
)=ú#·Āė/Û(‰žíƒ
ęÚ.qÎ)°Ēí+ªĖ„é,¸dBwüþ)+&#,8ġ@<
īNHWk
NHp: 236-239Ĭ
ĥ²LDmO,>dBªĖ„éī;=ïª+ÍAr3°ĒAĝćĬ.•«
oFYcmYo[pJ.ÉÜ¥Ď
ī1904Ĭı
*“Ž?>³ñ
.Ò¢’*
ĉà2.ˆĪ".åÝr)r>Ò8ĠĜ.®+Í*(.}ù9°Ē
o„é¥ģý
ī190507_09Ĭı»´„é¥*/Ž,ąá.ÖÄ
*+>[ï<
probability
AœªĖ„é¥AǛ
oïçĐ
ī1906-141921Ĭı™ĨĠ.ăâíġ€.ĊÏ
¶ČåÝr)­Š>ąáăâí,~øÔ,'(.ïª+îĒ
ođš.÷ßí¯øī1919ĬıYDU.ÈÂÿAý¾+)Ĕ†ğĩī1320 …c
kJ ¶Ð.YDU. GNP20 ²‹ĬA©7#\jđšÓö,¬>÷ߥíĉà<.
Í
İĭ61,(_kpdOajpoKkp`,>lpVCíœĨ
ĮĬlpVCíœĨıjSfpYolpVCĥ²Ð{,Ă¼#Ğê.Ą
ī¦¨í+
û2.ġºĬ*XlUHp
īð|íØü.ªèĬ.Đéíġ€lpVCĀė/uþ.
ġĚA—©í,Å
ò
Ħ ,>të.ēóAč>#7.nGHf]gijp.
ÆÚībNXeRZOdĬ*‡
Ħ ,>ÉÜío÷ßí+Øü.ęÚAŒ=Ĥ
bNXeRmo_kMhBojaijOd
A›>
įĬLDmOƊ#dB„é¥,>§Ê
*ě¹
.sĚú
_kpdOajpí±šĐ.Õº/^GpNQp.‚zí+„éLDmO.÷ß
Éô
ÌæqĈ
Bell, Quentin 1968. Bloomsbury, Weidenfeld & Nicolson.īŠÞˤċ_kpdOaj
poKkp`y”tõDIjN̒.îíāº5
ÑÀ, 1972Ĭ.
Rosenbaum, S.P., ed. 1983. Bloomsbury Group Reader, Blackwell.
Johnstone, 1963. The Bloomsbury Group, 1963.
Lang, Berel 1964. Intuition in Bloomsbury, Journal of the History of Ideas,25.
Levy, Paul 1981. G. E. Moore and the Cambridge Apostles.
10
Regan, Tom 1986. Bloomsbury's Prophet: G.E. Moore and the Development of His Moral
Philosophy, Temple University Press.
Rosenbaum, ed., The Bloomsbury Group, Croom Helm,
D[FA; 2007#-2'%,21-2$?d5ePU,>C8c
,>C1KL6;^a_
-2*/1(
21/ f<TJ 1883-1920iI1IIj
VYbZO@_
2//#,,2QN_
W=` 1989#-2'%,21-2$4B:g_
H79h 2007/
/#,]3\&!-0RM
.2,%+-1)2"
GSEXRI
11
Fly UP