情報通信サービスの融合とロックイン効果： 固定ブロードバンドと携帯電話

'Ly‹{lFi‡|wu‰2Œ
‚‡‹€‰i+#QI
NPB7=@>T ,)
8T S +
D<DL;Q5L3M
$T T 6
G/Œ.0l?LU‚‡‹€‰Šy‹{l:
mEaYV`qkU%m
Š?F(FMC)y‹{l*O\HKotsVa[aUc_hUf
l‡|wu‰2\(&`tgYsVfm‚‡‹€‰[q+#QInl‡|
wu‰2Ufm+#QI[q‚‡‹€‰nl‡|wu‰2hXsV0J
-lCJm4lLrhXsVAkU‚‡‹€‰[q+#QInl‡|wu‰
2m
^[jZ[1adVclC2UNTT x†‹ƒl‡|wu‰2mbsp
ll`Y_i\edVAkU+#QI[q‚‡‹€‰nl‡|wu‰
2m
^[jZ[1adVclC2UNTT x†‹ƒl‡|wu‰2maUcl
2p]Y_i\edV
v‹ˆ‹Œ FTTHU3GUFMCU„|w{Š‡z|~Š…}†
JEL RŒL96, H40
+
W606-8501 N"!809NB7M
Tel&Fax: 075-753-3477T E-mail:T [email protected]
1
I.ƒ ¡“¦Ÿ
ƒ EL '0f¯Õ½×¾Àx„`xŸ„¯ÕÆÏX+„·×Å»Z7
¡„[ ›§„À¾ÈTUŸˆ«(Taplin 2006, Fransman 2006, Ida 2006a, b)…'0
fÇÓ×ÁÃÕÁÖ·×Å» .g&lC­q«œ„2006 6K› 2500 &l(5F
Wg 50%)œž˜š‰«…• t¡„FTTHÙ31%„ADSLÙ53%„CATV ¯Õ½×Â
¾ÀÙ16%œž˜š‰«…¤—„ADSL Œz­¦«§ „FTTH ¹°®Œ‚‰ Œ„EL ÇÓ×ÁÃÕÁ V;›ˆ«…Qm¹°®­q«œ„NTT NpŒ„ADSL
4*› 39%„FTTH 4*› 68%­¦š‰«…i‰š„`x .gC­q«œ„
2006 6K› 9983 &lŸ{’„ËïÑÖ¯Õ½×¾À ZW¡ 87%›ˆ«…r
PŸq«œ„dA5€u(2G)Ù32%„dA5€u(3G)Ù63%œ„3G Œ
2G ­-Ž8’š‰«…Qm¹°®­q«œ„NTT Á¶ËŒ„2G › 63%„3G ›
51%­¦š‰«…
ƒ ‘š„
9„IJs‘¬«·×Å»¡„S¾ÀÔײ(Next Generation Network,
NGN) y3œŸLP”«'0xœ`x o$·×Å»(Fixed Mobile
Convergence, FMC)›ˆ«1…FMC ·×Å»­(”«œ„S ¨ŠŸž«…
ľ´×ºÈÏÕ FMCÙÔÕ»À¾ÈÅÐÕ³›v|·×Å»­!„• 8·×Å»­!«…
bKR% FMCÙؙ bK„Ø™ €u\#›„2›§„2,›§„xu·
×Å»­Z›«…
¾ÀÔײ FMCÙ1 ™ ¿×½É×»„¾ÀÔײŸ¨ª„¨ª ‚
‰„¹×ÊÒ»žh$·×Å»­Z›«…
ƒ ‹©¢`«£„Qm }]wZŒ‹‘¥Œ„ZmŸœ˜š ¡
‚Žž«…‘š„›cBe><‘¬«OŒ]Y”«…G§‚7ž FMC ·×
Å»¡„FTTH œ 3G ­Z”«bÍ׸Œ½×µ¾Àœž«…FTTH œ 3G ­
DϤ
@”«œŒ›« ¡„NTT ³Ñ×ȄKDDI ³Ñ×Ȅ¼ÆÀÃÕ²³Ñ×Ȝ~
©¬š‰«…
1
2005 6 6 H 15 E„BT ¡:M†ÇÑ×ƱÕÖÈÓº°²À‡œ’šy¦š– FMC ­
†BT ÆÌ׺ÎÕ(BT Fusion)‡œ’š·×Å»@­}/’–…¬¡„Ø™ A5€
u›„2,›¡ GSM A5€uRœ’š„2›¡ Bluetooth(1M^Ÿ¡ Wi-Fi)­
˜š'0xj xuZ­"nœ”«·×Å»›ˆ«(=)xk$_a?
2006)…
2
– £œ¥© ³®—$.ÚãçÖØåÖ®* ±ÎÇÅÃ?¬ NTT Qx¯A4~
®* ±ÎÇÅÃ?¬ NTT ÖËÞ³Œ®—°Âª¢³“0!7Ÿa§Á³žŸ—
kCn³Y¯±Á˜¨³&—2 ¬³G;ž¿—#‘ÃE`§Á£¯Ÿ® ¾
œ˜
NTT Qx³$.ÚãçÖØåÖæßçÍ´—NTT ÖËÞ³A4~ÌçÙÐÃ
a§Áe^Ÿ”›³ž˜”›¯§Âµ—¨Â´°³h6³* ¤ž˜
NTT ÖËÞ³A4~ÌçÙÐæßçÍ´— NTT Qx³$.ÚãçÖØåÖÃ
a§Áe^Ÿ”›³ž˜”›¯§Âµ—¨Â´°³h6³* ¤ž˜
– £³¾œ²—Xƒqž¿z­—¬³ÌçÙÐÃa§Á£¯Ÿ—¼œ¬³ÌçÙÐ
Ãa§ÁsZ;Ô»Á¾œ±;„ÃãÓÈÆåS¯"¹œ˜ãÓÈÆåS´—9
P—×ÓÕäçÈ(‰;½i†';Ÿ,%§Á¼¯®—\.³Uq½=vŸ]À
«§Á_‚Ÿ…£ÁFr®¦¿Â­ ©(Shapiro and Varian 1999—Witt 1999—
Liebowitz and Margolis 2002 [)˜££®´—NTT ÉáçÛ®$.ÚãçÖØåÖ
(šÁ›´A4~)ž¿A4~(šÁ›´$.ÚãçÖØåÖ)²gu§Á£¯³GŸ—
³UqŒ®$.ÚãçÖØåÖ(šÁ›´A4~)ž¿A4~(šÁ›´$.
ÚãçÖØåÖ)²gu§Á¾À¼—ÐÆÓÒåɃa±°³{Yž¿—1K®šÁ£¯Ã
ãÓÈÆåS¯"¶˜
– £³¾œ±#‘²mÁ©»²—2006 5 12 M—Š*-¯pc´—aqÅåÊ
çՀTÃ/H¥—$.ÚãçÖØåÖ¯A4~²§ÁXƒqaà Web ®ÅåÊçՀT¥©˜<™´—£³¾œ²¥­:¿Â©’fˆ+(Revealed Preference,
RP)ÔçÑÃa›—³ˆ+)V;Ãw_§ÁÝÓÈÐÖæãÏÓÕ(Mixed Logit,
ML) æÞÔឿR¥©˜IO³$.oÆåÑç×Ó Õ‡²¥­—Ida and
Kuroda (2006a)ŸRÃ¥­›Á 2 ˜º©—g‡²¥­—Ida and Kuroda
(2006b)ŸRÃ¥­›Á3˜¤¿²—ADSL ž¿ FTTH ·³ÜÆÉâçÎà岬›­—
¨³
—ÚãçÖØåÖæÌçÙгŽDˆ>R¯¥­—’fˆ+W(Revealed
Preference Method, RPM)®R¥©¼³²´—Madden et al. (1999)—Eisner and
Waldon (2001)—Kridel et al. (2001)—Dufy-Deno (2003)—•b—b (2004)lŸšÁ˜
wJˆ+W(Stated Preference Method, SPM)®R¥©¼³¯¥­—Madden and
Simpson (1997)—Savage and Waldman (2005)—Ida and Sato (2004)—Ida, Kinoshita,
and Sato (2006)—t—b (2004)—N—b—t (2005)lŸšÁ˜
3
A4~³/}dj´ºª3±¡—Taylor (2002, p.130)®¼—A4~³yL
;³R´8³‘¯@B¤Â­›Á˜º¥­—3G à ĪA4~y³|‹
R´¸¯Ä°,%¥±›˜(´ Kim (2005)®šÀ—£³F´ËåÏàÆåÕR
Ãa›­ 3G ²2§ÁXƒq³wJˆ+ÃR¥­›Á˜¨³
—Tishler et al. (2001)—
2
3
Ida and Sakahira (2007)z7ˆu˜syr!¯³¶ª¬´ªŠ.%d[™‚
ˆ7„
TEH‘…Œ|r5EHz“ˆŽZ’ŠŒ˜s
k 5^/ŽM^‡t˜sIr¯³¶ª¬´ªy–.%d[Ž³§Ÿœ´8
cˆr=Ž•vŒ}Šz†„sNTT 6VŽ¯³¶ª¬´ªŽ£›z 1%z˜Šr
NTT ª¡°Ž.%d[Ž£›z 0.06%z˜s³§Ÿœ´8NYC4)‰t
˜zrƒŽœ´­Ÿ©#~u(f'C‰t˜)sŒyš|r³§Ÿœ´8 2G •—
” 3G xuˆiS‰t˜sIr.%d[y–¯³¶ª¬´ªŽ³§Ÿœ´8
cˆr=Ž•vŒ}Šz†„sNTT ª¡°Ž.%d[Ž£›z 1%z˜Šr
NTT 6VŽ¯³¶ª¬´ªŽ£›z 1.05%z˜s³§Ÿœ´8NYC4)‰
t—rƒŽœ´­Ÿ©”{u('C‰t˜)sŒyš|r³§Ÿœ´8 ADSL •—
” FTTH xuˆiS‰t˜s
k 5^/Ž<*=Ž•vŒ†ˆu˜sIlK‰r]9;WŠ5CNY™\2
€˜sImK‰r-!°¨²™\2€˜sInK‰r¯³¶ª¬´ªy–.%d
[Ž³§Ÿœ´8™\2€˜sIoK‰r.%d[y–¯³¶ª¬´ªŽ³§
Ÿœ´8™\2€˜sIpK‰r¯³¶ª¬´ªŠ.%d[ŽbŽ³§Ÿœ´8
Ž?!™€˜sIqK‰rM^™w˜s
II.k ]9;WŠ5CNY
k 5K‰r7Au˜]9Ž;WŠ¨¶¦Ž5CNY‡uˆX\€˜s
2006 & 12 3r` µODr!¯³¶ª¬´ªr.%d[c€˜›´ ¶
©]9™"0„s°«¦BaFŽBaQŽy–r!¯³¶ª¬´ªŠ.%d[
ŽAQ 1874 ™+rWeb ‰›´ ¶©]9„s(r&jrR:r%&
Œ‹rJQ$(U 1 Ž_—‰t˜s
<U 1 ,>
k !¯³¶ª¬´ªŽL@>U 2 Ž_—‰t˜sPG£› ADSL(52%)r
FTTH(33%)rCATV(15%)ŽhŠŒ†ˆu˜sNTT 6VŽ£› ADSL(36%)r
FTTH(63%)‰t˜s!¯³¶ª¬´ªŽ¢¶®¥A@>U 3 Ž_—‰t˜s
Kim and Kwon (2003)rIimi (2005)³¤§©µ°¨²™Auˆrœ¥±ž²rgr1
5Ž.%d[ŽeW™7ˆu˜s
4
ADSL š 050-IP }m(45%)„FTTH š 0ABJ-IP }m(39%)Œ¦ŽV‘ª©…?
;ËP;Ÿ~EË=v³ÌÀ¶Vš ADSL › FTTH Ÿxšd+ h§
ª‡Œ„CATV ®Ê¸Ì¾¹¼š VŒ‡&Œj'‘ª©…
<f 2 4>
<f 3 4>
ƒ 6,}m³ÌÀ¶Ÿ"aRL f 4 Ÿr¨š†©…DcŸ´°­ NTT ½²Ç
(47%)„au(32%)„·Á¼¿Ê±(22%)Ÿ›—™‡©…iC<.Ÿ´°­ 2G(30%)„
3G(70%)š†©…6,}mŸ³ÌÀ¶VRL f 5 Ÿr¨š†©…3G Ÿ<Œ 2G ¦
¨¤ÆÌȄ¯°ÂŸ¦ˆ@³ÌÀ¶‹§W¥weKNŸ¦ˆ‚-³ÌÀ¶¢
š™žŠ‡™V-Œ‚‡…› l‰„3G š¤„‚-³ÌÀ¶ŸV- ”ª¡œ
‚‡«š ‡…
<f 4 4>
<f 5 4>
III.ƒ 5%Ç»È
ƒ @_š „AžV‡©5%ǻȞ˜‡™ko“©…@p:ŸYX „%Â
É̽¿Ê½›6,}mŸ 2 ˜Ÿ³ÌÀ¶Ÿu3ŸxŸÉ¹±®ÊBŸ<0›!
‘¬A“©›š†©…”Ÿ{„%ÂÉ̽¿Ê½›6,}m›‡ˆ 2 ˜Ÿu3€
t]<\.ǻȚ†¨„<\.ZŸ
$0„“«–U0¬b2žª©
/gŒ†©…t]|8u3´¶ºÅž(“©`kKM›’™„y1>*M¬
V‡• 2 Izɵ¹¼ËÇ»È5%M(Amemiya 1978)¥ 2 IzÃÉÀ¹¼ËÇ»È5%
M(Nelson and Olson 1978)Œ¦ŽV‘ª©…š „HŸ¦ˆž„2 Izɵ¹¼Ë
Ç»È5%M¬V‡™5%“©…
^Izš„<\.Jž„U9Ÿ£¬V‡™„n)¬Éµ¹¼ËÇ»È5
%“©…
^Izš„^Izu3ŸO[S¬79›’™„<\.Ÿqž
’„Fs¬Éµ¹¼ËÇ»È5%“©…š „Qž„^IzŸ|8u3Ç
»Èš „xŸu#Ÿ
G0¬fTš©¦ˆžÄ¹±¶½Ëɵ¹¼(ML)ËÇ
5
”žŽKpŒn
.%7ui6Lƒ…_g=…1A‚z€†a&kuGRt„
'{Œx‚(Independent and Identical Distribution, IID)Ž
z} CL š”žu@DL
oŒnztzmCL š”ž† IID ‚pq tŠ IIA uCJ{Œn|xmIIA ŽV{Œ1A‚z€ ML š”žud)BMy€pŒnML š”ž†e…?
0mUyƒpj\;0—“¢¡m]"Xƒ\…9TLƒNhŽ2q
x‚…vŒYLƒš”žoŒ(McFadden and Train 2000) 4n
l ML š”ž†7 u'Ž4‚
zmCL š”ž…e3PHŽ …'„h
z€Qz}-[IyŒ£Train 2003, Louviere et al. 2000¤nCL š”ž…e3P
H Lni †mb87…—™¢“Ž m n ue3W i tŠ/ŒK…q~]"
XƒfŽ Vni me3W…7Ž J ‚{Œ‚m
Lni ( ) = exp(Vni ( )) / j =1 exp(Vnj ( ))
J
oŒtŠmML š”ž…h7† …!*h7Ž f ( ) ‚sw‚m
Pni =
exp(V ( )) / J exp(V ( )) f ( )d j =1
ni
nj
‚ƒŒn
l ML š”ž†^=L„^wx‚uvƒp}ˆm5 „†‘˜›Ÿ¢‘œ¡uKpŠ
Œn u f ( | ) ‚pq'Ž4m'tŠ+vy} Ž r ‚:wx‚„zm
– ¢…7Ž R ‚{Œn f ( | ) tŠ r …– ¢ŽZqx‚m|… r …‰‚…e3
PH Lni ( ) Ž_SvŒnx…‘˜›Ÿ¢•y}PH…(†m
P̂ni = 1 / R r =1 Lni ( r )
R
‚ƒ‹mx…PH†O…PH Pni …
5
goŒn‘˜›Ÿ¢•y}#7$*h
7(Simulated Log Likelihood, SLL)†m d ni Ž,`e3Wue3y}„¦me3
y€pƒp„¥Ž‚Œ¡’¢“h7ŽK{Œx‚m
SLL= n=1 j =1 d ni ln P̂nj
N
J
‚ƒŒnx…‘˜›Ÿ¢•y}#7$*h7…<ŽrŒ u‘˜›Ÿ¢•y}
ML š”ž†—™¢“u'{Œx‚„FEŽ,€}„† Random Parameter
š”ž‚‡m;—“¢¡…>c0„FEŽ,€}† Error Components š
”ž‚‰‡Œ(Revelt and Train 1998, Brownstone and Train 1999, Ben-Akiva,
Bolduc, and Walker 2001)n
4
6
/(RmozZddlrY100 q‹™‰œŠ›žm 200 q˜œ†“Š›žq
,}KeYƒ’–šžƒ—œqV$}=MehZ
X ML •ˆ™lrY‘„q;pj\kYSqQ&ˆž…}vmpY?C
p˜”ž…q1
}J@laz(Revelt and Train 2000)Z?C n qQ&›
Ž~™ yn }%meh q!=:r
h( | yn ) =
P( yn | ) f ( )
P( yn | ) f ( )d m.czZ
IV. ›žŠŒœŠ_x)
TLsq›‡€ œ3
0AlrY›žŠŒœŠ_x)
TLsq›‡€œ3}J7fzZgY
NTT ›žŠŒœŠ<Cp^cz NTT Š‚•) TLq<96rE 6 qPyl
[zZNTT 2Gq›žŠŒœŠ<C` NTT Š‚•q)
TL}<fz5:
(51%)rYNTT 2Gq›žŠŒœŠ<C` NTT Š‚•q)
TL}<fz
5:(44%)wyvW\Z8pYNTT 2Gq›žŠŒœŠ<C` NTT Š‚•q 3G }
<fz5:(52%)rYNTT 2Gq›žŠŒœŠ<C` NTT Š‚•q 3G }
<fz5:(42%)wyvW\Z3hekYNTT ™žlY›žŠŒœŠ_x)
TLsY›‡€œ3r\k\z_n]_Z
<E 6 '>
X ddlrY3 iq•ˆ™_xY›žŠŒœŠ_x) TLsq›‡€œ3}
fzZ>q•ˆ™rYFN-*} NTT Š‚•) TLQ&(2G+3G)thr
NTT 2GŠ‚•q)
TLQ&(2G+3G)mek\zZ>q•ˆ™rYFN-
*} NTT Š‚• 3G Q&thr NTT 2GŠ‚•q 3G Q&mek\zZ>q
•ˆ™rYFN-*} NTT Š‚• 2G Q&thr NTT 2GŠ‚•q 2G Q&
mek\zZYU4YN-ek\bZ
DpYeh(B3}"zhuprY200-300 q˜œ†“Š›žY[z\r
100 q‹™‰œŠ›ž`#Hl[zmI|{k\z(Halton 1960, Bhat 2001, Train
2003)Z0O+q(B3r 100 ‹™‰œŠ›žl[zZ
5
7
K XLu 1LG>(2G+3G)DRfdePM;?#
jL(1)NTT vo
G>L(2)NTT voG>]WhM?# aL,<jWh€…
s}†y€~‡r‡]w…€…s}†y€~‡r‡_SfihM€…s}†y€~‡r‡jL
(1)NTT {ƒ‡vx…vD40L(2)$F&!E(B>+u‡rB+)8ˆ
5C1)]WhM"Lw…€…s}†y€~‡r‡jL(3)kl{1s|‡L(4)H
+2As|‡L(5)I(sk…ƒ‡v†s|‡L(6)2A1s|‡L(7)t‚z
G>1s|‡L(8)„…qnt‚z†€pm1s|‡L(9)E9-.1s|‡]WhM
u 1 `?#
`&37=a: 7(a)_Qfi[OhMu 1 `6'
a: 8(a)_Qfi[OhM
ZYT]a*`eP_c]dfihM
NTT {ƒ‡vx…vRf NTT voG>bL%^,`JjQhM
&!EaLG>`D_%^@`JjQhM
t‚zG>1LE9-.1aL NTT voG>_%^,`Jj
QhM
I(sk…ƒ‡vL„…qn1aLNTT voG>_%^@`Jj
QhM
<: 7 >
<: 8 >
K *_Lu 2L3G Dj?#UePM;?#
jL(1)NTT vo 3GL(2)NTT v
o 3G ]WhMu 2 `?# aLu 1 _/VL: 7(b)`Bg\NhM
u 2 `6'a: 8(b)_Qfi[OhM
ZYT]a*`eP_c]dfi
hM
NTT {ƒ‡vx…vRf NTT G>(3G)bL%^,`JjQhM
&!EaLG>(3G)`D_%^JjQ[O^O6M
t‚zG>1LE9-.1aL NTT G>(3G)_%^,`Jj
QhM
I(sk…ƒ‡vL„…qn1aLNTT G>(3G)_%^@`JjQ
$73/?;=20@
1(Ida
and Kuroda (2006b)3/?;=2)64>51<0@'
)64>5189=2: NTT ! 3GNTT
!"+ 3G #-
4>%A NTT !,.*
&
6
8
vT
R 'lS‹ 3S2G JxH&`sWTBH&$xS(1)NTT ‚|‹ 2GS(2)NTT
‚|‹ 2G ibvT‹ 3 mH&$nS€Ž†NGSK@13xM\S‹
1 l5aSA 7(c)mIuhUvT‹ 3 m"<,nA 8(c)lXtwgVvTe
d_in.msWlpiqtwvT
NTT ‡’‚„‚Zt NTT ‚|‹#NG(2G)oS)kOnDtwkVT
*%KnS#NG(2G)mJl)kOxXgVkVT
Vcwm$r)hnkVT
V. #NGZt‡’‚„‚omzy,
*;hnS#NGZt‡’‚„‚omzy,xF4bvTcS
NTT ‚|‹m#NG8?lY^v NTT ‡’‚„‚m862nA 9 mIu
hUvTNTT ‚|‹m#NG8?[ NTT +Cm‡’‚„‚x8bv07
(43%)nSNTT ‚|‹m#NG8?[ NTT +Cm‡’‚„‚x8bv
07(36%)surQVT-lSNTT ‚|‹m#NG8?[ NTT +Cm FTTH x
8bv07(65%)nSNTT ‚|‹m#NG8?[ NTT +Cm FTTH x
8bv07(62%)surQVTNTT {’ˆhS#NGZt‡’‚„‚oS
zy,nVgVvZjWZT
<A 9
>
R __hnS3 fm‹ZtS#NGZt‡’‚„‚omzy,x
bvT:m‹nSBH&$x NTT +C‡’‚„‚(ADSL+FTTH)p
dn NTT +Cm‡’‚„‚(ADSL+FTTH)i`gVvT:m‹nSB
H&$x NTT +C FTTH pdn NTT +Cm FTTH i`gVvT:m‹
nSBH&$x NTT +C ADSL pdn NTT +Cm ADSL i`gVvT
SP.SH&`gV]T
R cS‹ 4S‡’‚„‚(ADSL+FTTH)ZtqsWTBH&$xS(1)NTT
+C‡’‚„‚S(2)NTT +C‡’‚„‚ibvTH&$nS/E
xbvŒ~‰‘…ŒŠ’}’iƒŒ~‰‘…ŒŠ’}’l^twvTŒ~‰‘
…ŒŠ’}’xS(1)NTT ‚|‹#NGJ97S(2)(L*%K(>!=%K
9
+ISP 7wIP ;2S8=!7)PJ[@?ftqtcmuhqnvbv]?
(3)050-IP ;2(clv?(4)0ABJ-IP ;2(clv?(5))_via(clv?
(6)kt`ptclv?(7):$(6 :+)PJ[@odr 4 S3
S
!*-1T. 10(a)RDY\NB[@odr 4 S,#T. 11(a)RDY\N
B[@MLGPTEEXK%SXCRVPWY\[@
NTT e^o;2FY NTT jsvegteU?
!7T?jsvegteS6R Q<]DQB7@
0ABJ-IP ;2(?)_via(T? NTT jsvegteR Q&S
Q&S<]D[@
<]D[@
050-IP ;2(?kt`ptT?NTT jsvegteR Q4S<]
D[@
<. 10 >
<. 11 >
> %R?odr 5?FTTH 6]3HXC@/3
]?(1)NTT "0 FTTH?
(2)NTT "0 FTTH PJ[@odr 5 S3
T?050-IP ;2(clv]9
BN?odr 4 R'I?. 10(b)S5ZOA[@odr 5 S,#T. 11(b)RD
Y\NB[@MLGPT%SXCRVPWY\[@
NTT e^o;2FY NTT-FTTH U?
!7T?FTTH S6R Q<]DQB@
)_via(T? NTT-FTTH R Q&S<]D[@
kt`ptT?NTT-FTTH R Q4S<]D[@
Q&S<]D[@
> R?odr 6?ADSL 6]3HXC@/3
]?(1)NTT "0 ADSL?
(2)NTT "0 ADSL PJ[@odr 6 S3
T?0ABJ-IP ;2(clv]
9BN?odr 4 R'I?. 10(c)S5ZOA[@odr 6 S,#T. 11(c)R
DY\NB[@MLGPT%SXCRVPWY\[@
NTT e^o;2FY NTT-ADSL U?
Q&S<]D[@
';62D@B53E
4+Ida
and Kuroda (2006a)Ida and Sakahira (2007)!"$ #B5,
97C84A3E*
,97C84<=B5
> NTT :?!"$ #NTT :?%.!"$ #
&0
7C(F NTT :?/1-)
7
10
40MmTADSL lL*k3(j$QxYjWU
R")&mT NTT-ADSL k3(j:l$QxYvU
050-IP OJ?TŒ‘Ž‘ mTNTT-ADSL k3(jKl$QxYvU
VI.S Š’†‡‘†i."OJlNlƒ}{‘7l<
S 4DhmT-F7xkTL*A>l#'x6bsXUL*A>l#'i
mTVv€’‰‚l|z\ 1%\vi]kTl€’‰‚l|z\%\v[x
GbT2 fl!Nlƒ}{‘7xGc+8ibgpjc`i\5vU!NhT
#'l/mPC@hVu&vU
S dTŠ’†‡‘†[t."OJnlƒ}{‘7\ 1 kBawgWvU„
 1 hmTNTT Š’†‡‘†[t NTT †."OJnlL*A>l#'m
0.059(1%;=3()hVvU„ 2 hmTNTT Š’†‡‘†[t NTT-3G nlL*
A>l#'m 0.076(1%;=3()hVvU2%kT„ 3 hmTNTT Š’†‡
Ԡ[t NTT-2G nlL*A>l#'m 0.040(P3()hVvUIEcviTNTT
Š’†‡‘†[t NTT †."OJj[yd^ 3G nlƒ}{‘7mcv
rllTel{‘ˆ}…maW(P#@hVv)U
< 1 ,
>
S 9kT."OJ[tŠ’†‡‘†nlƒ}{‘7\ 2 kBawgWvU„
 4 hmTNTT ."OJ[t NTT Š’†‡‘†nlL*A>l#'m 1.046(1%
;=3()hVvU„ 5 hmTNTT ."OJ[t NTT-FTTH nlL*A>l#
'm 1.067(1%;=3()hVvU„ 6 hmTNTT ."OJ[t NTT-ADSL n
lL*A>l#'m 0.872(1%;=3()hVvUIEcviTNTT ."OJ[t
NTT Š’†‡‘†j[yd^ FTTH nlƒ}{‘7mbTel{‘ˆ}…m
k]WU
< 2 ,
>
S [tTNTT ~’‹kZ_vƒ}{‘7x9lsXkoiqv`i\h]vU
NTT ~’‹hmTŠ’†‡‘†i."OJNhTWkHbXsXj1
11
¿¯ª©ÀC‰'!¦‚ˆ›‰¤:/ˆ¤¸¿Á²´À²Ÿ¿¯ª©À
C>‰+¿¯ª©À£¥¡%Š„‚NTT «¾Á¹ž¸¿Á²´À²™:/|k
z˜F¢Ue‰hŽ§—„¦˜¿¯ª©ÀCž[{cN
^C™žj†›„‚Kob NTT ¸¼À²w&Y˜ƒ¦‚
€ Ž¤œ:/|kˆ¤¿¯ª©ÀCœg¦w&$H3¨ 3 œ9r—‡…‚
A»°¾˜žzw&$H3¨dQ˜Š¦ ML »°¾¨S„—„¦‚‘˜
:/|kˆ¤¸¿Á²´À²Ÿ¿¯ª©ÀC.¨¶­±«¼º˜d’‚:/|
kˆ¤¸¿Á²´À²Ÿ¿¯ª©ÀCž@4˜‘©Àµª±¡%Š„‚>˜
¿¯ª©ÀCzw&$H3¡%Š„‚
< 3 8>
VII.€ ^n
€ AVZ˜ž2 Mœ–„—)yTœB’‚\œ )¸¿Á²´À²ˆ¤:
/|kŸ¿¯ª©ÀCž‹ˆš…ˆB’‚‘^CNTT «¾Á¹¿¯ª
©ÀCž'!¦¡,Ž„™‰•’‚\œ:/|kˆ¤
)¸¿Á²´
À²Ÿ¿¯ª©ÀCž‹ˆš…ˆB’‚‘^CNTT «¾Á¹¿¯ª©À
Cž'!‘C¡%Š„™‰•’‚
€ AVZ4žIt¥˜ƒ¦‚:/|k™
)¸¿Á²´À²Oœ 3G ™ FTTH
ž FMC ¬Á·­ 2 AD˜ƒ¦‚‘?:/|k™
)¸¿Á²´À²3G ™
FTTH ¨?œ_¦¸¼À²-"
3 ¥‰52Ž§¦‚Oœ:
/|k¨pM™’¿¯ª©ÀC>‰
)¸¿Á²´À²¨pM™’¿¯ª©À
C£¥¡%Š„™‰•’‚^nž
)¸¿Á²´À²™:/|k¿¯ª©
ÀCœž}+X3‰ƒ¦™¨W¦‚
€ AVZœ–„—2 Ml~¨7;’„‚\œQ!vcRFGu#¨
¥6„Kobw&¡()—„›„˜sqmE‰1f˜ƒ¦‚\œ:/
|k™
)¸¿Á²´À²zœ@4›¿¯ª©ÀC‰i*Ž§’ˆ¤™„•—’
“”œ[<]~‰ƒ¦™„…¡˜ž›„‚0¡J4L‹»³®½À«¨`
Œ¦™‰xf˜ƒ¦‚
a=P
12
+)+
(2005) ,8C9@7C;245 IP '#(!3"-
57.2: 65-74.
*+) (2004) ,&%?:A6.13>BD<=C<
3(!-InfoCom Review 35: 25-36.
+) (2004) ,3>BD<=C<
2/05$%38C
9@7C;-InfoCom Review 34: 87-98.
Amemiya, T. (1978) "On a Two-step Estimation of a Multivariate Logit Model,"
Journal of Econometrics 8: 13-21.
Ben-Akiva, M., D. Bolduc, and J. Walker (2001) "Specification, Estimation and
Identification of the Logit Kernel (or Continuous Mixed Logit) Model," Working
Paper, Department of Civil Engineering, MIT.
Bhat, C. (2001) "Quasi-random Maximum Simulated Likelihood Estimation of the
Mixed Multinomial Logit Model," Transportation Research B 35: 677-693.
Brownstone, D. and K.E. Train (1999) "Forecasting New Product Penetration with
Flexible Substitution Patterns," Journal of Econometrics 89: 109-129.
Duffy-Deno, K.T. (2003) "Business Demand for Broadband Access Capacity," Journal
of Regulatory Economics 24: 359-372.
Eisner, J. and T. Waldon (2001) "The Demand for Bandwidth: Second Telephone Lines
and One-line Services," Information Economics and Policy 13: 301-309.
Fransman, M. (ed.) (2006) Global Broadband Battles, Stanford University Press.
Halton, J. (1960) "On the Efficiency of Evaluating Certain Quasi-random Sequences of
Points in Evaluating Multi-dimensional Integrals," Numerische Mathematik 2:
84-90.
Ida, T. (2006a) "The Broadband Market in Japan," R. Taplin and M. Wakui (eds.),
Japanese Telecommunications Market and Policy in Transition, Routledge: 37-64.
Ida, T. (2006b) "Broadband, Information Society, and National System in Japan," M.
Fransman (ed.), Global Broadband Battles, Stanford University Press: 65-86.
Ida, T., S. Kinoshita, and M. Sato (2006) "Conjoint Analysis of Demand for IP
Telephony: The Case of Japan," Applied Economics, forthcoming.
Ida, T. and T. Kuroda (2006a) “Discrete Choice Analysis of Demand for Broadband in
Japan,” Journal of Regulatory Economics vol.29: 5-22.
Ida, T. and T. Kuroda (2006b) "Discrete Choice Model Analysis of Demand for Mobile
telephone Service in Japan" Graduate School of Economics, Kyoto University,
13
COE21 Discussion Paper No. 90.
Ida, T. and M. Sato (2004) "Conjoint Analysis of Consumer Preferences for Broadband
Services in Japan," Graduate School of Economics, Kyoto University, COE21
Discussion Paper No. 32.
Ida, T. and K. Sakahira (2007) "Broadband Migration and Lock-in Effects: Mixed Logit
Model Analysis of Japan's High-speed Internet Access Service," Graduate School
of Economics, Kyoto University, COE21 Discussion Paper No.120.
Iimi A (2005) Estimating Demand for Cellular Phone Services in Japan.
Telecommunications Policy 29: 3-23.
Kim HS, Kwon N (2003) The Advantage of Network Size in Acquiring New
Subscribers: A Conditional Logit Analysis of the Korean Mobile Telephony
Market. Information Economics and Policy 15: 17-33.
Kim Y (2005) Estimation of Consumer Preferences on New Telecommunications
Services: IMT-2000 Service in Korea. Information Economics and Policy 17:
73-84.
Kridel, D.J., P.N. Rappoport, and L.D. Taylor (2001) "An Econometric Model of the
Demand for Access to the Internet by Cable Modem," in D.G. Loomis and L.D.
Taylor (eds.) Forecasting the Internet: Understanding the explosive Growth of Data
Communications, MA: Kluwer Academic Publishers.
Liebowitz, S.J. and S.E. Margolis (2002) "Network Effects," in: M.E. Cave et al. (eds.)
Handbook of Telecommunications Economics Vol.1, North-Holland: 76-96.
Louviere, J.J., D.A., Hensher and J.D. Swait, (2000) Stated Choice Methods,
Cambridge University Press.
Madden, G. and M. Simpson (1997) "Residential Broadband Subscription Demand: an
Econometric Analysis of Australian Choice Experiment Data," Applied Economics
29: 1073-1078.
Madden, G., S.G. Savage, and G. Coble-Neal (1999) "Subscriber Churn in the
Australian ISP Market," Information Economics and Policy 11: 195-208.
McFadden, D. and K.E. Train (2000) "Mixed MNL Models of Discrete Choice Models
of Discrete Response," Journal of A: lied Econometrics 15: 447-470.
Nelson,
F.
and
L.
Olson
(1978)
"Specification
and
Estimation
of
a
Simultaneous-Equation Model with limited Dependent Variables," International
Economic Review 19.3: 695-709.
14
Revelt, D. and K. Train (1998) "Incentives for Appliance Efficiency in a Competitive
Energy Environment: Random Parameters Logit Models of Households' Choices,"
Review of Economics and Statistics 80: 647-657.
Revelt, D. and K. Train (2000) "Specific Taste Parameters and Mixed Logit," Working
Paper No. E00-274, Department of Economics, University of California, Berkeley.
Savage, S.J. and D. Waldman (2005) "Broadband Internet Access, Awareness, and Use:
Analysis of United States Household Data," Telecommunications Policy 29:
615-633.
Shapiro, C. and H.R. Varian (1999) Information Rules: A Strategic Guide to the
Network Economy, Harvard Business School Press.
Taplin, R. and M. Wakui (eds.) (2006) Japanese Telecommunications Market and
Policy in Transition, Routledge.
Taylor L.D. (2002) Customer Demand Analysis. In: Cave ME, Majumdar K, Vogelsang
I (eds.) Handbook of Telecommunications Economics Vol.1. North Holland
Publishing.
Tishler A, Ventura R, Watters J (2001) Cellular Telephones in the Israeli Market: the
Demand, the Choice of Provider and Potential Revenues. Applied Economics
33: 1479-1492.
Train, K.E. (2003) Discrete Choice Methods with Simulation, Cambridge University
Press.
Witt, U. (1999) "'Lock-In' vs. 'Critical Masses'--Industrial Change under Network
Externalities," International Journal of Industrial Organization 15: 753-773.
15
-7G)*
3@4
"%
'
?:9
;6592
?97
:?5=2
86
9<9
7?5:2
96
=8?
9>5?2
:6
;6:
8<5?2
;6
8=>
7:5>2
(F
=<<
:65?2
,!
78?
<5?2
.+
766
;592
?>
;582
966 #
8>7
7;562
966;66
;88
8=5?2
3A41/
"%
3B4+!0
"%
&
>8
:5:2
!
9=6
7?5=2
3C4
"%
;66=66 =667666 76667;66 7;66
::8
:78
7<<
;7
895<2
88562
>5?2
85=2
16
MPILHJNMOKL
86;
765?2
$+
><
:5<2
DE
9>
8562
]PX\JLZJ
19ZD\KFI
').,
&$
"&
*//+
#
('/0
%
"
2').,6
-//
!$
"$
COILZ<
#&
%
9\[7<BA
%!
%#
7F;[KFIY\<A
%
%
56
&
&"
3*//+6
-//
&!
# !
dc_b
"
%
a^^`
!
=9[:QG8>S
&
# 56
#
%$
@UND\GW>S
RVETH87
?\MA
56
#"
$%
&!
#&
4('/06
17
*f
ZceUWdULeXO
#=$1397CLeXO#$
\ea
<@>Z_FNdI
0+.
/(,
0.&+"
/*&/"
','%68 +*++&0"
'
'&'"
C!
C!
C
C
)')(&)"
(('
((&*"
,.+
,0&("
)())&)"
#>$4::5CLeXO#$
\ea
<@>Z_FNdI
-(+
,)0
0/&0"
/,&)"
','%68 (('
(.&."
)+)
*0&'"
C!
C!
C
C
(*,
)(&."
-/
((&'"
*-,/&0"
(+'
))&,"
#?$21:;CLeXO#$
\ea
<@>Z_FNdI
).+
)*,
0.&,"
/*&-"
','%68 )'
.&("
'
'&'"
C!
C!
C
C
+*
(,&*"
(/
-&+"
(*,
+/&'"
++
(,&."
PH]`SDLeXO Gd_EdJe[ Gd_EdM^QYdI
*.+
*/&,"
SbX
)*+
)+&("
()
(&)"
B C
LeXO
'&-"
--(
-/&'"
ACCKd
SdR
)0
*&'"
PH]`SDLeXO Gd_EdJe[ Gd_EdM^QYdI
),+
+'&0"
SbX
(,'
)+&)"
((
(&/"
B C
LeXO
(&'"
+*/
.'&,"
ACCKd
SdR
)+&)"
PH]`SDLeXO Gd_EdJe[ Gd_EdM^QYdI
18
()++&/"
SbX
)&("
,/
)'&-"
B C
LeXO
)
'&."
(.0
-*&."
ACCKd
SdR
.
)&,"
VQTWdHdI
,.'
,/&-"
AC
'&-"
VQTWdHdI
*.-'&,"
AC
(*
)&("
VQTWdHdI
(*,
+/&'"
AC
*
(&("
:
$-795
2.6
!!
$(
"
04138,
"
2.6
$(
04138,
!
2.6
$(
04138,
!
%
&#/+*
'#)
19
2['"DZLF
+:,/7<DZLF+
QZT
>?N
AQR
!
($
)H>XVZJY
=OS
WXGBYRE@
1656*
.3/6*
/50
2.*
/45
2-*
3.
..*
0/
3*
1.
4*
/1*
M?SA
#%
&VZPXB
789
;<
3
.*
/1
1*
KZCZJ
SZHZ
/3
2*
.
-*
-*
3
.*
IUL'"
2
.*
+\,07<DZLF+
Y
$
.1
0*
,
QZT
>?N
AQR
!
($
)H>XVZJY
=OS
WXGBYRE@
./0/
60*
3-1
13*
5-6
3.*
435
25*
/12
.6*
/11
.5*
/20
.6*
4/
2*
M?SA
#%
&VZPXB
789
;<
..3
6*
.34
.0*
//
/*
13
0*
..*
IUL'"
,
06
0*
Y
$
...
5*
20
KZCZJ
SZHZ
/-0
.2*
!A<>@:;?:/432>976?
+)**<>@:;?:1.05)**:8=2
)**:8=
)**:8=
)**
#
!
"
#"
)**
!
"
%%
##
$$
#"
"
$
,)**<>@:;?:1.05)**:8='2
:8=
:8=
)**
"
"
"
#
)**
"
"!
&**(
!
!"
!
-)**<>@:;?:1.05)**:8='2
:8=
:8=
)**
$#
)**
!
!
&**(
$
""
$
$
21
4S
$"> (:)
$"> "
899HCK
899HCK
55/
14,.'
66/
2/,6'
%! &F?P
OPEBQL
?@J
! GMI$
#
NRH
DA
=0*/34
046
.2.
..6
26
00
2
+
10,-'
.4,.'
.0,2'
3,4'
0,4'
-,3'
=/*642
052
.22
.24
33
..
54
+
05,5'
.2,3'
.2,5'
3,4'
.,.'
5,5'
#
53
6,5'
03
0,3'
(;)07"> "
899HCK
899HCK
2013,4'
3-1
20,0'
%! &F?P
OPEBQL
?@J
! GMI$
#
NRH
DA
=0*045
=1*36/,5
/30
.-4
61
2
0/
+
+
16,3'
/-,/'
.4,4'
-,6'
3,-'
=0*-01
=1*03/,/25
.-/
..5
25
3
+
+
1/,4'
.3,6'
.6,2'
6,3'
.,-'
#
26,1'
12
4,2'
(<)/7"> "
899HCK
899HCK
/.6
14,4'
/12/,0'
%! &F?P
OPEBQL
?@J
! GMI$
#
NRH
DA
=0*-./
=1*/5.,6
3/3
..
+
+
/4,1'
..,6'
2,-'
-,-'
-,-'
=/*514
=0*642,/
4/
/5
.4
.2
1
+
+
0-,-'
..,4'
4,.'
3,0'
.,4'
22
#
1
.,5'
5
0,0'
'<\+(
%
/B0+(
IYRV
/C07?
%
5<;8
IYRV
/D06?
%
5765
IYRV
997
256643949
2<8;376=
27:<354;
256=<3=9<
2=593:8;
27<73754
434:4
#)
4377864
4354649
#
435::57
534;65;
2434447<8
4344455
#
4344578;
4344477
@AA2FGQ
436577:
4354=7;
@AA2,$
4347;68
435:<9=
434;9
#)
4389:86
435748=
435677<
634:5:=
111
243444985
4344459
111
43445:9<
43484
#)
4364657
435:=45
435<94;
7345:=8
243444455
4344456
4344484
111
111
4344446<
43444<:
43776<4
4357;45
11
434<<8;
435<9<<
2434554=
4364657
4359=47
4375;86
24348:55
43864=5
243;7:97
43:<57:
2
2
27535::84
2
5765964
2
UYLSZOUT[K
@AA2>>
*
111
111
NYUYLSZOUT[K
@AA2-
243848:7
435;=5=
@AA2$
24355<55
4369=9<
11
@AA2MWP+(
537;=:9
43879:8
111
@AA2XYJH
27384686
43985:6
@AA2*&
5389:79
436;879
111
111
"
243957:<
4364;47
2434;99:
436=85:
6367758
273667<8
439;<78
5386=8:
436=845
!\1115.#E119.#E154.#
23
439;:<6
11
111
111
111
$D27?AC=>B=65A<:9B
.+--=;@4138+--?AC=>B=5
+--
+--
+--=;@
#
##
!$
+--=;@
!
!
$$
!
!!
"
#"
$ ! /+--=;@4138+--'--)5
+--
+--
+--=;@
$"
!
! +--=;@
$"
!$
#
(
$
"
!
!!
#
!
0+--=;@4138+--%&,*5
+--
+--
+--=;@
#
!
$
+--=;@
!
!
!##
(
"
!
"
!
!
!
$"
24
)(ICFHABGA?
#;$CFHABGA?
JKK
JKK
>,%.0-'1
&
>+%0)/'/
&
68!
*,++')"
,-+
,('("
,,.
.('*"
.+/
-.'*"
DG@EG
*1/
,(')"
-,.
,0'*"
*'1
&
*'1
&
/,)
+1'-"
))++
.('-"
>-%+/('*
&
>,%1)*'0
&
68!
)0/'(
,/'-"
),,'(
.+',"
)-1
,(',"
0+
+.'."
DG@EG
*,.
.*',"
)*,
-,'."
*'1
&
+')
&
+1,
.+',"
**/
+.'."
>+%1(0'1
&
>+%+(0',
&
68!
))('(
+)'/"
+*('(
-)'*"
0.
*,'0"
+-(
-.'("
DG@EG
*((
-/'."
+/0
.('-"
*'1
&
*'0
&
+,/
+-'/"
.*.,'+"
#<$4::5?
JKK
JKK
#=$2397?
JKK
JKK
25
'44aU]`QS^Q&
.I/U]`QS^Q
.J/@HHA
M^V\
M^V\
4;:7
.K/=?GD
954
M^V\
<:5
14457243<
16<82373
1883253;
145<;2<8;
17632777
19:62:6<
"
32468
"
323;5
"
324;6
$)
$)
$)
[^PX_T[Y`O
44254783
4267;6<
000
<2<:;65
527:;64
000
<25795<
42<7::7
000
492:58;3
5258;9;
000
4828:6;3
725;<;<
000
47296;63
62;356;
000
32333488
323333<
3233345:
3233348
132333386
3233349
323333:5
3233366
3233333<
3233369
323339<7
3233374
EHH13831BF,(
142:8879
325543<8
000
1
1
142:4779
325:734
EHH13=>C1BF,(
4278843
325758<
000
3295;44
32594::
00
1
1
EHH1%
326::5:
32444<6
000
32:489:
324<8;3
000
325495<
324::54
EHH1W^NZ^
13276::<
3247479
000
132588;3
3256676
132<;683
325553:
EHH1+
132333<3
3236955
324:8<4
3239:9;
324:6:6
3238;6<
EHH1
*
$
$
R^[^PX_T[Y`O
#a0004-!$L008-!$L043-!$
26
000
000
000
000
27
28
3
29