Path Integral Monte Carlo Simulation of the Low

!#"%$&''()*,+-.0/213&45687:9;7*<&=>?45"
B@ ACDFEGDFH#IKJMLON
PRQMST6U#VW'U-PYX[ZMU#T'\^]KTU`_aQcb[Xd]MV5QcePQ2f]MT6Qcbd]KT#gKhjiRV
X[ZMU#T#kXlb[gm]onqp=Qce X nO]MT'VrXdQMh?PYXGZMU#T#\s]MTU#hsputwvOxry2y{z
|}A}C~AJM€RJML#EGJK‚
ƒ*U…„†QKT‡b[\^U#V5bB]on-ˆ=‰8gMkXdW‡kh&_!QMb[Xd]MVQMe!pU#V5bŠU#T*nO]KT}‹
ŒK„
U#ToW]M\a„5Œ†b[X[V{tŽ„2„e XdWQcb[Xl]MVrkh
iVrX[ZMU#T'kXlb[g]onqe[e X[V5]MX[k}QcbmiT‡f'QKVQc‘pu‰
QM\„†QMX’MVrh“iT‡f'QKVQMhs”P,•c–M—8z2–
˜ |š™{H‡JM›Yœ
™8ž5Ÿ™†L#) †¡¢ †£†£¤{¥
¦§O¨o©6ª«’¬#©§®­°¯5±²©³°«µ´8©§‡¶Mª'±M·{¸¹c´{©§º±²ª·µ¹¨6«µ»š¼
·’±K©«µ¹c´
¨½±Kª§=¼r¨6§O­°©¹¬‡±M·’¬‡¼r·’±²©§©³r§=§®¾{¼r«µ·µ«µ¿
ª«µ¼r»À¯†ª¹c¯§‡ª6©«µ§O¨
¹KÁB³{Â
­†ª¹M¶c§O´«µ´~©³r§j­
§‡´r¨6«Ã©”Â>±M´r­©§O»^¯§‡ª'±²©¼
ª§ª'±K´r¶c§j¹KÁ&ĆŠÆcÇmÈ>ɮʆË5Ì>ÍÏÎÐÍÊ8ŵɲÑMÇ=¶2¬‡»qË5ÒÓ±M´r­
ÑKÊcÊcÊÐÍÔÕÍ×ÖMÑMÊ=ÊcÊcÊØsÙÛÚܧj©§‡¨o©}©³
§j±c¬O¬‡¼†ª'±c¬#Â~¹MÁ*©³r§Ó¯r±M«ÃªÓ­†§O´r¨6«Ã©”»-±K©6ª«ÃÝ>±M´r­0±M´5±K·ÃÂ
އ§j©³
§
­†§O¯§O´5­†§O´5¬#§°¹c´©³
§°¨oÂ
¨o©§‡»ß¨6«µÞO§Mà¹c´©³
§!©«µ»^§°¨o©§O¯q¹MÁY©³
§°¯5±²©³q«µ´8©§‡¶Mª'±M·½±M´5­}¹c´©³
§!©”†¯§°¹MÁ´
¹8­r±M·
¨6¼†ª6Ál±c¬#§cÙÚ§*¬‡±M·’¬‡¼r·’±²©§&©³
§°§®¾{¼5±K©«µ¹M´q¹MÁ¨o©'±²©§B±K´5­q¬#¹c»^¯5±²ª§!á«Ã©³Ó¹M©³r§#ªa»^¹8­†§O·µ¨ÁG¹Mª³{Âr­8ª¹c¶M§O´qâM±M·µ«’­
«µ´m©³
«µ¨aª§O¶c«µ»^§cٚãr¼†ª6©³r§‡ª®à᧚¬'³r±Kª'±M¬#©§‡ª«µÞO§s©³r§B¨o©'±K©§s¹KÁ³{Â
­†ª¹M¶c§O´m±M´r­m­†§O¨¬#ª«µ¿§š©³r§š¬'³r±M´
¶c§O¨!ÁFª¹c»
±j¯r·’±M¨6»-±q©¹)±M´±²©¹c»^«’¬}±K´5­“»^¹c·µ§®¬#¼r·’±Kª^·µ«’¾{¼r«’­“¿{“±M´r±M·Ã†ÞO«µ´r¶j©³r§-¯5±K«Ãª-¬‡¹Mª6ª§‡·F±²©«µ¹c´ÁG¼r´r¬#©«µ¹c´r¨š±M´r­
§O¨o©«µ»-±²©«’´
¶š©³r§a´†¼
»š¿§‡ª¹MÁ=±K©¹M»^¨±M´r­}»^¹c·µ§®¬#¼r·µ§O¨¯
ª§O¨6§‡´8©®Ù
Kä åæä‡çqè&é-êsëìqíBèBäOêsç
î6žqï#€DFH#J!ð8ñuH#òJ*ï'DGóq€EFJ°ôKð†óq€Rðrï'DFH#DGð†ž=¢8ò55›L#ð
õ†JKž}J²öòDG÷DFH‡ï™
ï#ŸL#€L#D[ï'DGžõ
EF-ôKð†óq€EGJ²ö`€òR™†ï#Ja›D[™8õ
L‡™†ó¢{ø°òDGôOòD[ïH#òJ°ï#Ÿ÷ùJcô®H
ð8ñӞ5ŸóqJKL‡ð†ŸRïJ²ö€RJML#DGóqJKžrH‡™†E`™8žR›úH#òJMð†L‡J²H#D[ôK™†E`™8€€L#ðr™†ôOòJcïKA
î6ž0H‡òDGï}øað†L‡ûu¢øJÜïH‡Ÿ›H#òJmòDGõ†ò0H‡JKóq€RJML‡™8H#ŸL‡JjL‡JKõ
DFóqJÓð8ñ
ü £
£†£×ýÿþ ý ü ££†£
£ ø°òJML#J ò55›L#ð
õ†JKž Ÿž›JKL‡õ†ð5Jcï™
ï#óð5ð†H#ò;H‡L‡™†žï#D’H‡DFð
ž ø°DFH#ò DGžôKL#Jc™†ï#DFžõ H#JMó€uJKLO™{H‡ŸL‡JñdL‡ð†ó ™
óqð†EGJMôKŸEG™†L ŸDG›H‡òL‡ð†Ÿõ
ò™8ž ™8H#ð†óqD[ô-L‡JKõ
DFóqJ`™†ž
› ž™†EFEGÜH#ð
™Høð>ô²ð†óq€uð†žJMžrH€E[™†ï#óә ð†ñ&JKEGJMô²H#L‡ð†žïq™8žR›0€L‡ð8H#ð
žï ˜ ï#JKJ
ŽDFõRA¤{¥O
A !òJ܀L#ð
€RJML'H‡DFJcï-ð†ñ&ò55›L#ð
õ†JKž0DGž0H‡òDGïL‡JKõ
DFóqJ)™†L#J
ô²L‡ŸôKDG™†Eñdð
L&H‡òJqJ ð†EGŸH#DGð†žð8ñï'H‡™†L‡ïs™8žR›“H#òJqôOòR™8LO™†ô®H‡JKL‡DGï'H#D[ôKï
ð8ñŽH#òJ`8ð 5D[™8ž)€EG™†žJ²HOïKA
{™†L#DGJ²H^ð†ñuï#DFó}ŸEG™8H#DGð†ž}H#JcôOòžD ŸJMï?™8žR›}™†ž™8EGrH#D[ôK™8E5óqð› JKE[ï?ò™ J!÷RJMJKžÓ›J JKEGð†€uJM›`H#ð-›Jcï#ôKL#DG÷uJ°òr›L‡ð†õ
JKž™{HEGð{øЛJMž ï#D’H
A !òDGïaL‡JKõ†DGóqJ&ò™
ï÷uJKJMžÜï'H#ŸR›DFJc›jø°DFH#òÜôOòJKóqD[ôK™8E½óqð›JKE[ï
¤ 5¡ BH‡ò™{H›JMï‡ô²L‡DF÷uJ ò5›L‡ð†õ†JMž;™†ïm™ÀóqD’ö5H‡ŸL#Jð8ñ-DGž
H‡JKLO™†ô²H DGžõ~óð
EFJcô²ŸEGJMïM¢!™{H#ð
óÓïK¢ñdL#JMJ€L#ð†H#ð
žïә8ž› JKEGJMô²H#L‡ð†žïM
A !òJ
ôOòJMóD[ôK™†E
ôKð†óq€Rðrï'DFH#DGð†ž`DGJ²H‡JKL‡óqDFžJc›^÷5sóDGžDGóqDFIMDFžõš™8ž`™†€ €L‡ð2öDFóә{H‡J-ñdL‡JKJ}JKžJML#õ
mñdŸžô®H‡DFð
ž>ôKð†žï'H#L‡Ÿô®H‡JM›ñdL‡ð†óÕû5žð{ø°ž
H#òJKð†L‡J²H‡DGôM™8E°EGDFóqDFH‡ïMA3î6žÐH#òD[ïӀ™†€RJMLM¢aøJÜñdðô²ŸRïqð†žÛEFð{ø™8ž›
DGž
H‡JKL‡óqJM›D[™{H‡J›JKžï#D’H‡DFJcï †!
¡ Û¤c£ "$# &
ý % ýÕ£ G¤ ü ¡õ
ô²'ó ")(
ô²ð
L#L‡JMï#€uð†ž›DGžõmH#ð0+¤ *-,/.102, 3¢ø°òJKL‡Jqð†žJÓJKö5€uJMô²H‡ïsH‡òJ
ôOòJMóD[ôK™†Esóð›JMEGïÜH‡ð øað†L‡û3øaJKEGEs™†E’H‡òð†Ÿõ†ò;H‡òJ~€L‡ð†€uJKL#H#DGJMï
ð8ñò5›L‡ð†õ
JKž“™8L‡J-›J²H‡JKL‡óqDFžJc›“÷5ÜH#òJô²ð†óq€EGJ²öDGž
H‡JKL‡€E[™2)ð8ñ
EGð†ž4õ ”LO™8žõ
Jð†ŸEGð†ó}÷Bñdð
L‡ôKJMï=EFJc™†›DGžõ!H#ðšïH‡L#ð
žõ*ô²ð
Ÿ€EGDFžõ&™8ž›
÷uð†Ÿž›ï'H‡™8H#JMﰙ
ï!øJMEFE™
ﰛJKõ
JKžJML‡™
ô²ÓJ 5uJcô®H‡ïMA
EGE=H‡òJMï#J-6J 5½JMô²H‡ïšôK™†ž ™8E[ï'ðÓ÷uJ}›Jcï#ôKL#DG÷uJM›ñdL‡ð†7
ó LOïH&€L#DGž ô²DG€EGJMïï'DGó`ŸEG™8H#DGð†ž8
A !òJKL‡Jm™8L‡J 9;:=<?>@<BAC<EDjóqJ²H‡òð›ïï'ŸôOò ™†ï
FHGJILKHMONQPCRSTLMUWVVPCKXCXZY;[]\Z^+\H_`6aWb6c6^^Zd+^efgih
j GJILKHMONQPCRSTLMUWVVPCKXCXZY)kiailaWb^WaWm6cin\On1k;e?aWoWn
L‡JMï'H#L‡D[ô®H#Jc›-€™8H#òqDGž
H‡JKõ
L‡™†EC“ð†žrH#J&a™8L‡EGðšï#DFó}ŸE[™{H#DGð†žRï ˜Cp î'C°¥
*3™8žR››JMžï#D’H“ñdŸžô®H‡DFð
ž™8EH‡òJKð
L# óqð
EFJcô²ŸE[™8L^›5ž™†óD[ôKï
˜ q| rC“|^¥ Ls t¢ ”A !òJÓñdðôKŸï^ð8ñ!H‡òJjøað†L‡û DGï^H#ð“H‡JMï'H-H#òJ
J1rŸ™{H‡DFð
ž ð†ñšï'H‡™{H‡J E˜ urvxw ¥`›JKL‡yD JM› ñdL#ð
ó ôOòJKóqD[ôK™†Eaóqð›JMEGï
™†ž›ÓH‡òJ^™†ô²H#Ÿ™†Eu›JMžï#D’H; ”H#JKóq€uJKLO™{H‡ŸL#JšEGDFóqDFH‡ïað8ñH#òzJ {™8EGDG›DFH
ð†ñ*H#òJÜôOòJMóqDGôM™8Ea€DGô²H#ŸL‡J†A ››DFH#DGð†ž™†EFEG†¢øJ܀L‡ð rD[›Jܛ™{HO™
H‡ð ›J²H‡JKL‡óqDFžJqH‡òJӀ™†L‡™†óJKH#JML‡ïšð8ñaH#òJÓñdL#JMJqJKžJML#õ
 óqð5›JKE[ïKA
òJKóqDGôM™8Eóqð›JMEGï}™8L‡JÓJ²ö€RJcô®H‡JM›>H#ð÷RJcô²ð†óqJjDGž™
ôKô²ŸL‡™8H#JÓDGž
L‡JKõ
DFð
žï}ð8ñBòDFõ
ò ›JMžï'DFHÀø°òJML#JmH#òJÜEGDFñdJ²H#DGóqJ“ð8ñšóð
EFJcô²ŸEGJMï
L‡JM›Ÿô²JcïaH#ðә}ñdJKøúóð
EFJcô²ŸE[™8{L 5DG÷LO™{H#DGð†žRï oA
|>J €L‡JMï#JKžrH)L‡JMï#ŸE’HOïÓñdL‡ð†ó žJKø^¢°óqð
L#J™
ôKôKŸL‡™8H#J
¢ p î'C
ï#DGó`ŸE[™{H‡DFð
žïK'A ŽDFLOïHc¢=øaJ)™8žR™8EGrIMJH#òJ)™
ôKôKŸL‡™
ô² ð†ñH‡òJj€™†DFL
›JKžï#D’H`óq™8H#L‡D’ö™8ž›}H#òJ°JKL‡L#ð
Lð†ñRH‡òJ }H‡DFóq+J ~s›D[ï‡ô²L‡J²H#DGIM™8H#DGð†žA
!òJKžøJ!™8ž™†EF5IMJH‡òr
J žDFH#J°ï'DGIKJ°›JM€RJMž›JMžô²J!ð8ñRH#òJ°›JML#D †Jc›
u€vxw ™8ž››D[ï#ôKŸï‡ï!H#ò
J öJM›žð›J^JML#L‡ð†LOï!÷5mô²ð
óq€™8L‡DFžõL‡6J ï#ŸEFH‡ïñdL‡ð†ó ï#DFó}ŸEG™8H#DGð†žïŸRï'DGžõ^ñdL‡JKJ°€™†L'H‡DGôKEFJ ˜ p ¥Žžð›Jcï™8žR›
{™†L#D[™{H‡DFð
ž™8EYžð›JcïK{
A ŸL'H‡òJKL‡óqð†L‡J†¢RøJ-ôM™8E[ô²ŸE[™{H‡J-€™8DGL&ôKð†L‡L#J E[™{H‡DFð
žqñdŸžô²H#DGð†žïø°òD[ôOòjøJ&Ÿï'JBDFžmô²ð†ž8ùŸžô®H‡DFð
žjø°DFH#ò)™}ô²EGŸHï H‡JKLš™8ž™†EFï#DGï!H‡ð)ôOò™†L‡™
ô®H#JML#DGIKJšH‡òJ}ï'H‡™8H#J-ð†ñò5›L‡ð†õ
JKž“™{HB›D’?ñ ñdJML#JMžrHBH‡JKóq€RJML‡™8H#ŸL‡JM8žR››JMžï'DFH#DGJMïM‚A |>J}Ÿï#Jq™{H#ð
óqDGô}ŸžDFH‡ï
˜ EFJMžõ8H‡òïDGžj@að†òLL‡™
›DGD™8ž›qJMžJKL‡õ†DGJMïDF„ž ƒB™8L#H#L‡JKJMﮥ=H#òL#ð
Ÿõ†ò ð
ŸH!H#òD[ï°øað†L‡ûÓJ²öô²JM€H*ø°òJML#JsDGž›D[ôK™{H‡JM›Üð8H‡òJKL‡ø°D[ï'J
A
ä®äK内ˆ‡°èŠ‰×ä#çqèq‹€Œ}遇Ž;êsçq芋 íq‡`遍?ê
‘‹q
è ‰jêsë
‡ 
é ’4“W”W•–—+”W’4˜™…›š;”Wœ~iä ”W’Ÿž•6š !òJ^›JMžï'DFHÓóә{H‡L#DFö ˜ |sC¥ð8ñ™-ñdJML#óqDGð†žÜï'ï'H#JKóי{HaH#JKó¡
€uJKLO™{H‡ŸL‡£J ¢¤¦
þ ¥ ¤ §¨ÛôK™8ž÷RJqø°L‡D’H#H#JMž~™
ïs™8žDGžrH#JMõ†LO™8Eð †JML
™†EFEY€R™{H#òRï ©ªO¢
¬
10
14
200000
10
°
100000
®4
­6
rs
Plasma
¯ 2.6
3
± Pa
10
±
0G
GP
a
¶ 01
50000
0.
² ³Pa
1G
20000
0.1
10000
±
µ
0.1
T ´(K)
Atomic Fluid
GP
a
5000
Molecular Fluid
10
−3
−2
10
ρ (gcm
« −3)
10
−1
Žî ·A¤
œ p ò™†ï#J*›D[™8õ†LO™8óßð8ñYò55›L#ð
õ†JKžq™†ï™sñdŸžô²H#DGð†žÓð8ñ½H‡JK¡
ó u€ JKLO™{H#ŸL#Jj™†ž›0›JKžRï'DFHñdð
L-H‡òJ)›Dy5uJML#JMžrH`L#JMõ†DGóqJMïMœ`€E[™†ï#óә¢
H#òJ&™{H‡ð†óqDGô°™†ž›}H#òJ&óð
EFJcô²ŸE[™8LL#JMõ†DGóJ
A¸!òJB›™†ï#ò6›ð8H?EGDFžJcï
DGž›D[ôK™{H‡JqH#òJj™†€€L‡ð2öDFóә{H‡J}÷uð†Ÿž›™8L‡DGJMïMA£!òJjô²L‡ð
ï‡ï'Jcï&DGž›Dy
ôK™8H#J“H‡òJ €™†L‡™†óqJ²H#JML‡ïñdð
Ljø°òD[ôOò p î'C×ï#DFó}ŸE[™{H#DGð†žRïÓò™ †J
÷uJKJKž €RJML'ñdð
L#óqJM›¢jH#òJ ï'ð
EFD[› EGDFžJcï ™†L#J3D[ï'ð
÷™8LOïM¢)™8ž›wH‡òJ
›™
ï'òJc›>EFDGžJMïsL‡JK€L#Jcï'JMž
H-ôKð†žrH#ð
ŸL^EFDGžJcï^ð8ñ°ô²ð
žïHO™8žrH^€RJML#ó}Ÿ H‡™8H#DGð†ž €L#ð
÷™8÷DFEGD’H>ð8ñ&H#òJÜJKEGJMô²H#L‡ð†žï ˜ ™
ï`DGž›D[ôK™8H#JM› ð†ž0H‡òJ
EGDFžJ
AÃ¥
¤
% ˜„
© ¹]ºZ©„»½¼¨Ž¥t¥ ¾™¿;ÀÁ ˜HÂ
ÁÄÃ
É © ªËÊ "ÍÌ@Î ÅÐÏ?Ñ ˜ ¤2¥
ÅÆZÇ ÅtÈ
©„ª&ï'H‡™†ž›ïšñdð†LšH‡òJqJKžrH#DGL#Jq€™8H#òïsð†ñr¾ €™8L#H#D[ô²EGJMïsDGž>¡Ü›Dy
óqJKžï#DGð†ž™†E†ï'€R™†ô²J›©„ª¥ ˜BÒ4Ó ªº+½º Ò4Ô 'ª ¥u÷uJKõ†DGžžDGžõš™{H¸© ¹ ™8ž›
JKžR›DFžõš™8H¸Á ÕÖ©„»½A¸Õ E[™8÷uJKE[ïH‡òJ!€RJML#ó}ŸH‡™8H#DGð†ž}ð8ñH‡òJ€R™8L#H#D[ô²EGJMï
™8žR› ˜H ¤{¥ H#ðqD’HOï!ï'DGõ†ž™8H#ŸL‡J†A ð
L!žð†žo L‡JKE[™{H#D5
DGï'H#D[ô*€R™8L#H#D[ô²EGJMï
DGž
H‡JKLO™†ô²H#DGžõ^ø°D’H‡òj™s€Rð†H#JMž
H‡DG™†EJ× ˜ Ü© ¥®¢†H‡òJ&™
ô®H#DGð†žqð†ñuH‡òJ*€™8H#ò
Ø © ª D[ï°õ†D†
JMžm÷5†¢
»
¤{¥
Á
É © ˜Û¥
ßÞÞ á$à É]Û ÞÞ × ˜ © ˜ Û ¥'¥Qä ô²ð
žïH+ ˜ ¥
¹
Þ
Þ
î6ž)€L‡™
ô®H#D[ô²Jšð†žJš›D[ï‡ô²L‡J²H#Þ DGIKJcï ½Þ âÐH‡òã Js€™{H‡ò)DGž
H‡ð㠙֞DFH#Jsž5Ÿó¡
÷uJKLsð8ñDGóә8õ
DFž™†L#mH#DGóqJï#EGDGôKJMï‚å ô²ð
L#L‡JMï#€Rð
ž›DGžõÓH‡ðܙ-AE<?æç
å A
è AQçHé„ê2¥‘¨ˆ§w
ð†LqñdJML#óqDGð†žD[ôï'ï'H#JMóqï}H‡òJ“DFžrH‡JKõ†LO™{H‡DFð
ž D[ïÓô²ð
ó€EFD[ôK™8H#JM›
›ŸJ!H‡ðsH#òJBôK™8žRô²JKEGE[™{H#DGð†žð8ñ½€uð
ï#D’H‡Dy
J!™†ž›žJKõr™{H‡Dy
J!ôKð†žrH#L‡DG÷Ÿ
H#DGð†žRï*H‡ðjH#òJ}DGžrH#JKõ
L‡™†E…¢ ˜ AEëçì6ç6íæ¡<ED> è <ïî4>é$íZD;:ðyç-æ ¥OAsîoHšòR™†ï
÷uJKJKžï#òð{ø°ž ¤M£¢Y¤†¤Y H‡ò™{H°ð†žJsôM™8žÜJ{
™8EGŸ™8H#JBH#òJs€™8H#òDFžrH‡J6
õ†LO™8E½÷5ÓL‡JMï'H#L‡DGô²H#DGžõ`H‡òJ^€™8H#òmH#ðqð†žEGjï#€RJcô²DyR ôs€Rðrï'DFH#D†
Jsô²ð
ž
H#L‡DG÷ŸH#DGð†žRïKA v žJqDGž
H‡L#ð›ŸRô²JMïs™ÜL‡J²ñdJKL‡JKžRô²Jq€Rð
DFžrH©'}ñ ð
žH‡òJ
€™8H#òÓH‡ò™{Hï#€uJMô²Dy JcïH‡òJ&žð›Jcïð†ñuH‡òJB|sC~¢;% ˜ ©Ëºi© ñ º Û ¥t¥ £A
>JD1ò4çó9ôD<Eò<?>
î €™{H‡ò ñdð
LB£'õ Û ýöÀ
¨ žJKDFH#òJMLBH‡ð†ŸôOòJMï*žð†L
ô²L‡ð
ï‡ï#JMïq™>žð›J†œ!% ˜ © ˜ Û ¥Wºi© ñ º Û ¥¥ ÷ £A;@aÀL#JcïH‡L#D[ô®H‡DFžõH‡òJ
Ø ©„ªC)¥ÚÙ
É;ÛzÜ+Ý
DGžrH#JMõ†LO™8EuH#ðӞð›Jo™
ð†D[›DGžõ`€™8H#òïM¢
%ø ˜ ©»ÍºZ© ñ ¼Z¨Ž¥ ¥
ÙÖÉ ©„¹q%ø ˜ ©„¹]ºZ© ñ ¼‡£r¥
Ã
É © ªËÊ ")Ì@Î Å Ï Ñ º
ÅÆiǂÅtÈ;ù4úûyśüZý
˜ ¡r¥
ÿ˜ þ˜ © ñ ¥›JKžð8H#JcïH#òJÐL#JcïH‡L#D[ô®H‡DFð
žu¥“H#òJÛô²ð
ž
H‡L#DG÷ŸH‡DFð
žï>™8L‡J
u€ ð
ï#DFH#D
†Jm™†ž›~H‡òJKL‡J²ñdð
L#J p î'CL‡JK€L‡JMï#JKžrH‡ïM¢DFž €L#DGžôKDF€EGJ†¢™
ï#ð†EGŸH‡DFð
žÛH#ðÀH‡òJï#DGõ†ž3€L‡ð†÷EGJKóA !òJóqJ²H‡òð›3DGï)J²ö™†ô²HmDFñ
H‡òJšJ²ö™†ô²HñdJML#óqDGð†žD[ôB|sC DGïaŸï#JM›jñdð†LaH#òJsL‡JMï'H#L‡DGô²H#DGð†žAƒ*ð{ø€
+J †JMLM¢uH#òJ}JKö™
ô®H^|šC D[ïBð
žEGÜû5žð{ø°žDFž>™jñdJMøßôK™
ï'JcïKA-CðrïH
™†€€EGDGôM™{H‡DFð
žïšò™ †Jә8€€L#ð2öDGóә{H#Jc›H#òJqñdJKL‡óDGð†žDGôq|sC ÷5>™
›J²H#JML#óqDGž™8žrH°ð8ñ?ï#DFžõ
EFJs€™†L'H‡DGôKEFJ^|sC“ïM¢
% Ó E˜ Ò Ó º ÒÓ ¼ ¨Ž¥&+™% Ó ˜EÒ Ô º ÒÓ ¼¨Ž¥
+
+
+
% ˜8
© ºZ© ¼ ¨Ž¥Ð¥ Þ
ÞÞ % Ó ˜BÒ Ó º Ò Ô Z¼ ¨Ž¥+Ž% Ó ˜BÒ Ô º Ò Ô ¼Z¨Ž¥ ÞÞÞ
ÞÞ
ÞÞ ˜ *5¥
Þ
Þ
!òD[ïB™†€€L‡ð
™
ôOò“ò™†ïB÷RJMJKžJ²ö5H#JMžï'D†
JMEF™8€€EFDGJM›Ÿï#DFžõ)H#òJ
ñdL‡JKJ`€™8L#H#D[ô²EGJ ˜ p ¥!žð›Jcï&›JML#D†
Jc›ÜñdL#ð
ó H‡òJ}ï#DFžõ†EGJ6o €™8L#H#D[ô²EGJ
›JKžï#D’H)óq™8H#L‡D’ö ¤
¤” œ
% Ó{˜EÒ º Ò º ¨Ž¥t¥
˜ *¨Ž¥ "J( J²ö€
Â-˜BÒqÂ-Ò ¥ §*¨ ˜ ü ¥
ø°DFH#ò¥ áà §8 Ý ¢DGžôKEFŸ›DFžõܙ8€€EFD[ôK™8H#DGð†žï!H‡ð)›JMžï'J}ò55›L#ð4
õ
JKž *3”AsîoH^ôK™†ž ÷RJqï#òð{ø°ž“â H#òR™{H&ñdð
L&H‡JKóq€uJKâLO™{H#ŸL#Jcï&E[™8L‡õ†JML
H‡ò™8žÜH‡òJJML#óqDJMžJKL‡õ†
¢5H#òJ-DGžrH#JML‡™
ô®H#DGžõqžð›™†E=ï'ŸL'ñŠ™
ô²J^™8€ €L#ðr™†ôOòJcïaH#òâ JÖ p žð5›™8Eï#ŸL#ñŠ™†ôKJ†Aaî6ž ™†››DFH#DGð†ž=¢RDGžH#òJ`EFDGóqD’H
ð†ñŽEGð{ø ›JKžï#D’H
¢JKöôOòR™8žõ
JBJ 5uJcô®H‡ïB™8L‡JsžJKõ
EFDGõ†DG÷EGJ†œH#òJ^žð›™8E
ôKð†žï'H#LO™8DGžrH-ò™†ï}™ï#óә8EGE6J 5½JMô²H}ð
ž0H#òJm€™{H‡ò ™8žR›>H#òJML#JKñdð†L‡J
DFH‡ï}€L‡JMôKDGï#Jmï#ò™8€uJ)D[ï}žð8HDFóq€uð†L#H‡™8žrHcA !ò'J p žð›JMï™8E[ï#ð
÷uJMôKð†óqJjJKö™
ô®H`DGž0H‡òJ)EGDFóqDFHð†ñ°òDFõ
ò ›JMžï'DFH>ø°òJKžÀû5DGžJ²H‡DGô
J 5uJcô®HOï›ð†óqDGž™{H‡J°ð †JMLH‡òJ°DGž
H‡JKLO™†ô²H#DGð†ž€Rð†H#JKžrH‡DG™†E…A ƒ*ð{øaJ JKLc¢
ñdð
LsH#òJӛJMžï#D’H‡DFJcï-™8ž›H#JMóq€RJML‡™8H#ŸL‡JMž›JKL`ôKð†žï#DG›JKLO™{H#DGð†ž=¢
DGžrH#JML‡™
ô®H#DGð†žRïšôKð†ŸE[›ò™ †Jq™ï'DGõ†žyD RôM™8žrHšJ 5uJcô®H-ð
žH‡òJqžð›™8E
ï#ŸL#ñŠ™†ôKJMïMA
ðÓõ
™8DGž ï#ð†óq
J rŸ™8žrH#DFH‡™8H#D †J^JcïH‡DFóә{H‡J-ð8ñH‡òJ`€uð
ï‡ï'DG÷EGJ^J²?ñ ñdJcô®Hð†ñYH#òJ&žð›™8ERL#JcïH‡L#D[ô®H‡DFð
žð
žqH#òJ*H#òJML#óqð›5ž™8óqD[ô°€L‡ð†€ JML'H‡DFJcïK¢=D’H`D[ïsžJcô²JMï‡ï‡™8L‡H#ðH#L‡™†ž>™†E’H‡JKL‡ž™{H‡yD J†Aqî6ž0™†››D’H‡DFð
ž
H‡¡ð p žð›JcïK¢øaJBŸRï'Jc›)žð›™†Eï'ŸL'ñŠ™
ô²Jšð8ñŽŽ™ {™8L‡DG™8H#DGð†ž™†Eu›JKž ï#DFH-óә{H#L‡DFö ˜ |šC¥ ¤21 R›JML#D †Jc›^ñdL‡ð†óz™ {™8L‡D[™{H#DGð†žR™8E5€L‡DFžôKïD €EFJ`H#ò™8H&DFžRô²EGŸ›JMïBDGž
H‡JKLO™†ô²H#DGð†žï*™†ž› ™8H#ð†óqD[ô-™8žR›óð
EFJcô²ŸE[™8L
÷uð†Ÿž›)ï'H‡™8H#JMïMA |J^™
ï#ï#ŸóqJB™`H#L‡DG™†EY|šC ø°D’H‡òm€™†L‡™†óqJ²H#JML‡ï H‡ò™{H&›JK€uJKž›Üð†žÜDGóq™†õ†DGž™8L‡qH#DGóq‚J ¨0™8ž› © ¢
˜ 3r¥
% ˜ ©8ºZ© ¼¨ŽÐ
¥ ¥‘% ˜ ©Ëº Ó º+½ºs›¥ @ajóqDGžDGóDGIKDGžõqH‡òJ^DFžrH‡JKõ†LO™8E”œ
˜ ˜Qs ¥
Ù É © % ©Ëºi© ¼¨Ž¥
% ˜ ©Ëºi© ¼¨Ž¥! ¥3£ º
¨
ð
žJ*›JKH#JKL‡óqDFžJMï?J1
ŸR™{H#DGð†žRïŽãñdð† L?H‡òJ*›5ž™8óqD[ôKâï?ð†ñRH‡òJ*€™†L‡™†ó¡
JKH#JML‡ï!DGžDFóә8õ
DFžR™8L‡qH#DGóJ
œ
¤
&
#" ' ‚$( ¥ £ ø°òJKL‡J ") Ù % % É ©7 ˜ r¥
%$
ã
¡
' +*
¥
qó ™8H#L‡D’ömDGïMœ
Ù
EGDGÇ ó *
/
,.-
, É ©/% ˜ 8
© º r¼¨¥ˆ% ˜ Ë
© º ¼ ¨Ž¥10ö ˜ r¥
$
$
â D[ï™ w EG™8H#JML›JKH#JKL‡óqDFžR™8žrHð8ñ=ï#DGžõ†EGJ*€™†L
|>JB™†ï‡ï#ŸóqJ!H#òJš|šC:
H#D[ô²EGJÖ·s™8ŸRï#ï#DG™†ž)ñdŸžô®H‡DFð
žï
% Ó B˜ Ò º Ò º¨Žt¥ ¥ ˜ 32s¥ "J( JKö5€ Â-˜BÒzÂ4 ¥ §2 É3 ˜ ¤c£r¥
ø°òJML#JwH#òJ 2™†L#D[™{H‡DFð
ž™8E~€™†L‡™†óqJ²H#JML‡ï,™†L#JwH#òJÏã óJc™8ž 4 ¢
iï ŸR™8L‡JM›ø°DG›H#5
ò 2;™8žR›Ó™8óq⠀EGD’H‡Ÿ›J É tA !òJ&›â yD 5uJML#JMžrH#D[™8E1J ŸR™ H#DGð†žRï°ñdð†L*H#òD[ïB™†žï‡™{H#I-™†L#J^õ
yD JKžDGž ¤21 o€A !òJ`DGžD’H‡DG™†EôKð†ž›yD H#DGð†žRï&™{qH ¨ Â76 £j™8L‡8J 2 ¥,Ÿ ¨¢ 4 ¥ Ò ™8ž› É ¥ú£ÓDGž“ð†LO›JKL
H#ð L#JMõ
™†DFžÛH‡òJ>ôKð†L‡L#Jcô®2H p EGDGóDFHMA îoHmñdð†EGEFð{ø*ïjñdL#ð
ó u uA s
H#òR™{H™{HEGð{øÀH‡JKóq€uJKLO™{H#ŸL#J
¢8H#òJ |sCõ†ð5JMïŽH‡ðsH#òJ*EGð{øaJMï'HJMž JKL‡õ†“ø!™ †J`ñdŸžô²H#DGð†ž~ø°D’H‡òDGžH‡ò£J {™8L‡DG™8H#DGð†ž™†EŽ÷R™†ï#DGïMŽA ð†L-™8ž
D[ï'ð
EG™8H#JM›™{H#ð
ó:ð†L&óqð
EFJcô²ŸEGJ`H‡òD[ï&ø°DGEFE÷uJ™)÷Rð
Ÿž›ïHO™{H#J
¢½DFž
ô²ð
žrH#LO™†ï'HH‡ð&H‡òJ*›JKEGðôK™†EFDGIKJc›`ï'H‡™{H‡J!ð8ñH‡ò{J p |sC~A ñdŸL#H#òJKL
›D[ï#ôKŸï‡ï'DGð†ž ð†ñH#òJ |šC €L‡ð†€uJKL#H#DGJMïBDGïšõ†D †JMž DGž ¤c1 o:A 9*ð†H#J
H#òR™{HH#òJcï'Jܞð›JMï™8L‡J)ð
žEG>ŸRï'Jc›0H#ð~›JKH#JKL‡óqDFžJ)H‡òJmžð5›™8E
L‡JMï'H#L‡DGô²H#DGð†žÓDGž u uA ˜ î#î®A ¡5¥OtA !òJBôKð†óq€EGJ²H‡J&€uð8H#JMžrH#D[™8EuDGïH‡™†û†JKž
DGž
H‡ð ™†ôMô²ð†Ÿž
H^DGž~H#òJӀR™{H#ò~DGžrH#JKõ
L‡™†E™†ô²H#DGð†ž0™†ï^›D[ï‡ô²Ÿï‡ï'Jc›>DFž
›JKH‡™8DGEDGž oA
;
‡Ö——<$•š;—>=@?A›”WœJ’2 ’Ÿ”œ7?@˜
!òJžrŸóJML#D[ôK™†EDGóq€EGJKóqJKžrH‡™8H#DGð†žÐð8ñ*H‡òJ p î'C óJKH#òð›
L‡J+rŸDGL#Jcï&ð
žJ`H‡ðmóә†û†J}ï#J
JKLO™8E™8€€L#ð2öDGóq™8H#DGð†žïMAšî6ž™†ôMô²ŸLO™
ô²DGJMïôK™8ž÷uJ&ôK™†Ÿï'Jc›`÷5ïHO™{H#D[ï'H#D[ôK™8EJKL‡L#ð
L‡ï=ñdL#ð
ó%H‡òJ&C DFžrH‡6J õ†LO™{H‡DFð
ž¢DGž™†ôMô²ŸLO™†ôKDFJcï!DFžH‡òJ-ž5ŸóqJKL‡D[ôK™8EGEG)›J²H‡JKL‡óqDFžJc›€™8DGL
›JMžï'DFHóә8H#L‡DGôKJMïM¢™“›JM€RJMž›JKžRô²Jjð
žH‡òJÓH‡DFóqJjï'H#JK€0ð†ñH‡òJ
€™8H#òÀDGžrH#JKõ
L‡™†E÷uJMôK™†Ÿï#J)ð8Šñ ¾!”÷u𛁠˜ ¾ ,¡r¥-ô²ð
L#L‡JKE[™{H‡DFð
žïK¢
žDFH#Jï'DGIKJ}6J 5½JMô²H‡ïM¢½™†ž›“žð›™†E=JML#L‡ð†LOï!ñdL‡ð†óՙ8€€L#ð2öDGóq™8H#DGð†žï
DGžjH#òJ*H#L‡D[™8E½›JKžï#DFHóә8H#L‡D’öYtA !òJKDGLa6J 5½JMô®HOïð
žÓH#òJš™
ôKô²ŸL‡™
ô²
ð8ñH#òJÓôKð†óq€ŸH‡JM›H#òJML#óqð›5ž™8óqD[ôq™ †JKLO™8õ
JMï*™†L#£J rŸ™8žrH‡D’HO™ H#D †JMEF)JMï'H#DGóq™8H#Jc›mDGžÜH#òD[ï*ï#JMô²H#DGð†žA
w H‡™8H#D[ïH‡DGôM™8EJML#L‡ð†LOïšDFž~H‡òJÓJMï'H#DGóә{H#ð
L‡ï^ñdð†LsH#òJÓH#òJML#óqð›; ž™†óD[¡ô ŸR™8žrH#DFH#DGJM8L‡J}ôM™8E[ô²ŸE[™{H‡JM›ñdL‡ð†ó:H‡òJ}÷EFðôOû ™ †JML‡™†õ†Jcï
õ†JMžJKLO™{H‡JM›÷r H#òJjCßï'DGó`ŸEG™8H#DGð†žïMŽA !òJÓôKð†L‡L#JMEG™8H#DGð†žïB÷RJ HøaJKJKž ÷EFðôOû†L#J~HO™8û†JMž DFžrH‡ð ™†ôMô²ð†Ÿž
H ÷5ú€RJML'ñdð
L#óqDGžõ ™
÷EGðôOûrDGžõš™8ž™†EFï#DGï ¤c¡ ”A !òJaL#Jcï'ŸE’H‡DFžõBJKL‡L#ð
L=÷™†L‡ï ˜ ð
žJaï'H‡™†ž ›™†L‡›“›+J 5DG™8H#DGð†žu¥!™†L#J`õ†D †JKžÜñdð
LB™8EGE=ð
÷ï#JKiL 2™†÷EGJMï!H‡òL#ð
Ÿõ†òð†ŸH
H#òDGïӀR™8€uJKL)™
ïәž5Ÿó}÷RJMLjDGžÐ€R™8L‡JKžrH#òJcï'D[ïqL‡J²ñdJKL‡L‡DFžõH#ð~H‡òJ
EGJM™†ï'H*ï'DGõ†žïD RôM™8žrH*›DGõ†DFHMA
î6ž H‡òJñdð†EGEGð{ø°DFžõ0›D[ï‡ô²Ÿï‡ï'DGð†ž=¢øaJ ô²ð†óq€™†L#JmH#òJ“DFžrH#JML#žR™8E
JKžJKL‡õ†j™8žR›jH‡òJ^€L‡JMï‡ï'ŸL‡JBôM™8E[ô²ŸE[™{H‡JM›mŸï#DFžõH‡ò‚J 5DFL‡DG™†EuH#òJMŸð L‡JKóœ
˜ ¤
¤2¥
¡ BED¡¥ G F ×
C
ø°òJML#J DsD[ïH‡òÐJ ð†EGŸóqJð8ñH‡òJï#DGó`Ÿã E[™{H‡DFð
ž`ô²JMEFE”¢ FÏH#òJû5DFžJ²H#D[ô
JKžJKL‡õ†)™†ž!
› ×H#òJ-€uð8H‡JKžrH#D[™8E=JKžJML#õ
†A ôMô²ŸLO™{H‡J^JMï'H#DGóә{H#DGð†ž
ð8ñBH#òJ“€L#Jcï#ï#ŸL‡JmL‡+J rŸDGL#Jcïq™~òDFõ
òЙ
ôKôKŸL‡™
ô²0DGž H‡òJ“û5DFžJ²H#D[ô
™8žR›0H#òJm€uð8H‡JKžrH#D[™8E!JKžJKL‡õ†DGJMï}÷RJcôK™8ŸRï'J)H#òJM0H#JMž›0H‡ð>ôM™8žôKJKE
ð†ŸHMA?î6žjH‡òJ^óqð†EGJMôKŸEG™†LL‡JKõ
DFóqJs™{H°EGð{ø ›JKžRï'DFH†¢5÷uð8H#òÜH‡JKL‡óqïM¢
›ð
óDGž™8H#JM› ÷rDGžrH#LO™ oóð
EFJcô²ŸE[™8LBô²ð†žrH‡L#DG÷ŸH‡DFð
žïK¢½ôK™†žô²JME=H‡ðm™
E[™8L‡õ†JÓJ²ö5H‡JKžrH`EGJM™ 5DFžõ“÷RJMòDFžR›>H#òJmóð
EFJcô²ŸE[™8L`õ
™†ï-€L#Jcï#ï#ŸL‡J†¢
ø°òDGôOòÀD[ï}ó`ŸôOòÀEGJMï‡ï^H‡ò™8žÀH#òJÜDFžrH‡JKLZ”óqð†EGJMôKŸE[™8L^ñdð
L‡ôKJMïMA ï
™~L‡JMï#ŸEFHM¢aH#òJ €L‡JMï‡ï'ŸL‡J“D[ïK¢!DGž3õ†JKžJKLO™8E”¢aï#DFõ
žyD RôK™†ž
H‡EF óqð†L‡J
ï#JKžRï'DFH#D †JH‡ð ™8€€L#ð2öDGóq™8H#DGð†žïH‡ò™8ž3ð†H#òJM2L rŸ™8žrH‡D’H‡DFJcï)ï#ŸôOò
™
ïaH#òJ^DGžrH#JML#ž™†EYJKžJML#õ
†A
–ÿˆQKX[T°ƒ*U#V
k'X[b[g8HjQcb[T'XJI
2.0
M
1.5
Energy error (eV)
!òJ^žð
L#ó
2K+V
E−Eexact
1.0
P
0.5
0.0
−0.5
−1.0
K
0
L
1
O nA
order
M
2
N
3
QSR.TVUXWZY[]\\_^Z`aC\bdc!e^[email protected]^gtsaGeqsiCugc%iCkvewZx8qsciGy
tzaexfdw{bhfh`iC|xudaGeir}^gc.qsuZ|~fhq€7x`xue%iC`fhx`c3‚ƒq€ujewZxEx„{y
… aGugcq€iuVkiC`r^Ztza~†>W]kiC`‡ewZxˆaC\‰eq€iu5aGugf~xuZx`|CbUvŠ%wZx]\aGtz\_^hy
tzaexf‹WCŒŽ}‘’x_„ZaC\_e“aGts^Zx”x•{^gaCtsc–x`i—maGugf˜ewgxˆfhx“{qzaeq€iu
k`iCr™ewgx‡x_„Za\‰e … iGexu{eqzaGtxuZx`|bˆiCk›š]Wœh WžxŸ aG`x‡cwZi¡¢uEkiC`
fZqJ#x`xu{e8iC`fhx`cˆk`irc.qsr^gtsaGeqsiCugc8aGeE£¥¤¦†§§§C§¨©^gcq€ug|
ª#«›¬ ¤­†>§C®¨~U
R1kEiCuZx¯iCugt€b°^Xc.x>f°ewZx±gaG`x … iCexu{eqsaCt”aCc~qsu³²•7U‡W´‘ewZx
`
s
q
… r~qJeq€“x]a …Z… `i„hqsr~aGeqsiCuVkiC`ewgxˆaC\_eqsiCu7—‰µCewZxE\_iCu“x`|CxuX\_x
¡iC^gtsfV±7x]“Cx`b˜c.tsi¡Ž¶€†·G¸7aGuXf~¡i^ZtsfV`xc^Zt€e‡q€u‹aCu5x_„e`xr~xt€b
qsuZx¹5\q€xu{e@r5aGub{y … aC`.eqs\t€xƒcq€r˜^ZtsaGeqsiCugcUºR»uXc!exaCf›µ8¡x°u^hy
r~x`qz\aCt€tsbVciCts“Cx”ewZxˆe!¡iCy … aG`eqz\_tsx … `i±Ztsxr¼¡¢qJew‹ewZxˆr5aGe`qJ„
c•{^gaG`qsuZ|%ex>\wZuZqz•^gxˆ¶€†>½¸1Uv¾]^Zr~x`qs\aGt{`x … `xcxu{eaGeqsiCugc3iCkhewZx
x„ZaC\‰e … aGqs`8fhxuXc.q€e!b¯r~aGe`qs\xc¿aG`x˜c.ei`x>fÀqsuÀeaC±Ztsxc¿^gcxf±b
ewZx]l‡R.n@o°cqsr^Ztzaeq€iu … `i|C`aGrÁ±bx„ … aGugfZq€uZ|8qsu~ewgxˆcr~aCt€t
“aC`qzaG±Ztsxc¢ÂaGugfÄÃgY
Å ‘’ÆÇ.ÆÈÊÉ ª —¤
¡¢wgx`x
Ó8¤
†
W
†
¶ Å Ë ‘ÌÉ ª v
—  7
Å Ë ‘’ÌÈÊÉ ª —ʸ
W X
Ð
¼Ï ÍGÎ Ï
Å Ð Ò Ô‘ ÓÉ ª —Ã{Õ Ò Â>ÕÖ Ð « Ò× Çؑ.†>W{—
Ë
Ð‰Ñ ¬ Ò Ñ
‘Ù ÆhÙ>pÙ Æ È Ù —Úˆ¤Û٠ƈšÆ È ÙÜäÛÙ ÆZٚÝÙ Æ È ÙÞÇ
‘.†ß—
aCugfàÆjaGuXfàÆ È fZxuZiCex~ewgx‹c.x … aG`aeq€iu@iGkewZx~e!¡i … aG`eqz\_tsxc
aGe:aCfá.a\_xu{e8eq€r~x‹ct€qz\_x>cU‹Š%wZx5a\\_^g`a\_biGkewgxcx~eaG±gt€x>cEqsc
\`^X\_qzaGt#kiC`ˆaGtst\_ir … ^hex>fj`xc^Zt€ecUâˆc.qsuZ|~ewgx … `x>\_ir … ^hex>f
*
€™†DFL›JKžï#D’Hóә{H‡L#D[ô²Jcï™8EGEFð{ø*ïð†žJ!H‡ð-JKóq€EGð{}™^ó}ŸôOòqEG™†L#õ
JKL
H#DGóqJ}ï'H#JM€ ÷RJcôK™†Ÿï'J`ð†žJ`ï'H‡™†L'HOï*ø°DFH#ò™)ï'ð
EFŸH‡DFð
ž“ð8ñ?H‡òJ-HøaðŸ
€™†L'H‡DGôKEFJ°€L‡ð†÷EFJMóÜAŽDFõRA
sï#òð{ø*ïòð{ø ™
ôKôKŸL‡™8H#JaH#òDGïóJKH#òð›
D[ïKŠA !òJ`DGž
H‡JKL‡ž™8EJKžJML#õ
)ð†ñ™8ž“D[ï'ð
EG™8H#JM›ò5›L‡ð†õ
JKž“™{H‡ð†óՙ{H
ï#hŸ ãjô²DGJKžrH#EGBEGð{øH#JKóq€uJKLO™{H‡ŸL#J ˜ þ ¥ ¤c££†£
£ `¥DGž`™!E[™8L‡õ†J?÷uð2ö
’˜ ä ¥ Ÿ
35¥DGïôKð†óq€™†L#Jc›`ø°DFH#òqH‡òJ°J²ö™†ô²Hõ†L‡ð†ŸžR›}ï'H‡™8H#J°JKžJKL‡õ†
ð8ñ  ¤c¡ 3?J A !òJ*H‡JKóq€RJML‡™8H#ŸL‡J&ø!™†ïôOòð
ï#JKžÓEGð{ø3JKžð†Ÿõ
òjï'ð
H#òR™{H*J²öôKD’H‡JM›ïHO™{H‡JMï°ôK™†žm÷uJ^žJMõ†EGJMô®H‡JM͛ ¼H#òJ-ôKð†žrH#L‡DF÷ŸH#DGð†žmH#ð
H#òJ^JKžJML#õ
ÓñdL#ð
óH‡òJ-ðôKôKŸ€™{H‡DFð
žmð†ñH‡ò‚J LOï'H!JKöô²DFH#JM›“ï'H‡™8H#J
D[ï svå ¤M£ "7æYJ ™{HH#òDGïH‡JKóq€uJKLO™{H#ŸL#J
A EGï#ð^ï'òð{ø°žD[ï?òð{ø øaJKEGE
H#òJ-û5DFžJKH#D[ô-JMžJKL‡õ†Ä F™8ž›ÜH‡òJ`€uð8H‡JKžrH#D[™8EJKžJML#õ
' ×Ï{H‡DGï'ñd
H#òqJ 5DGL#D[™8ERH#òJMð†L‡JKóG F × ¥;£¢rH#ò5Ÿï!›JKH#JML#óqDGžDFžõ-H#òJš™
ô ô²ŸL‡™
ô²Üø°D’H‡òø°òD[ôOò“Ó H‡òJ}€L#Jcï#ï#ŸL‡J}ôK™†ž ÷uJ›JKH#JML#óqDGžJM›Y‚A ð†L
™ÜH#DGóqJmï'H#JM€0ð8€ñ ê)" ¥ ã ¤M£ ç6q¢H#òJ)™†ž™8EGï'D[ï-ï#òð{ø*ï-!
™ rŸD[ôOû
ô²ð
ž †JKL‡õ†JMžô²Jø°D’H‡òH#òJ°ð
L‡›JML?ð8ñRH#JKL‡óÓïô²ð
žï#DG›JML#Jc›-DGžH#òJ*™
ô H#DGð†žÜJ²ö€™†žï#DFð
ž u uA ˜ ¤2 ¥OmA èBï'DGžõ}H#JKL‡óÓï!Ÿd€ é3ê¥;¡}L#Jc›ŸôKJMï
H#òJJKL‡L‡ð†LqH#ðУ £†¡
¡ ˜ ¡5¥rJ DGž;JKžJKL‡õ†Û™8ž›ÐH‡ð £ £†]¡ ˜ 5¥rJ ñdð†LqG F ×ÓA !òDGïô²ð
L#L‡JMï#€Rð
ž›ïsH‡ð™8ž DFž™
ôKôKŸL‡™
ô²DFž0H‡òJ
€L‡JMï‡ï'ŸL#J°1J ŸyD {™8EGJKžrHH‡ð}™^žð†ž oDFžrH‡JKLO™†ô®H‡DFžõ^óð
EFJcô²ŸE[™8Lõ
™†ï™{H
þ ¥ 4 3†£ 㠘 ¡†£r¥ qA
ëíì
X[\-U!k'bŠU…„î{U…„
U#Vî{U#VW'U
0.5
ð
ð
0.3
[X VrXlbŠU!‹rXõôKU°ƒ*U…„
U#Vî{U#VW'U
!òJJMï'H#DGóә{H‡DFð
ž ð8ñBH#òJ'žD’H‡Jï#DGIKJÜJKL‡L#ð
L‡ï}DGïóqð†L‡J›DJã£
ôKŸEFH*H#ðܙ†ï‡ï'Jcï#ï!÷uJMôM™8Ÿï#J^H#òJ`žJMJM›Jc› p î'C ï#DFó}ŸEG™8H#DGð†žï&™8L‡J
ôKð†óq€ŸHO™{H‡DFð
ž™8EGEF ó`ŸôOòÛóqð†L‡J“›JKóә8žR›DFžõA !òJ“L‡+J rŸDGL#Jc›
ôKð†óq€ŸH‡JKLH#DGóJBDFžRô²L‡JM™†ï#JMïL‡™†€DG›EFø°D’H‡òÓH#òJ&ž5Ÿó`÷uJKLað8ñY€™†L H‡DGôKEFJcï^óә8û5DGžõ“D’HôOò™8EGEFJMžõ†DGžõÜH#ð“ð
÷H‡™†DFžÀôKð†ž †JML#õ
JM›L#Jcï'ŸEFH‡ï
ñdð
L°€™{H‡òï°ô²ð
L#L‡JMï#€uð†ž›DGžõ}H#ðqE[™8L‡õ†J^ï'ï'H#JMóqïMA
CðrïH&L‡JMï#ŸEFH‡ï*ñdL#ð
ó×óә8ž5; o÷Rð›ï'DGó`ŸEG™8H#DGð†žï&L#JM€Rð
L'H‡JM›DGž
H‡òD[ïmøað†L‡ûÐøJML#J>ôK™8E[ô²ŸEG™8H#JM›;ø°D’H‡ò ¾ ¥ ¡
0€™8DGL‡ïmð8ñ}JKEGJMô H‡L#ð
žï^™8žR›€L‡ð8H‡ð†žïsDGž0™Ü€RJML#DGð›DGôM™8EGEFL#JM€RJc™{H#Jc›~ï'DGó`ŸE[™{H‡DFð
ž
ôKJKEGE…tA ð`ï'H#Ÿ›qH‡òJ&J 5uJcô®H!ð†„ž ¾0¢5øaJ*€uJKL#ñdð†L‡óJc›jï#DFó}ŸEG™8H#DGð†žï
ñdð
L ¾ ¥:+¤ 3™8ž
› 34*܀R™8DGL‡ïsð†ña€L‡ð8H‡ð†žï^™†ž›JKEGJMô®H‡L#ð
žïšñdð†L}™
›JKžï#D’H ð8‚ñ . 0 ¥ 30™†ž›Ðþ , ¤c££†£
£ q
A |JôOòð
ï#JH#òJ
òDFõ
òJMï'H*›JKžï#DFHjŸž›JML*ô²ð
žï'D[›JML‡™8H#DGð†ž)÷uJMôM™8Ÿï#Jsð†žJsJKö5€uJMô²H‡ï
H‡ò‚J žD’H‡J}ï#DFIMJ`›JK€uJKžR›JKžôKJ-H‡ðj÷RJ`EG™†L#õ
JMï'H°H#òJML#J`›ŸJ-H‡ðÓH#òJ
ï'H#L‡ð†žõ†JKL!DGžrH#JKLO™†ô²H#DGð†žm÷RJKHøJMJKžÜH#òJ-™8H#ð
óqïMA
òÚó
0.2
0.2
0.1
0.1
0.0
0.5
1.0
−1
6
τ (10 K)
2.0
Žî·Ac¡œ½!òJJML#L‡ð†LYDGž^H#òJÐ
5DFL‡D[™8E†™
ï™!ñdŸžô²H#DGð†ž-ð†ñ5H#òJžrŸó`÷uJKL
ð8ñ^H‡DFóqJ>ï'EGDGôKJMïjñdð†L™8ž3D[ï'ð
EG™8H#JM›Ûò5›L‡ð†õ
JKžÛóqð†EGJMô²ŸEFJ
A ! òJ
ô²E[™†ï‡ï#DGôM™8E½ž5Ÿô²EGJKD=™†L#Jz öJc›Ü™8H°H#òJ^J1r ŸDFEGDG÷L#DGŸó×÷Rð
ž›ÜEFJMžõ8H‡ò¢
H#ò5Ÿï&H#òJ`J²ö™
ô®HŠ{
™8EGŸJ`ñdð†Lš CF Ï
× D[ï&IMJKL‡ðj™{Hs™jï'ŸZãÓôKDFJMžrH#EG
EGð{ø;H#JMóq€RJML‡™8H#ŸL‡J†A
ã
u óq€EGð{rDGžõqH‡òJ`€™†DFLš™8€€L#ð2öDGóq™8H#DGð†žÜð8ñ?H‡òJ}›JMžï#D’HÜóә
H#L‡DFöq›ð5Jcïžð†HDGžô²EGŸ›Jšô²ð†L‡L‡JKE[™{H#DGð†žqJ 5uJcô®H‡ïñdð†LH#òL‡JKJ&ð†Lóqð
L#J
€™†L'H‡DGôKEFJcï ˜ ñdð
LJ²ö™†ó€EFJ*÷uJ²HøaJKJMžÓð†žJ&JKEGJMô®H‡L#ð
žÓ™8ž›Høað-€L‡Ÿð H#ð
žï®¥O!
A |>Jjžð{ø JMï'H#DGóә{H#J)òð{øÏï'óә8EGEH‡òJÓH‡DFóqJmï'H#JM€0ó`Ÿï'H
÷uJÓH#ð ð
÷H‡™†DFž0™“õ
yD JKž0™†ôMô²ŸLO™†ôK“ñdð†L}™8ž0D[ï'ð
EG™8H#JM›>óqð†EGJMôKŸEGJ†A
ŽDFõRA°¡ ï#òð{ø*ïmL#Jcï'ŸEFH‡ï)ñdð†L“›yD 5½JKL‡JKžrHmH‡DFóqJ~ïH‡JK€ï™†ž›3H‡JK¡
ó €uJKLO™{H#ŸL#Jcï-ø°DFH#òÀH‡òJܞrŸRô²EGJKDaû†JK€ŽH öJc›À™{HH#òJm+J rŸDGEFDG÷L‡DFŸó
0.0
∆P/P
ï
2K+V (eV)
0.4
T=3906 K
T=1953 K
€uð
ï#DFH#DGð†ž ð†ññ¦¥¤4 *
£
£4AxL‡ð†óH‡òJŽ
5DGL#D[™8EH#òJKð†L‡JKó¢½DFHšñdð
Eï
EGð{ø*ïaH#òR™{Hš CF × ¥ £Ó™8HB™Óï'ŸZãÓôKDFJMžrH#EG)EGð{ø H‡JKóq€RJML‡™8H#ŸL‡J†A
!òJmJKö™
ô®HJKžJML#õ
€uJKLә{H‡ð†ó D[ï  ¤ ü s ¡?J ¤+3”A™!òJÜþ
›JK€uJKž›JMžô²J}DGïšã ï#óq™†EFEŽï'Ÿõ†õ†JcïH‡DFžõqH#ò™8H&H#òJ`JKEGJMô²H#L‡ð†žïB™8L‡J-DGž
H‡òJ°õ†L‡ð†Ÿž›}ï'H‡™8H#J
ˆA ƒ&ð{ø+J †JKLc¢{ð†ž€J ž›Ó ï™^ï#DGõ†žyD RôK™†žrH?›JK€uJKž ›JKžôKJ}ð
žH‡òJ`H‡DFóqJjï'H#JM€A è&ï#DGžõ ê)" ¥w2 0¤M£ çÏL‡JM›ŸRô²JMï
H‡òJÓJKL‡L‡ð†LšDFž>H#òJÓJKžJML#õ
 €RJML-™{H‡ð†óÕH‡ð £ £†4¡ 3 ˜ ¡5¥?J ™8ž›DGž
F ×H‡ð £ 4£ †£ ˜ +¤ 35¥rJ =A !òJÓH#DGóqJ)ïH‡JK€0JML#L‡ð†L^D[ï-E[™8L‡õ†JML
C
H‡ò™8žÛH‡òJ JML#L‡ð†LOïð8ñsH#òJDFž™
ôKôKŸL‡™
ô²DGJMïqDGžÛH#òJ€™8DGL)›JMžï'DFH
óә8H#ãL‡DGôKJMï›DGï‡ô²ŸRï#ï#JM› ™8÷uð †J†™
A !òJÜJKL‡L‡ð†L`DGžÐC F × ôKð†L‡L#J ï#€uð†ž›ïH‡ð™}€L‡JMï‡ï'ŸL‡J&ð†ñ™8žmžð†ž ”DGžrH#JKLO™†ô²H#DGžõ-óqð†EGJMôKŸE[™8Laõ
™†ï
™8Hšþ ¥ s £
£ ˜ ¤c£†£r¥ q¢ø°òD[ôOò€L‡ð 5DG›JMïBŸïšø°D’H‡ò™8㠞>™8€€L#ð2öyD óә8H#J°EGDFóqDFHð8ñY™†ôKôKŸLO™†ô²^DGžH#òJ°1J rŸ™{H‡DFð
ž}ð†ñ½Ó ï'H‡™8H#J*ôK™†EGôKŸE[™{H#Jc›
ñdL‡ð†ó óq™†ž5] o€™†L'H‡DGôKEFJsï'DGó`ŸEG™8H#DGð†žï!ø°DFH#ò ê)" ¥;¡ >¤MC£ ç+qA
−0.1
(P16−P64)/P64
(P32−P64)/P64
−0.2
−0.3
10000
ö
100000
ö
T (K)
÷
Žî ·$A *Ð
œ ŽDGžD’H‡J`ï#DFIMJ-JKL‡L#ð
L!ð8ñH#òJ`€L#Jcï#ï#ŸL‡J^™†ï*™ñdŸžRô®H#DGð†ž“ð†ñ
H‡JKóq€uJKLO™{H#ŸL#J*L‡JKE[™{H‡Dy
J!H#ðï'DGó`ŸE[™{H‡DFð
žï?ø°DFH#ò'¾ ¥ö3Ÿ*-€R™8DGL‡ï?ð†ñ
€L#ð†H#ð†žRïa™†ž›ÜJKEGJMô²H#L‡ð†žï!™{H&™q›JMžï#D’Hjð†ˆñ . 0 ¥ 3A
!ò=
J žDFH#Jï'DGIKJ›JM€RJMž›JKžRô²JÜð8ñ*H‡òJm€L#Jcï#ï#ŸL‡J†¢ï#òð{ø°žÀDGž
ü
0.4
10
Saumon & Chabrier
PIMC FP
PIMC VDM
10
ÿ
rS=2.6
1
E16−E64
E32−E64
0.2
∆E (eV)
2
rS=4.0
10
0.0
10
û
0
4
ý
10
þ
T (K)
ý
10
5
Žî·A3œ!òJBJ5uJcô®H°ð†ž)H#òJs€L‡JMï‡ï'ŸL#JBð8ñHøað›Dï5½JKL‡JKžrH!žð›™8E
−0.2
ï#ŸL#ñŠ™†ôKJMïMœ}ð†ñ°H#òJ)ñdL#JMJ)€™†L'H‡DGôKEFJ)›JKžï#D’H~óә{H‡L#DFö0™8ž›0ð†ñ°H#òJ
{™†L#D[™{H‡DFð
ž™8EY›JMžï'DFHjóә{H‡L#DFöYA
10000
ö
100000
ö
T (K)
÷
Žî ·A ü œ DGžDFH#Jšï'DGIKJBJKL‡L#ð
Lð8ñYH‡òJBDGžrH#JML#ž™†EJMžJKL‡õ†q™†ïa™sñdŸžô6
H#DGð†ž“ð†ñH‡JKóq€uJKLO™{H#ŸL#J-L‡JKE[™{H‡Dy
JšH#ð)ï#DFó}ŸE[™{H#DGð†žRï°ø°D’H‡ò˾ ¥ 3Ÿ*
€™†DFLOï!ð8ñŽ€™8L#H#D[ô²EGJMﰙ8H°™Ó›JKžï#D’H)ð8ñ . 0 ¥; 3A
DGõA ü ï'òð{ø*ïH#ò8
J žDFH#Jï#DFIMJ“JKL‡L#ð
LÓð8ñsH#òJ DFžrH‡JKL‡ž™8E*JMž JKL‡õ†
2A !òJ)ï#óә8EGEFJML-ï'ï'H#JMóqï`™8L‡Jóqð
L#Jjï'H#L‡ð†žõ
EF÷Rð
Ÿž›~÷5
™8€€L#ð2öDGóә{H#JMEFq£ à ^J €RJML°™{H#ð
ó¢r€L#ð
÷™8÷EG÷RJcôK™8ŸRï'Jšð8ñH‡òJ
DGž
H‡JKLO™†ô²H#DGð†žÐð8ñ^™>ôOòR™8L‡õ†JÜø°D’H‡òÐDFH‡ïjð{ø°ž DGóә8õ†J
A ð
LÓEFð{øaJKL
›JMžï'DFH#DGJMïM¢øaJsJ²ö€RJcô®H°H‡òDGï 2™†EFŸJBH‡ðÓ÷RJ-ï#óә8EGEFJMLMA
x _a]‰î2Qcet„c„5T6]‰IMXG\^Qcb[Xd]KV
î6ž0H#òJ™8÷uð
†J
¢øaJ)òR™
†Jjï'H#Ÿ›DGJM› ô²ð
ž
H‡L#ð
EFEGJM›0™†€€L‡ð2öDFóә
H#DGð†žRïKA‘!òJð†žEGÀŸžRô²ð†žrH‡L#ð
EFEGJM› ™8€€L‡ð2öDFóә8H#DGð†žÀDGžÐH#òJL‡J6
ï'H#L‡DGô²H#JM› p î'C óqJ²H#òð5› DGï*H#òJ}Ÿï'J`ð8ñ?H#L‡D[™8E›JKžï#D’HÜóә{H‡L#DFö
H#ð~ô²ð
žï'H#LO™8DGž0H#òJ€™8H#òïMA !òJžð›™†E!ï#ŸL#ñŠ™†ôKJMï™8L‡J)DGó€uð†ZL H‡™†žrH!ð
žEGjD’ñH#òJ^JMEFJcô®H‡L#ð
žï!™8L‡Jš›JMõ†JMžJKLO™{H‡J†œ™{H°EFð{ø;H#JKóq€uJKZL ™{H‡ŸL‡JMïšð†L^™{HsòDGõ†ò~›JKžRï'DFH#DGJMïM˜A ü°JcôK™†EFEŽH#òR™{H^DFžH#òDGïsøað†L‡ûøJ
ñdðô²Ÿïð
žÀò55›L#ð
õ†JKž0ð
žEG~™8H}EGð{ø›JKžRï'DFH†¢ø°òJKL‡JjH#òJmJMEFJcô H#L‡ð†žRï*™8L‡J^÷Rð
Ÿž›DGž™{H‡ð†óÓï*™†ž›óqð†EGJMô²ŸEFJcï*™8ž›òR™ †J-™qEGð{ø
ð†L}óqð5›JKLO™{H#Jm›JKõ
JKžJML‡™
ô²†A u †JKžÀ™8H`EGð{ø ›JKžï#D’H
¢?ð†žJmïH‡DFEGE
žJMJM›ïs™jžð5›™8E?ï'ŸL'ñŠ™
ô²J`DGžð
L‡›JKL*H‡ðm€L#+J †JKžrHBH#òJ}ñdð†L‡óә{H#DGð†ž
ð8ñšŸž€ò5ï#DGôM™8E°ô²EGŸï'H#JKLOïEFDGû†J " ( ™8ž› " # ð
LqJ †JMžÀH‡òJ“ô²ð†yE E[™8€ï#Jqð8ñaH#òJÓJMž
H‡DFL‡Jjï#5ï'H#JMó¢=÷ŸH^H‡òJӀL‡JMôKDGï#Jjï'òR™8€uJð†ñH‡òJ
žð›JcïD[ïžð†HDFóq€uð†L#H‡™†ž
Ha™{HEGð{ø3›JKžï#DFH™
ïï#òð{ø°žqDF2ž ŽDGõ;A 3A
ð†óq€™†L#DGžË
õ p ™†ž› |sCæžð›Jcï^ñdð†ÖL .10„¥ 3¢Žð†žJ)ð†žEG
ž›ï=›yD 5uJML#JMžô²JcïDGžsH#òJ€L‡JMï‡ï'ŸL‡Jñdð†L=þ ýú¤ ü 3r ü q¢Kø°òDGôOò^D[ï
™8€€L#ð2öDGóә{H#JMEF“ø°òJKL‡J†¢=™8H^H#òD[ï^›JKžRï'DFH†¢=H#òJjï#ïH‡JKó ï#òð{ø*ï
™~ï'DGõ†žïD RôM™8žrHqóð
EFJcô²ŸE[™8LÓï#DFõ
ž™{H‡ŸL‡J ˜ ï'JMJï#JMô²H#DGð†žÐî'î#î@™8ž›
ŽDGõAu¤+35¥OAŽî6žjH#òDGïL#JMõ†DGóqJ†¢ p
žð›JMïï'ï'H#JMóq™8H#D[ôK™†EFEGqEFJc™†›H#ð
ә H#ð5ð)òDGõ†ò“€L#Jcï#ï#ŸL‡J†¢ø°òDFEGJ}ï#DFó}ŸE[™{H#DGð†žRï*ø°DFH#ò |šCžð›JMï
ï'H‡™2ô²EGð
ï#JKL?H‡ð-H‡òJ*€L‡JM›D[ô®H‡DFð
žÓð8ñ=™^ï#JKóqDy”JMó€DFL‡DGôM™8EuôOòJKóqD[ôK™8E
óqð›JME ¤”A H}™ EFð{øaJKL-›JMžï#D’H
¢¸.0„¥ *R¢L‡JMï#ŸEFH‡ïsñdL‡ð†ó p
™†ž› |šC žð›JMïq™†õ†L‡JKJjø°DFH#òDGžÀH‡òJJKL‡L#ð
L`÷™†L‡ïM
A !òJܛD’?ñ −5
Saumon & Chabrier
PIMC FP
PIMC VDM
E (eV)
−0.4
−0.6
3
P (GPa)
ŽDFõRA *¢?D[ïï#óә8EGE°™{HqòDFõ
ò0H#JMóq€RJML‡™8H#ŸL‡JMï÷ŸHqõ†L‡ð{ø*ï^H‡ð>™†€ € L‡ð2öDFóә{H‡JKEGË* ˜ ¥Zø՞JM™†L-þ ¥¡†££
£†£qAÓî6ž>H‡òDGï`L#JMõ†DGóqJ†¢
H#òJBò5›L‡ð†õ†JMžÓŸž›JML#õ
ð5JMïï'H#L‡Ÿô²H#ŸLO™8E½ôOò™8žõ†JMïDFž
ð†E
rDGžõ^H‡òJ
ñdð†L‡óә{H‡DFð
ž^ð8ñR™8H#ð†óÓïM¢2ø°òDGôOò}™5½JMô®HH#òJa€L‡JMï‡ï'ŸL#J
A !òD[ïï'H#Ÿ›
€L‡ð 5DG›Jcï^Ÿï}ð†žEG>ø°D’H‡ò ™8žÀJcïH‡DFóә8H#Jjð†ñ°H#ò2J žDFH#Jmï#DGIKJm›6J €uJKž›JMžô²J
A ž JKö5H#LO™8€uð†E[™{H#DGð†ž~H‡ð ¾ 6úù øað†ŸE[›0L‡+J rŸDGL#J
ï#DFõ
žïD uôK™8žrH‡EFÓE[™8L‡õ†JMLï#5ï'H#JMóÓïK¢žð†H*ô²ŸL‡L#JMžrH#EG}ñdJc™†ï#DF÷EFJ^™{H!EGð{ø
H#JMóq€RJML‡™8H#ŸL‡JMïMA
−10
−15
0
10000
20000
T (K)
30000
40000
Žî·A s œŽî6žrH‡JKL‡ž™8E½JKžJKL‡õ†Óô²ð
ó€ŸH#Jc›)ø°DFH#ò p î'C3Ÿï#DFžõ}Høað
›Dï½5 JKL‡JKžrH&žð›™†E=ï#ŸL'ñŠ™
ô²JcïKœH#òJ^ñdL‡JKJ`€™8L#H#D[ô²EGJ-›JKžRï'DFHmóә8H#L‡D’ö
™†ž›)H#òJ‚{
™8L‡D[™{H#DGð†žR™8EY›JKžRï'DFH)óә{H‡L#DFöYA
ñdJML#JMžô²Jcï!DFžÜH‡òJ^DFžrH‡JKL‡ž™8EYJMžJKL‡õ†
¢5™
ï°ï'òð{ø°žmDGž!DGõA s ¢Ÿï#DFžõ
p ™†ž› |sC žð5›JMïj™†L#J“ï#DFõ
žïD uôK™8žrH‡EFÐï'óә8EGEGJKLqH#òR™8žÐH#òJ
€L#Jcï#ï#ŸL‡Jq›J 5DG™8H#DGð†žïMA v žJjJMD’H‡òJKÖL ž›ï}™8õ†L‡JKJMóqJKžrH-ø°D’H‡òDGž
H‡òJÜJKL‡L#ð
L`÷™†L‡ï}ð†L}H#ò™8H |sC žð›Jcï`€L#Jc›DGô²HEGð{øaJKLDFžrH#JML žR™8EJKžJML#õ
DFJcïK¢½ø°òD[ôOòø!™†ïBŸï#JM›DFž ¤ s H#ðï'òð{ø H#ò™8H |šC
žð5›JMï?™8L‡JH#òJ°óqð†L‡J°™†ôMô²ŸLO™{H‡Jžð›™†Eï'ŸL'ñŠ™
ô²J†ˆA !òJ°ð†÷Rï'JMZL JM›
JMžJKL‡õ†j›ïD 5½JKL‡JKžôKJMﰛD[›Üžð8H*JKöô²JKJc›m@£ F¤=J €uJKL&™8H#ð†óA
3
ä®ä®ä²å 運R쎍è
‡
Molecular gas
Fermi gas
Ideal
Saumon & Chabrier
25
PIMC
20
15
E (eV)
gas
Molecular
Atomic gas
−11
FVT
Saumon & Chabrier
−12
PIMC
ActEx
−13
−14
−15
−16
0
10000
T (K)
20000
Žî·A)œ!î6žrH#JML#ž™†E=JMžJKL‡õ†m€RJMLš™8H#ð†ó&
ïKA*H#JKóq€uJKLO™{H‡ŸL#J-ñdð†Ls™
›JKžï#D’HÜð8ñ.0qw
¥ ¤c£j™†ïBï'òð{ø°ž“DFž8Ž DGõAJÓ
÷ŸHsòJKL‡J^ñdð
L&EGð{øJML
H‡JKóq€uJKLO™{H#ŸL#Jcïa™†EGï#ðDFžôKEFŸR›DFžõL‡JMï#ŸEFH‡ïañdL‡ð†óÏH‡òJ^™†ô²H#Dr
DFHjJKö;
€R™8žï#DFð
ž ¤+” A
.0{¥,¤M£@ £¢™†ï°ï#òð{ø°žmDGžDGõAAt!òJKL‡JšH#òJ w 3JKžJML#õ
DFJcï!™8L‡J
ø°DFH#òDFž`H#òJaJKL‡L#ð
L÷™†L‡ïð8ñH‡òJ p î'CL‡JMï#ŸE’HOïKA HòDGõ†òJKLH#JKó¡
€uJKLO™{H‡ŸL‡Jï#òð{ø°ž DGž Ž DGõA½ ¢YøJŽ ž›>ï'ï'H#JMóq™8H#D[ô}›J
5DG™8H#DGð†žï
ð†ñŸ€ÜH‡ð ü J €RJML*™{H#ð
óי8H!þ ¥ ü ££†£†£Ðq A ! òJK)DFž›DGôM™{H#J
H‡ò™{HH#òJ w  JKžJML#õ
DFJcï`™8L‡JjH‡ð5ðEGð{ø™{HòDFõ
òÀH‡JKóq€RJML‡™8H#ŸL‡JMï
™†ž›“H‡ð5ðmòDGõ†ò>™{HsDFžrH‡JKL‡óJc›D[™{H#J}H#JMóq€RJML‡™8H#ŸL‡JMï ˜ ï#JKJ£Ž DFõRA)5 ¥OA
v žJB€uð
ï‡ï'DG÷EGJ&JKö5€EG™†ž™{H‡DFð
žjñdð†LH#òJs›J5
DG™8H#DGð†žïa™{H!òDGõ†ò)H#JKó¡
€uJKLO™{H‡ŸL‡J°DGïH#ò™8HH#òJ w  óqð›JKEuŸž›JML#JcïH‡DFóә8H#JMïH#òJB›JKõ
L#JMJ
ð†ñDGð†žDGIM™8H#DGð†ž ˜ ï#JKJ-›D[ï‡ô²Ÿï‡ï'DGð†žmDFž 8£Š ¥OA
| J-™8E[ï'ðÓï'H#Ÿ›DGJM›ÜH‡òJMï#J-›J+r
D[™{H‡DFð
žï°™†ï°™ñdŸžô®H‡DFð
žÜð†ñ›JKž
>
ï#DFH†A!! òJmôKL#ðrï#ïo ð†
JKLBH#JMóq€RJML‡™8H#ŸL‡J†¢?™8÷uð†
JÓø°òDGôOò~H‡òJ w Ð
u€vxw Ÿž›JML#JcïH‡DFóә{H‡JMïsH‡òJjJMžJKL‡õ†
¢DGžô²L‡JM™
ï'Jcïsø°D’H‡òÀ›JKžRï'DFH†A
‹X<$š;”–s?ƒ?A”Wš;”W’
35
30
−10
E (eV)
ð†L&J †JMžEFð{øaJKL°›JMžï'DFH†¢H#òJ^žð5›JMï&™†L#JsEGJMï‡ï°L‡JKEGJ {™8žrH°÷RJ Kô ™†Ÿï#JqH#òJM÷uJMô²ð
óqJjð†žEGDGóq€Rð
L'HO™8žrH-DGžÀ™“ô²ð†EGEGDGï#DFð
ž~ð8ñaHøð
óqð†EGJMôKŸEFJcïK¢Žø°òD[ôOò0ðôKô²ŸL-EFJcï#ï^ñdL#J1
ŸJKžrH#EG>™8H-EFð{øaJKL-›JKžï#D’H
A
!òD[ï?H‡L#JMž›ÓôK™†žj™8E[ï'ð^÷uJ*Ÿž›JKLOïH‡ðrð›qDGžqH#JML#óÓïð†ñ½H#òJ&›JKõ†JMž
JKLO™†ôK“ð8ñaH#òJqJMEFJcô®H#L‡ð†žRïKA !òJӛJMõ†L‡JKJqð8ñ!›JKõ
JKžJML‡™
ô²“óә8žyD ñdJMï'H‡ïDFH‡ï#JKEFñRDGž}H#òJ!€™8H#ò`DGžrH#JMõ†LO™8Erñdð†L‡óә8EGDGï#ó,÷r-H#òJ!€L‡ð†÷™†÷DGïE DFHÓñdð†L!H‡òJsJKEGJMô®H‡L#ð
žïH#ðq÷uJ^DFž †ð
yE JM›)DFž™€RJML#ó}ŸH‡™8H#DGð†žA H
òDGõ†òH#JMó€uJKLO™{H‡ŸL‡J†¢YH‡òJӀ™{H‡òï^™8L‡¡J †JKL‡ ï#òð†L#H-™8ž›€RJML#ó}Ÿ H‡™8H#DGð†žï`™8L‡JÓL‡™†L#J
A H`EGð{øßH‡JKóq€RJML‡™8H#ŸL‡Jj™8žR›òDFõ
ò~›JKžï#D’H
¢
H#òJ܀R™{H#òRL#JÜEGð†žõ~™8ž› ôK™†ž ñdð
L#óEGð†žõ>€uJKL‡ó`ŸHO™{H#DGð†žÐô²; ô²EGJMïMqA ƒ&ð{ø+J †JML*DFžòr›L‡ð†õ
JKž“™{HšEFð{ø%›JKžï#D’H
¢H‡òJ€™{H‡òï&™†L#J
EGð5ôM™8EGDFIMJM›À›ŸJ)H‡ðH‡òJ™{H'H‡L‡™
ô®H‡DFð
ž0DFžÐ™{H#ð
óÓï}™†ž›Àóqð†EGJMôKŸEGJMï
™8žR›0€RJML#ó}ŸH‡™8H#DGð†žï™8L‡JjLO™8L‡J†A DGõAa¤mï#òð{ø*ï-H#ò™8H}H‡òJm€uJKZL ó`ŸH‡™{H‡DFð
ž €L‡ð†÷R™8÷DGEFDFH0ž+J †JKLqL‡JM™
ôOòJMï)¤ ø ñdð
¡L .0!¥ * ˜ ï#JKJ
Ž™8÷ARî#¥Oq
A ð†LBòDFõ
òJKLš›JKžRï'DFH#DGJMïM¢H‡òJ`€uJKL‡ó`ŸH‡™{H‡DFð
ž €L‡ð†÷™†÷DGïE DFHD[ï^DGžô²L‡JM™
ï'Jc›>™
ï^DGž›D[ôK™{H‡JM›~÷5 H‡òJmôKð†žrH#ð
ŸL^EGDFžJcïKA !òD[ï
D[ï)ô²ð
žï#DGï'H#JMž
Hjø°DFH#òÛH‡òJ“H‡JKóq€RJML‡™8H#ŸL‡J ™8žR›3›JKžï#DFH ›JM€RJMž ›JMžô²J-ð†ñ?H#òJ`žð›™8EJKL‡L#ð
L°DFž €L#Jcï#ï#ŸL‡J-™8ž›DGžrH#JKL‡ž™†E=JKžJKL‡õ†
›D[ï#ôKŸï‡ï'Jc›m™†÷Rð J†A
10
5
0
−5
20
−10
15
−15
−20
150000
10
Žî·AJœ!î6ž
H‡JKL‡ž™8EJKžJML#õ
)€uJKLs™{H‡ð†ó&
5ïMA°H‡JKóq€RJML‡™8H#ŸL‡J-ñdð
LB™
›JMžï'DFH`ð†ñJ. 0 ,
¥ ¤M£sôKð†óq€™8L‡DGžõšH#òJ w Ð urvxw= ¤ ø°DFH#ò p î'C
5
0
50000
100000
T (K)
E (eV)
ôK™†EGôKŸE[™{H#DGð†žRïKA
™†÷A5îõ†D †Jcï?H#òJšôKð†óq€EGJ²H#Jsï#J²H!ð8ñ=JMžJKL‡õ†DGJMï™8ž›)€L#Jcï#ï#ŸL‡JMï
™{ˆH 3*›JKžRï'DFH#DGJM8ž‚› °H#JKóq€uJKLO™{H‡ŸL#JcïK¸A |Jžð{ø0ô²ð†óq€™†L#JH‡òJMï#J
L‡JMï#ŸE’HOï&ø°DFH#ò>ï'+J †JML‡™†E=óqð›JKE[ïBñdð†Lšòr›L‡ð†õ
JKžqA |J÷uJKõ†DGžð
ŸL
›D[ï#ôKŸï‡ï'DGð†ž~÷5>ï'H#ŸR›5DFžõ H#òJjDGžrH#JML#ž™†EJMžJKL‡õ†€RJML`™{H‡ð†ó ™†ï
™)ñdŸžô®H‡DFð
žð†ñH#JMó€uJKLO™{H‡ŸL‡Jï#òð{ø°ž DGž ŽDGõ
ïM)A 2^¤†¤`ñdð†LBHøð
ï#JKEGJMô®H‡JM›3›JMžï#D’H‡DFJcïmôKð†L‡L#Jcï'€uð†ž›DFžõ>H‡ð .10¥ ¤M£ £0™8žR›; 3A
·šJKžJKLO™8EGEF
¢=øa£
J ž›~™ÜñŠ™8DGL#EGõ
ð5ð5›ð †JML‡™†EFE?™†õ†L‡JKJKóqJMž
H^ø°DFH#ò
H#òJ u€vxw ÷5 w  ¤ =ð †JMLH‡òJsJKžrH#DGL‡JBH‡JKóq€uJKLO™{H#ŸL#J^™8žR›m›JMž ï#D’HjLO™8žõ†J^›D[ï#ôKŸï#ï#JM›mDGžmH‡òD[ï°øð
L#û½A !òJ^™†õ†L‡JKJKóqJMž
H°D[ﰀ™†L H#D[ô²ŸEG™†L#EG õ
ðrð›ÛDGžÛH#òJóð
EFJcô²ŸE[™8Lm™8ž›Û™{H‡ð†óqD[ô“L#JMõ†DGóqJñdð†L
Molecular gas
0
Fermi gas
Ideal
Saumon & Chabrier
−5
PIMC
−10
−15
−20
0
50000
100000
150000
T (K)
Žî·Aa¤M£œ}î6žrH#JML#žR™8EJMžJKL‡õ†>€uJKL}™8H#ð
ó ïMA“H#JMóq€RJML‡™8H#ŸL‡J)™†ï
ï#òð{ø°žÜDFžŽ DFõRA@ ÷ŸH*òJML#Jšñdð
L&™q›JKžï#DFHjð8ñ.10{¥; 3A
s
−11
−12
14
40
10
rs
3
4
6
2.6
30
125000 K
−13
E (eV)
Molecular gas
Saumon & Chabrier
ActEx
FVT
PIMC VDM
PIMC FP
20
E (eV)
−14
−15
−16
10
PIMC
31250 K
0
−10
0
10000
T (K)
5000 K
20000
Žî·A¤†¤
œsî6ž
H‡JKL‡ž™8EJMžJKL‡õ† €uJKL-™8H#ð
ó ïKAH#JMóq€RJML‡™8H#ŸL‡Jñdð†L
™›JKžï#D’H~ð†ñŠ.10':
¥ 
3 ™†ïï#òð{ø°ž0DFž ŽDFõRA¤c£ ÷ŸHqòJML#J)ñdð†L
EGð{øJMLÓH#JMó€uJKLO™{H‡ŸL‡JMï)™†EGï#ð0DGžô²EGŸ›DGžõ L‡JMï#ŸEFH‡ïjñdL#ð
ó H‡òJ™
ô
H#D5
D’H J²ö€™†žï'DGð†ž ˜ ô®H u öR¥ ¤+B ™†ž› H#òJR ŸDG›‘{
™†L#D[™{H‡DFð
ž™8E
H#òJKð†L‡ ˜ & ¥ ¤1o A
Ð
H .0 ¥
& Chabrier
Saumon
ActEx
¤M@£ £¢{H#òJBô²L‡ð
ï‡Hï oð †JMLD[ï?žJc™8L s ££†£
£ 3ô²ð
ó€R™8L‡JM›}H#ð
M¤ ¡
££†£
£ ˜ ŽDFõRA¤M£r¥*™{Hx.10¥w 3A HšH#JMóq€RJML‡™8H#ŸL‡JMïš÷uJKEGð{ø
8££†£†£Ð~ñdð†Lˆ.10{¥; 3¢2ð†žJ™†EGï#ð€ž›ïï#ð†óqJï#óә8EGE
›J+
rD[™{H‡DFð
žï
Ÿ€ÜH#ðÓ£@ ü J €RJML&™{H‡ð†ó ˜ ŽDFõRA¤†¤{¥OA
DGõA?¤2 )ï#òð{ø*ïs™ô²ð
ó€R™8L‡DGï#ð†žð8ñJMžJKL‡õ†!
 ïMA›JKžï#D’H ñdð†L
ï#J †JML‡™†EH‡JKóq€RJML‡™8H#ŸL‡JMïMA~îoHqï#òð{ø*ï`H#ò™8H}H‡òJ w Ð u€vxw ð †JML JMï'H#DGóә{H‡JMï`H#òJmJKžJML#õ
ñdð
L`&
þ ¥ ü £
£†£ ™8žR›À¡¤ ü £ י8ž›
Ÿž›JKL‡JMï'H#DGóq™8H#Jcï°D’H&ñdð†L-¤2 ü £
£†£ ñdð†LB›JKžï#DFH#DGJMï*òDFõ
òJKL!H‡ò™8ž
H#òð
ï#JsôKð†L‡L#Jcï'€uð†žR›DFžõ`H‡¡ð . 0 ¥ 3A
9*ð{øÕEGJ²HŸïô²ð†óq€™†L#J H#òJ>€L‡JMï‡ï'ŸL‡J“ñdL‡ð†ó H#òJ w Ð
 urvxw
ø°DFH#òúH#ò™8HñdL#ð
ó H#òJ p î'CÕï#DGó`ŸE[™{H‡DFð
ž Ÿï#DFžõ u uA^¤†¤>DFž
Ž™8÷A
A |>
J Rž›qL#JMóә8L‡û2™†÷EG`õ†ð5ð›Ó™8õ
L#JMJKóqJKžrHð†ñuH‡òJ&JMžrH#DGL#J
LO™8žõ
Jmð†ñBH‡JKóq€RJML‡™8H#ŸL‡J ™8žR› ›JMžï#D’H Ÿž›JML)ô²ð
žï'D[›JML‡™8H#DGð†žA
ð
L)™~EGð{ø›JMžï#D’HÛï'ŸRôOòۙ
ï .10¥ ¤c£ £¢H#òD[ïjD[ïjï#òð{ø°žÛDFž
ŽDFõRA¤c¡A ï`JKö5€uJMô²H#Jc›Y¢ð†ž2
J ž›ï`H#ò™8H`÷uð8H#ò óqJ²H#òð5›ï-DGž H#JML#€uð†E[™{H‡J&÷uJ²HøaJKJMžjH#òJBEGDFóqDFHað†ñ™8ž)DG›Jc™8ÍE JML#óqDuõ
™
ï™8HaòDGõ†ò
H#JMóq€RJML‡™8H#ŸL‡JMï™8ž› žð†ž ”DGžrH#JKLO™†ô²H#DGžõóqð
EFJcô²ŸE[™8L}õ
™†ï™{HqEGð{ø
H#JMóq€RJML‡™8H#ŸL‡JMïMA ŽDFõRA¤ *Óô²ð
ž L‡óÓïaH#òJ^õ
ðrð›™8õ
L#JMJKóqJKžrH°™{H&™
òDGõ†òJML?›JKžï#DFH-ð8Jñ . 0 ¥; 3A ï?™šL‡JMï#ŸEFHŽð†ñH#òJ!ï'H#L‡ð†žõBDGžrH#JKZL ™†ô²H#DGð†žï™{HH#òD[ï›JKžï#D’H
¢
ð
žJ Rž›ïH#ò™8HH#òJ&€L‡JMï‡ï'ŸL#J*™8HEGð{ø
H#JMóq€RJML‡™8H#ŸL‡JMï)DGïÜï'DGõ†žïD RôM™8žrH#EGÛ™8÷uð †J“H‡òJžð
ž oDFžrH#JML‡™
ô®H‡DFžõ
óqð†EGJMôKŸEG™†L!õ
™†ï!EGDGóDFHMA
|q
J ž›jH#ò™8HH‡òJ w Ð u€vxw Ÿž›JML#JcïH‡DFóә8H#JMïH#òJB€L‡JMï‡ï#ŸL#J
÷5j™8÷uð†ŸH°{¡ øßñdð
L!
þ ‘3
ü £†£ q¸A !òDGï!›yD 5½JKL‡JKžôKJBD[ï!ð†ŸHOï'D[›J
H#òJJML#L‡ð†L÷R™8LñdL#ð
ó H‡òJ™†€€L‡ð2öDFóә{H‡DFð
žïYDGž p î'C>›D[ï#ôKŸï#ï#JM›
DGžï#JMô®H‡DFð
žî#î5@ ™†ž›ôKð†ŸE[› ÷uJqDFžrH‡JKL‡€L#JKH#Jc› ™†ïs™ÓñdŸL'H‡òJKLsDGž ›D[ôK™8H#DGð†ž¢DGž0™†››D’H‡DFð
žH‡ðmH‡òJÓð†÷Rï'JMZL JM› JMžJKL‡õ† ›J 5DG™8H#DGð†žïM¢
H#òR™{HsH#òJ w  óð›JMEŸž›JML#JcïH‡DFóә{H‡JMïBH#òJq›JKõ†L‡JKJ}ð8ñDGð†žDFIc™ H#DGð†ž;™8H)òDGõ†òÛH‡JKóq€RJML‡™8H#ŸL‡JMïMA ð†L)DFžrH#JML#óqJc›DG™8H#J“H‡JKóq€uJKLO™ H#ŸL#JcŽï 3r ü £
£ ,Ïþ ,Õ¤ ü 3r ü q¢Žð†žJ ž›ï€L‡JMï‡ï#ŸL#Jm›ïD 5½JKZL JKžRô²JMïM¢5ø°òD[ôOòm™8L‡J&ð†ñYH#òJ^8óqJ&óә†õ†žDFH#Ÿ›Jš™
ïH‡òŠJ RžD’H‡J^ï'DGIKJ
6J 5½JMô²H‡ïqDGž p î'CBA ð
L`H‡JKóq€RJML‡™8H#ŸL‡JMï÷uJKEGð{ø ¤ ü 3
ü q¢H‡òJ
DGžô²L‡JM™
ï'Jc›ï'H‡™8H#D[ïH‡DGôM™8EJML#L‡ð†LOïšDFž~H‡òJ p î'C €L‡JMï‡ï#ŸL#Jә†L#Jqð8ñ
−20
10
−3
−2
10
−3)
ρ (gcm
10
−1
Žî ·Aa¤c œî6žrH‡JKL‡ž™8EaJKžJML#õ
€uJKLq™{H‡ð†ó ïKA>›JKžï#DFHñdð
L›D’ñ?
ñdJML#JMžrHjH#JMó€uJKLO™{H‡ŸL‡JMïqñdL‡ð†ó w Ð urvxw ¤”¢!H‡òJ™
ô®H‡Dy
5DFH JKö;
€R™8žï#DFð
ž ˜ ô®H u öR¥ +¤ ˜ žð8H&ï#òð{ø°ž)ñdð†L ü £
£†£ ï#DGžô²JsžJc™8L‡EF
D[›JMž
H‡DGôM™8E½H‡ð w °¥a™8ž› p î'C3ôK™†EGôKŸE[™{H#DGð†žRïsA
H‡òJ-8óqJ^ï'DGIKJ^™†ïaH‡òJ^ð†÷Rï'JMLZ
JM›)›J
5DG™8H#DGð†žïMA
î6!
ž ŽDFõRAY¤ ü AøaJ^ï'òð{ø H#òJ^€L#Jcï#ï#ŸL‡Jš™
ﰙñdŸžô®H‡DFð
žð8ñŽ›JKž
ï#DFH†¢rø°òDGôOòmô²ð†ž L#óÓïH#òJBõ†ð5ð›j™8õ
L#JMJKóqJKžrHMˆA !òJRõ†ŸL‡J&™8E[ï#ð
DGž›D[ôK™8H#JcïH#ò™8HM¢r™{H ü £
£†£ 3™†ž¡› .10q, *¢{H‡òJ*€L‡JMï‡ï'ŸL#JaDGïô²EGð
ï#J
H‡ðH#òJ^€L‡JMï‡ï#ŸL#Jšð8ñ?™žð†ž ”DGžrH#JKLO™†ô²H#DGžõóð
EFJcô²ŸE[™8L°õr™†ïMA
î6ž0ð†ŸL-ô²ð†óq€™†L#D[ï#ð†ž¢øJj™†EGï#ðDFžôKEFŸR›JM›0L‡JMï#ŸEFH‡ïsñdL‡ð†ó H#òJ
™
ô®H‡yD 5DFH^J²ö€™8žRï'DGð†ž-÷5: ü°ð
õ†JML‡ï 1¤ o¢8ø°òD[ôOò}ï#òð{ø*ˆï †JKL‡sõ†ð5ð›
™†õ†L‡JKJMóJMžrH-DFžÀ€L#Jcï#ï#ŸL‡Jj™8ž›~DGžrH#JKL‡ž™†EJKžJKL‡õ† ˜ ï'JM2J ŽDFõrïKA ¢
¤
¤†¢™†ž›~¤c r¥OrA !òJ`›yD 5uJML#JMžô²Jcï&™†L#J^ï#óq™†EFE÷ŸH&DGžôKL#Jc™†ï#J^ø°D’H‡ò
›JKžï#D’H
AÀî6žÀH‡òJóqð†EGJMô²ŸEG™†L™†ž› ™8H#ð
óD[ômL#JMõ†DGóJ
¢?ð†žJ™8E[ï#ð
Rž›ïÓõ
ðrð›Û™8õ
L#JMJKóqJKžrHqø°D’H‡òÛH#òË
J ŸD[
› {™†L#D[™{H‡DFð
ž™8E!H‡òJKð
L#
˜ &¥÷5m†ŸL‡™†žJKûj™†žd› ü*JM›óqJKL +¤ ™†ï!ï#òð{ø°ž)DG!
ž DGõ
ïMA ¢
¤
¤†¢R¤M¡¢r™8ž›Ü+¤ *A ð†LòDGõ†òJML?H#JMó€uJKLO™{H‡ŸL‡JMïM¢8H#òqJ Ðóqð›JKE
D[ï-žð8H™†€€EGDGôM™8÷EGJ)ï#DFžRô²JjDFH›ð5Jcï-žð†H}DGžô²EGŸ›JmDFð
žDFIc™{H‡DFð
ž>ð†ñ
™8H#ð
óqïMA
;
…›š;–•í]?•6•6’] yš;”–s?7<))—1”–€?)“
!òJML#Jߙ†L#J%ñdð†ŸLú›ïD 5½JKL‡JKžrHú€™8DGL ôKð†L‡L#JMEG™8H#DGð†žñdŸžô²H#DGð†žï
°ø òDGôOòÛôK™†ž ÷uJ“›DFL‡JMô²H#EGÀð†÷H‡™8DGžJc›ÀñdL‡ð†ó óә†žr;o÷R𛁠ï'DGó`Ÿ
E[™{H‡DFð
žï™†ž›j€L#ð
5D[›J&›DGL#Jcô®HaDFžñdð
L#óә8H#DGð†žj™8÷uð†ŸHH‡òJBï'H‡™8H#J&ð†ñ
H‡òJ!ï'ï'H#JKóA w òð{ø°ž`DGž-H‡òJñdð†EGEFð{ø°DGžõRõ†ŸL‡JMïDG8ž}J²ö5H#JMžï#Dy
J
ï#J²H^ð†ña€™†DFL-ôKð†L‡L#JMEG™8H#DGð†žïBø°òD[ôOò0™8EGEFð{ø%ð
žJqH#ðJcïH‡DFóә{H‡JqH#òJ
óqD[ô²L‡ð
ï‡ô²ð
€DGômïH‡L#ŸRô®H#ŸL#JÜð8ñBH#òJ“ï#5ï'H#JMó ™8ž›Ð™8EGEGð{ø™›DGL‡JMô®H
ôKð†óq€™†L#D[ï'ð
ž~ø°D’H‡òÀð8H‡òJKLï'DGó`ŸE[™{H‡DFð
žïM8
A !òJj€L‡ð8H‡ð†ž o€L‡ð8H‡ð†ž
€R™8DGLqôKð†L‡L#JMEG™8H#DGð†ž~ñdŸžRô®H#DGð†žRïñdL#ð
ó p î'C ï#DGó`ŸE[™{H‡DFð
žïø°D’H‡ò
ñdL‡JKJ€™8L#H#D[ô²EGJžð5›JM8L‡Jï'òð{ø°ž^DF¡ž DGõAr+¤ 3¸A ð†L=
þ 8££
£†£ ™j€RJc™8û“™{HBH#òJ÷Rð
ž›“EGJKžõ†H#ò ð†ñ*4¤ *)JMóJML#õ
JMïM¢ø°òD[ôOòôKEFJc™8L‡EF
›JKóqð†žï'H#LO™{H‡JMï`H#òJÜñdð
L#óә{H‡DFð
žÀð8ñBóð
EFJcô²ŸEGJMïMA |>J)ñdð
Ÿž› D’H
ŸRï'JKñdŸEH‡ð`ó}ŸE’H‡DF€EFqH‡òJ&€™†DFL!ô²ð
L#L‡JKE[™{H‡DFð
žñdŸžô®H‡DFð
žj÷5Ó™8žjJK;ö 1
10
d
P (GPa)
@ u  p L‡JMï‡ï'ŸL#Ja™8ž›}DFžrH‡JKL‡ž™8E5JKžJKL‡õ†^€uJKL™{H‡ð†ó%™†ž›-H‡òJ
L‡JMï#ŸE’H‡DFžõփ*Ÿõ
ð†žDGð8HÓ ñdL#ð
ó p î'CÐï'DGó`ŸEG™8H#DGð†žïø°D’H‡ò)¡
š€™†DFLOï
ð8ñŽ€™8L#H#D[ô²EGJMﰙ†ž=› ê " ¥ å ¤M£ ç %Ÿï#DGžõñdL#JMJš€R™8L#H#D[ô²EGJšžð5›JMï
J²öôKJK€H^ñdð
L ñ ø°òJML#J |šCæžð5›JMï^øaJKL‡JqJKóq€EGð{†JM›>DGžï'H#JM™
›YA
!òJ}€L#ð
÷™8÷DFEGD’H‡DFJc"
ï !ñdð†L Rž›DGžõm™Ó€L#ð†H#ð†ž“DGž™)õ†D †JKž ï'H‡™8H#J
ñdð†LH#òJ*H#òL#JMJB›ð
óDGž™†ž
H!ï'€uJMôKDFJcL#JB›JKL‡yD JM›ñdL‡ð†óϙ`ôKEFŸRïH‡JKL
™8žR™8EG5ï#D[ïKA B$#&%('*) D[ïqH#òJ“€RJML#ó}ŸH‡™8H#DGð†žÛ€L‡ð†÷™†÷DFEGDFH0ñdð†LÓH‡òJ
JKEGJMô²H#L‡ð†žïMA
Ô .l0Ø /213.54 6Y&± /
78.l:§ 9;/ <>=@? < = < =BA 1DC-EGFIH
+-, "
:É J
Ù ÊmÖcÑKÊÊMÊcÊ J
Ù ÊMÊcKÊ .Š&Ö / L2Ö{Ù ÄcKÇ .MJN/
ʆ٠ÊMÊcÊ
:É J
٠ʓɲÖMÑ=ÊMÊcÊ ÉcÙ ÄcÑcOÑ .Š&Ö / ÖMÄ8Ù &Ä PO.MJN/ ʆ٠ÄcÄ)ʆ٠ʆÉqʆ٠ÊcÊ Ê†Ù ÊMÊcÊ
:É J
Ù Q
Ê L2ÖÑKÊcÊ Ê†Ù ÄMʆ$É .Š&Ö / ÉcÉMÙ Æ2OÑ .MJN/ ʆ٠Ä2Ñjʆ٠Ê2Ñ)ʆ٠ÊcÊ Ê†Ù ÊMÊcÊ
:É J
Ù Ê Ç†ÉuÖMÑMÊ Ê†Ù ÇMRÇ JS.Š&Ö / T†Ö{Ù &Ä PO.dUÇ / ʆ٠LRJmʆ٠VÇ Lmʆ٠ÊcÊ Ê†Ù ÊMÊcÊ
:É J
Ù Ê É²WÑ LcÖcÑ Ê†ÙµÉ®VÖ PO.Š&Ö /XT5ÉMÉcÙ ÇcSÊ .MJN/ ʆ٠YÖ Jmʆ٠PRLmʆ٠ÊcÊ Ê†Ù ÊMÊcÊ
:É J
Ù Ê É®ÊÊMÊcÊ Ê†Ù ÊMƆ$É .MJN/XT5É®Ö8Ù J2SÇ .*LU/ ʆٵɲÖjʆ٠PcÖ)ʆٵɲÑ;ʆ٠ÊMÊcÊ
:É J
Ù Ê PYÆ8É²Ö Ê†Ù YÊ JUPO.Š&Ñ /ZT5ÉOdž٠RÇ J.oÉ®UÇ / ʆ٠ÊcÆ)ʆ٠ÑMÆmʆ٠ÇcÇ Ê†Ù ÊMÊcÊ
:É J
Ù Ê ÑYÊMÊcÊ Ê†Ù ÊcÖMKÆ .*LU/ZT5É®Ñ8Ù ÊcSÊ .oɲ&Ö / ʆ٠ʆÉʆٵÉcÉqʆ٠ÆcÆ Ê†Ù ÊMÊcÊ
ɮʆ٠ÊmÖcÑKÊÊMÊcÊ É®Ê8Ù ÄMÊ2KÖ .MJN/ L2Ö{Ù ÊcKÊ .dUÇ /
ʆ٠ÊMÊcÊ
ɮʆ٠ʓɲÖMÑ=ÊMÊcÊ Ñ8Ù ÖMÑMKÄ .*LU/ ÖMÆ8Ù RÑ LK.dUÇ / ʆ٠ÄcÆ)ʆ٠Ê2Ö)ʆ٠ÊcÊ Ê†Ù ÊMÊcÊ
ɮʆ٠Q
Ê L2ÖÑKÊcÊ Ö8Ù ÇcÖMKÄ .Š&Ñ / Ä8Ù J
$É .dUÇ / ʆ٠ÄcÊ)ʆٵɮÊmʆ٠ÊcÊ Ê†Ù ÊMÊcÊ
É®Ê†Ù Ê Ç†ÉuÖMÑMÊ Ê†Ù ÆMdž$É .Š&Ñ / TUJ†Ù Ć$É .dUÇ / ʆ٠VÑ Pjʆ٠J2Çmʆ٠ÊcÊ Ê†Ù ÊMÊcÊ
É®Ê†Ù Ê É²WÑ LcÖcÑ Ê†Ù YÇ JVJS.MJN/XT5ÉMÉcÙ J2SÄ .dUÇ / ʆ٠ÖMÇ)ʆ٠PYJÜʆ٠Ê2Ö;ʆ٠ÊMÊcÊ
É®Ê†Ù Ê É®ÊÊMÊcÊ Ê†ÙµÉOÄcKÆ .dUÄ /XT5É®Ö8Ù PMSÄ .Š&Ñ / ʆٵÉcÉʆ٠LcÊmʆ٠VÖ P;ʆ٠ÊMÊcÊ
É®Ê†Ù Ê PYÆ8É²Ö Ê†Ùµ[É JVJS.5P&/XT5ÉOdž٠YÑ J.dUÄ / ʆ٠ÊcÇ)ʆ٠RÇ JÜʆ٠L2Ö;ʆ٠ÊMÊcÊ
É®Ê†Ù Ê ÑYÊMÊcÊ Ê8Ù RÊ LcSÆ .oɲ&Ñ /\T5É®Ñ8Ù Ê2KÑ .5P&/ ʆ٠ÊcÊ)ʆ٠&Ê P)ʆ٠Ä2Ö;ʆ٠ÊMÊcÊ
L†Ù ÊmÖcÑKÊÊMÊcÊ J2Ä8Ù J&LK.dUÇ / ÑMÄ8Ù ÇcKÇ .MJN/
ʆ٠ÊMÊcÊ
L†Ù ʓɲÖMÑ=ÊMÊcÊ ÖMÇ8Ù ÊcKÊ .dUÇ / YÖ J†Ù PMKÊ .MJN/ ʆ٠RÄ Jmʆ٠VÊ Lmʆ٠ÊcÊ Ê†Ù ÊMÊcÊ
L†Ù Q
Ê L2ÖÑKÊcÊ Ä8Ù RÑ LK.Š&Ö / J†Ù PMKÄ .dUÇ / ʆ٠ÆcÊ)ʆ٠ÖMÊmʆ٠ÊcÊ Ê†Ù ÊMÊcÊ
L†Ù Ê Ç†ÉuÖMÑMÊ
Ç8Ù ÑMKÆ .dUÇ / TNL8Ù Ä2OÖ .MJN/ ʆ٠ÑcÖjʆ٠J&Lmʆ٠ʆÉÐʆ٠ÊMÊcÊ
L†Ù Ê É²WÑ LcÖcÑ
ÉMÙ ÑcOÖ .Š&Ö /XT5ÉMÉcÙ ÆcSÇ .MJN/ ʆ٠Ö8Éʆ٠LcÆmʆ٠ÊcÄ Ê†Ù ÊMʆÉ
L†Ù Ê É®ÊÊMÊcÊ
Ê8Ù PVPO.MJN/XT5ÉOdž٠ÇcSÆ .*LU/ ʆ٠ÊcÆ)ʆ٠J2Ämʆ٠J2Ê Ê†Ù ÊMÊcÊ
L†Ù Ê PYÆ8ɲÖ
Ê8Ù LcKÇ .Š&Ñ /XT5ÉOdž٠Ä2KÑ .5P&/ ʆ٠RÊ Jmʆ٠ÇcÆmʆ٠RÑ L ʆ٠ÊMÊcÊ
L†Ù Ê ÑYÊMÊcÊ
Ê8Ù ÖMKÄ .dUÄ /ZT5É®Ñ8Ùµ-É PK.oɲ&Ö / ʆ٠ÊcÊ)ʆ٠ÊcÄmʆ٠ÄcÊ Ê†Ù ÊMÊcÊ
J
Ù ÊmÖcÑKÊÊMÊcʏ:É L2Ö{Ù JVL.oÉOUÊ / ÑcÑ{Ù LcKÇ .MJN/
ʆ٠ÊMÊcÊ
J
٠ʓɲÖMÑ=ÊMÊc]
Ê PKdž٠ÊcSÊ .ŠÖM&Ç /(^ ÖMÊ8Ù -Ö J\.d&Ä /(^ ʆ٠ÆcÆ)ʆٵɲÖ)ʆ٠ÊcÊ Ê†Ù ÊMÊcÊ
J
Ù Q
Ê L2ÖÑKÊcÊ ÖKĆ٠PcKÑ .o_É L&/ ^ ÉcÙ ÖKSÇ .*L&/ ^ ʆ٠PcÖjʆ٠RÖ Lmʆ٠ÊcÊ Ê†Ù ÊMʆÉ
J
Ù Ê Ç†ÉuÖMÑMÊ ÉMÉcÙ ÖcKÖ .ŠÖcVÖ / ^ T8Æ8Ù ÇcSÖ .d&Æ / ^ ʆ٠JUPjʆ٠J&Lmʆ٠ÊcÇ Ê†Ù ÊMRÊ J
J
Ù Ê É²WÑ LcÖcÑ Ñ8٠ʆ`É .o-É PV/(^aTrÉcÉMÙ VÆ PS.*L&/(^ ʆٵɮÄ)ʆ٠ÑMÆmÊ†ÙµÉ®Æ Ê†Ù ÊMÊcÆ
J
Ù Ê É®ÊÊMÊcÊ Ç†Ù ÖMSÇ .dÇc&Ê / ^ T5É®Ç8Ù J2Ç .oÉMYÉ / ^ ʆ٠ÊcÇ)ʆ٠ÇcÊmʆ٠LcÇ Ê†Ù ÊMÊ2Ñ
J
Ù Ê PYÆ8É²Ö Ö8Ù ÖKSÊ .o[É JN/XT5[É J
Ù ÖMSÄ .*LU/ ʆ٠ʆÉʆٵɮÆmʆ٠ÆcÊ Ê†Ù ÊMRÊ J
J
Ù Ê ÑYÊMÊcÊ ÉcÙµÉOSÄ .ŠÖM&Ñ /XT5É®Ñ8Ù ÖMSÊ .dUÄ / ʆ٠ÊcÊ)ʆٵÉcÉqʆ٠ÆcÆ Ê†Ù ÊMÊ2Ö
dž٠ÊmÖcÑKÊÊMÊcÊÜVÇ PYJ†Ù J&PS.o[É JN/ Ñ8ÉMÙ PMKÄ .Š&Ö /
ʆ٠ÊMÊcÊ
dž٠ʓɲÖMÑ=ÊMÊcʏ:É L2Ñ{Ù Ö{bÉ .ŠÖM&Ö / _É L8Ù ÑMKÆ .MJN/ ʆ٠ÆcÇ)ʆٵɲÑ)ʆ٠ʆÉÐʆ٠ÊMʆÉ
dž٠Q
Ê L2ÖÑKÊcQ
Ê L&P{Ù PKÊ .ŠÖM&Ñ / T5ÉMÙ RÊ JS.MJN/ ʆ٠LVL)ʆ٠ÖMÄmʆ٠ʆÉÐʆ٠ÊMÊ2Ñ
Ç†Ù Ê Ç†ÉuÖMÑMÊ RÖ L8Ù LVPS.Š-Ö JN/ T8Ä8Ù Ê2OÖ .MJN/ ʆ٠J{Ñjʆ٠J2Çmʆ٠VÊ L ʆ٠ÊcÖMÆ
Ç†Ù Ê É²WÑ LcÖcÑ É®Ç8Ù ÊMÆ .ŠÖKUÆ /XT5É®Ö8Ù ÖMSÄ .MJN/ ʆٵɲÑjʆ٠J{Ö)ʆ٠RÇ J ʆ٠ÊcÑMÄ
Ç†Ù Ê É®ÊÊMÊcÊ Ä†Ù YÖ LS.ŠYÖ LU/XT5ÉOdž٠PMSÄ .MJN/ ʆ٠ÊcÇ)ʆ٠Ç2Ñ)ʆ٠LcÊ Ê†Ù ÊM&Ç P
Ö8Ù LmÖcÑKÊÊMÊcÊ RÑ LRL†Ù JS.MJN/ J2Ä8Ù ÑMKÆ .MJN/
ʆ٠ÊMÊcÊ
Ö8Ù L“ɲÖMÑ=ÊMÊcÊ YÖ JVL†Ù Ê .ŠVÑ /(^ :É J†Ù RÑ PS.ŠVÑ /(^ ʆ٠ÆcÊ)ʆٵ-É P)ʆ٠ʆÉÐʆ٠ÊMÊ2Ö
Ö8Ù LQL2ÖÑKÊcÊ É®Ê8ÉcÙ PS.MJU/ ^ T†Ö{Ù ÖMSÑ .MJU/ ^ ʆ٠L2Ñjʆ٠ÖMÆmʆ٠Ê2Ö;ʆ٠Ê8:É J
Ö8Ù L džÉuÖMÑMÊ J2Ç8Ùµ`É .ŠVÑ / ^ T8Ä8Ù ÇMÆ .ŠVÑ / ^ ʆ٠J{Öjʆ٠ÇcÆmʆ٠ÊcÄ Ê†Ù VÊ PMÆ
Ö8Ù L ɲWÑ LcÖcÑ É®Ä8Ù SÊ .d&Æ /(^aTrɲÖ{Ù Ñ{bÉ .d&Ä /(^ ʆٵ:É Jmʆ٠J{Ö)ʆ٠ÇcÇ Ê†Ùµ:É LcÆ
Ö8Ù L É®ÊÊMÊcÊ ÉcÉMÙ PK.d&Ä /(^8T5É®Ç8Ù PMÇ .oÉOUÊ /(^jʆ٠Ê2Öjʆ٠RÇ JÜʆ٠LcÊ Ê†ÙµÉ®RÖ L
Ideal Fermi gas
Ideal molecular gas
FVT
Saumon & Chabrier
PIMC
0
10
−1
10
K 4
10
T (K)
c
K 5
10
QSR.TVU{†ßgY›l`xcc.^Z`xž“hcUexr … x`ae^Z`xaeSa]fhxugcq€e!bˆiCkÌ&e¢¤ †>§
cwZi¡¢qsuZ|E`x>c.^gtJecSk`irÁewgx fg^Zqzf~“aC`qzaeq€iugaGt{ewZxi`bĶJ†Vg¸ÊµCewZx
h o‡y1² i h ¶€†_¸1µgaGugfÄlR.nàoÝcq€r˜^ZtsaGeqsiCugcU
e`a@fhxugcq€e!b@k’a\‰ei`™¤kjml&nc.iewgae˜ewZxÄaG`xa¯^ZuXfhx`˜ewZx
a o˜qzc … `i … i`.eq€iugaGtZei:ewZx]r~it€x>\_^ZtzaG`mk`aC\_eqsiCu›UmŠ%wZx … x>N
a o
… xp
wgxqs|Cw{e|x_eccr5aGtst€x`¡¢q€ew¯fhx\`x>aCcq€ug|fhxuXc.q€e!b‹aCc%a:`xc^Zt€eiCk
xu{e`i … qz\fhqzccih\_qzaeq€iu¿iCkhewZxr~iCtsx\_^gt€x>cµfh`q€“xu8±b]ewZx‡u^ZrVy
±7x`ˆiGkž^Zu±Xi^ZugfÀc.eaGex>c”ae]tsi¡­fhxugcq€e!bCU%Š%wZx`r5aGtfhqzcc.ih\_qzay
eq€iu˜aCtsci”`xfh^g\xcvewgxu^Zr˜±Xx`viCkgr~iCtsx\_^gt€x>c¡¢q€ewVq€uX\_`xaCcqsuZ|
exr … x`ae^g`xUvQZi`žÌ e;q r WZµ¡xx_„ … x\‰ežewgae … `xcc.^g`xfhqscci\qJy
aGeqsiCuVfhq€r~qsuZqzc.wZx>cSewZx¢u^Zr˜±Xx`žiGkXr~it€x>\_^ZtsxcS¡¢q€ew~q€uX\_`xaCcqsuZ|
fZxugcqJe!b¯¶€†·¸7±Z^he‡ewZqzcfhxugcqJe!bV`aCuZ|Cx¢qzc±7xbiCugfVewZx]c\_i … x”iCk
ewZqzc … a … x`>U
Š%wZx … `iGeiCuhy1xtsx\_e`iCu … aGqs`À\_i``xtzaeq€iu k^Zug\_eqsiCu­r^gtJeqJy
€
t
s
q
a o
… xf ±bŽewgx´fhxugc.q€e!b­qsccwZi¡¢u q€u¥Qvqs|gUV†œhU Š%wZx … x>N
ugxaG`ewZx”i`qs|Cqsu~c.wZi¡”cmewZx”qsug\`x>aCcxf … `iC±gaC±Zq€tsq€e!b:iGt
k sgugfZq€uZ|
aCu´xt€x>\‰e`iu ugxaG`‹a … `iGeiCu³fh^Zx¯eiƒewZxàoi^Zt€ir±³aee`aC\‰y
eq€iu›UÀŠ%wZx … x>N
a owZxqs|Cw{e˜fhx>\_`xac.x>c8¡¢qJewexr … x`aGe^Z`xdaGuXf
qsug\`x>aCcxc¡¢qJewÄfhxugcqJe!b5±7x\aG^gcxˆiCkewZx`r5aGt#q€iuZqs–aeq€iudaGuXf
xu{e`i … b5q€iuZqs–aeq€iud`xc … x>\‰eq€“xtsbCUm[e¢t€i¡pexr … x`ae^Z`xµewZx
a o:\aCu˜±7x%q€u{ex` … `xexfVaCcSih\\^ … aGeqsiCuiCkX±7iC^ZuXf˜c.eaGexcmaCtJy
… xp
ewZiC^g|Cw ‘’^Zu±Xi^ZugfX—]c\aeex`qsuZ|jc.eaGexc¿\aCu@aGtzcij\_iu{e`q€±Z^ZexCU
Qg`ir … `iCeiuhyÊxt€x>\‰e`iu … aGqs`¿\iC``xtsaGeqsiCuÀaCt€iuZxCµ7iCuZx~\aCuZuZiCe
fZqsc.eqsuZ|C^gqscwj±7x_e!¡xxuaGu¯aeir~qs\EaGuXfÄaVr~iCtsx\^ZtzaG`¢c!eaexCU
QSq€|{cU]R† uaGuXf™V† gc.wgi¡ ewZxÀxtsx\_e`iCuhy1xtsx\_e`iCu … aGqs`d\iC`y
`xtzaeq€iuÀk^ZuX\‰eqsiCuXcEkiC` … aCq€`cE¡¢q€ewaGu{eq€y … aG`aGtst€xtmc … qsu›U‹Š%wZx
a oaGeVcr5aGtstcx … aC`aGeqsiCugc\_iCr~x>c8k`iCr ewZxdkiC`r5aeqsiCuiCk
… xp
ewZxVrVit€x>\_^ZtzaG`ˆ±Xiugf3UEQZi` … aCq€`cˆiGkxtsx\_e`iCugc]¡¢qJew … aC`aCt€tsxt
c … qsu›µCiuZx”aGts¡%ab`
c sXugfZca8c.e`iCuZ|E`x … ^gtscq€iu5fh^Zx%eiEewZx]lmaC^Zt€q
x„Z\_ts^gc.qsiCu … `qsug\_q … tsx”aGugfVeiaEt€x>ccx`‡x_„exuemei8ewgx¿oiC^ZtsiCr˜±
`x … ^ZtscqsiCu›UmŠ%wZqzc%qsc]c.wZi¡¢uÄqsu¯QSqs|gU3V† gZU
v
wyx[z{x:|~}B€‚„ƒD…-}B†B|p‡
R»u ewZqzc‹cx\_eqsiCu›µ¡xfhqzc\_^gcc~ewg‰
x ˆyŠB‹UŒYŽN5‹Y‘p’“‹U” iGkEwby
fZ`i|CxuaCc8cwZi¡¢u@qsuQSq€|XUm†CU5Š%wZx‹fhqzaG|`aCrc.wZi¡”cˆewZx‹a … y
… `i„hqsr~aGex¿t€ih\aeqsiCu¯iCkvewZx8r~iCtsx\_^gtsaC`µewZx:aeiCr~qs\8aCugfjewZx
3
10
˜
2
Ideal Fermi gas
Ideal molecular gas
FVT
Saumon & Chabrier
ActEx
PIMC VDM
62500
rs=10
rs=6
rs=4
rs=3
¿
rs=2.6
0.05
0.00
31250
10
0.05
0.00
P (GPa)
15625
—
rs=14
T (K)
n gpp(r)
10000
0.05
0.00
0.05
0.00
1
10
7812
•
10
4
T (K)
–
•
10
0.00
5
5000
Žî·A¤*œ p L#Jcï#ï#ŸL‡J
ïKAšH‡JKóq€RJML‡™8H#ŸL‡J}™8Hs™m›JKžRï'DFH“ð8ñÐ. 0 ¥
q3 ™†ï°ï#òð{ø°žÜDFžŽDFõRA¤M¡A
€E[™†ï#óәmL‡JKõ
DFóqJcïKA£!òJ p î'C ï#DFó}ŸEG™8H#DGð†žïM¢=ï#DFžRô²JqH#òJK™†L#J
÷™
ï'Jc›ð†žH#òJ`÷™
ï'D[ô-›Jcï#ôKL#DG€H#DGð†ž“DGžH#JML#óÓïBð8ñ?JKEGJMô²H#L‡ð†žïB™8ž›
€L‡ð8H‡ð†žïM¢u›ðmžð†Hš›DGL‡JMô®H‡EF“EGJKžR›“H#òJKóÓï'JMEy
JMï&H#ð›J²H‡JKL‡óqDFžDGžõ
H#òJ*ž5Ÿó`÷uJKLð8ñYô²ð†óq€uð†ŸžR›q€™8L#H#D[ô²EGJMïï#ŸôOòә†ïóð
EFJcô²ŸEGJMï™8ž›
™{H‡ð†óÓïMA ˜ CJ²H‡òð›ïsñdð†L^›JKH#JML#óqDGžDFžõmH‡òD[ïsñdL#ð
ó p î'C ï#DF¡ó ŸE[™{H‡DFð
žïÓø°DGEFEB÷RJ›DGï‡ô²Ÿï‡ï#JM›ÐDFž;™>ñdŸH#ŸL‡J €Ÿ÷EFD[ôK™8H#DGð†žAµ¥:î6ž
ð†LO›JML^H#ðð†÷HO™8DGž ™8ž0JcïH‡DFóә{H‡J)ð†ñ°H#òJܙ{H#ð
óqDGôj™†ž›0óqð†EGJMôKŸ
E[™8LañdL‡™
ô®H‡DFð
ž¢5øJBJKóq€EGð{†JM›m™}ôKEFŸRïH‡JKL°™8ž™†EFï#DGïð8ñ=H#òJ p î'C
€™8H#ò3ô²ð
ž õ†ŸL‡™8H#DGð†žïMA ïj›Jcï#ôKL#DG÷uJM›ÐDFž ¤ o¢!øJ“ôKð†žï#DG›JKL
Høað“€L#ð†H#ð
žï^™†ï^÷uJKEGð†žõ†DGžõÜH#ð ð
žJjô²EGŸï'H#JKL`D’ñ!H#òJK™†L#JÓEGJMï‡ï
H#òR™8ž>4¤ K™{š™8€R™8L#HMA žJKEGJMô²H#L‡ð†ž)÷uJKEGð†žõ
ïH#ðqð†žJš€R™8L#H#D[ô²ŸE[™8L
ô²EGŸï'H#JMLšDFñ!D’H^D[ïBEGJMï‡ïBH#ò™†ž ]¤ *™›š ™2øa™2ÜñdL‡ð†ó ™8ž5“€L‡ð8H‡ð†žDFž
H#òJqôKEFŸRïH‡JKLc¡A !òJHøaðÜôKŸH oŸð 5ÀLO™†›DFDøaJKL‡JôOòðrï'JMž ñdL‡ð†óÕH‡òJ
3
10
gas, T=5000K
ž Molecular
Saumon & Chabrier
2
PIMC
10
Ÿ 000

P (GPa)
1
125
10
K
50 K
312
0
10
Ÿ 00 K
100
−1
Ÿ
10
0K
500
−2
10
−3
10
−2
10
œ −3)
ρ (gcm
0.05
−1
10
¡`¢¤£‚¥t¦V§@¨`©Kª[«R¬[¬¤­yª“«®@¬R¥b¯>«Y°y¬“±³²µ´‚¶*·›ª\¯@±¹¸t«Yª[«Y°{²S²[«Yº¼»„«Rª[½N²“­>ª[«R¬R¥
0.05
¾0 ¿2 À4 ¾0 ¿2 À4 ¾ 0 ¿2 À 4 ¾0 ¿ 2 À4 ¾ 0 ¿ 2 À 4 ¾0 ¿ 2 À4 Á 6
0.00
r
Â`äĂÅbÆRÇyÈ;ÉKÊ[ËNÌ[ËpÍ@ÎÐÏ>Ê[ËNÌ[Ëp͉ÏyÑNÒIÊÔÓ-ËpÊ[Ê[ÕYÖ×ÑU̓ÒIËp͉Ø*ÙyÍyÓ_Ì[ҹ˛Í3ÚÛÙyÖ³Ì[Ò³Î
ÏyÖ¹ÒIÕRÜaÝB޼̓ß>ÕàÜ@ÕRÍyá¤Ò¹ÌµÞmâOÅKã ß>ÕÔÓ-˛ֹÙyڂ̈́áÓ-ËpÊ[Ê[ÕRá“Ï„Ë›Íyܼ̓˂Ì[Ëåä&æ
ç ÑpÖ¹Ù>ÕVáÑNÍyÜè̓ßyÕàʓËUé"á\Ì[˼Ü>Ò³êtÕYÊ[ÕYÍ{Ì̓ÕRڼτÕRÊ[ÑN̓Ù>Ê[ÕRá ëìÅ
ڼ˛ֹÕVÓ-Ù>Ö×ÑNÊíÑNÍyÜîÑN̓ËpÚ¼Ò×Ó8ï›Ê“Ë›Ù>ÍyÜîá¤Ì[ÑUÌ[Õ3Ü@Ò×áµÌ[ʓÒIÝ>Ù@Ì[ҹ˛ÍðÅñã ßyÒIá
ÑpÍyÑNÖIÞ@á¤Ò×ábïpÒ ç ÕVáOÊ[ÕRÑpá“Ëp̈́ÑNÝ>ÖIÕÕVáµÌ[Ò¹Ú~ÑN̓ÕRáKØ*ËpÊOÌ[ß>Õ"Ú¼ËpÖIÕRÓYÙ>Ö×ÑNÊKÑN̈́Ü
ÑN̓˛ڂÒ×ÓØ*Ê:ÑpÓ_Ì[ҹ˛Íyá"ÑNÌ;Ö¹ËUé̓ÕRڼτÕRÊ[ÑN̓Ù>Ê[ÕRáRÅ\ò\Ì0ß>Ò¹ï›ß‰Ì“ÕRڂÏDÕYÊ:ÑUÎ
Ì[Ù>Ê[Õpó&Ò³Ì$Ë ç ÕYÊ[ÕRá¤Ì“ÒIÚ~ÑUÌ[ÕRáD̓ßyÕSÍBÙ>ÚÛÝDÕYÊôËNØ@݄˛Ù>ÍyÜìá¤Ì[ÑN̓ÕVáðÝDÕRÓYÑpÙyá“Õ
Õ ç ÕRÍ~Ò¹ÍèÑpÍ8õ*Ù>ÍBÝDËpÙ>̈́܄öKÓYËpÖIÖ¹Ò×á“ҹ˛ÍðóN̵é\ËìÏyÑpʤÌ[ÒIÓYÖ¹ÕVáSÑNÊ[Õ"Ó-˛Ù>Í{̓ÕVÜ
Ø5ÑpÖIá“ÕYÖIÞ~Ñpá݄ÕRÒ¹ÍyïÛÏyÑpʤÌ\ËNØW̓ßyÕÓYÖ¹Ùyá¤Ì“ÕRÊRÅb÷ÕÓYËpÊ[ʓÕVÓ_Ì[ÕR܂Ø*ËpÊ̓ßyÒIá
ÝBÞ3ÑpÏ>Ï>ÖIÞBÒ¹Í>ï‰ÑNÍøÑpÜyÜ@Ò³Ì[ҹ˛ÍyÑNÖOÓYʓҹ̓ÕRʓÒIËpÍðÈÔÑíÏyÑNʓ̓Ò×Ó-ÖIÕ¼ÓYÑN͏ËpÍyÖ¹Þ
ÝDÕ¼Ó-Ëp̈́á¤Ò×Ü@ÕYÊ[ÕRÜùћá;ÝDËpÙyÍyÜ8Ò¹ØK̓ßyՂÜ@Ò¹êtÕYÊ[ÕYÍyÓYÕåÒIÍúћÓ_̓ÒIËpÍ8̓ËèÊ[Õ-Î
Ú¼Ë ç ÕÛÒ¹ÌØ*Ê[ËpÚûÌ[ß>Õ~Ó-ÖIÙyá¤Ì“ÕYÊÔÒ×áτË{á¤Ò¹Ì“Ò ç ՛ÅÛã ß>Ò×áÔڂÕY̓ß>Ë@ÜúÖ¹ÕVÑpÜ>á
Ì[Ëù̓ßyÕaÕYüBÏDÕRÓ-̓ÕVÜýÓ-˛ʓÊ[ÕRÓ-̓ÒIËpÍyáìÑNÌÛß>ÒIïpßþÌ[ÕYÚ¼ÏDÕYÊ:ÑU̓Ùyʓ՛Åõ5ã ß>Õ
Ê[ÕYï›Ò¹Ú¼Õ~ÝDËpÙ>̈́Ü>ÑNÊ[Ò¹ÕVáÔÒ¹ÍýÂ`ÒIïyÅÆmÜ@ÒIá[Ó-لá“á“ÕR܏ÝDÕYÖIËUéÿÑpʓÕ~ßyÑpÊ[Ü>Ö¹Þ
ÑNêDÕVÓ_Ì[ÕRÜíÝBÞ~̓ß>ÕìћÜ>Ü@ҹ̓ÒIËpÍyÑpÖðÓ-˛ʓÊ[ÕRÓ-̓ÒIËpÍðÅ ö
ã ß>ÕÖIËUéÕRÊOÜ>Ñpá“ß>ÕRÜåÖIÒ¹Í>ÕÊ[ÕYÏyʓÕVá¤ÕR͛Ì:á`̓ß>ÕÊ[ÕYï›Ò¹Ë›ÍåéßyÕYÊ[Õ Ç ËpØ>̓ßyÕ\ÏyʓËp̓Ëp̈́á$ÑpʓÕ݄˛Ù>ÍyÜìÒI͂ڂ˛ֹÕVÓ-Ù>ÖIÕRáRÅô÷îßyÕYÍå̓ß>Õ\ÍBÙ>ÚÛÝDÕYÊ
ËpØOÏ>ʓËp̓˛ÍyáÝDËpÙ>ÍyÜ8Ò¹Í3ÑN̓˛ڼáÛ
õ ;éҹ̓ßúÑNÍùÕYÖIÕRÓ-̓Ê[ËpÍDöÜ@ʓ˛Ï
ÝDÕYÖIËU
é é\ÕKÖIÑp݄ÕRÖ¹ÕVÜ̓ß>Ò×áôá¤Ì[ÑN̓ÕSћáWÏ>Ö×Ñpá“Ú~Ñ"Ñpáðá“ß>ËUéÍÔÒIÍà̓ß>Õ
ÙyÏ>τÕRÊ0Ü>ћá¤ßyÕRÜBÎ(Ü@ËN̓̓ÕV܉ֹÒIÍ>ÕpÅ ÃÐÌÔá¤ß>˛Ù>Ö×܉݄ÕìÕRÚ¼Ï>ßyÑpá“Ò YÕRÜíÌ[ßyÑUÌ
Ì[ß>ÕÖ¹Ë@ÓYÑN̓ÒIËpÍmËpØð̓ßyÕRá“Õ;ÖIÒ¹Í>ÕVá Ü@ÕYÏDÕYÍyÜyá˛ÍmÌ[ß>ÕÓ:ßyËpÒ×Ó-Õ;ËpØW̓ß>ÕVá¤Õ
ÖIÒIڂҹÌ[á‚Ñpáåé\ÕYÖIÖ\ћáìËpÍý̓ß>ÕíÓ-Ù@̓ΠËpê Ê:ÑpÜ>Ò¹ÒÙyá¤ÕVÜø̓ˏÜ@Õ-Ì[ÕYÊ[Ú¼Ò¹Í>Õ
Ì[ß>ÕÛÓYÖ¹Ùyá¤Ì“ÕRÊ[á;Ò¹Í8̓ß>Ò×á"Ï>Ö×ÑpÓYÕpÅ"Â`ÒIïyÅôÆåÑNÖ×á¤Ëmá“ß>ËUé"á Ì[ß>ÕÛÖIË@ÓYÑUÌ[ҹ˛Í
ËpØSÒ×á¤Ë›ÝyÑNÊ:áYótéß>Ò×Ó:ßøÑNÏ>ÏDÕRÑpÊћáÑpÖ¹Ú¼Ë{áµÌàáµÌ[Ê[ÑpÒ¹ï›ß{ÌÖIÒ¹ÍyÕRáÒ¹Íú̓ßyÒIá
Ü>ËpÙ>Ý>ÖIÕÖIËpï›Ñpʓҹ̓ßyڂÒ×ÓïpÊ:ÑNÏ>ßðÅ`ã ß>Õ"á“ֹ˛τÕÒ×áOÜ@Ò¹êDÕRʓÕR͛ÌOØ*Ê[ËpÚ Ì“ß>Õ
Ò×Ü@ÕVÑNÖyï{ÑpáOÝDÕRÓRÑNÙyá“ÕÌ[ß>Õ"Ï>Ê[ÕRá[á¤ÙyʓÕ"Ü@ÕRτÕRÍyÜ>áËpÍ~ÒIËpÍ>Ò RÑN̓ÒIËpÍ~ÑN̈́Ü
Ü>ÒIá[á¤Ë@ÓYÒIÑN̓ÒIËpÍðÅ
ã`ÑNÝðÅ>à á“ß>ËUé"á\̓ß>ÕÔØ*Ê:ÑpÓ-̓ÒIËpÍíËNØ`̓ß>Õì̓ß>Ê[ÕYÕàڼ˛á¤ÌØ*Ê[Õ {Ù>ÕYÍ{Ì[Ö¹Þ
Ø*˛Ù>ÍyÜúá¤ÏDÕRÓYÒ¹ÕVáYÈ"ڼ˛ֹÕVÓ-Ù>ÖIÕRáRóWÑU̓˛Ú~á0ÑpÍyÜùØ*Ê[ÕYÕåÏ>ʓËp̓˛Íyá;éßyÕYÊ[Õ
Ø „ÍyÜ@ÒIÍ>ïÑ8Ï>ʓËp̓˛ÍþÒ¹Í Ñ
ÒIá‚Ü@Õ yÍ>ÕRÜ Ñpáì̓ß>ÕaÏ>ʓ˛ÝyÑNÝyÒ¹ÖIҳ̵ޏËN
ÓYÕYʓÌ[ÑpÒ¹Í3ÓYËpÚ¼ÏDËpÙ>ÍyÜúÏyÑpʤÌ[ÒIÓYֹ՛ÅàÃÐÌàá“ß>˛Ù>ÖIÜ3݄ռÍ>Ëp̓ÕVÜù̓߄ÑUÌÔ̓ß>Õ
á“Ù>Ú‰È Ò×ámÖIÕRá[á~Ì[ßyÑNÍ Æ8á“ÒIÍyÓ-Õ8Ëp̓ß>ÕRÊaÓYÖ¹Ùyá¤Ì“ÕRÊ[á
ß„Ñ ç ՉÑúÍyËpÍ@Î YÕRʓˏÏ>Ê[ËpÝyÑpÝ>Ò¹ÖIҹ̵ÞpÅ ã ß>ՉÖIÑpʓï›ÕRá¤Ì¼ÓYËpÍ{̓Ê[Ò¹ÝyÙ@̓ÒIËpÍyá
ÝDÕRá“Ò×Ü@ÕRá"̓ß>Ë{á¤ÕåÖ¹Ò×áµÌ[ÕRÜùÑpÊ“Õ !" éÒ³Ì[ß3Ñ~Ú~ÑUü@ÒIÚÛÙ>ÚûËpØ Å Ç¼Ø*ËpÊ
æ #%$'& ǼÑpÍyÜíë # Æ (KÇ $ (*)Ø*ËpÖIÖ¹ËUé\ÕRÜaÝB+
ä
Þ -,ÔéÒ¹Ì“ß /. & 10
¦
2
rs=14
T (K)
rs=10
rs=6
rs=4
rs=3
4
rs=2.6
0.02
0.1
0.01
0.0
0.00
0.02
0.1
0.01
0.0
0.00
0.04
15625
0.3
0.01
n gee(r)
0.0
0.4
10000
0.3
0.00
0.04
0.03
0.2
0.02
0.1
0.01
0.0
0.00
0.04
7812
0.3
0.03
0.2
0.02
0.1
0.01
0.0
0.00
0.04
0.4
5000
0.03
0.02
0.4
7812

rs=2.6
0.03
0.2
0.1
10000
rs=3
0.04
31250
0.3
0.2
n gpe(r)
rs=4
0.03
0.2
0.4
15625
rs=6
0.04
62500
0.3
0.4
31250
rs=10
0.05
0.4
62500
rs=14
T (K)
0.5
5000
0.3
0.03
0.2
0.02
0.1
0.01
30 42 54 30 42 54 30 42 54 30 42 54 30 42 54 30 42 54 66
0.0
r
0 2 ‘ 4 0 2 ‘4 0 2 ‘4  0 2 ‘4 0 2 ‘ 4 0  2 ‘4 ’6
0.00
r
¡`¢¤£‚¥K8¦ 7@¨©Sª“·p²“·›:° 9 « ;¹
« <_²[ª“·›°ù»y½N±I=
ª <-·›ª“ª[« ;×½U²[±¹·›°ù¶*­>° <-²“±I·p°øºÛ'­ ;>9
²“±I»';I±¹«V¯@?B´¼²BA>«à¯@«Y°y¬“±¹²µ´DCO¥FEGAy«H<Y·I;I­>º¼°y¬G<-·pª[ª[«R¬“»„·›°y¯¼²“·¼¯@±¹¶9
¶*«Yª[«Y°{Ö
² .8J¼®UK½ ;I­>«R¬å½N°y¯B² A>«èª[M· L"¬Ô²[·3¯@±¹¸D«Rª“«R°›²å²“«Rº‚»D«Yª:½U²[­>ª[«R¬
Nì¥
¡`¢¤£‚¥¦ “>=
¨ ZŽ;¹
« <_²[ª“·›:° 9 « ;¹
« <_²[ª“·›°ú»y½p±¹=
ª <Y·pª[ª“« ;I½N²“±I·p°ú¶*­>° <-²“±I·p°ø¶*·pª
«;¹«
<_²[ª“·›°y¬L±¹²SAù·p»y»„·{¬¤±¹²“«Û¬“»>±I°ùºÛ­';¹²“±I»';I±¹«V¯”?B´è²BA>«Û¯@«R°y¬“±³²µ´•C
±×¬"S¬ A>M· L°ð–¥ EGA>=
« <-1· ;¹­>º¼°y¬ <-·pª[ª[«R¬“»„·›°y¯m²[·è¯@±¹¸D«Rª“«R°{
² —
J®UK½ ;I­>«R¬
½p°y¯èS² A>«àª[M· L"¬²“·m¯@±¹¸D«Rª“«R°{²\²[«Yº¼»D«Yª:½U²“­yª“«VG¬ Nì¥
½N°„P
¯ O=QRL±¹S² ATVUW2X 2Y@¥ ZS®p«YP
° ;I½pSª [›«Y\
ª <];I­y¬¤²“«Yª:¬:· <<-­yªà®p«Yª[´
I± °@¶*ª“«
^{­>«Y°{²S;I´p¥EGAy« <];I­y¬¤²“«Yª½N°y½I;¹´@¬“±I¬½I;I¬“·_[›±¹®›«R¬"½p°í«V¬µ²[±¹º~½N²“«
¶*·pª0²SAy«ì¶*ª:½I<_²[±¹·›°8·N¶O¶*ª[«Y«å«;I«<-²“ª[·p°y¬`aLAy±<bA3½I[pª[«Y«V¬L\«;;cL±¹²SA
²SAy«à°{­yº ?D«Yª·N¶b±I·p°>± dY«V¯è»>ª[·N²[·p°y¬RF¨ Tefb¥
¡$± [yI¥ YI2;S¬ A>M· L"¬b
½ <Y·pº¼»y½pª“±×¬¤·›°ì·N¶„S² A>«\¶*ª:I½ <-²“±I·p°Û·p¶„º¼I· ;I« <Y'­ ;I«R¬
½N°„¯¼±¹·›°>>± dR«R¯¼½U²[·pº~¬b¶*·›Ðª .
Jg ¦ 2>*¥ h0°>« i„°y¯>¬OB² Ay½U²SS² A>«"º¼1· ;¹
« <j9
­ ;×½Nª;¶*ª[1½ <_²“±I·p°„¬0¯@
« <Y½&´@¬ª:½N»>±×:¯ ;Ik
'
´ L±³B² Aù²“«Rº‚»D«Yª:½U²[­>ª[«p
¥ EGAy«Ûª[]« 9
¬“'­ ;³²[±¹° [½U²[·pº~¬~½Nª[«‰S² A>«R°î±¹·›°>± dY«R¯ ½N²è«Y®›«Yl
° A>± [IA>«Rª¼²“«Yº¼»D«YSª 9
½U²[­>ª[«RD
¬ ;I«R½›¯@±¹° [þ²“·øB² A>«31· ?y¬¤«Rª“®›«R¯ ±¹a° <-ª[«R½p¬“«ù±I° S² A>«ú°{­yº ?D«Yª
·N¶\¶*ª[«Y«m»>ª[·N²[·p°y¬R@
¥ EGA>«m©Sn¢ m/o »>ª“«V¯@p± <_²“±I·p°„¬Ô¶*·pªàB² A>«mº¼I· ;I« <Y:­ 9
;×½Nª‚¶*ª[1½ <_²[±¹·›°K½ [›ª“«R«è®p«Rª“q
´ L\« ;;GL±³B² AB² A>s
« roÿº¼·@¯@« ;"½›t
¬ L\« ;;
½p¬ L±³B² AùS² Ay«‚v¡ uEÔ¥ h0°ùB² A>«Û·pS² A>«Rª Ay½p°y¯ `„S² A>«¼©Kn¢ m/o ª[«R¬“'­ ;¹²[¬
S¬ A>M· L"¬b½à¬¤± [p°>>± ia<R½N°{S² ;Iw
´ A>± [IA>«RªK¯@« [›ª“«R«\·p¶D±I·p°y>± dV½U²“±I·p°ÛS² Ay½p_
° ro0¥
EGA>«ì¬[½Nº¼=
« <-·›º¼»y½Nª[±I¬“·p°è¶*·pª;x
½ Ay>± [1A>«Yª"¯@«R°y¬“±³²µ´a·N¶ .
JgyY:X z‚±¹°
¡`>± [„c¥ Y@¦mS¬ A>M· L"¬B² Ay½U²ìB² A>_
« <];I­y¬¤²“«RªÛ½N°yI½ ;¹´@¬“±I\
¬ ;I«R½›¯>¬Ô²[·8¬¤º~K½ ;;I«Yª
°B­>º ?D«Yª·p¶`º¼1· ;¹
« <-'­ ;I«R¬\B² Ay½N°‰»>ª[«R¯@p± <_²[«R+
¯ ?B´mS² Ay« ro º¼·@¯@« ; ¥
rB­>º¼º~½Nª[>± dR±¹'
° [Ô·›°>« <Y½N°‚¬“½&´ìS² Ay½N²`B² A>
« <];I­y¬¤²“«RªK½N°yI½ ;¹´@¬“±I¬`»>ª[K· 9
®B±I¯>«R¬ù­ys
¬ L±³B² A ª“«V½p¬“·p°yI½ ?';¹««R¬¤²“±Iº~½U²[«R¬‰¶*·›ªùS² A>«þ°B­>t
º ?„«Rª8·N¶
½U²[·pº~¬b½N°y¯Ûº¼I· ;I« <-­ ;¹«V¬$±I°åS² A>« <-·›°y¬“±I¯@«Rª“«V¯ì¯@«R°y¬¤±¹²µ´ìª:½N'° [›«p¥ {«
<Y½p­@²“±I·p° S² Ay«ùª“«V½p¯@«RªåB² Ay½U²~·pS² A>«Rªm¯@]« iy°y±³²[±¹·›°y¬~·N¶Ô½U²[·pº~¬~½N°y¯
º¼I· ;I« <Y'­ ;¹«V¬ `@»D·›¬[¬“>± ?';I«±¹°‰½‚º¼½p°B1´ 9?D·B¯>D
´ A{´@¯@ª[I· [›«Y° `LA>± ;¹\
« [›±¹® 9
±I'° [-^{­yK½ ;I±¹²[½U²[±¹®›« ;I´;¬“±¹º¼± ;I½pªðª“«V¬¤­ ;³²:¬ `Vº~½&´0¯@±¹¸D«Rcª ^{­y½p°›²[±³²:½U²[±¹®›« ;I´p¥
h0­>ª <Y·pº¼»>­@²[«R¯‰°B­>º¼«Yª[p± <YK½ ;$®UK½ ;I­>«R¬ºå­y¬¤² ?„«å­y¬“«Rk
¯ L±¹S² As<Y½p:­ 9
²“±I·p°ô}¥ | ª[>± [›·pª[·p­y¬ `Bº~½N°B´ 9~?D·@¯@´è¯@« iy°>±¹²“±I·p°ù·N¶Ox
½ ?D·p­>°y¯ù¬¤²[½N²“«
ª[«Yº~½N±I°y¬$²“\
· ?D« ½p»>'» ;I±¹«V¯W¥ rB«Y®›«Yª:K½ ;{±I¯@«V½p¬O½pª“« ¯@±×S¬ <Y­y¬“¬“«R¯Û±¹k
° € YIY
Ð¥
½p°y¯wi„°y¯¼½;ª[«Yº~½NªBŒU½K?';I´\[p·B·@¯Û½I[pª[«Y«Yº¼«R°›²FL±¹²SAå²SA>«roŽ9˜Z–h\rt¥
£«R°>«Yª:K½ ;;II´ `N·›°>« iy°y¯y¬bS² Ay½N²KS² Ay«;¯@«Y®B±×½U²[±¹·›°y¬O±I°¼S² A>«"«R°>«YBª [p´å½Nª[«
º¼·›ª“«8»yª“·›°>·p­>a° <-«R¯ B² Ay½N° S² A>«¯@±³¸t«Yª[«Ya° <-«R¬a±I°îS² A>«ú»>ª[«R¬[¬¤­>ª[«p¥
{*
« i„°y¯ì¬“>± [›°>™± iš<Y½N°{²$¯>«Y®B±I½N²“±I·p°y¬ô±¹°ÔB² A>}« ZGh\r·N¶@²[«Yº¼»„«Rª[½N²“­>ª[«R¬
² ;I>± Œ›« ;IP
´ <R½N­y¬“«RP
¯ ?B´ú½N°ø­>°„¯@«Yª[«R¬¤²“±Iº~½U²“«~·p¶
› ¦ 212I2I212Iœ`Dº¼·{¬µ=
²BA>«0¯>« [pª[«Y«0·N¶ð±I·p°>± dR½N²“±I·p°è½N²SB² A>·›¬“«"²[«Yº¼»„«Rª[½N²“­>ª[«R¬R¥`¢(°m¶*­@²[­>ª“«
L\·pBª Œ`IL\
« L± ;>;D]« žB²“«R°y¯¼B² A>±I–¬ <-·›º¼»y½Nª[±I¬“·p°‚²[· A>± [IA>«Rª¯@«R°y¬“±³²[±¹«V¬Y¥
EGAy«Yª[«\·›°>«]« ž@»D« <-²[¬`²“\
· i„°y¯~¬¤­ ?y¬µ²:½N°{²“±×K½ ;>¯>±³¸t«Yª[«Y° <Y«RF¬ ?D«-Ÿ² L\«Y«R°
²BA>D
« roº¼·@¯@« ;O½N°„¯3©Kn¢ mPo`šLAy± <bA8º~½p°>±³¶*«V¬µ²ÔB² A>«Yº~¬“« ;I®p«R¬0±I°
½¼¯@±¹¸t«Yª[«Y°{²;n¬ Ay · <bŒ_O;'­ [p·›°>±I·N² €¹8¦ 7Ð¥
‚nƒ@„†…\‡\ˆ_…‰vŠx‹a‚j‡\ˆ_‹
¢(°ÔS² A>±×¬ L\·pBª Œ`L\«S¬¤²“­y¯@±I«R¯²BA>«ŽAy±>[1A:9G²[«Yº¼»D«Yª:½U²“­yª“«O«
^›­„½U²“±I·p°
·N¶à¬¤²[½U²[«ù·N¶\AB´B¯>ª“·1[p«Y° ½U²_;I·MLû½N°y¯ ±I°›²[«Yª[º¼«R¯@±×½U²[«‰¯>«Y°y¬“±³²[±¹«V¬
¡ …¢xˆ_‡-£¤‰c¥–¦D§ ¨l¥–ˆx©H‹
EGA>« ½N­@B² A>·pª:c
¬ L·›'­ ;I¯ ;¹±Œp«²“·0²SA„½N°'Œ Z;¥ ªS¥U©b·I;;¹·:<bŒ0¶*·pªb­y¬“«-¶*­';
>¯ ±I¬B<-­y¬[¬“±¹·›°y¬ ½p¬GL\«;;ô½p¬«å¥ar@½p­>º¼·p°`>¡\¥¬·1[p«Rª[¬`@½N°y¯kO쥚­N­:9
ª:½N°y«Œ8¶*·›ªì»>ª[·U®B±I¯@±I°'[‰­y¬ L±³²BAþ²SA>«R±¹ª®Z–h\r3²[½I?';I«R¬R¥•EGA>±×¬ìª[«]9
¬“«R½pBª <bAlL ½p¬è¶*­>°y¯@«V¯
¯ ?B´ ²SA>«°ì¥±rt¥«;«R»y½Nª“²“º¼«R°›²‰·N¶ ZS°>«YªB[p´
²BA>ª[·p'­ [1A3B² A>_
« °"°>±I®p«Rª[¬“±¹²µ´8·N¶ o\K½ ;I±³¶*·›ª“°y±I½í­>°y¯>«Yt
ª rB­ ?š<Y·p°{²“ª:I½ <-²
°B­>t
º ?„«Rw
ª ²–³I´y¦ ´1µK´a½N°y¯ú±¹°»y½pª¤\
² ?B´ùS² A>D
« °;°>±¹®›«Yª:¬¤±¹²µ´ù·N
¶ o\K½ ;I™± 9
¶*·›ª“°y±I ½ ¶Mªô8½ Lª[«Ya° <-*« ªð±I®p«Rª“º¼·›ª“*« ·0½U²“±I·p°„K½ ; ªôK½ ?D·pª:½U²[·pª[®
´ ¸¹ªªc·-ªvº
­y°y¯@«Y*ª <Y·p°{²“ª:I½ <-²`°y·yv¥ {l9Ÿ7M´12›M§ 9ZS'° [K9´1“ya¥ {«­y¬“«R¯ÛS² A>
« <Y·pº¼»>:­ 9
²:½U²[±¹·›°yK½ ;p¶5I½ <-± ;I±³²[±¹«V¬$½N²ôS² Ay}« ªªc·-ªa½N°y¯à½N²ôS² Ay}« ·;½N²“±I·p°yI½ ;:o«R°{²“«Yª
¶*·›ª rB­>»D«Ybª <-·›º‚»y­@²“±I'° [D|"»>» ;¹p± <Y½N²“±I·p°y¬R¥
¦›¦
rs=14
T (K)
62500
rs=10
rs=6
rs=4
rs=3
½
rs=2.6
1.0
0.0
31250
1.0
0.0
15625
gee(r)
10000
1.0
0.0
1.0
0.0
7812
1.0
0.0
5000
1.0
»0 ¼ 5 10» » 0 ¼5 10» »0 ¼5 10» » 0 ¼ 5 10» »0 ¼5 10» »0 ¼5 10» 15¼
0.0
r
¡`¢¤£‚¥B¦µ>¨ZŽ;¹«
<_²[ª“·›°:9 «;¹«
<_²[ª“·›°»„½N±Iªv<Y·pª[ª“«;I½N²“±I·p°¶*­>°<-²“±I·p°ð¥FEGA>«
¬“I· ;I±IR
¯ ;I±¹°>«V@
¬ <Y·pª[ª“«V¬¤»D·p°y¯²“·þ»„½N±Iª[¬~·p¶« ;¹
« <_²[ª“·›°yD
¬ L±¹S² Aî»y½pª[I½ ;™9
;I« ; ¬¤»>±I°ð¥8¡y·pªìB² A>«a¬[K½ Œ›«m·N
¶ <Y·pº¼»y½Nª[±×¬¤·›° `cL\«èI½ ;I¬“·8n¬ AyM· LñB² A>«
»y½p±¹w
ª <-·›ª“ª[« ;×½U²[±¹·›°‰¶*­>° <-²“±I·p°y¬Ô·p¶S»y½N±Iª:
¬ L±¹S² Aú·p»>»D·›¬“±¹²“«~¬¤»y±¹°½p¬
¯>½›n¬ A>«V/
¯ ;I±I°>«R¬R®
¥ EGAy±I¬¶*­>a° <_²“±I·p°ø±×¬à¬µ²[ª“·›'° [I;I´‰»„«VK½ Œ›«R¯ú°>«R½pª0B² A>«
·pª[± [p±I°8±¹°úS² Ay«‚»yª“«V¬¤«R° <-«‚·N¶Sº¼1· ;¹
« <-'­ ;I«R¬Ô½p¬ÔS¬ A>M· L°3±I°ø¡$± [y¥b
¦ “>¥
EGA>”
« <-1· ;¹­yº‚°„®
¬ <Y·pª[ª“«V¬¤»D·p°„¯ø²“·ø¯@±¹¸D«Rª“«R°›D
² —8J~®UK½ ;I­>«R¬~½p°y¯þB² A>«
ª[M· L"¬S²[·m¯@±¹¸D«Rª“«R°›² ²[«Yº¼»„«Rª[½N²“­>ª[«RG¬ NÛ¥
¾=¥–¿*¥–¾=¥–ˆD…¥‹
€¹¦]Ž«å¥šr>½N­>º¼·p°‰½N°„¯í£‚¥šo}A„½K?>ª[±¹«Rª`>©ŽAB´B¬R¥:¬«Y®t¥|WÀÁ`YK2I“I´•¸¤¦µ1µ1Y1º_¥
€ Y8*{ ¥aZ*D
? «I; ±¹°'m
[ ½p°y¯+{ ¥
¬ ±p<b>
A «Yª“²y
` ©ŽB
A ´B¬R¥:ð
ª «Y²¤²R¥a|àĚÅ`'{“ §•µ¸ ¦µ1›“ §:º ¥
€ ³MŽÛ
O ¥Ô
Æ ±¹²[½Nºå­>ª:½å½p°y¯”t
r ¥>¢Ÿ<b>
A ±Iº~½Nª[­`>
­ ¥>©ŽB
A ´B¬R¥B
r ·:N< ¥›­ ½N»„½N°”ÁšÇRÈnÉÊ`a›µ §K2•¸µ¦
µIµ1“º:¥
€ ´K–0
o ¥„©K±I«YªB¹; «R·p°>±~`:Û
« ¥
o «Y»D«YªB¹; «R´I`'
² ¥'\
² «Yª[°{­>
` ½N°y¯•{ ¥aù
m ½Ip[ ª[·@
` ©*B
A ´@¬R¥ "
¬ «Y®t¥ð
ª «Y²¤²V¥šÇÉ`Y@¦´{§+¸µ¦
µIµK´:º:¥
€ §8*{ ¥aà
¬ ¥aù
m ½Ip[ ª[·`:Û
« ¥šø
m ¥š
o «Y»D«YªBI; «Y´I`a0
o ¥„©K±I«YªB¹; «R·p°>±~>
` ½N°y¯•
² ¥'\
² «Yª[°{­>
` ©*B
A ´@¬Y¥'
¬ «R®t¥ð
ª «Y²¤²R¥ÇÁW
` ¦
YK´12•¸µ¦µ1µIz º:¥
€ zMŽ
² ¥aù
m ±>I; ±³²BYd «Rª`'{ ¥šù
m ½K›[ ª“·a{` ½p°y¯kÛ
« ¥š
o «R»„«RªSI; «Y´1`a
o ·p°{²“ªV¥>©*×; ½p¬“º~½å©ŽB
A ´B¬“±pY< ¬ÉšËÂ1ÌjÍW
` ¦V§1Y@¤¸ ¦µ1µIµ_º ¥
€±7
ŽÔ
E ¥š>
­ ¥'ô
ª «Y°>·{¬nB
Œ ´I`W
r ¥à
¬ ¥\
² ±p<bŒ„
A ½Nºk`>
­ ¥'å
« ¥Ô
Æ ª[«R¬[¬@
` ½p°y¯kK
ª ¥'ì
| ¥
o ·I;¹; ±I°y¬y
` ©*B
A ´@¬Y¥:
¬ «R®t¥²%ÁÂað
` ¦D¸~YK2I212_º ¥
€ “M
 £‚¥D£Ô½K;¹; ±~`à
¬ ¥;
O ·B·B¯`'ì
| ¥0
O ½KYd ±~y
` ½p°y¯a¡\¥„£´ ›[ ±¹y
` ©ŽB
A ´B¬R¥:
¬ «Y®t¥
² ¥ÁÂa`'µ12Iµk¸¹YI2I212:º ¥
€ µMŽå
« ¥šþ
m ¥a
o «Y»D«YªB¹; «R´I`
¬ «R®t¥‰
m ·@¯W¥y©*B
A ´@¬R¥ÁšÇ`Y17Kµ+¤¸ ¦µI{µ §1_º ¥
€¹¦2MŽå
« ¥šþ
m ¥a
o «Y»D«YªB¹; «R´I`ay
­ ¥{r ²[½N²R¥y©ŽB
A ´B¬R¥ÁšÉW
` ¦8YK³7@µ¸ ¦
µIy
µ ¦8:º ¥
€¹¦p¦]Žå
« ¥šþ
m ¥a
o «Y»D«YªB¹; «R´P¸
Z ¯@±¹²“ª[±Y< «=
o ·›º¼»„·{¬¤±¹²“·›ª“±~`:
² ·1¹; ·1p[ °y½B
` ¢Ð²[½KI; ´Iô
` ¦µIµ1z_º ¥
€¹¦
Y8Ž
² ¥aù
m ±>I; ±³²BYd «Rª"½N°y¯k"
Z ¥'S
ª ¥y©b·I;I; · <bŒ@
` ©*B
A ´@¬R¥ "
¬ «Y®t¥ZÎÁš`'³K´:7M2•¸¹YI2I2I2 :º ¥
€¹¦³M}þ
m ¥|;¹; «R°ù½N°y¯kå
« ¥E ±>×; ¯@«V¬nI; «Y´1`ÏÐKÑ-ҚÓ'Ô~ÕÖwךØÑtÓ:Ù>ÚIÔØÐKÛÐnÜ-ÝFØÞÓ:Øß8à@¸~h-B
ž ¶*·›ª[¯•"
° °>±I®p«Rª[¬“±¹²µ´m©Kª[«R¬[¬`:"
· «L%K
á ·›ªSŒ`W¦
µI“71º:¥
€¹¦´KŽ
² ¥aù
m ±>I; ±³²BYd «Rªy
` ©Žð
A ¥Û
« ¥B²B>
A «R¬“±I¬`;
° °>±¹®›«Yª:¬¤±¹²µ´m·p¶$¢˜;¹; ±I°>·p±×¬½U²-;
° ªS„
? ½N°y½K9Ÿo}y
A ½pº¼»y½N±p[ °/¸~YK212I2_º ¥
€¹¦V§8Žì
¬ ¥„£‚¥a{
r ²[·pª[«Yª
`>
­ ¥ù
m ½N²Sð
A ¥„©*B
A ´@¬Y¥'Ë`µIzI´•¤¸ ¦µIz1“_º ¥
€¹¦zM*{ ¥aÔ
Æ ·II; ·›¬ ½N°y¯kS
ª ¥'ú
{ ·1¹; °y±¹«
L ±<dI`y
­ ¥šo}>
A «Yº‰¥>©Ž{
A ´@¬R¥'Àš`'³Iz 78´kµ¸ ¦
µIzK´::º ¥
€¹¦87
Ž
² ¥aù
m ±>I; ±³²BYd «Rª"½N°y¯kå
« ¥aø
m ¥š
o «R»„«RªSI; «Y´1>
` ©*B
A ´@¬Y¥'
¬ «R®t¥'ð
ª «-²“²R¥aōâð
` ¦“1µI2@¸~YK212I2_º ¥
€¹¦“MS
 ¡\¥"
¬ ·Ip[ «Rª[¬`:;
| ¬¤²“ª[·p»'B
A ´@¬R¥>
­ ¥ÉâaÍ`'zI“1µ+¤¸ ¦µ1µI2_º ¥
€¹¦µMŽÛ
O ¥ap­ ­>ª[½p°>«a
Œ ½N°y¯•à
¬ ¥
¬ «V¯@º¼«Yª
`>
­ ¥o}>
A «Yº‰¥y©Ž{A ´@¬R¥¸¹YK212I2 :º ¥
€ YK2MŽå
« ¥š>
r ½N­>º¼·p°y
` £‚¥šo}y
A ½Ky
? ª“±I«Yª
@
` ½N°y¯kì
O ¥šø
m ¥:Û
u ¥;
O ·pª[°`0
| ¬µ²[ª“·›»'B
A ´B¬R¥'>
­ ¥šËaË`aB
7 ¦
³+¤¸ ¦µI{µ §1_º ¥
€@
Y ¦]Ž
² ¥aù
m ±>I; ±³²BYd «Rª`'{ ¥šù
m ½K›[ ª“·a{` ½p°y¯kÛ
« ¥š
o «R»„«RªSI; «Y´P5¸ ©*I; «Y°B­>º ©Kª[«R¬[¬`:;
· «LãK
á ·pªBŒ@·á®ð
` ¦µ1µI“_º ¥
€ YIY8}þ
m ¥Û
« ¥D£±¹ª:½Nª:¯@«R½p­@
` ©*B
A ´@¬Y¥'"
¬ «Y®t¥|WÀcÂa`'z1µI›³ §+µ¸ ¦
µIµ12:º ¥
¦8Y
1.0
0.8
0.6
x
æ
çFVT xH2
SC xH2
PIMC xH2
çPIMC xH+
SC xH+
0.4
0.2
0.0
4
10
ä
T (K)
å
10
ä
5
¡`¢¤£‚¥ YK2y¨¡>ª:I½ <-²“±I·p° ·p¶Ûº¼I· ;I« <Y'­ ;¹«V¬‰½N°y¯ ¶*ª“«R«ú»>ª[·N²[·p°y¬í½p¬‰½
¶*­>°<-²“±I·p°à·p¶{²[«Yº¼»D«Yª:½U²“­yª“«O¶*·›ª—
Jg ¦2<-·›º¼»y½Nª[±¹°[ ²SA>«Ž<;¹­„¬µ²[«Yª
½N°„K½ ;I´B¬“±×¬·N¶bS² Ay«å©Kn¢ mPo ª[«R¬“'­ ;¹²[¬ L±¹²SA8²SA>«xro º‚·@¯@«;–€¹¦jO½N°y¯
²SAy\
« èy­>±×¯a®U½pª“±×½U²[±¹·›°yK½ ;DS² Ay«Y·pª[/
´ ¸Gc¡ uHE-º\€¹¦ µ8Ð¥
1.0
FVT xH2
SC xH2
PIMC xH2
PIMC xH+
SC xH+
0.8
0.6
x
æ
0.4
0.2
0.0
4
ä
10
å
T (K)
ä
10
5
¡`¢¤£‚1¥ Y@¦›¨ô¡>ª:I½ <-²“±I·p°‚·N¶Dº‚1· ;¹
« <-'­ ;I«R¬b½p°y¯ì¶*ª[«Y« »>ª[·N²[·p°y¬O½›¬b¬nA>·ML°
±I°‰¡`±[y¥YI2t?y­@²A>«Yª[«¶*·pª"½~¯@«R°y¬“±³²µ´m·p¶v—8Jg¯Y:X z>¥