花街・上七軒における歴史的まちなみ保全活動の変遷ー本当 - R-Cube

by user

on 28 марта 2017

Category: Documents

>> Downloads: 3

views

Report

Comments

Description

Download 花街・上七軒における歴史的まちなみ保全活動の変遷ー本当 - R-Cube

Transcript

花街・上七軒における歴史的まちなみ保全活動の変遷ー本当 - R-Cube

ǟāˇŗ˔ǽʒƪ˞ Vol. 4˶2010ŝ7ƽ˷
n o.10v[Eb:=^AIy
/ZO7\389/
A Study on a History of Residents' Association for Conservation of Historic and Cultural Townscape
in Kamishichiken Area
-How Participatory Planning should be Managed?ġƽ˝İ1ʛȒȭʮ2˓ʚʑ3İǖȦā4ˎǦȰŪ5
Masahiro Shirotsuki, Yusuke Toyoda, Ryo Sekiya, Satoshi Otsuki and Hidehiko Kanegae
1ȸĎ˭İĹ
ȸĎ˭ez[yjȨȶǘǔ ȨȶĐ˶603-8341 ¦ˇŗëíōǄõëȕ58˷
Postdoctoral Fellow, Ritsumeikan Global Innovation Research Organization, Ritsumeikan University
2ȸĎ˭İĹİĹ˗
ƢȿȱĹȨȶȱƢȿȱĹŊơ òĩʎȴŰǀʎȴ˶603-8577 ¦ˇŗëíȾƐ˗ëȕ56-1˷
Graduate School of Policy Science, Ritsumeikan University
3ȸĎ˭İĹİĹ˗
ƢȿȱĹȨȶȱƢȿȱĹŊơ òĩʎȴáǀʎȴ˶603-8577 ¦ˇŗëíȾƐ˗ëȕ56-1˷
Graduate School of Policy Science, Ritsumeikan University
4˱ȦİĹ
¨ƪȫ³ĹɄ Õƥƕ˶780-8520 ˱ȦŗƸȕ2ȟ5-1˷
Associate Professor, General Education Centre, Kochi University
5ȸĎ˭İĹ
ƢȿȱĹˆ ƥƕ˶603-8577 ¦ˇŗëíȾƐ˗ëȕ56-1˷
Professor, College of Policy Science, Ritsumeikan University
This study primalily intended to descrive dynamics of a community association, which aimed conservation of historical
townscape and culture in Kamishichiken as the most honoured preasure quarter in Kyoto, interms of the stake/interest
and management sysytem of the association. At first, the morphologic analysis of all meeting records for 7 years figured
out that the stake had changed from economic stake of the members to more common and general one among the
community. Second, it is indentified that the change of the interest of the association made attribution of the members
from self-employed individual or party to non-self-employed individual basis. These changes have drove the
association’s decline of activities and finally led the disbandment of the association.
Key Words : stake, morphologic analysis

ǁȵ;¢¼<.:ɇª0RʪBÐțŝʲ(A´ɍVL8¦ˇ;ƼþAɧɰ<.:ǎÝA~nl
VÂ7:!R˶ˎǦ. 2008˷3AƮ;ȬĜĞíMńŔȕ<!74ŗɰĞAɧɰ<Bˁ!·ĺĞV
ʝʸ0RʪʸǪ!Aɧɰ<!"żʡLȢH7:ʁSRɺÌłAƧBĮ!<Bɼ#1ʪVƟ#4ɵ
˘ɕȐǓAɳʵ?O7:ŭƶA˛ȞB3AūVǸK:!R3AɋǇ$ɩŒ1<.:Þȑ-S:'4´
ɍȜ>ȕņAƧLŝǴŎÉć? R
+Aʪ;ǟāȜ>H6>I<´ɍƪêVÂÎ0R+<VȟȜ<.4ʪH69(QĶĐ³&
1
łAɶƿ?Ÿ/:ƫȌVȑž.ɨɤĵVţƩ?Ƅˈ.:ʼɮAĦƃV#Rēũſ
−317−
Țʥ.4ABŜƁ
ŝ˶ŝ˷ƽA+<; Rʉ.(BǚɁ?ʙR&+AʪH69(QĶĐ
³BŨÛʪʸċʰ;ēīVėJɠėǓɛMˆAʘ³ʘĐ!UNRĞĢAĆĩ<čCSRˆ
A·Ǥ&ŵz; 743.:+AĶĐ³AƼLİ'>˓ŵ¢BɳʵAʷV4=Rʪʸ
QAȧȘê?ORɧɰʪAÔǯƛ? 74
+AʪH69(QĶĐ³B3AŰŜƁ˶˷ŝAëˋʪȗU!H69(QĶĐ³
FAƠɉVɊ:ŜƁŝ˶ŝ˷ƽĞĢ?$)RǟāȜˬɢAɐƐøDć?˓0RǬů˶ʸ
Ȳ˻ǟāH69(QǬ˶ŝƽưƯɮ˷?ģ9(¦ˇŗǟāȜˬɢɐƐćɽȖAɽȖʊĿ?
ORʪʸAˡǈĞêA¢ǓǧĿVǀ?²³VŃɼ.4
+Aŝ˒?LøEʪĞí?$)R·Ǥ¹AǟāȜH6>IAÂÎǭè;BĶĐ³z5)
;>(ĞĢVŖ'ʱW;AǕ>žɸAE8%Qă!MÞŅ˓ÀA˴˵3AɋǇ<.:AzA
ɟÍ³Mɉɕ¹àAĬƹ>=İōĔU1Ǖ>Ĕ˪Mʎ˪?ȡˣ.4
ǁȵB+AʪĞí?$)R·Ǥ¹AǟāȜH6>IÂÎǭè?8!:ȸĎ˭İĹɅ~
eƪê˄ȐVǌ<.4ǟāˇŗA˔ǽȨȶƍǾ¢Ǔ˶ŝŢŝŢ˷ąez
~eǟāˇŗVĻRƪê˄Ȑ˔ǽĹƘʻƍǾ¢Ǔ˶ŝŢ˷Aȍ<.:ŝ˒?U
47:ȽɛPȨȶe~&˓.:ú˞.4toMʟƫŨʈĶĐ³zP%PÄÝ?ú˞.4Ɋ
˰ʐVL<?ǔƁ-SRLA; R
ǁȵBʪĞí?$)R·Ǥ¹AǟāȜH6>IÂÎǭè?8!:·Ǥɉɕ<.:AH69(Q
ĶĐ³AʽėžŻǧĿjlsAɺǾ%PŨʈĞĢ?$)RǭèɊɓA;ȏ/4Ǖ>ʎ˪AȚȏ<
3AɻǧƄǠAǒɾVʸ/:·Ǥ¹?ORǟāȜH6>IÂÎ?˓0RȪĒVȊŲ0R+<VȟȜ<.
:!Rƪê˄ȐÂÎ R!Bƪê˄Ȑ˔ǽBĞˢMǻǽȾAɠȁǽŅ?ŉ0Rŉȿ5);Bǧ
.:>!ƪê˄Ȑ3.:3AċʰȍħVÂÎ0R+<VʓK4<'ǟāƪêAǰĲ<!"ǽŅ
VL4P0+<B HQ?LɠƳ; R˶ġƽ¬ŝ˷ǁȵBMML0SCȌźȜ>lb;
.%>%74·Ǥ¹AH69(QĞĢ¹A˔ǽH69(Qʒ?ŉ.:Ò¹Ȝ¢¼AǒʄV
ʸ/:OQ˂Ù>ʽėVěR4KAƢȿȜȦɸVƚ½0RLA; R
10v7\38[E:=^ATe
ŜƁ ŝ˶ ŝ˷ ƽʪʸAȧȘê?ŉ
0R·Ǥ˶?$ɩŒɉă˷AȚžV'7%)<.:
ɘ˳Ĺíɠǩʺă³ċʰȕÓA·Ǥëˋıǵń
$ɩŒɉă&ą?³.4+S&ȋĝ?8>&R
ʪȗU!?$)R·Ǥ¹AH69(QǭèAõǾ
; R3AŰëˋʪH69(QĶĐ³ʂȸ
ǶÇ³&ʂȸ-SŜƁ ŝ˶ ŝ˷ ƽA
ëˋʪH69(QĶĐ³ȚʥF<8>&74
3+?BʪʸAȧȘê?ORċʰɺÌĞ; R
ëˋıǵńîǁˉʳĤ<AɺÌuê?ORH6
Aǭżê<!"ȟȜ& 74˶ě ÷Ȃ˷
.%.>&PĶĐ³³ʘAʽėAĔ˪<.:
$ɩŒɉăÅBēīį&Įŷ>Ʈ;ȕÓ³ˏ
>=BÎɥȜ?ư?ƶ˒VûR+<&ˠ.(ǚȻ
?÷æ¨ƧAǴŎVƌ!4H4Ò¹Ȝ>ƁǇVƒ
*R+<&;'>%74+<&÷æɛAĶĐ³FA÷
ě 1 ¦ˇŗëí?µɖ0RëˋʪȗU!Ğě
æAqjV¶-2Rɶę<>74
2
++;ɼ"Ćĩ<BĞĢ?$!:ˏŝ?U47:ŬɜȾ?ŏ!:!R·ǤM$ɩŒMƫ§ȾA!UNRəɣA
ɊėɛȾɑ/:ȫ³ȜɊǳȜĞµ&˱!<·Ǥ˒;ʊȦ-S:!R¨D<VƑ0
3
ǁȹB3 ȹ¯˕AØǅ<BÝ?ëˋʪȗU!H69(QĶĐ³AˏʚŔōǚ˅ǣøD˓ÀɛAȚɼVL<?ǔ
Ɓ-S4ʀʴ; R
−318−
-P?ŜƁ ŝ˶ ŝ˷ ƽ?ˆAēŠ<$ɩŒɉă&ŵ?>7:±Ȗ.:'4[u
˶ʪǐǼʦȯ˷?$!:ʪʸAȧȘêɠ¹?ùŉ0R·ǤLĸĝ0R+<&ƳRI<>74+
AO">Ɋɓ%PH69(QĶĐ³&ȟǗ<.4ȧȘêɽȖB˦Ɠ.ŜƁ ŝ˶ ŝ˷ ƽ ư
?ǭèV²ǜ0R?ɡ74
ɲȸ74ǭèB²ǜ.4LAAɶzBĶĐ³AÔlouFć)4³ăVĿǀȜ?ŁƯ.4
H4·ǤAĶĐ³ǭè?ŉ0RȌɻVÁ04KʪȗU! 12 ȕ4˶ʪȗU!ƷɺƨÇĞí?ŉ
Ÿ˷AĞĢ·ǤVŉʜ<.4ĶĐ³AʌƳVɮ">=ȌɻAŴşVě743AŰĶĐ³BŜƁ 17 ŝ
˶ 2005 ŝ˷ 5 ƽ?ëˋʪȗU!H69(QǶÇĶĐ³F<ƠȲ.4+AǶÇĶĐ³Bʪ
ʸAȧȘêAIVȟȜ<.4ƱH69(QĶĐ³&˖ĿȜ>·ǤAƟƐ.%ü)PS>%74ùȣVL<?
ȧȘ5);B>!ċʰĞĢÎ¹AH69(QVɚ#:!(ɉɕF<ɱƻ#Vě74LA; R3.:Ŝ
Ɓ 19 ŝ˶ 2007 ŝ˷ 6 ƽŨʈǶÇĶĐ³BëˋʪȗU!H69(QĶĐ³˶¯Űƭ˽H69(
QĶĐ³<0R˷<.:ǝť?ÔȚʥ.4
ƭ˽H69(QĶĐ³˶ǶÇ³VĉJ˷B 2 8Aˆ³?ÝSļŵļÎˆ³;BȸĎ˭İĹ<Ñą;
H6Ǟ'Vɮ!ļŵļÎr~V»ƁĽƁ.4r~VʪȗU!A 12 aȕÎřFˈŘ.4
H4ʪʸA¥ʸˌʏǊVÑą; 3 ŢŁƯ.3AʏǊɋǇ?ģ9!:¦ˇšÏļĶĐ³Fʪʸ
?$)Rʾã>ʸʾ¥ʸ?˓0RɶƿVɮ74ɋǇʪʸAǃȺʦˣ?ʹŢɪ<2Aʿʦ[u
VɲȪ0R?ɡ74L"ƮAǟāƪêˆ³BŜƁ 19 ŝ˶ 2007 ŝ˷?ʪǛɤɔĦ?:ɧɰƪ
êjk\VˑÈ.4H4ƭ˽H69(QĶĐ³<.:²³?ɡRH;ëˋʪȗU!H6
9(QxlV 4 Ę?U4QȚɮ0R>=·ǤFAŽĥƚ½LɎɏȜ?ŁƯ.4.%.ŨÛBĮ
Ǖ>·Ǥ&÷æ.:!4?L˓UP1ǚȻ?ʪʸǪ!A·Ǥ&÷æɛAŵ<>74-P?
ʪʸċʰAēǓ?OQǔƁ-SRì³AɋƁ¦ˇŗŤʂŐ&Ō.:ʂȸ-S4ʪʸȀˡ
êȾïʘ³˶ʪʸǪ 6 ȕǛɤ³ì³?OQǔƁ-SR˷?O7:ʪʸAȀˡê?˓0R
[xjYsZ}&<PSRO"?>74ɋǇƭ˽H69(QĶĐ³FA÷æɛAǴŎ&Ȏ5.(>7:(
R>=ȉǫ&Ĭ.ŜƁ 22 ŝ˶ 2010 ŝ˷ 1 ƽ?ƭ˽H69(QĶĐ³B²³0R?ɡ74
IBKF5$%!
++;BʪH69(QĶĐ³øDëˋʪȗU!H69(QĶĐ³?$)Rls[d˶ÞŅ˷
ŉʜ&ǭèǀ˒?$!:=AO"?Ĭê.:'4A%VƳP%?0R+<VȟȜ<0R3+;
ŝŢ%PŝŢ?%):ɑ³Aũť;ˑÈ-S4H69(QĶĐ³?$)Rʘ¢ˍAÎtoVũſ
Ɇɻǅ
Vȑ!:ØǅVɮ"
}~t4{ /,/';pC6]L
++;BũſɆɻǅ?ȑ!RŽĥA˃ĿƮǬ<ɼɫAñµVǧĿ0RH1ŝŢ%PŝŢH
;Aɑʘ¢ˍˆ?8!:ĿĠ|_ruA%PĶĐ³ĆM÷æɛĆˑÈưƶȾ!1SAʘ¢
ˍ?LŶ1ʀʭ-S:!RŽĥ?8!:˙ö.4;ʘ¢ɶƲÒ¹Ȝ>÷æɛAȚɼÓŇAIVĂŝŢ
,<?Ƌ×.4
ɥȜ?ưǁʋBǠɪƪƪɁñʋƪķA˥?Øɻ0R+<&Āɞ; R¸ɭP˶˷&Ƒ
ƞ.:!RO"?ʸśưǁʋVØɻ0RƼōñµBñʋ; R.%.¼#Cɗ.!ǟāȜƷɺ
<!"ƪȹAĦăɗ.!ǟāȜƷɺɗ.!ǟāȜƷɺɗ.!ǟāȜƷɺ
<!"O"?ɻˉ0RÅAÜƬMɺ?O7:ñʋ<.:ñµ&İ'(Ĭê0R3+;ǁØǅ;B
cv<.:AñʋVƋ×0RƮǬA8<.:ȑ!PS:!RũſɆɻǅAƄǬVȑ!:Îʘ¢ˍ
toVũſɆ<čCSRƪǬȜ?žČVƐ8ƼōñµAƪķÚ?Øä.43A;ɥĆʆAIV
4
ƭ˽H69(QĶĐ³&ŉʜ<0RʪȗU! 12 ȕ<Bǃ©ōʦȕëɉǃɵðëȥȞȕëˮĖȕ
ǢǨːȕȫņˏŒȕǃ˲őáȕǃɵǉȕȄõȕVƑ0
5
ɠȁɼʋ;ƺ%S4ƪVɼʋ;žČVƐ8Ƽōñµ?Øä.Øä-S4ɼʋAďʆVȈĿ0RƄǬ
6
ĳɦËȺȱĹƈɯİĹ˗İĹŽĥȱĹȨȶȱɠȁɼʋÖȌĹʕţ?O7:ˑȚ-S4ũſɆɻǅ^k; Rɩ
ȼVȑ!4
−319−
Øǅŉʜ<.:Ɩȑ.4˶ăɽʋ˷
}~i_b>M=8b>M$%!IB
ěBũſɆɻǅ?O7:ŲPS4ñʋA%PɥĆʆ?8!:ĂŝŢ,<?˞ɽ.4ɋǇA
µµH;AcvAäăVȪ.4LA; RĂŝŢ,<A˞ɽɋǇ?8!:H6MĞĢ
< ! 7 4 3 A ñ ʋ A I ; B ɻ ˉ & Ā ɞ > ñ ʋ V ˙ ĭ . : ɸ 4 Ħ ă ŝ Ţ ; B $ ɩ Œ
˶˷<ȧȘ˶
˷&cv<.:İ'>äăVóK:!R+SBʪH69(Q
ĶĐ³&ʪʸAȧȘêVȟȜ<.:ɉɕ-S4+<Vɴ):!RŝŢ?8!:BȧȘAc
v&µµ%PĭS$ɩŒ˶
˷?8!:L3Aäă&¶.:!R+<&Ø%R
ŝŢ;B$ɩŒ&cv%PĭSR®UQ?ȧȘ˶
˷&ÔDµµ?ƒ&7:!4
.%.>&P
ŝ¯˕?8!:B$ɩŒ<ȧȘAcvBµµ?ÍR+<B>(
ʶ?ŝŢ¯˕¥ʸ<ˡǈ<!"cv&ǡʬȜ?İ'>äăVóKRO"?>74É
ć&ʍIûSR.4&7:Ŏ>(<Lǁto%PȡƗȜ?ƳP%>ABŝ?ʪH69(
QĶĐ³&ɋƁ-S:%PƠɉVɊ:ŝ?²³?ɡRH;Ŷ1.LĶĐ³ǭè&ŨÛAʪʸ
AȧȘê<ˡɒĞê<!"ls[d?O7:èǘ)-S:!4U);B>(Ȉ?ëˋʪȗ
U!H69(QĶĐ³<.:Ơɉ-S4A6BʪĞíA¥ʸĔ˪Vŵ<.4!UNRļŵļÎĔ
˪F<˓ŵ&ȳ7:!4+<&ƳP%?>74
ě 2 ũſɆɻǅVȑ!4 2002 ŝ%P 2010 ŝH;AĶĐ³ʘ¢ˍ?$)R˨×µ 10 vAɊŝĬê
[email protected])(#+-&8?2<
++;BH69(QĶĐ³Aƅă2ʀˍ$ODĿ¼³ʘ¢ˍto%PĶĐ³÷æɛAʡȜˌȜĬ
ê<ĶĐ³AʽėžŻǧĿAʎ˪Vǒʄ0R
7
ǁɻǅBH69(QĶĐ³&ǭèAŉʜ<.:!4ȷ˒˧Ģ;AÒ¹Ȝ>ʘʒAÓŇVƳP%?0RLA; R
+A4KH6ĞĢ>=ʘʒŉʜAȷ˒˧Ģ3ALAVɲ0ɥĆʆ?8!:BØǅAŉʜ%Pĭ.4
8
>$2006 ŝ¯˕ʪH69(QĶĐ³øDëˋʪȗU!H69(QĶĐ³ÓAʘʒAʾȴ;ɬɛPȨ
ȶe~?ŉ.:ʪʸA¥ʸˌøDʦ˯ʩĔ˪?8!:AʏǊ¾˩& Q2006 ŝŢ%P 2009 ŝŢA˒?
ɽ 3 ĘA¥ʸˌʏǊVŁƯ.4+".4ûQɉI&ąĶĐ³Ó;A¥ʸĔ˪?ŉ0R˓ŵŢă!V˱K45T"+
<Bʀ.:$(
−320−
}~KF5D@mNQD@mVJ
IB
ěBĂƅ6ăU2$ODĿ¼³FA÷æɛV·ǤɠėɮƢİĹH69
(QĚ¹3A¬¯˺8Aœż?Ø˫.ĂŝŢ,<AäăVȪ.4LA; R+Aě%P
ŝŢ¯˕ɠėǓɛA÷æäăBǴŎ.Ʈ;ɥ·ǤA÷æäă&ɊŝȜ?Ĩæ.:!4+<&
Ø%RH4ŝŢ¯˕BİĹ$ODH69(QĚ¹A÷æäă&Ĩæ.4+<LØ%R
ě H69(QĶĐ³AœżÝäăAɊŝĬê
ɲBĂŝŢAH69(QĶĐ³?$)RAG÷æɛƧ<ĶĐ³ˑÈƧ$ODŜğ÷æɛ
AɊŝĬêVȪ.4LA; R+Aɲ%PŝŢ%PŝŢ?%):BAG÷æɛƧĶĐ³ˑ
ÈƧ<L?Ĩæ.4Ʈ;Ŝğ÷æɛƧBŝŢV{d?3S¯˕ǴŎ?ʫ/4+<&Ø%R
¯%PH69(QĶĐ³AȚʥ%P²³?ɡRH;śſȜ?÷æɛœżAĬʡ<ĶĐ³÷æɛƧA
Ĭè&ʣ+7:!4+<&ƳP%?>74
ɲ 1 H69(QĶĐ³FAAG÷æɛƧ$ODĶĐ³ˑÈ
}~XcxH.RP]L"$%*YS`
Ȼ£ȹ?$!:ʪȗU!H69(QĶĐ³A÷æĶĐ%PŨʈĶĐ³ǭè?$)R÷æɛA QƮ
ĶĐ³AžŻǧĿ?˓0Rʎ˪&Ƒƞ-S4ɲBʪH69(QĶĐ³&ʂȸ-SRáAƀʐ³%
Pŝƽ?ĶĐ³&²³?ɡRH;ˑÈ-S4ƅă2ʀˍøDĿ¼³ʘ¢ˍ%PĶĐ³AʽėƮǬ
9
++;ɼ"ɠė<BëˋʪȗU! 12 ȕ˶á×˷?ő·.>$%8ŨʈĞĢÓ?$!:ɠėǓVėW
;!R·ǤVƑ0.4&7:ɠėǓVėW;!RLAAŨʈĞĢĭ;ɠė.:!R·Ǥ?8!:B·Ǥ
<0R
−321−
˶÷æɛA QƮžŻǧĿƮǬ˷?˓0RȚɼÓŇAÎ:VûQ×.4LA; R
8ȟ?ʪȗU!H69(QĶĐ³AʂȸáAŜƁŝƽAƶǾ?$!:ĶĐ³z<.
:ȕ³ˏV˃°0R+<?8!:ȕ³ˏ<.:AŬɜV¥®.4ŰLɎɏȜ?÷æ;'R«ɉI»Q?8
!:ʘʒ-S:!4+<&Ø%R3AŰLĶĐ³&²³ŃɼV×0ȡáH;ȕ³ˏMŬĐVB/K
<0RĶĐ³÷æzAȩÂ&ś?ʎ˪<.:ʊʗ-Sɏ):$QĞĢÓ?$!:ĶĐ³&ɉɕȜ>
ɴ)VƐ8+<&;'>%74+<&ʽėAʎ˪; 74<ɚ#PSR
£8ȟ?ĶĐ³Ó?$)RžŻǧĿƮǬ&İ'>ʎ˪A8<.:ʊʗ-S:!4+<&Ø%Rʜų
$#!
Ȝ>ȚɼBŜƁŝƽưAĶĐ³Ŀ¼³?$)R RŞˆzAȚɼ; R
"
% & ɲ H69(QĶĐ³ʘ¢ˍ?$)R>ȚɼÓŇ
−322−
+AȚɼ&ȺȜ?Ȫ.:!RO"?ʪĞíAH69(QĶĐ³;BĶĐ³AžŻǧĿ?Ŷɶ>Ƽ
¶˖A÷æɛƧ?8!:AɹĿžŻǧĿ?ģ9(ǚAYdjĞĢÓ;AăžũƁVÁʻ0R«ɉI
&ĸĝ.>!HH?ĶĐ³&ʽė-S43AɋǇȈ?ŝ˶ŜƁŝ˷?ɠėA÷æɛ<·
ǤA÷æɛAäă&ʶʫ.˶ě˷ʪĞíA¥ʸĔ˪?ʘʒAŵ&ȳ7:¯˕˶ě˷ĶĐ³Ó
;ʘʒVžŻǧĿ?8>*R+<&;'>(>QĞĢ;Aǭè?ùƴ-2R+<&;'>(>74
3AɋǇɲ?$)R÷æɛAȚɼÓŇ?ɸPSRO"?ŝ˶ŜƁŝ˷¯˕ʽėžŻǧĿ
jls?ŉ0R÷æɛAǵ&Ĩİ.4+A+<?OQąŝVħ?÷æɛ&æʹŢȜ?ǴŎ.:!7
4˶ɲ˹˷+S&ʪĞíAH69(QĶĐ³&²³?ɡ74ȡƗɶę; R<ɚ#PSR
7\38q|
áȹH;ʪĞí?$)RH69(QĶĐ³AɊɓ<ʽėžŻǧĿAʎ˪?8!:ƨȌV.4&
ǁʒƪBąĞíAĶĐ³VĲƤ¢¼<Ƭ/:!RLA;B>!
·ǤAɠȜ>Țž?ģ9(°žɉɕ; RH69(QĶĐ³B3L3LǮèȜ>ĸĝ; R÷æɛ
&ˌȜʡȜ?ĬŇ.4QûQɉIʎ˪&ĬŇ0R+<BŨȁ; Qʎ˪AǰǷM˓ŵAˊ>R¬Ě¹
A×ȋ?O7:ǰǷ0R+<L Q#Rɼ!Ɯ#R>P·Ǥ&H69(QĶĐ³VĉK4ĮǕ>e
~AȏƁ<˟ă˞ƦVʸ/:ĞĢʎ˪VɻǧƠĕ.O"<0R~ml+3&H69(QAp[w
dl3ALA; R<!#O"
Ʈ;ʪĞíAH69(QĶĐ³BĞĢ·Ǥ&ŋǂÊVÑƾ.:ŁƯ0RăžũƁAĦ<.:A
ǝɍżV8!?ȊŲ;'>%74
3S;BʽėžŻǧĿV"H(ˀƁ0R4K?H69(QĶĐ³?ʥQ>%74LABº>A
%ƂB|XjsjA«ɉIAǙĴ5<ɚ#:!R
áȹ;Ȫ.4O"?ʪĞíAH69(QĶĐ³B˂Ù>ʽėžŻǧĿjls&ƨÇ-S:!
>%743AɋǇ¥ʸĔ˪<!"·Ǥ˒AĮǕ>ls[d˶ÞŅ˷&ɌIă"H69(Qʎ˪Aʘʒ?
$!:ĶĐ³<.:AƳȩ>žŻǧĿVȪ0+<&;'>%74H4ȽɛPA÷ɺň?$!:L
ĶĐ³ɑ³;÷æɛAąž?O7:ǧĿ-S4¢ˤ&÷æĶĐÄ¨&"U-ʇM·Ǥ%PAƆÜVü)R
+<;ļ?˚QǚĘAɑ³;BáɼVɷ0ǧĿ¢ˤ?ŉ.:șĔVĊ0+<;ǧĿ¢ˤ&ùƣ?>R
+<&.C.CɸPS4H4ĞĢÓAăžũƁVȟȜ<.:YfuʏǊVŁƯ0RLAAʠƁù
ŉ<L?ƎƊ.:!RO">ȉǫMÎĐɢ;>!ɋǇ?˓.:ăžũƁ-S4LA<ÜƬ0G'%=
"%?8!:ś?Ǳ¡.4ȉǫ&ɸPS43AɋǇ<.:YfuɋǇVǍƍ?ǚAÒ¹Ȝ>lsr
~?ɋD)R+<&;'>%74
ɮƢAÏȜɉɕ;B>(ɠȚȜ>˞Ě; RH69(QĶĐ³BĮƧǧMƉȮ?ORžŻǧĿ<BȢ
ŇS>!ĸĝ; R3AO">;ǭèVŁƯ0R4K?BĮǕ>÷æɛAžɸVŦ'×.ʏƨ.
˖PS4ƶ˒;ăžũƁVƟƝ0R³ʘAɮ¢Ŭ˶|Xjso˷&ĀǙ; R.%.÷ɺ
ňøDȚɼÓŇAØǅVʧH#R<ʪĞíAH69(QĶĐ³?$!:B+A«ɉI&ȩȸ.:!>
%74+S&·Ǥ¹AH69(QA¼<.:ʪĞíAH69(QĶĐ³VƔ#4˜Aİ'>ʎ
˪; 74
ZfjrUgbdG
ǁȵB¦ˇ;ƼLǎť˱!ɧɰ<čCSRʪĞí?$)R·Ǥ¹AǟāȜH6>IÂÎǭèV¢
¼<.:3AʽėjlsAɺǾ%PɚňVʻK:'4
H1ʪĞí?$)R·Ǥ¹AǟāȜH6>IÂÎǭè&ŨÛʪʸAȧȘêV>ȟȜ<
.:ɮUS:!4LAAƼɈȜ?BȧȘêAŁȋ?ɡRá?ĶĐ³ǭèV²³0R?ɡ74+<VƑƞ.
43A;ʪH69(QĶĐ³øDëˋʪȗU!H69(QĶĐ³Aʘ¢ˍtoVL<?
ũſɆɻǅVȑ!4ɊŝȜ>ĶĐ³Als[dAĬŇʾȴVǒʄ.4ɋǇŝŢ%PŝŢ?%):
ȧȘ&cv<.:˨×.:!4?L%%UP1¯ŰȧȘ&>ʘ˪<.:ƒ&R+<B>(Ķ
Đ³ǭèAɈǿǀ˶ŝŢŝŢ˷?$!:B¥ʸĔ˪&ĶĐ³?$)R>ls[d<.:ʊʗ
−323−
-S:!4+<&ƳP%?>74ǚ?ʘ¢ˍto%Pŝ˒A÷æɛAʡȜˌȜ>ĬêVǒʄ.4
ɋǇĶĐ³z%Pű?ɊǳȜ>ÞŅ˓Àɛ<.:AɠėǓɛA÷æɛ&ǴŎ.ĂŝŢ,<A÷
æɛƧLŝŢ¯˕ű?ǴŎ.:!74Éć&ƳP%?>74
ȫ³AŋǂÊVƙ'3S?ɡRvr~<3AßˀƄǠVɚȶ0RƢȿȱĹ<.:ǁȵAɋʒ<
BÝ? #:©ŰA·Ǥ¹AH69(QA RG'Ʈćż?8!:ɼø.:$'4!
ǁȵ;BǁŨA·Ǥ¹AH69(Q<Bº%˼<!"ɬɛPAĔ˪žʗVâ˪?ɿ.4Ë
?LʴG4O"?ʪĞí?$)RǟāȜH6>IÂÎA4KA·Ǥ¹AH69(QǭèVɬɛP
BĈĿȜ?ɋʒ9)RLA;B>!ŝ˒?LøE·Ǥ¹?ORǟāȜH6>IÂÎǭè&ɮƢh[v
Ahu& 74?2O·ǤP&¹Ȝ?ʽė.4<!"Ǿ?$!:BJ.TɝĿȜ?ʅ¿0G'
˸˸˸˸˸˸˸˸˸˸˸˸˸˸˸˸˸˸˸˸˸˸˸˸˸˸˸˸˸˸˸˸˸˸˸˸˸
; R45.·Ǥ¹<B·Ǥ&ɠPAĞĢA QƮ?8!:¹Ȝ?ɚ#R<!"žČ; 7
:ɮƢAƏƄÆɺVʃ0+<;Bǧ.:>!ȻɁ;LƑƞ.4O"?ʪAH69(QĶĐ³;
B·Ǥ÷æA QƮMžŻǧĿƮǬVŕ7:÷æɛ˒AǱ¡&ś?ʣ':!4·ǤɠʨƢȿȸǏMʽ
ėA~|]rjw;B>!·Ǥ¹?ORǟāƪêȜH6>IÂÎǭèAI>P1Ǖ>H69
(QǭèV·Ǥ&¹Ȝ?ʻK:!(4K?BĮǕ>ls[dp&÷æ0R+<Váƚ?˞Ě;
Aȇ¢AǧKƮMǧK4<!"+<A¢Ł&Ɛ8žČAȌɻVç)Rho<.:A|Xjs
oAĸĝ&ŶɶĀǙ; Q3S?O7:·Ǥ¹AH69(Q&u%PƟ#PS:!(Ŷɶ
& R+AŬäVǇ40+<&©AɮƢMİĹ?ǀŮ-S:!RA;B>!5T"%3A;ˏ
ǀȜ?BĞĢ&ɠȸ˶ɠů˷Ȝ?H69(QVʻK:!(4KAlcVȳǑ.·ǤɠPAƄ?ĞĢ
AʽėVĶ@:!(Ʈćż&ˊɶ; R·Ǥ÷æĠH69(QAŶɶż&Ī˱?ÿCSRO"?>7:%
P .!·Ǥ¹AH69(Q?ŉ0RɹɂȜ>ŧ R!B3S&!1SBɠȁȚȏȜ?ȏHSR
5T"<!74ȠÃȜ>ſŢVɮƢLȨȶɛLƠKRƶǀ?ǂ:!R
DlWa
1˷ ¸ɭɘʮǆƵȔȆɅȔ¤yýľƁTFIDF/TFƑǗVȑ!4ôǘɀȌØˋ?$)Rɼʋʟƫ¹%PAc
vɠèǒ×ƄǬAˑȚ2004ŝƭǹȤʤĞˢǽŅVûQ*4\]}xlFA˂ȑ¢¼ĞĢļÎĹ³
ʒƪ˞No.8, 2006
2˷ ȸĎ˭İĹƪê˄Ȑ˔ǽĹ+<B/KɃ×ȅĶĐ³ƪê˄Ȑ˔ǽĹ+<B/KɃǋť³ȫYvl
3˷ ġƽ˝İİǖȦāĄǁŀāȃǺʯǥȒđȏˎǦȰŪĞĢ·ǤAǟāˇŗ?ŉ0Rgm~uũƁ
?˓0RȨȶǟāˇŗ˔ǽʒƪ˞No.1, 343-342, 2007
swH1B/K?2003ŝOQȽɛPAȨȶe~&ŨƶAʪH69(QĶĐ³øDëˋ
ʪȗU!H69(QĶĐ³?`}iz÷æ0R+<?ŉ.:Ź(,Ƈʔ.:(5-74İʢ
ˏ³ˏVB/KĶĐ³zAȝǕƮ?ŉ.:ŵOQʖžVɲ.H0H4ǁȵA»Ɓ?˜.:ą
ĶĐ³ɑéAˏʚŔōā˅ǣ<¦ˇŗƷɺH69(Qmo?¢Ł˓ÀAȩʊMŽĥƚ½ȾAǕ>ˣ
;,ïåV!45'H.4++?ʀ.:ʖžVɲ.H045.ǁȵAʀʴ?˓0R0G:Aʞ°Bɬ
ɛP?Ś0R+<Vȓ.ǲ#H0
>$ǁȨȶBȸĎ˭İĹ21ɅCOE~eƪê˄ȐVǌ<.4ǟāˇŗA˔ǽȨȶƍǾ¢Ǔ
˶ŝŢŝŢ˷øDezCOE~eǟāˇŗVĻRƪê˄Ȑ˔ǽĹƘʻƍǾ¢
Ǔ˶ŝŢ˷?O7:ŁƯ-S4ȨȶƁǇ; R
−324−

花街・上七軒における歴史的まちなみ保全活動の変遷 ー本当 - R-Cube

Comments

Description

Transcript

花街・上七軒における歴史的まちなみ保全活動の変遷ー本当 - R-Cube