ｩﾂｻ cZ^·Z仆 ] iR» ｶｻYﾂｾﾌﾌ^e ﾉ Y|ｰｿZ] d ﾀ ½Y ﾋY

by user

on 28 марта 2017

Category: Documents

>> Downloads: 4

views

Report

Comments

Description

Download ｩﾂｻ cZ^·Z仆 ] iR» ｶｻYﾂｾﾌﾌ^e ﾉ Y|ｰｿZ] d ﾀ ½Y ﾋY

Transcript

ｩﾂｻ cZ^·Z仆 ] iR» ｶｻYﾂｾﾌﾌ^e ﾉ Y|ｰｿZ] d ﾀ ½Y ﾋY

'()*( +,"%-.( +" !"#$%&
117- 150 ;"<=> 81390 '"-9!: 849 56"71 82,34"1 /"0
'()*( +6(MN4"E OA#> 6, ?@A! ;"BC"D! )E )FG! H!(@I JKKBL
4#5"6-./&0#$1&2(3&,
!"#$%&'()*&$+%#
1390 ()*+ 26 :$%&'
1389 #" 1 :!"
'()*( RN4"E OA#> 6, "P4"E ?@A! ;"BC"D! ,"Q*( H!(@I R06)E C"S! J*( TM
6@Y#! J*( +()E .O0( +,"%-.( 'XU H!(@I RN4"E V"W H!(@I H!"1 U O0(
R4"!: 56, /@Z 6, 6@[U P4"E 12 H!"1 4@74 P* +()E "*@ H4" /M! P* :(
R*(6"\U \U M\,R\! '"\[4 \AC"D! J*( ]*"-4 .O0( 5M1 5,"=-0( 1381- 1387
6, 6(,"#A! 5M##UJKKAL +")K`-! 8"P4"E OKNC"! ^@4 RZ"K-_( 6"-&6 8RL"K$7I
8]*"-4 +6(@-0( 6@Y#! E .M#-9 '()*( RN4"E b"Y4 6, ?@A! ;"BC"D! 6"-&6 cKa@L
5M1 5,: JK7gL 'XU ,"%-.( f*()1 :( R#K[4"e +"dW"1 "E R06)E ,6@! /M!
)\F( 'X\U ,"%-.( OKAa U M,R! '"[4 h$-g! +"/M! JK7gL c*"-4 .O0(
.O0( -1(, R06)E ,6@! 4@74 6, ?@A! ;"BC"D! )E +6(,"#A!
B@%-C 5-A,-.+ /0-1234 5-2' 6-.' 78-9 5:2;9 /<=>9 5,.+ 5?@%@ :+MK$U +"5j(
.?DE "3FG@
.C23 5N1 5G21 :JEL +M#ESBZ
!MS! .1
O-QR M->S. HT.-+ U-V. P -A,-.+ M-9.O@% -94P M-E 8-A"H9 ?I. JKFL9 #A2IE M+%N
A2-IE O@ #0-X+ " 1.-Z@ H-KK)=@(0-+ P #2-IE Y>-Z " #"-3FG@ #-A?@%-W+ O@ #0X+
P :2-;9 58-+ 5^-Z_9. /-<=>9 \@]-!@ P H-KE 2-`M-+ 5-A,-.+ H-@@" M-+ U@P [*-Z \@]!@
/@%-S9 J;-c .-Z@ -A,-.+ M9.O@% 94P 60=" (%[*9 5b4 2`M+ 57212=@a2TI9
[email protected]
[email protected]
_0Z HKd2+ efI.@" "FZ@
"3FG@ 8C@ g_CE
(2011) ]_0T@ P (0TI09 .1
49 56"71 2,34"1 /"0 '()*( +,"%-.( +" !"#$%& 118
\@]-!@ j-d+ 5?i8-.%0ih%-G %+ /V. P #%f=+%Q " A,.+ ?"2+ M+%NH+ P e8__E@8A
-A,-.+ ek-P $O@ ?-3S. j-d+ "2-4 (-@ ME e8C :2;9 /<=>9 (F!%i H.P]! P A U@P ?O
-l. M-+ M-E e8-C U@P #->d@ #@%+ %F)E m+_9 O@ #@"24%+ HF0;cP (0_l MN0F. .Z@ e8"%i
" M-n.R 8-_.9 M9.O@% 88C 94P 5(@ %+ ?P]!@ .Z@ MFC@" 7<." M+ @ HK9 "3FG@ " h<S.@
j-d+ 58-C e8A-I9 2001-2002 (0-F.@oR P 1997-1998 HG%C #0ZR 51994-1995 ,]T9
2
.Z@ e8C H=9 [0Vd #A?@%W+ P A,.+ p2SZ 5HT.+ 1g@%A
/<=>9 e8_@]! %0Z 52IE HT.+ UV. #P@%! #A\=l (%[*9 O@ HT %04@ 7Z 8_l "
O@ -A,.+ #@"24%+ P 2IE H=2' P H=9 @O+ ?"2+ 2W9,.+ M+ Mr2 + %9@ (@ 3.e"2+ :2;9
/-<=>9 t2-)N9 \@]-!@ .-Z@ e8C 78<9 HK9 \=l , M+ 52IE Hf_8S. 81" 90 "P8s
.-Z@ -A,-.+ 4#-<Fd@ ,-X \@]!@ e8_A"?I. 5H>d@ /D0*X \@]!@ #FZ@ " :2;9
J0;-c "%-TK)d P -A,-.+ M-9.O@% 94P #2i HZ%+ "29 #A7Z " <X. (@ \@]!@
2-IE " H=-9 [0-Vd ?@%-W+ M-+ 8-.@2H9 b4 B@%C " ME Z@ ,X %89 " A,.+
"2-rPM-+ 6-9@2d H-Z%+ P -A,-.+ -F! 60KW P M]N 5HF0;cP (0_l J012 " ."2C %N_9
mG@P " .Z@ MF4@"%' ?R M+ M=S9 (@ ME Z@ @"24%+ H14 0)A@ O@ :2;9 /<=>9 e8.PR
#@8-T.+ ;_-1 " -A,-.+ :2;9 /<=>9 e8__E"N@ HK1@ 69@2d 4_C 5u0SW (@ MKvX9
#"-3FG@ ?D-E 6-9@2d P HT.+ b4 69@2d 69C 5H+%N P #%V. "2r29 H.<9 gZ@%+ 2IE
.Z@
M-+ 3 \L+ ."2CH9 Mw@@ 2IE HT.+ UV. :2;9 /<=>9 O@ e2E #%23 XL. 5M9@"@ "
-A,-.+ :2-;9 /-<=>9 #%0i eO@8.@ M_09O " e8C UN.@ /;=>9 (% [*9 P%9 P u0SW M_0I0'
-Ae"@" #-9R J0-12 P ?R " M-F! -EM-+ #-A%0xF9 578-9 H!%;9 M+ 4 \L+ ."@" b3F4@
P #8-_+m-)r M-+ ]-0. %-4R \-L+ ."2-CH9 Mw@@ 5 \L+ " yF. 60KW P 789 (0)L ."O@"%'H9
."@" b3F4@ #%0iMN0F.
1. Bank Panic
(2011) ]_0T@ P (0TI09 .2
?@%@ H9DZ@ #2*)r #]E%9 ,.+ 5(1387) HT.+ [FX0Z HV. -HFZ0Z MFX+ .3
- ?i8-_A"U@P M-r2F9 5?i8-.%0ih%-G B-Z2 HF!-" #AU@P 4@"%'O+ U8d ^<Z M+ ME Z@ HTX #<Fd@ ,X .4
."2CH9 ?@@&iM9%Z
119 '()*( +6(MN4"E OA#> 6, ?@A! ;"BC"D! )E )FG! H!(@I JKKBL
'()*( RN4"E b"Y4 ?@A! ;"BC"D! :( +)*@%L .2
/-<=>9 P 72-12=@a2T-I9 5:2-;9 5MFC&i 80Z%Z /<=>9 ?@]09 1387 e9 8_zZ@ ?' "
e8-09. 2-IE HT.-+ MT<-C 1:2-;9 /-<=>9 {-' (-@ O@ M-=S9 (-@ " ME A,.+ e8C 42Z
8-1" 29 7"-;9 #8-C 1386 7-Z M-+ <-X. ME Z@ e80Z 7 "0K09 219335 M+ 2"2CH9
2 -*_ P H-1234 \-L+ M-+ u-K;F9 1387 7Z " :2;9 /<=>9 ?@]09 O@ 81" 98 .Z@ MFC@"
(%F-I0+ 7- "-0K09 39134 (F-C@" -+ M|-Z ,.+ .Z@ e"2+ =P" M+ uK;F9 ?@]09 (@ O@ 81"
7-Z " @ :2-;9 /-<=>9 ?@]-09 (%-F)E 7 "0K09 250 (FC@" + ,.+X' P :2;9 /<=>9
51387 7-Z " :2-;9 /-<=>9 t2-)N9 O@ 51 @"2-). M+ Mr2 + .8.@e"@" b3F4@ "24 M+ 1387
8-1" 23 P 9 P 68 ^-0% M-+ H-1234 #-A,.+ P HF=P" H33L P #N #A,.+ [*Z
P -A,-.+ /D0*-X 6-E M-+ (H-F=P"%0Q P H-F=P" \-L+ 69C) :2;9 /<=>9 <X. .Z@ e"2+
M-F! \@]-!@ 1387 7Z ?' " 81" 17/5 M+ 1386 7Z " 81" 11/4 O@ #<Fd@ /XZ}9
\@]-!@ e8-_A"?-I. 5H->d@ /D0*-X \@]!@ #FZ@ " :2;9 /<=>9 t2)N9 \@]!@ .Z@
#-2i H-Z%+ "2-9 #A7Z " <X. (@ \@]!@ mG@P " .Z@ A,.+ 4@"%' U8d ,X
M-+ :2-;9 /-<=>9 <-X. (0-_l[-A .-Z@ ,-X %8-9 M-_09O " -A,-.+ J0;c "%TK)d
1387 7-Z ?-' " 8-1" 7/3 M-+ 1386 7-Z " 81" 6/3 O@ 2IE HT.+ [FX0Z #AH@@"
5/D0*X O@ 81" 91 HF=P" #A,.+ 1387 7Z " HZ%+ "29 M.2). " 3.Z@ MF! \@]!@
57-Z (-@ " .8-.@e"@" b-3F4@ "2-4 M-+ @ :2;9 /<=>9 O@ 81" 78 P Ae"%|Z O@ 81" 83
<-X. (-@ M-E H=-s " e"2-+ 81" 13 HF=P" #A ,.+ /D0*X 6E M+ :2;9 /<=>9 <X.
.Z@ 81" 37 H1234 #A,.+ #@%+
1. Non-Performing Loans (NPL)
e9 2 O@ \0+ pXG@ 4@"%' m>G P ?R "2Z P 61@ 80Z%Z O@ ME Z@ H<=>9 :MFC&i 80Z%Z /<=>9 .2
80Z%Z O@ e9 18 O@ %F)E P e9 6 O@ \0+ ME Z@ H<=>9 ::2;9 /<=>9 .Z@ e"2)_. OPN e9 6 O@ O2_A P MFC&i
O@ P 80Z%Z O@ e9 18 O@ \0+ ME Z@ H<=>9 :7212=@a2TI9 /<=>9 .Z@ e8C #%|Z pXG@ 4@"%' m>G P
O@ %-V. ~%-1 ME Z@ A,.+ /<=>9 O@ \L+ ?R :e8C 42Z /<=>9 .Z@ e8C #%|Z ?R pXG@ 4@"%' m>G
?@2-_d M+ ,.+ e%89 /0A ^23 + P e"2<. 721P 6+G %f" 6Kd P HfFXTCP 60<G O@ (SF9 6" M+ 80Z%Z
(1386) ?@%@ H9DZ@ #2*)r #]E%9 ,.+ .Z@ e8C HSK e8C 42Z /<=>9
.?@%@ #@8T.+ H=d $O29R MXZ}9 52IE HT.+ UV. "%TK)d $@]i 5(1388) 5(1387) 5(1386) 8)W9 5"@k.#809@ .3
49 56"71 2,34"1 /"0 '()*( +,"%-.( +" !"#$%& 120
87 /"0 6, ?@A! ;"BC"D! :( "P4"E 2k0 .1 6(,@74
(1388) 52IE HT.+ UV. "%TK)d $@]i :&49
lKS<L #K[K .3
?DE "3FG@ B0W9 P B@%C 69C 69@2d MFZ" P" %+ :2;9 /<=>9 60KW H+%N P #%V. /0+"@
M-+ e-2E 5M-9@"@ " M-E 8__EH9 eC@ HT.+ ;_1 F4Z P A,.+ "%TK)d M+ p2+%9 69@2d P
.[O@"%'H9 /0+"@ (@ P%9
6T0-Z #-A78-9 M-+ %F-I0+ :2-;9 /-<=>9 P ?D-E "3FG@ B@%C M>+@ Y0c2 #%V. #_<9
,- #-N /-< " H=-9 #AM>Z@P "%TK)d \S. %+ 80E + A789 (@ .""%iH9 O+ #N
1
.8.@e"2). [A@%! :2;9 /<=>9 e8__E(00; 69@2d #OZ789 #@%+ @ 24 M_09O
?@P" " M-E #@M-.2iM+ MFC@" HKT0Z #F! A,.+ :2;9 /<=>9 52ll (@ gZ@%+
P -A@2.4 5H-K9 8-0=2 \@]!@ + u.P MKs%9 " .8+H9 \@]!@ "2E ?@P" " P \AE u.P
"2-4 /@8-*; P ?2-" -4@"%'O+ ?-%r (09- #@%-+ H!-E ?@2- P #89R" ?%r O@ Aef_+
e"@" ?-I. 2()!-E M-E M-.2i?-)A -9@ 5Z@ "P8W9 :2;9 /<=>9 [Ns (@%+_+ P 8.@"24%+
6-)d g2-T;9 -*r " y8- M-+ e8-C J0;-c #@ M->+@ (0-_l %-H.2` H.9O u!@ " Z@
B@%-C O@ #@"2-4%+ ^<-Z M-+ A,.+ 5HK9 80=2 8C FC P #"3FG@ u.P UP@8 + .8_EH9
#-A"@8.F-Z@ 5HT.-+ (0-+ -+G -I! (0-_n)A P e8-_R M-+ <-X. H-_0+ $2-4 5M9.O@% 24
M+ /@<Fd@ 4@"%' )Z M+ P e"@" UN.@ @ #%J0;c #%f=+%Q 5MF!%i 6*Z @ <Fd@ 4@"%'
:2-;9 /@-<Fd@ [-Ns "2-CH-9 OQR "2E ME H9f_A {' .8.PH9 %0z0E[E ?i8.%0iU@P
#"2-E B@%C " ?2" 4@"%'O+ " 0z0E[E ?i8.%0iU@P H.@2. .8+ H9 \@]!@ d%ZM+
g2=2'_%i P (Kiyotaki and Moore) 1997 29 P HE20E 5(Minsky) 1986HTX_09 51933 %I0! 51987 ?2X90KP .1
(Geanakoplos) 2009
2. Kaufman (1998)
121 '()*( +6(MN4"E OA#> 6, ?@A! ;"BC"D! )E )FG! H!(@I JKKBL
HT.-+ [FX0Z "]. " ?i8.%0iU@P #AMS0P $O@ \AE P U*Z $O@ p2SZ O@ HC. (0_n)A
M-+ -A?R $O@ 7]-_ j-d+ "@2-9 H-4%+ " M-E -AM-S0P $O@ \AE 5"2E ?@P" " .Z@
4@"%'O+ O@ _Fr@ #@%+ ?i8.%0iU@P 6) \@]!@ 5"2CH9 HF!" #AU@P $O@ O@ %(0'
H-F4@"%' /@-<Fd@ [-Ns h-<S.@ 5#"2-E B@%C " 5(@ %+ ?P]!@ .Z@ MFC@" 7<."M+ @ AU@P
" @ ?i8-.%0iU@P %F-I0+ H.@2-. P e8C Kd %+ 8]9 A?R ?8C %]%i,X ^<Z M+ A,.+
M-+ @ "2-4 HF!-" #-AU@P M-E H.-XE #@%-+ ekP M+ H.@2. (@ ."@" 7<."M+ AU@P 4@"%'O+
M-+ O-0. "2-4 -AU@P t%-! P 6-1@ -4@"%'O+ #@%-+ P e"@" b3F4@ /898_K+ #A#@&iM9%Z
."2+ 8A@24 %FI0+ 58.@" U@P "8N9 !"
/-0K)d " -AU@P -0z0E P ?D-E "-3FG@ B@%-C (0-+ M>+@ #OZ 789 M+ HzKFL9 /;=>9
" ?D-E "-3FG@ B@%-C P (U@P ?-O) 1M-F!u-SW #-<Fd@ ,-X (0-+ M>+@ (0_n)A P HT.+
%-. 5#-T0+ %-. 5GDP 8-C /;=>9 (@ " .8.@MF4@"%' AU@P 72T. %. M<ZW9 2ll
72T. [Ns P A,.+ HF4@"%' U@P @8S9 %+ ?DE "3FG@ B@%C 4C ?@2_d M+ ?R 8_.9 P U2
\A-E %-@ 5H=8-9 (0_l H!%;9 + (1995) ].2= 5M.2). ?@2_d M+ .Z@ MF!%i @%G Mr2 "29 A?R
78-9 (-@ M-_0*+ @8-S9 M<ZW9 + P e"@" @%G M;=>9 "29 AU@P 72T. 7)Fs@ %+ @ bLC@ 89R"
-]0n.-Z P #8-=_ ."2-CH-9 -AU@P 72-T. 7)Fs@ \@]!@ jd+ H3LC 89R" ?Z2. "@" ?I.
#@%--+ --Ae--f_+ B--Z2 h@%SF--Z@ ?--T9@ ?"%--E M!--c@ MK0--ZP M--+ ].2--= 78--9 M;--Z2 --+ 22--.@
%0- W A,.+ U@P 72T. 7)Fs@ ME 8."@" ?I. 5HS0Ss H=9 #AH@@" " #@&iM9%Z
-AU@P 8-C %-. P (e8_R M+ <X. H._0)`@. O@ H34C ?@2_d M+) #T0+ %. 5HK9 89R" 8C
."@" @%G
P a-.%+ " j-W+ "2-9 3H=9 e8_A"FC M%V. (0_n)A 5#N 6T0Z #A 789 %+ ?P]!@
#@%+ #%V. H.<9 (%[*9 O@ %f" HT 5(1997) 29 P HE20E P 5X%nK0i P a.%+ 4%K%i
?D-E "3FG@ " H=9 e8_A"FC M%V. .Z@ :2;9 /<=>9 %+ ?DE "3FG@ 69@2d \S. Y0c2
u%` O@ /@%@ (@ .8_EH9 jW+ %f8T %+ H;G@P "3FG@ P H=9 #A@O+ 94P 6+SF9 \S. %+
\@]!@ jd+ #"3FG@ "2E 5M%V. (@ #_<9 %+ .89N.@H9 P" %A 94P M+ #"24O+ P" ,
1. Ex Post Credit Risk
2. Rinaldi and Sanchis-Arellano (2006)
3. The Financial Accelerator Theory
4. Bernanke and Gertler (1989)
5. Bernanke and Gilchrist (1999)
49 56"71 2,34"1 /"0 '()*( +,"%-.( +" !"#$%& 122
p2S-Z 5H=-9 #-A"-*. HfF-XTCP M+ :2;9 /<=>9 [Ns \@]!@ P e8C :2;9 #AU@P [Ns
MF-C@" 7<."M+ @ "2E u0); 5H=9 #A@O+ P A"*. p2SZ ."2CH9 H=9 #A@O+ P U*Z $O@
e8-_@]! d%-Z j-d+ #8-_@%! (0-_l ."@" e@%-)AM-+ @ -AU@P 72-T. %-+ %. "24 ]0. (@ ME
."2CH9 #"3FG@ "2E u0); P A,.+ HfFXTCP P :2;9 /<=>9 $%FXi
.-X0. ?D-E "-3FG@ B@%-C - @]-.P%+ 69@2d 69C *_ :2;9 /<=>9 @8S9 %+ %}9 69@2d
6-9@2d ?@2-_d M+ HT.+ ;_1 " +G B@%C P U@P 4@"%' " ,.+ , F! P /01234
#@%-+ H-zKFL9 #%-V. H.-<9 .8_-C+ MF-C@" \S. ,.+ :2;9 /<=>9 @8S9 %+ 8_.@2H9 ]0. H.P"
M-+ e-2E 5M-9@"@ " ME 8_FXA "_FZ@ 6+G ""%iH9 O+ A,.+ /01234 M+ ME HK9@2d @%LFZ@
.[O@"%'H9 *.R HZ%+
H.<9 (@ MK)r O@ 1«Hi8_). MKvX9» 2ll " HGD4@ e%`L9 M0c%! P ?SF9. /dD`@
5g-Z@ (-@ %-+ ."@" 7<."M+ @ /@<Fd@ 4@"%' " A,.+ %]09Re%`L9 F! ME 8_FXA #%V.
(-@ 2l-l " .8-.@"24%+ #%F-I0+ :2-;9 /-<=>9 O@ 58-.@" "P8W9 M9%Z ME HA ,.+
M-+ (@%+-_+ P e8-C HfF-XTCP O@ -A?R %-F)E H-.@%f. j-d+ -A,.+ %"P8W9 M9%Z 5M0c%!
,-.+ #-AU@P ^-0E% " HT-X #-AU@P [*-Z /21 (@ " ."2CH9 %N_9 HGD4@ e%`L9
/@%`-L9 /@%-@ O@ %-f" H-T 2.-Z@ :2-;9 /<=>9 @8S9 \@]!@ ?R MN0F. ME MF! \@]!@
-4@"%' M-+ /"-<9 ,-.+ , ei%A 4.Z@ #@8T.+ /0K)d " 3«m!_9 "» "2rP HGD4@
Mw@@ (F!%i Z"M+ O@ HC. #A"]9E P AM!%; O@ 8_E ?ZR 0X+ B@%C + ef_+ , M+ U@P
" m!-_9 "- 5""%-i @"2-4%+ @"-*+ :@P@ $P%-! 8-*; 8-_.9 e-f_+ ?R M+ /984 #%XT
,-.+ #<Fd@ ,X \@]!@ P /@<Fd@ #@E. 03L M+ ME Z@ MF! t2GP HT.+ /0K)d
5
.""%iH9 %N_9
/-<=>9 6-" Y0-c2 " "2-r29 #%-V. j-s<9 MK)r O@ HT.+ ;_1 #@O+ F4Z t2.
]-E%) + HT.+ F4Z , 8."@" ?I. (2004 P 2000) 7i P (=R .Z@ HT.+ ;_1 " :2;9
" .8-.@" /-<=>9 72-T. P H=-9 ?@%-W+ M-+ DF-+@ #@%+ #%FI0+ "@8;FZ@ 5,.+ %FI0+ "@8; P %F)E
1. Principle Agent Problem
2. Berger and DeYang (1997)
3. Conflict of Interest
O@ 58-__E 6-)d ?@@&-iM9%-Z M-)A m!-_9 (%-F*+ #FZ@ " 5(v)>9 P T@ 6+G /dD`@ Mw@@ + Z@ @%G ME H1LC@ %i@ .4
."2). 8A@24 @80' :@839 m!_9 " 58_C+ @"24%+ U2)d ^%! #@%+ #2G #A e]0f.@
(2011) ]_0T@ P (0TI09 .5
123 '()*( +6(MN4"E OA#> 6, ?@A! ;"BC"D! )E )FG! H!(@I JKKBL
P -A,-.+ %F-I0+ #@O-+ /8-G j-d+ 8-.@2H-9 %-]E%)F9 HT.-+ ;_1 5M%V. (@ 2ll
P e8-C %-HTX /0K)d #@%+ A,.+ %F)E e]0f.@ jd+ %FI0+ #PR"2Z ."2C A?R #PR"2Z
%-+ /-V. M-E 8-."2). 78F-Z@ %f" HAP%i 1."2CH9 %F)E :2;9 /<=>9 ^r29 ?R 7<." M+
M-E ei8-" (@ gZ@%+ ."2+ 8A@24 % ?ZR ]E%)F9 HT.+ [FX0Z , " ,.+ #"P8W9 "@8;
P #-<Fd@ ,-X M+ ME e"2+ %89@E A,.+ @8A P /V. 5"2CH9 e809. 2]E%) #@8'
"-O "@8-; -+ -T%9R HT.-+ U-V. " "O H<H+ 37i P (=@ ."2CH9 %N_9 %F)E H=9 H< H+
H+2-4 e@2-i @ ,-.+ "P8-W9 "@8; + @".E P UK HT.+ #AUV. a8.@ H< H+ M+ <X. ,.+
.8_EH9 H!%;9 HAi8" (0_l #@%+
" 4H.-0i P 82+ ."2CH9 %N_9 HT.+ UV. Hi8__TC M+ %FI0+ 5]E%) 5J=L9 #"%TP "
%FI0+ M<=>9 M+ A,.+ %FI0+ #@O+ /8G P ;_1 %FI0+ ]E%) ME 8."@" ?I. #%V. 60KW ,
%-HT-X /-0K)d )-Z M+ e8.%0iU@P #Aef_+ "2CH9 ^r29 ]0. (@ ME e8C %N_9 e%*+ %.
M-.2iM-+ .8-C 8-A@24 %-N_9 -A,-.+ %F-I0+ :2-;9 /-<=>9 P #<Fd@ ,X M+ "24 (@ P MF!
M-+ 8-.@2H9 %F)E +G ME 8."@" ?I. #%V. 789 , 2ll " 5{2n9 P 7_0)E 5?X)A
" (0-_n)A .""%-i %-N_9 -AU@P %F-I0+ 72-T. 7)Fs@ P %Fi]+ #AU@P 5%F)E #<Fd@ #8_+ Mr"
#-AM.@ 6«"2C XTCP ME ?R O@ %]+» 61@ gZ@ %+ A,.+ %]E%)F9 HT.+ UV. ,
7
.C@" 8_A@24 ,X $%&' #@%+ #%FI0+ e]0f.@ (@%+_+ P e"2). !" ]+
M-r2 "2-9 e@2-)A "%-TK)d %-+ %}-9 6-9@2d O@ %-f" HT ?@2_dM+ ]0. 0T=9 F4Z t2.
8-C+ %z-1 "-3FG@ " M-="<9 M_]A ei%A ME Z@ ?R %f.0+ 8OP2E 2*I9 #2v .e"2+ (0SSW9
M-="<9 M-_]A ?P8-+ #-0." H-;G@P #-0." -9@ 9.8-_EH-). %F9 @ #"3FG@ H@E 0T=9 F4Z
" 5(-@ "2-rP -+ 10."2-CH-9 "%TK)d /Pz jd+ 0T=9 F4Z %00x 5/21 (@ " .X0.
1. Hellmann (2000), Besanko and Thakor (1993), Boot and Greenbaum (1993) and Matutes
and Vives (2000)
2. Concentration Stability
3. Allen and Gale (2000)
4. Boyd and Gianni (2005)
5. Caminal and Matutes (2002)
6. Too Big to Fail
(1999) (0TI09 .7
8. Coase
10. Cooter and Ulen (2000)
(1960) OP2E .9
49 56"71 2,34"1 /"0 '()*( +,"%-.( +" !"#$%& 124
HT ?@2_d M+ %FI0+ HF=P" 0T=9 ."@8. "2rP #8s@P M%V. 5"%TK)d %+ 0T=9 t2. \S. "29
"]-. " P-+ (-@ 6-0=" (%-[-*9 1."2-CH-9 H-SK -Aef_+ J0;c "%TK)d P H@E. 69@2d O@
5(-@ "2-rP -+ 2.-Z@ H-F=P" #-Ae-f_+ " "%TK)d "2<*+ #@%+ H!E e]0f.@ ?@8S! 5?@%fIAPk'
?R 8-_.9 P H=9 m+_9 M+ HZ%FZ" P /@O0F9@ 5=P" )s 8_.9 H)*9 #@]9 O@ HF=P" #Af_+
M-E H;9@2-r " %-f" #2-Z O@ ."2-C ^r29 @ ef_+ "%TK)d "2<*+ 8.@2H9 (@ ME 8.@"24%+
P (0-;9 #-Ae"@2.-4 ,K) " H1234 H=9 /XZ}9 58C+ #8r HKTI9 H2r.@ P "X!
" UO #A"@8.F-Z@ P -Z@ -A,-.+ (-@ " m-C #@MKvX9 H2C72' 5e"2+ HZ0Z #AeP%i
(09- #@%-+ HT-X D
9-E #-AU@P P e8-I. -d H-1234 #A,.+ BZ2 AU@P 4@"%'
8-1"81 ,-.+ ,- 5P (-@ O@ 3."2-CH-9 4@"%' B<%9 #AeP%i P bLC@ H=9 #AO0.
8-_.9 H-;=>9 M-E -Z@ 6-0=" (0)A M+ ."@8. #%F)E U@P ?O 9P]= e8CH1234 H1234
-0T=9 ?"2-+ H-1234 58-IL+H-9 "2-<*+ @ "%TK)d Mn.R ME 8.@e"%E jW+ 4%E' P "@P609
5
.Z@ HF+G 0;G29 " (FC@" @%G MTK+ X0. ef_+
.-Z@HT.-+ U-V. " :2;9 /<=>9 [Ns ?"2+ + 6" O@ %f" HT ]0. J0;c %89
5?i8-.%0iU@P #%f=-+%Q #@%-+ [-E /-*9 6T-C " 8-.@2 H9 HT.+ /XZ}9 " 7O. H@E
.8-C+ /-XZ}9 (-@ " ?i8-.%0iU@P /-0K)d %-+ J0;-c /-V. P -A M-S0P ^-Z_9. H+O@
-+ M-*r@29 P U@P ?-O #@%-+ #%F-I0+ "@8;F-Z@ O@ (0-' H-0K)d H@-E + H=9 #A "*. 5(@%+_+
.8.@"24%+ #<Fd@ ,X
-0=;! g0S9 \@]!@ u%` O@ ef_+ , BZ2F9 M_]A \AE M+ ME g0S9 #AM!%1 "2rP
{-' .8-_E H-!%;9 @ A,.+ " U@P ?O e8__E(00; 69@2d O@ %f" HT 8.@2H9 58_EH9 eC@
.8-A" Y0-c2 @ :2-;9 /-<=>9 ?-Z2. O@ H-IL+ 8-.@2H-9 M-E -Z@ #%f" %0xF9 ,.+ eO@8.@
6
P%-)KG P g-0S9 M-+ p2-+%9 #-AM!%-1O@ #@"2-4%+ ^<-Z M-+ %Fi]+ 0=;! g0S9 + A ,.+
.8_C+ MFC@" "@%!@ ,X O@ #%u0G" H+O@ 8_.@2H9
)Fs@
1. Alchian (1965)
(1995 P 1974) ]F0KfFZ@ .2
(2004) 20A .3
4. Millward and Parker (1983)
5. Louzis, et al
6. Economies of Scope
125 '()*( +6(MN4"E OA#> 6, ?@A! ;"BC"D! )E )FG! H!(@I JKKBL
(0-+ e-C@ "2-9 p-<@ Y0-c2 M-+ #0-X+ H+%N /;=>9 e8C MFzi js<9 2ll "
-+ HT.-+ #-AU-V. F4-Z P -A,-.+ /0-1234 (0-_l [A P ?DE "3FG@ #A%0xF9 P B@%C
.[0_EH9 P%9 @ /;=>9 (@ (%[*9 H4%+ M9@"@ " .8.@MF4@"%' HT.+ :2;9 /<=>9
M-w@@ -T%9R HT.+ UV. " AU@P ?O 69@2d HZ%+ e+" #@M0=P@ M;=>9 1{29 P ?2F0E
?I. :2;9 /<=>9 =4 M+ p2+%9 ?O O@ e"zFZ@ + AU@P ?O M0=P@ #%0ieO@8.@ + ?I@ .8."@"
#AU@P ?O " /Pz 5b4 #A\L+ J0;c "%TK)d + e@%)A HK4@" "3FG@ B@%C ME 8."@"
O2-_A M-E 8-C e8AI9 69@2d (@ %@ 7%F_E O@ {' HFs .8_A"H9 Y0c2 @ A,.+ (0+ e8C <
/-0K)d ,-X /P-z M-+ 5e8.)0G+ /Pz (@ .Z@ /PzF9 JKFL9 #A,.+ (0+ AU@P ?O
H-Z%+ M-+ #%-f" /-;=>9 (1987) {2-9 P ?2F0E M=S9 7<." M+ ."2CH9 e"@" <X. A,.+
P HT_0-Z 5M-.2). #@%+ .8.@MF4@"%' e8WF9 /@ " :2;9 #AU@P P AU@P ?O e8__E(00; 69@2d
@%-G H-Z%+ "2-9 H-+%N M-.2iM-+ @ e8-WF9 /@ " #N #A,.+ U@P ?O 2=@P (%i
#-A,.+ O@ HAe"@" #@%+ H)Ff= H>4 ?20Z%i 789 , (0)L M+ M;=>9 (@ " .8.@e"@"
HT.-+ b4 69@2d ME 8."@" ?I. A?R .8.@MF4@"%' 1987 1984 7Z O@ T%9R #N ]+
[0-XS 6-1s /2-1 M-+ M-E) -A,-.+ U@P ?-O %-. 8-_.@2H9 #"3FG@ ?DE #A4C P
J-%; =-4 M-_]A P U@P 6-E m-)r6-1s %-+ :2-;9 /-<=>9 ePDd M+ U@P =4 #AM_]A
%"S9 5e%*+ #A%. 8_.9 H.P" 69@2d P U@P ?O %. (0+ <9 M>+@ .8_A" Y0c2 @ ("2CH9
-=@P (%-i P HT_0-Z (0_n)A .Z@ M;=>9 (@ #AMF! MK)r O@ M9%Z zE P HF4@"%' U@P
%-. %-+ %}9 69@2d MK)r O@ ]0. HK4@" "3FG@ #"2E B@%C ME 8.80Z MN0F. (@ M+ ]0. (1991)
.Z@ #N #A,.+ ?O
P M-_]A H@-E P :2-;9 /-<=>9 (0-+ -0Kd M>+@ "24 [*9 M=S9 " (1997) . P %i%+
P e"2-). H-Z%+ 1985-1994 eP" " T%9R #N #A,.+ O@ #@M.2). #@%+ @ ,.+ M9%Z
"2-rP :2-;9 /<=>9 P M_]A H@E (0+ Hz_9 M>+@ 6TC M+ #@M!%`P" 0Kd ME ME 8."@" ?I.
O@ e8-WF9 /-@ " U@P #-A72-T. %-+ /-<Fd@ 8-C %-@ HZ%+ 2V_9 M+ (1999) ?2F0E ."@"
/2-1 M-+ U@P 72-T. M-;=>9 (-@ " ."%-+H9 E M+ @ VAR 789 , 1996 1982 #A7Z
."2-CH-9 J-%; 5MF!%f. uK; ?R M+ #@e%*+ 8.@MFC&i 80Z%Z O@ OP 90 O@ \0+ ME HAU@P
1. Keeton and Morris (1987)
2. Sinkey and Greenwalt (1991)
49 56"71 2,34"1 /"0 '()*( +,"%-.( +" !"#$%& 126
U@P %F-I0+ ?O M+ #<Fd@ (0' #A"@8.FZ@ + u+>9 /@<Fd@ m%Z 8C ME 8A"H9 ?I. ?2F0E
.Z@ e8C %N_9 e8WF9 /@ O@ H14 #A\L+ "
U-N.@ /-;=>9 -+ H*+I9 yF. 8.@e"@" @%G HZ%+ "29 @ %f" H=9 #AUV. ME H;=>9
#@8-T.+ U-V. HfFXTCP 1?@T)A P ~E%+ M.2). #@%+ .8_A"H9 Mw@@ e8WF9 /@ " e8C
M-E 8-."@" ?-I. -A?R .8-.@e"@" @%-G H-Z%+ "2-9 1993-1996 H.9O eP" 72` " @ (0F.@oR
M-+ ?i8_-X2. .8_F-XA "3FG@ ?DE Y>Z 69@2d P HT.+ b4 69@2d %0 W :2;9 /<=>9
2-V_9 M-+ 3_-Z P g-Z .8-.%+H-9 E M+ @ 2S+ 60KW $P 569@2d (@ %0 ,0Tz 2V_9
#-2' 789 , O@ 0.|Z@ #N P O@8.@{' #A,.+ " @"6TI9 #AU@P HK1@ 69@2d HZ%+
8-C 5GDP 8-C M-E 8_A"H9 ?I. A?R .8."%E e"zFZ@ 1985-1997 H.9O eP" 72` " 6.'
M-+ ,-.+ "%-TK)d P -0T=9 F4-Z 5@O-+ /8-G 5M9%Z <X. 5,.+ eO@8.@ 5/@<Fd@ m%Z
P ?-r@ .8-_A" Y0c2 @ :2;9 /<=>9 " /@%00x 8_.@2H9 %89 0z0E O@ H34C ?@2_d
"-3FG@ 2-K>9 B@%C ME 8_A"H9 ?I. 6.' ?20Z%i 60KW P M]N , #%0iEM+ + 47A"
B@%-C P M-_]A 580-Z%Z 8-_.9 H=-9 69@2d P ("2CH9 MF!%i eO@8.@ GDP 8C u%` O@) ?DE
" #-N #-A,-.+ :2;9 /<=>9 %+ #@"_;9 %0 #<Fd@ #%0i *r P ,.+ eO@8.@ 5<Fd@
50000 69-C 2-IE 119 O@ ]-+ M-.2). , O@ e"zFZ@ + (2004) ?@T)A P 2T09 .8.@" 8_A
[Ns P HF=P" 0T=9 (0+ H)0SFX9 M>+@ 8."@" ?I. 50T=9 /PzF9 #AF4Z + H=9 MXZ}9
7-Z O@ 0.|Z@ #@8T.+ \L+ HZ%+ M+ 5_Z P ]_)0r 5(@ %+ ?P]!@ ."@" "2rP :2;9 /<=>9
%F-I0+ 8-C ^<-Z M-+ :2-;9 /-<=>9 88-I %-+ H-_<9 #8A@2C A?R .8.O@"%'H9 2003 1984
?I. (0_n)A M;=>9 (@ .8_A"H9 Mw@@ ?ZR #<Fd@ B@%C P HS0Ss e%*+ #+ #A%. 5GDP
^-%! @ ,-.+ ?@%8-9 -Z@ (T)9 8Hi8_). 6TI9 P 7#@MKi F! 56H_0+,"]. ME 8A"H9
O@ e"zF-Z@ -+ 9,-!2! .8-__E -4@"%' eO@8-.@ O@ \0+ #AU@P 5u.P ?@P" " ME #@M.2iM+ 5e"@"
1. Bercoff, et al (2002)
2. Survival Analysis
3. Salas and Saurina (2002)
4. Meanwhile, Rajan and Dhal (2003)
5. Jimenez and Saurina (2005)
6. Myopia
7. Herd Behaviour
8. Agency Problems
9. Fofack (2005)
127 '()*( +6(MN4"E OA#> 6, ?@A! ;"BC"D! )E )FG! H!(@I JKKBL
e%-*+ %. 51H;G@P O@ %. 5GDP 8C ME 8A"H9 ?I. HS%!R 2IE 8_l #@%+ 6.' 789 ,
(-@ " :2-;9 /-<=>9 HK-1@ 6-9@2d M-K)r O@ 2HT.-+ (0+ #AU@P P =4 "2Z M0Cs 5HS0Ss
#-A,-.+ 0T=9 F4Z P :2;9 /<=>9 (0+ B+@P HZ%+ M+ 3?@T)A P 20A .8_FXA A2IE
.8-.O@"%'H-9 1996-1999 H.-9O eP" " 6-.' e"@" M-d2)N9 , O@ e"zFZ@ + ?@2 " #N
-< :2-;9 /-<=>9 5H-F=P" -0T=9 -+ #A,.+ ME Z@ ?R %f.0+ M;=>9 (@ O@ 61s yF.
t2-_ M-E H=-s " "@" :2-;9 /-<=>9 -+ Hz_9 p<@ ,.+ eO@8.@ (0_n)A .8.@" #%F)E e8C
" -0=F@ #A,.+ O@ ]+ 6.' , #@%+ 4P0Ki@2E .8C<. e8__E(00; 69d , Z@ (T)9
6P P @%0'"2' .8_EH9 %F9 @ :2;9 /<=>9 5#N 6T0Z ME "2). e8AI9 2002 1985 eP"
-2005 eP" #@%-+ ,-l HT.-+ ;_-1 " @ M-_]A H@-E P :2;9 /<=>9 (0+ M>+@ (2008)
:2-;9 /<=>9 [Ns %+ [0SFX9 %@ 5%89 J;c ME "@" ?I. M;=>9 (@ .8."2). ?29OR 1996
@ HF;_-1 80=2 MzGP + %0 , H<3d MT<C O@ e"zFZ@ + 5?@T)A P %Fz0i 5?R %+ ?P]!@ ."@"
e8A-I9 2007 %<9@2-. - 2001 M-2.@o eP" #@%-+ @ M-0E% H=-9 UV. " :2;9 /<=>9 "@8; %+
%-+ @ ?.2 HT.+ UV. " :2;9 /<=>9 t@2.@ #Ae8__E(00; 6?@T)A P ]O2= UN.@%Z .8."2).
58-__EH-9 %-F9 @ /-<=>9 (@ A,.+ /01234 (0_n)A P ?DE 69@2d ME M0c%! (@ #_<9
5#-T0+ 5GDP 69C ?DE "3FG@ B@%C P 69@2d ME 8A"H9 ?I. M;=>9 (@ .8.@e"2). HZ%+
(-@ e8-_A"Y0-c2 6-" (%-[-*9 5HT.-+ %8-9 -0z0E _E " H92)d HA8+ P e%*+ %.
.8_FXA /<=>9
5,"=-0( ,6@! /M! R&)A! .3
e8__E"N@ HK1@ 69@2d (00< #@%+ 52 \L+ " HZ%+ "29 H+%N P #%V. /0+"@ 2ll "
#P %-+ MF-X+@P %-0xF9 ?@2-_d M-+ :2-;9 /-<=>9 M.Z 8C 52IE HT.+ UV. " :2;9 /<=>9
#2' 789 , O@ e"zFZ@ + 58_A"H9 Y0c2 @ A,.+ /01234 ME HA%0xF9 O@ #@Md2)N9
4-C 5-A,.+ H`0Fs@ F! 4C 69C Md2)N9 (@ .Z@ e8C $O@%+ HN_Z"3FG@ 6.'
1. Real Effective Exchange Rate
2. Inter-bank Loans
3. Hu, et al (2004)
4. Quagliarello (2004)
5. Cifter, et al (2009)
6. Louzis, et al (2011)
49 56"71 2,34"1 /"0 '()*( +,"%-.( +" !"#$%& 128
(-@ Y0-c2 M+ M9@"@ " .Z@ A,.+ 0T=9 0;cP P eO@8.@ 4C 5A,.+ H0K)d H@E
.[O@"%'H9 :2;9 /<=>9 8C P A?R (0+ VF.@ "29 M>+@ t2. P A%0xF9
6-9@2d O@ HT 5"2C J%; H@@" M+ U@P <X. 4C + 8.@2H9 ME A,.+ H`0Fs@ F!
5%-+ #%&-',-X #@@" #-A,-.+ m-G@P " .-Z@ :2-;9 /;=>9 <X. e8__E(00; HK1@
O@ .8.2CH9 #"3FG@ "2E ?@P" 72` " :2;9 /<=>9 <X. O@ #%+ 2>Z 6)WF9
)Fs@
1
.8C+ MFC@" "2rP :2;9 /<=>9 8C P H@@" M+ U@P <X. (0+ HF<9 M>+@ [@" VF.@ P (@
]O2-= J0;c %89 M0c%! ?29OR) :2;9 /<=>9 F! %+ %89 \S. e8AI9 2V_9 M+
.-Z@ e8-C -W= 789 " HW0c2 %0xF9 ?@2_d M+ ]0. A,.+ H_! H@E 5((2011) 5?@T)A P
O@ e"zF-Z@ + ME Z@ e8C e"zFZ@ (1389) Mn+"%E BZ2 e8C 80=2 #Ae"@" O@ H_! H@E UG@
M-.2). -+ ?-XT #@M-.2). #@%+ H<X. H@E M<ZW9 M+ (MEA) HF*r8_l H@E (0)L $P
?@2-_d M-+ -A,.+ %FI0+ H@E ME "@" "2rP VF.@ (@ .Z@ MF4@"%' M=S9 (@ " e"zFZ@ "29
#<Fd@ ,X \AE P HT.+ /0K)d ^Z_9 7%F_E " ,.+ %89 %FI0+ H.@2 O@ H34C
2
."2C :2;9 /<=>9 \AE jd+
g-Z@%+ -9@ .8-). %-F9 @ :2;9 /<=>9 @8S9 8.@2H9 ME Z@ #%f" %0xF9 ,.+ eO@8.@
2-Z ,- O@ .-Z@ [*<-9 :2-;9 /-<=>9 <-X. %+ ,.+ eO@8.@ %0 H+%N 8A@2C P #%V. H.<9
M-+ .8-.@" #%F*+ ,X %89 #A#k@%FZ@ %,l2E #A,.+ M+ <X. % ]+ #A,.+
^<-Z M-+ P 8-_A"H-9 b-3F4@ "24 M+ @ @O+ O@ #%FI0+ [*Z % ]+ #A,.+ 5%f" /<d
,-X O@ #%-u-0G" H+-O@ 8_.@2H9
)Fs@ P%)KG P g0S9 M+ p2+%9 #AM!%1O@ #@"24%+
#%-F)E /D0*X M+ :2;9 /<=>9 <X. 8_.@2H9 %]+ #A,.+ 5(@%+_+ .8_C+ MFC@" "@%!@
P :2-;9 /-<=>9 <-X. (0+ <9 #@M>+@ 8_A"H9 ?I. 4/;=>9 H4%+ 56+S9 " 3.8_C+ MFC@"
%-]-+ #-A,.+ " /V. P 7%F_E +2;1 M+ #@M>+@ (0_l M0r2 ."@" "2rP ,.+ eO@8.@
A,.+ F! %+ HGD4@ e%`L9 %0 O@ H34C ?@2_d M+ 8.@2H9 M9%Z M+ U@P <X. 58C eC@ #%V. H.<9 " ME M.2i?)A .1
H-@@" M+ U@P 4C O@ X0. g%FZ" " A,.+ H;G@P M9%Z #Ae"@" MT_@ M+ %V. 9@ ."%0i @%G Mr2 "29 HA"U@P M_09O "
M-r2 "2-9 #"O H+%N /S0SW " P 8C+ A ,.+ #%&',X e8_A"?I. 8.@2 H9 H+24 M+ 4C (@ .[@e"2). e"zFZ@
.Z@ e"2+
(1997) ." P %i%+ .2
(2004) ?@T)A P 20A P (2002) _Z P gZ 5 (2003) 7A" P ?r@ .3
(2003) 7A" P ?r@ .4
129 '()*( +6(MN4"E OA#> 6, ?@A! ;"BC"D! )E )FG! H!(@I JKKBL
u-0SW (-@ " 1."2CH9 m!_9 " P ?SF9. /dD`@ 6wX9 %FI0+ /8C jd+ ME ""%iH9 O+
"2-9 M-.2). " -A,-.+ H-@@" 6-E M-+ ,-.+ %A #AH@@" <X. 5%f" H+%N /;=>9 P%0'
%-+ 0T=9 %@ e8AI9 #@%+ (0_n)A ."2CH9 "@P 789 " ,.+ eO@8.@ O@ #0;9 ?@2_d M+ HZ%+
-0T=9 #@%+ %0xF9 (@ .[@e"2). e"zFZ@ #ON9 %0xF9 , O@ AU@P %89 " A,.+ "%TK)d
O@ #0-X+ g-Z@%+ Ml%i@ .Z@ e"2). 0F4@ %z1 $O@ H1234 0T=9 P , $O@ HF=P"
6-0KW M-+ M-r2 -+ -9@ 5"2-C H-9 #%F-I0+ U@P ?O jd+ A,.+ HF=P" 0T=9 H+%N /;=>9
8-A@2L. VF.@ O@ P" 58C Mw@@ M=S9 (@ #@8F+@ " ME ?@%@ " A,.+ :2;9 /<=>9 O@ Hz012
M-.2i?-)A .8-C+ #<Fd@ ,X %89 " A,.+ %F*+ "%TK)d jd+ HF=P" 0T=9 %i@ "2+
.8C+ ]0. #%V. M.@2FI' #@@" 8.@2H9 #@M>+@ (0_l 8C eC@ %FI0' ME
F4-Z O@ H-34C ?@2-_d M+ ]E%) Mr" "@" ?I. 6<G \L+ " HZ%+ "29 #%V. js<9
:2-;9 /-<=>9 [-Ns %+ @&i%@ 69@2d O@ %f" HT Aef_+ #3W.@ /8G P @O+ #3W.@
,- HK-1@ #-Ae-f_+ B-Z2 @O-+ 7%-F_E Mr" %f.0+ 5]E%) Mr" .Z@ HT.+ UV. , "
\L+ " .Z@ %F)E +G H_; %#3W.@ @O+ F4Z %f.0+ %+ ]E%) Mr" .Z@ ;_1
.8C+ :2;9 /<=>9 [Ns [*9 6" O@ HT 8.@2H9 4C (@ ME ["2). MVsD9 M=S9 (@ 3
^-0% (8-+ .8-C+ MFC@" :2;9 /<=>9 %+ M.iP" %0 8.@2H9 %+ ]E%) ME [8" (0_l [A
e"zF-Z@ -+ ;_1 , ]E%) Mr" .Z@ [*<9 :2;9 /<=>9 F! + %0xF9 (@ M>+@ P %0 t2.
(%-y-@ O@ H-T 2()-CP%0A 7@8-_0!%A 4-C .-Z@ \N_-Z 6-+G #"8-;F9 #A 4C O@
"2-CH-9 J%; HH " !i "1 S i2 /21 M+ 4C (@ .Z@ ]E%) \N_Z #@%+ A4C
N
(-@ J-%; #@%-+ .8-A"H-9 ?I. @ ,.+ %A #@O+ [*Z Si P A,.+ "@8; N M>+@ (@ " ME
#-Ae"%|-Z t2-)N9 M-+ ,-.+ ?R #-A e"%|-Z <-X. ?@2-_d M-+ @ ,.+ %A #@O+ [*Z 4C
.[@MF!%i %V. " HZ%+ "29 #A,.+
6T0-Z %-@ 69C H.P%+ B@%C %0 W :2;9 /<=>9 ME ["2). MVsD9 #%V. js<9 O@
5H-+%N #-AM-F! #@2F-Z@ 2-V_9 M-+ -A,-.+ #-AH-ikP %+ ?P]!@ {' ."@" @%G ]0. #N
"%TK)d M.2fl ME (@ O@ Z@ H2i M.2). HX0Kf.@ %<F;9 ,.+ , 5(Barings) ]f_+ p2SZ .(2011) ]_0T@ P (0TI09 .1
M+ 24 0X+ M9.O@% + #@MXZ}9 O@ @ H=9 MXZ}9 , e9 , 72` " 8.@2H9 @]iE -9%!E MKvX9 P m!_9 " MKv X9
.8_E 68< MFXTCP MXZ}9 ,
2. Herfindahl–Hirschman Index
49 56"71 2,34"1 /"0 '()*( +,"%-.( +" !"#$%& 130
.8-.@e8-C $O@%-+ + %@ ?@2_d M+ #N 6T0Z 4C (0I.r #A%0xF9 + ?20Z%i /";9
O@ H-Z%+ "2-9 eP" 72-` " (2 @"2-).) :2-;9 /<=>9 " #i8.9 %@ %+ M<KQ #@%+ (0_n)A
e8-C e"zF-Z@ ?20Z%i Z@ )Z " 2' 6.' 789 2ll " :2;9 /<=>9 MzGP + %"S9
.[O@"%'H9 A%0xF9 (@ %u0G" Y0c2 M+ M9@"@ " .Z@
" H-)w@" P G29 /@%00x M]N #@%+ @8F+@ 5:2;9 /<=>9 %+ #N 6T0Z %@ e8AI9 #@%+
]-r M-E Z@ e8C e"zFZ@ /TZP%'-,8A %FK0! 1357-1387 eP" #@%+ GDP H.9O #%Z
M-E #2-`M-+ y t " $ t # ct H_; .Z@ ?R 8.P O@ HK9 80=2 H)Ff= %"S9 ~@%W.@ HKT0Z
.8). 6G@8s @ %O M>+@ e89R Z"M+ 8.P %0X9 %"S9
T
!
1
( yt % $ t )2 # &
T %1
! [($ t #1 % $ t ) % ($ t % $ t %1 )]2
2
B@%-C %-@ e8A-I9 #@%-+ O@ %. P U2 %. 5#T0+ %. 5GDP 8C #A%0xF9 MzGP (0_n)A
?@2_d M+ 8.@2H9 #T0+ %. .8.@e8C W= 789 " ^0G #A%0xF9 ?@2_d M+ @]N9 2`M+ H>0W9
."%0i @%G Mr2 "29 :2;9 /<=>9 [Ns %+ #N /.Z2. %@ J012 #@%+ #%f" (]fr
#-T0+ \@]-!@ @%-O 5"2-CH-9 -A,-.+ :2-;9 /-<=>9 <X. \@]!@ ^r29 %. (@ \@]!@
\A-E ?2-" -4@"%'O+ " @ ?-I@ ?@2- P e"2-). J0;- @ -A?R 8-9R" ?-%r A@2.4
\A-E ^<-Z M-+ ME Z@ 80=2 \AE O@ HF9Dd ]0. Aef_+ e+" #T0+ %. \@]!@ .8A"H9
.C@" 8A@24 7<." M+ @ Aef_+ O@ A,.+ :2;9 /<=>9 \@]!@ (@%+_+ P e"F!@ :z@ cS
?@A! ;"BC"D! +6"mM4"! .2 6(,@74
131 '()*( +6(MN4"E OA#> 6, ?@A! ;"BC"D! )E )FG! H!(@I JKKBL
?-I. @ :2-;9 /-<=>9 %-+ ?D-E "3FG@ B@%C %@ 8.@2H9 ME Z@ #%f" %0xF9 U2 %.
%-. \@]-!@ -+ "PH9 VF.@ :2;9 /<=>9 + 69d (@ <9 M>+@ 5u0SW /0+"@ gZ@%+ .8A"
%f" /<d M+ .8+ \AE A,.+ O@ HF!" #AU@P bLC@ #AHA8+ HS0Ss $O@ 5U2
%-F)E 4@"%'O+ M+ A?R 609 {' 58.2CH9 mzF_9 HF!" U@P O@ ?i8.%0iU@P 5H92 B@%C "
M-E @%-O 58-.O@8.@ u-2; M-+ @ HF!-" #-AU@P -4@"%'O-+ ?-T9@ 8s 8__EH9 H;Z P e8C
-+ [@" VF.@ (@%+_+ .8_EH9 e8.%0iU@P Mr2F9 @ H*r2 6+G mz. AU@P (@ %04 + 4@"%'O+
.8+ 8C :2;9 /<=>9 U2 %. \@]!@
@ "2-4 -0=;! M-E ,.+X' ]N+) HF=P" ,.+ 8 69C \APk' (@ " e"zFZ@ "29 M.2).
5HK9 #A,.+ 69C HF=P" #A,.+ .Z@ H1234 ,.+ 4 P (Z@ e"2). OQR 1383 7Z O@
69-C H-1234 #-A,-.+ P (TX9 P #OPIE 5?@%iE e! 5K9 5/N 5/@"1 5M|Z
1381-1387 M-;=>9 "2-9 eP" " ME Z@ (2. "3FG@ P ?0Z' 5?9Z 5(%!RE #A,.+
O@ 81" 92 @8S9 1387 7Z " 5u0SW (@ " HZ%+ "29 #A,.+ Md2)N9 .8.@MFC@" 0=;!
#@8-T.+ \-L+ H.-X.@ #P%-0. O@ 8-1" 95 O@ \0-+ P Ae"%|Z 6E O@ 81" 99 5AH@@" 6E
e"@" [0-); 2-IE #-A,-.+ 6-E M-+ 8-.@2H9 ?R yF. 5P (@ O@ .Z@ e8CH9 69C @ 2IE
O@ /-dD`@ #PRm-)r #@%-+ P -Z@ #@M-.L+FE /2-1 M-+ /-dD`@ #PR"%-i $P ."2C
J0-12 (0_n)A .[@e"%E e"zFZ@ #]E%9 ,.+ Z P 2IE HT.+ UV. "%TK)d #A $@]i
O@ H-KE #%2-3 1 7P8-r .-Z@ e8-9R 1 -Z20' " u0SW (@ " MF! EM+ #A%0xF9 #9R
.8_EH9 Mw@@ 58.2CH9 J%; #%V. P H+%N /0+"@ gZ@%+ ME :2;9 /<=>9 %+ %}9 #A%0xF9
HF+- @8-S9 789 7D4@ ]r {.@P ME Z@ (@ H>4 ?20Z%i 789 [*9 hP%! O@ HT
8-+ 5-Z@ e8C 60TI H.9O #%Z P H;>S9 #Ae"@" O@ H<0E% #Ae"@" MT_@ M+ Mr2 + .Z@
@%-O "@" U-N.@ H-AP%i H.-X)A. {.-@P "2-rP 0L-I ?29OR ]0. A e"@" t2. (@ "29 "
P 8_-C+ MF-C@" %0- %-V. "29 m+ #P %+ 789 HW0c2 #A%0xF9 O@ %0Q M+ HK9@2d Z@ (T)9
8-_A@24 ?-I. HZ%+ "29 789 8.)X' " @ "24 /@%@ A%0xF9 M.2f_@ .8_C<. #%0ieO@8.@ 6+G
@]!@U%. O@ e"zFZ@ + M;=>9 (@ " .8_C+ JKFL9 #A{.@P #@@" m`S9 Z@ (T)9 {' ."@"
H_<9 ?29OR (@ %z1 M0c%! .Z@ MF!%i UN.@ LR test16.' {.@P H.X)A. ?29OR stata10
{.-@P H.-X)A. "2-rP #-_;9 M-+ ?R 6-+S9 M0-c%! P 6.' #Ae"@" {.@P H.X)A. U8d %+
1. Likelihood Ratio
49 56"71 2,34"1 /"0 '()*( +,"%-.( +" !"#$%& 132
M-+ hP%-z9 6-.' 78-9 " H 0 M0c%! 52 Z20' M+ Mr2 + ?29OR (@ O@ 61s yF. u<` .Z@
."2CH9 " {.@P H.X)A. U8d
?@A! ;"BC"D! )E )FG! +")K`-! R&)A! .1 /Me
")K`-!
6, )K`-! O!XI
"/M!
)K`-! h*)AL
,6@!
6"Y-4(
RN4"E V"W +")K`-!
H@@" M+ U@P <X.
lloas
,.+ eO@8.@
lsize
H@E 4C
, LOANit )
'
ln(L / Ait ) " ln**
'
+ ASSETit (
, ASSETit
ln( SIZEit ) " ln*
*
ASSETit
+
)
'
'
(
P e2S=+ "2<*+ 4C gZ@%+ e8C M<ZW9
!
H0K)d
leff
HF=P" 0T=9
StateOwner
]E%) Mr"
lhhi
MEA $P
StateOwner=1
ln(HHI t ) " ln,*
+
O!XI
!i "1 Si2 )'(
N
+
+/-
+/+/-
+,"%-.( 'XU +")K`-!
#N 6T0Z 4C
HP
cy
GDP 8C
lgdpg
U2 %.
linf
#T0+ %.
lue
?R 8.P O@ GDP H)Ff= %"S9 ~@%W.@
(/TZ%' ,8A %FK0!)
, GDPt % GDPt %1 )
'
ln(GDPt ) " ln **
'
GDPt %1
+
(
, CPI t % CPI t %1 )
'
ln(INFt ) " ln**
'
CPI t %1
+
(
ln(ue)
-
+
+
.80_E M;r@%9 (1389) Mn+"%E M+ $P (@ /0w]r #@%+
M-E 7D-4@ /D-)r (0+ HfFX<A"24 ME Z@ (@ 6.' #2' 789 [*9 hP%! O@ %f" HT
" HfF-X<)A"24 U8-d "2rP HZ%+ #@%+ ."@8. "2rP 5"2CH9 "@P M;9r ?20Z%i m+ "
2F-Z" -+ stata10 @]-!@ U%-. " M-E (2002) y8-=PP ?2-9OR O@ 6-.' 789 " 7DF4@ /D)r
133 '()*( +6(MN4"E OA#> 6, ?@A! ;"BC"D! )E )FG! H!(@I JKKBL
(0-+ HfF-X<)A"24 U8d %+ H_<9 ?29OR (@ %z1 M0c%! .[@e"2). e"zFZ@ "2C H9 @%r@ xtserial1
+ .Z@ 7D4@ /D)r (0+ HfFX<)A"24 "2rP #_;9 M+ 6+S9 M0c%! P ( - " 0 ) 7D4@ /D)r
%-0xF9 %-@ ?P8-+ P ?D-E %0xF9 %@ + 789 P" " F e9R 52 Z20' 7P8r O@ 61s yF. M+ Mr2
Y>-Z " 6G@8-s M-E -!%i M-N0F. ?@2H9 5Z@ 0/089 6G@8s + 7";9 P-Value #@@" ?DE
78-9 #@%-+ H M0-c%! 8-1" 90 ?-_0)`@ Y>-Z " M-F<=@ ."2CH). " H 0 M0c%! %5 #@"_;9
" {.-@P H.X)A. 6TI9 "2rP M+ Mr2 + 57s%*+ .8C 8A@24 " ?DE %0xF9 + %@ #@@"
e"zF-Z@ 2@2F-Z@ (0-)L $P O@ A789 (0)L " 5HfFX<)A "24 6TI9 "2rP 7)Fs@ P Ae"@"
P {.-@P H.-X)A. /DT-I9 M-+ <-X. H-_0)L ^@%-c -0;9 ~@%-W.@ ?R " ME Z@ e8C
.Z@ @2FZ@ HfFX<)A"24
]*"-4 HK$<L JK7gL .4
6-0KW P H-Z%+ 6-<G \-L+ " e8-C Y%-3 78-9 (0-)L O@ e89R Z"M+ yF. 5\L+ (@ "
-+ @8-S9 5NPL 578-9 MF-X+@P %-0xF9 -F! " #i8.9 ^<Z M+ 8C MFzi ME M.2i?)A ."2CH9
?R " M-E 78-9 ,- " MT_@ M+ Mr2 + .[0_EH9 W= 789 " 6SFX9 %0xF9 ?@2_d M+ @ ?R MzGP
(0-+ HfF-X<)A "2-rP ?-T9@ 58.2-CH-9 "@P HW0-c2 %0xF9 ?@2_dM+ MFX+@P %0xF9 %04 + %"S9
GMM3$P O@ 78-9 "PR%+ #@%+ 5"@" "2rP $2 6TI9 P >4 MK)r P #%04 MFX+@P %0xF9
" 7P@ M-Ks%9 .[0-_EH-9 e"zFZ@ 5Z@ e8C Mw@@ 2' 6.' #Ae"@" #@%+ 48.+ P 2.R BZ2 ME
M-+ M-r2 -+ .-Z@ /"-;9 [F-X0Z ,- /2-1 M-+ 78-9 H-Z_C 8-.+ P 2.R e8__E"PR%+
B-Z2 e8-C M-w@@ $P O@ u-0SW (@ " (1991) 8.+ P 2.R e8__E"PR%+ " e2S=+ #A J;c
H)F-X0Z GMM M-E e8-C D1@ $P (@ " .Z@ e8C e"zFZ@ 68.+ P 78.D+ P 52+ P 2.R
%-0xF9 "-N@ #A8-_@%! H@8-F+@ B@%-C %-+ H!c@ #A"P8W9 O@ Md2)N9 , "2CH9 e809.
.""%iH9 7)d@ MFX+@P
."2C M;r@%9 (Drukker (2003)) %EP" M=S9 M+ %FI0+ M;=>9 #@%+ .1
2. Robust
3. Generalized Methods of Moments
4. Arellano-Bond (1991)
5. Arellano-Bover (1995)
6. Blundell-Bond (1998)
49 56"71 2,34"1 /"0 '()*( +,"%-.( +" !"#$%& 134
:2-;9 /-<=>9 M.-Z %-00x H)F-f= g-0S9 M-E M F-X+@P %0xF9 (0+ M>+@ 2ll (@ "
@]-!@U%-. O@ e"zFZ@ + 8_A"H9 ?I. @ A,.+ /01234 ME HA%0xF9 P (lnplg) Z@ A,.+
M-+ MF-X+@P %-0xF9 O@ MzGP 2 "@8; maxldep() 2FZ" O@ e"zFZ@ + .Z@ e8C e"O (0)L stata10
2V_9 M+ A,.+ /01234 %+ ?P]!@ .Z@ e8C MF!%i %V. " 2' 6.' 789 " @]+@ %0xF9 ?@2_d
$O@%-+ ;_-1 F4Z P #N 6T0Z 4C (0I.r #A%0xF9 + hP%z9 789 5yF. #@2FZ@
" @2F-Z@ 0;9 ~@%W.@ (0)L M+ 80S9 5H)FX0Z GMM 789 (0)L O@ 61s yF. .8C 8A@24
.Z@ e"PR 2 7P8r
?@A! ;"BC"D! 5M##UJKKAL H!(@I "*@ H4" +"/M! ,6n)E :( H>"_ ]*"-4 .2 /Me
")K`-!
1 /M!
o*()a
Lnplg_1
-0/36
Lnplg_2
-0/31
H@E 4C
(leff)
,X 4C
(lloas)
eO@8.@ 4C
(lsize )
0T=9 t2.
(StateOwne )
GDP ?Z2.
ln(cygdp)
8C MzGP
#"3FG@
ln(gdpg_1)
#T0+ %. MzGP
ln (lue_1)
U2 %. MzGP
ln (inf_1)
]E%) 4C
ln(hhi) ;_1
-1/28
2 /M!
z
1/94
2/08
-
2/16
-
o*()a
3 /M!
z
o*()a
4 /M!
z
RN4"E V"W +")K`-!
-0/37
-2/03
-0/29
- 0/ 4
-2/37
-0/37
- 2/ 9
-1/84
-2/19
5 /M!
6 /M!
o*()a
z
o*()a
z
o*()a
z
-0/42
-2/21
-0/42
-2/37
-0/37
-2/04
-0/31
-2/05
-0/27
-1/88
-0/34
-2/42
-1/92
-1/96
-1/31
-1/99
-1/82
-1/31
1/91
2/46
-
1/91
-
0/26
1/72
0/ 3
1/88
0/30
2/17
0/25
1/96
0/24
1/95
0/27
1/57
0/36
1/12
0/38
1/27
0/45
1/48
0/35
1/19
0/356
1/21
0/36
1/15
- 2/ 5
- 1/ 9
-2/13
-2/23
-1/96
-2/02
-2/08
-2/02
-1/84
3/44
1/34
-0/77
-1/65
-1/63
-0/38
- 1/ 7
2/08
-
2/13
-
+,"%-.( 'XU +")K`-!
2/11
1/33
-10/3
2/08
-
135 '()*( +6(MN4"E OA#> 6, ?@A! ;"BC"D! )E )FG! H!(@I JKKBL
y-F. .-Z@ e8-C e"PR 3 -Z20' " -A789 M)A #@%+ @]!@U%. HrP%4 ?@2_d M+ yF. /0w]r
?-XT -A,-.+ /0-1234 /@%-@ #-A%-0xF9 %V. O@ A789 .Z@ e89R 2 7P8r " 789 \C
%-V. " 789 " ?DE "3FG@ B@%C %@ 7%F_E #@%+ ME ?DE "3FG@ %0xF9 M+ A?R /Pz P 8_FXA
?R J012 " JKFL9 #A789 yF. XL. \L+ 57P8r (@ " .""%iH9O+ 5Z@ e8C MF!%i
M-+ p2-+%9 M-E 8-A"H-9 \-). @ Z@ :2;9 /<=>9 M.Z 8C ME MFX+@P %0xF9 F! O@ \L+
.Z@ A,.+ /01234
-+ M-E 8-.@" H-)wDd A%0xF9 %FI0+ H_0)L ^@%c 5Z@ e8AI9 6+G yF. O@ ME M.2i?)A
%-0xF9 #-AM-zGP ^@%-c -A78-9 M0KE " .Z@ iOZ 6<G \L+ " HZ%+ "29 #%V. [0Az9
.8_F-XA @"-_;9 #9R %V. O@ %5 #@"_;9 Y>Z " UP" MzGP ^@%c ekP M+ %FI0+ P Hz_9 MFX+@P
eP" ,- + A,.+ H_; m`S9 %FI0+ #@%+ NPL 8C HKT0Z F! %f.0+
)Fs@ #@MN0F. (0_l
eP" P" - eP" ,- " -A,-.+ O@ , %A #@%+ NPL 8C \@]!@ ME _;9 (8+ Z@ %04
."2CH9 #r eP" NPL 8C \AE jd+ 6<G
M>+@ , "2rP e8_A"?I. A,.+ /01234 HW0c2 #A%0xF9 e8C e"O (0)L ^@%c
^@%-c (@ 9Dd .Z@ A,.+ #AHikP P HT.+ UV. " HF4@"%' #AU@P 0z0E (0+ (0;9
%"-S9 P ?-XT (""%-i H-9 O-+ ?D-E "3FG@ B@%C 4C M+ A?R /Pz ME) A789 M)A "
.8-C+ H-_0)L y-F. #@2F-Z@ %-+ #8-0 8.@2H9 (@ .Z@ /<+ A789 M)A " A?R H_0)L
%-V. O@ P H-z_9 -Z@ e8-C J-%; H-0K)d H<-X. H@-E g-Z@%+ ME "%TK)d 4C ^%c
#@%-+ #8A-C y-F. (@ .Z@ @"_;9 81" 10 P 5 #@"_;9 Y>Z " A789 %FI0+ " #9R
8.@" #%(0' HF%89 H@E ME HAef_+ ME _;9 (8+ .8).H9 Mw@@ J0;c %89 M0c%!
4-C " \A-E 8-1" ,- M-E #@M-.2iM-+ 58_F-XA @"2-4%+ :2;9 /<=>9 %+ 8C O@
.8-C 8-A@24 :2-;9 /-<=>9 [-Ns " 8-1" , O@ \0+ \@]!@ jd+ A789 M0KE " H@E
-+ M-;=>9 (-@ " M-E "2-C H9 d AU@P 4@"%' " ME H`0Fs@ Mr" P ,.+ HTX F!
(-@ ^%c .8A"H9 ?I. @ VF.@ "29 #"3FG@ %0 ]0. 5Z@ e8C e80N_Z H@@" M+ U@P <X.
M-Z " #-9R %-V. O@ ^%-c (-@ #@%-+ 61s #A(0)L MF<=@ .Z@ <9 A789 M)A " %0xF9
57-s%*+ .Z@ @"_;9 81" 90 ?_0)`@ Y>Z " 789 P" " P 81" 95 ?_0)1@ Y>Z " 789
M0--c%! O@ --)s e--+" --A?R O@ ?@2--F+ --)Fs@ M--E 8--.@e"2--). [A@%--! @ #8A@2--C y--F. (--@
49 56"71 2,34"1 /"0 '()*( +,"%-.( +" !"#$%& 136
M-N0F. -+ iOZ MN0F. (@ ME Z@ (@ ^=r MFT. ."2). e"zFZ@ AU@P %89 " #]%i:D4@
?R \-S. P %8-9 0z0E O@ %f" #@M<_r ME Z@ "%TK)d 4C H_0)L ^%c O@ 61s
-<9 #@M>+@ e8_A"?I. 5eO@8.@ 4C. 8A"H9 ?I. 2IE HT.+ UV. " U@P ?O "N@ " @
#-9R %-V. O@ M-l%i@ 4C (@ .Z@ ?@%@ HT.+ UV. " AU@P ?O MKvX9 P ,.+ eO@8.@ (0+
^<-Z M-+ (0-_n)A P :2-;9 /-<=>9 %+ ?R %0 %+ #"3FG@ M%V. 80E ^<Z M+ 9@ X0. @"_;9
#->4 O@ - -Z@ e8-C -zs eO@8-.@ 4C %0xF9 5?R \S. %+ H+%N /;=>9 %FI0+ %V. :z@
#"-3FG@ e-f_+ ,- " P%-)KG P g-0S9 #-AM!%-1 t2GP ."2C _Fr@ [*9 %0xF9 ~&s $2
j-d+ 8-0=2 P%-)KG - g-0S9 \@]-!@ /21 (@ %0Q " P Z@ 8_).@2 HF%89 "2rP U]KFX9
4-C -<9 M->+@ 5e8C e"O (0)L ^%c #@"_;9 /21 " {' ."2CH9 "%TK)d J;c
HT.-+ U-V. " U@P %8-9 J;-c O@ #%-f" ?-I. X.@2H9 :2;9 /<=>9 4C + eO@8.@
#%F-I0+ 7%-F_E 8-_.@2H-9 ME(@ ^<Z M+ %FTl2E #A,.+ zi ?@2F+ 8C (0_n)A MF<=@ .8C+
#O-N9 %-0xF9 ^%-c .8_F-XA @"2-4%+ #%-F*+ U@P "%-TK)d O@ 8_-C+ MF-C@" A U@P #%f=+%Q %+
?@2-H-9 ^@%-c (-@ #9R #@"_;9 /2G M+ Mr2 + .Z@ Hz_9 A789 M)A " HF=P" 0T=9
6-)d %-F*+ 5-VF.@ ~D4%-+ H-1234 %89 M+ <X. A,.+ HF=P" %89 ME !%i MN0F.
#-A%0xF9 "PP -+ %8-9 H@-E P ,.+ HTX F! 5g0S9 %@ ME (@ M+ Mr2 + .8.@e"2).
-0A9 M-+ ?@2-F+ 8-C @ #@M-N0F. (0-_l 58-.@e8C 7%F_E ?20Z%i #A789 " ^Z_9 HW0c2
M-+ -A?R H-F4@"%' /D0*-X O@ #%F-I0+ [*-Z M-E "@" <-X. H-F=P" #-A,.+ HF4@"%' #AU@P
(0-_n)A yF. (@ 1.Z@ %F)E A?R 72T. 7)Fs@ ME Z@ HF=P" #A E%C P Aef_+ 5A%`
-4@"%' u-%` O@ %FI0+ "2Z ^XE #@%+ H1234 #A,.+ %FI0+ e]0f.@ P :0FC@ ^<Z M+ 8C
8-.@2H-9 %F)E M+%N 60=" M+ H1234 #A,.+ " AU@P ^Z_9 #%f=+%Q U8d .8C+ %FI0+ U@P
53 \L+ " HZ%+ "29 H+%N P #%V. /0+"@ M+ Mr2 + .8C+ #@MN0F. (0_l #@%+ #%f" 60="
(FC@8. "2rP ^<Z M+ 9@ 58_C+ "_FZ@ 6+G #@MN0F. (0_l 723s #@%+ #%f" 6" Z@ (T)9
.[0_EH9 %V.~%1 A?R M+ (F4@"%' O@ 5%f" 6" e+" (@%G P 8A@2C M.2i%A
-9Dd Hf)A ]0. :2;9 /<=>9 P #"3FG@ ?DE B@%C M>+@ Y0c2 #@%+ H_0)L ^@%c
?-Z2. 4-C .8_F-X0. @"_;9 #9R %V. O@ *.R O@ H;+ Ml%i@ 58_A"H9 \). @ VF.@ "29
P H-1234 #A\L+ M+ HF4@"%' #AU@P O@ , %A :2;9 /<=>9 t2. M+ p2+%9 #Ae"@" ?"2<. g%FZ" " 60=" M+ M.zZF9 .1
.X0. [A@%! M;=>9 (@ " #@M0c%! (0_l ?29OR ?T9@ HF=P"
137 '()*( +6(MN4"E OA#> 6, ?@A! ;"BC"D! )E )FG! H!(@I JKKBL
VF.@ "29 <9 M>+@ (/TZP%' P ,8A %FK0! O@ e"zFZ@ + $8.P O@ GDP ~@%W.@) GDP
%-@ e8__E?0+ 8.@2H9 MN0F. (@ .8A"H9 \). NPL 8C 4C + @ #9R #@"_;9 8G! 9@
?@2-_d M-+ GDP 8-C M-zGP .8-C+ :2-;9 /<=>9 %+ #"3FG@ /.Z2. P H<H+ \@]!@ [0SFX9
M-r2 "2-9 2 78-9 " NPL 8-C P #"-3FG@ ?DE B@%C M>+@ e8AI9 #@%+ #%f" 4C
M-E M-.2i?-)A [02-f+ ME 8A"H9 eOr@ %0xF9 (@ @"_;9 D9E P Hz_9 ^%c .Z@ MF!%i @%G
U-V. " :2-;9 /<=>9 8C \AE jd+ ?DE "3FG@ B@%C "2<*+ 58C eC@ #%V. js<9 "
%. MzGP (0I.r #A%0xF9 O@ ME 5 P 4 #A789 " VF.@ "29 yF. "2rP ."2CH9 2IE HT.+
%-@ %-+ #%-f" 8-0 ]-0. 8-.@e"2-). e"zFZ@ ?DE "3FG@ B@%C Y0c2 #@%+ U2 %. P #T0+
;_-1 ]E%) 4C M>+@ .Z@ :2;9 /<=>9 8C \AE %+ ?DE "3FG@ B@%C "2<*+ <9
?"2-+ H-z_9 .-Z@ MF!%i @%G Mr2 "29 6 789 " :2;9 /<=>9 8C + (HHI 4C) HT.+
8-C -+ #-9R %-V. O@ @"-_;9%0Q 9@ Hz_9 #@M>+@ e8_A"?I. %0xF9 (@ e8C e"O (0)L ^%c
.Z@ :2;9 /<=>9
+)KmQK-4 +M#Ep7e .5
;_-1 " (NPL) :2-;9 /-<=>9 #-A%i(0-0; ?@2-_d M-+ HT.+ ekP 69@2d \S. M=S9 (@ "
5H-+%N #-AM-F! #@2F-Z@ 2-V_9 M-+ 5 ?R %-+ ?P]-!@ .-!%i @%-G HZ%+ "29 ?@%@ #@8T.+
-+ %@ ?@2_d M+ ;_1 F4Z P #N 6T0Z 4C (0I.r #A%0xF9 + ?20Z%i /";9
" #i8-.9 %-@ %-+ M-<KQ #@%-+ (0-_n)A .8-.@e8C $O@%+ HT.+ ;_1 P #"3FG@ ?DE B@%C
6-.' 789 2ll " :2;9 /<=>9 MzGP + %"S9 O@ HZ%+ "29 eP" 72` " :2;9 /<=>9
.Z@ e8C e"zFZ@ ?20Z%i Z@ )Z " 2'
e8-__E(0-0; 6-9@2d P MF-X+@P %0xF9 ?@2_d M+ :2;9 /<=>9 M.Z 8C (0+ M>+@ (0)L #@%+
#@%+ e"zFZ@ "29 4C /Pz M+ A789 (@ /Pz .["2). e"zFZ@ (]fr 789 \C O@ ?R
(-@ (0-)L y-F. .""%iH9O+ ;_1 F4Z + %@ #"3FG@ ?DE B@%C + %@ J012
?R 8-C M-E #@M-.2iM-+ "@" "2-rP :2;9 /<=>9 F! " #@"_;9 #i8.9 "@" ?I. A789
M--E 8-A"H--9 ?-I. (0--_n)A u-0SW (--@ #-AM--F! ."@" @%-G 6--<G #-AeP" 8--C %0- -W
P e8-__E(0-0; \-S. -0T=9 t2-. P H`-0Fs@ -F! 5H-0K)d H@E 69C A ,.+ #AHikP
49 56"71 2,34"1 /"0 '()*( +,"%-.( +" !"#$%& 138
?-Z2. M-E "@" ?-I. 6-1s y-F. (0_n)A .8.@" :2;9 /<=>9 8C %+ #9R %V. O@ #@"_;9
HT.-+ U-V. " :2-;9 /-<=>9 8-C \@]!@ jd+ HK9 "3FG@ B@%C 94P P HK9 80=2 %FI0+
.Z@ e8C 2IE
5:2-;9 /-<=>9 e-+" H-F=P" #-A,-.+ %-F*+ "%-TK)d 8-0 u-0SW (@ #AMF! O@ HT
M-+ %F-I0+ ME A,.+ (@ HF4@"%' #AU@P t2.
)Fs@ Ml%i@ .Z@ %f" B@%C /< M+ hP%z9
HZ%+ P u0SW 9@ 58C+ #@MN0F. (0_l #@%+ HW0c2 8.@2H9 5Z@ HF=P" #A"*. P AE%C
P H-1234 5H-F=P" #-A\-L+ O@ ,- %-A ,-0Tz M-+ -A U@P t@2.@ #A e"@" gZ@%+ #%u0G"
M--+ #@M--;=>9 (0-_l U--N.@ .8--). M-w@@ H=--)Fs@ (0--_l #@%-+ H=8F--X9 --Z' 8-.@2H--9 -A@2.4
."2CH9 M012 t2c29 (@ ?@8_9MGDd
(0-_l[-A P -A,-.+ %8-9 -0F4@ " #8_)-CO@ /-dD`@ 8.@2 H9 u0SW (@ #AMF!
P "%-TK)d 4-C (0-+ H-z_9 e8-C e8AI9 M>+@ M.2). ?@2_d M+ .8A" @%G HT.+ UV. " (%.
/DT-I9 %-+ 8.@2H9 ?R J;c ME HIS. P OP%9@ "%TK)d M+ Mr2 0)A@ M+ :2;9 /<=>9 8C
M-+ 8-_.@2H-9 "%-TK)d #-A4-C g-Z@ (@ %+ .8_EH9 eC@ 8C+ MFC@" HT.+ UV. " e8_R
-F! [0SF-X9 P @"_;9 M>+@ .8_C+ e8_R " (%!RMKvX9 #A,.+ 4_C #@%+ H)_A@ ?@2_d
?@%8-9 M-+ @ #-<Fd@ ,-X %8-9 M-+ M-r2 0)A@ :2;9 /<=>9 8C P A,.+ HTX
.8_EH9 "]C2i %FI0+ H=9 /< #@%G%+ #@%+ HV. (0=2vX9 P HT.+
pE"#!
R06"& -hC(
M--XZ}9 52--IE HT.--+ U--V. "%--TK)d $@]--i 5(1388) P (1387) 5(1386) 8--)W9 5"@k--.#8--09@
.?@%@ #@8T.+ H=d $O29R
P :2-;9 5MF-C&i80Z%Z /-<=>9 72-1P M-9.(0-R 5(1386) H9D-Z@ #2*)r #]E%9 ,.+
.A,.+ 7212=@a2TI9
.?@%* 51387 2IE #"3FG@ /2W M1D4 5(1388) H9DZ@ #2*)r #]E%9 ,.+
HT.-+ UV. "%TK)d H+O@ " HF*r 8_l H@E 60KW $P "%+E» 5(1389) 80)s 5Mn+"%E
.93 e)C 5?@%* efI.@" 5#"3FG@ /S0SW MKN9 5«?@%@
139 '()*( +6(MN4"E OA#> 6, ?@A! ;"BC"D! )E )FG! H!(@I JKKBL
R9K$r4( -q
Alchian, A. A. (1965), “The Basis of Some Recent Advances in the Theory
of Management of Firm”, Journal of Industrial Economics, No. 14, pp.
30-41.
Allen, Franklin and Douglas Gale (2000), Comparing Financial Systems,
Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
Allen, Franklin and Douglas Gale (2004), “Competition and Financial
Stability”, Journal of Money, Credit, and Banking, No. 36, pp. 433-480.
Andreeva, Olga (2004), “Aggregate Bankruptcy Probabilities and Their Role
in Explaining Banks’ Loan Losses”, Working Paper 2004/2, Norges
Bank, February.
Bercoff, Jose J., Giovanni, Julian di and Franque Grimard (2002),
Argentinean Banks, Credit Growth and the Tequila Crisis: A Duration
Analysis, (Unpublished).
Berger, A. N. and R. DeYoung (1997), “Problem Loans and Cost Efficiency
in Commercial Banks”, Journal of Banking and Finance, No. 21, pp.
849-870.
Bernanke, B. and M. Gertler (1989), “Agency Costs, Net Worth and
Business Fluctuations”, American Economic Review, Vol. 79, pp. 14-31.
Bernanke, B. and S. Gilchrist (1999), “The Financial Accelerator in a
Quantitative Business Cycle Framework”, in Handbook of
Macroeconomics, Ed. by J. Taylor and M. Woodford, 1C, pp. 1341-1393.
Besanko, David and Anjan V. Thakor (1993), “Relationship Banking,
Deposit Insurance and Bank Portfolio” in: Mayer, C. and X. Vives (Eds.):
Capital Markets and Financial Intermediation, Cambridge, UK:
Cambridge University Press, pp. 292-318.
Boot, Arnoud W. and Stuart Greenbaum (1993), “Bank Regulation,
Reputation, and Rents: Theory and Policy Implications” in: Mayer, Colin
and Xavier Vives (Eds.): Capital Markets and Financial Intermediation,
Cambridge, UK: Cambridge University Press, pp. 292-318.
Boyd, John H. and De Nicolo Gianni (2005), “The Theory of Bank Risktaking and Competition Revisited”, Journal of Finance, Vol. 60, No. 3,
pp. 1329-1343..
Caminal, Ramon and Matutes Carmen (2002), “Market Power and Banking
Failures”, International Journal of Industrial Organization, No. 20, pp.
1341-1361.
Cifter, A., Yilmazer, S. and E. Cifter (2009), “Analysis of Sectoral Credit
Default Cycle Dependency with Wavelet Networks: Evidence from
Turkey”, Economic Modeling, No. 26, pp. 1382-1388.
Coase, Ronald H. (1960), “The Problem of Social Cost”, Journal of Law and
Economics, Vol. 3, No. 1, pp. 1-44.
49 234' 5#/67' () *+,-+ ./01+ .#"#$%& ! 140
Cooter, Robert and Thomas Ulen (2000), Law and Economics, 3th Ed.
Reading, Mass.: Addison-Wesley.
Drukker, D. M. (2003), “Testing for Serial Correlation in Linear Panel-data
Models”, Stata Journal, No. 3, pp. 168-177.
Fisher, I. (1933), “The Debt Deflation Theory of Great Depressions”,
Econometrica, No. 1, pp. 337-357.
Fofack, Hippolyte (2005), “Non-performing Loans in Sub-saharan Africa:
Causal Analysis and Macroeconomic Implications”, World Bank Policy
Research Working Paper No. 3769, November.
Geanakoplos, J. (2009), “The Leverage Cycle”, Cowles Foundation
Discussion Paper No. 1715.
Godlewski, C. J. (2004), “Bank Capital and Credit Risk Taking in Emerging
Market Economies”, Journal of Banking Regulation, Vol. 6, No. 2, pp.
128-145.
Hasan, Ifetkhar and Larry D. Wall (2003), “Determinants of the Loan Loss
Allowance: Some Cross-country Comparison”, Bank of Finland
Discussion Papers No. 33/2003.
Hellman, Thomas, Murdock, Kevin and Joseph E. Stiglitz (2000),
“Liberalization, Moral Hazard in Banking and Prudential Regulation: Are
Capital Controls enough?”, American Economic Review, Vol. 90, No. 1,
pp. 147-165.
Hoggarth, Glen and John Whitley (2003), “Assessing the Strength of UK
Banks through Macroeconomic Stress Tests”, Financial Stability Review,
Bank of England, June, pp. 91-103.
Hu, Jin-Li, Yang, Li and Chiu Yung-Ho (2004), “Ownership and Nonperforming Loans: Evidence from Taiwan’s Banks”, Developing
Economies, Vol. 42, No. 4, pp. 405-420.
Jimenez, Gabriel and Jesus Saurina (2005), “Credit Cycles, Credit Risk, and
Prudential Regulation”, Banco de Espana, January.
Kearns, Allan (2004), “Loan Losses and the Macroeconomy: A Framework
for Stress Testing Credit Institutions’ Financial Well-being”, Financial
Stability Report, CBFSAI, 111-121.
Keeton, William R. (1999), “Does Faster Loan Growth Lead to Higher Loan
Losses?”, Federal Reserve Bank of Kansas City, Economic Review,
Second Quarter 1999.
Keeton, William R. and Charles S. Morris (1987), “Why Do Banks’ Loan
Losses Differ?”, Federal Reserve Bank of Kansas City, Economic
Review, May, pp. 3-21.
Kiyotaki, N. and J. Moore (1997), “Credit Cycles”, Journal of Political
Economy, Vol. 105, No. 2, pp. 211-247.
Kuafman, G. (1998), “Central Bank, Asset Bobbles and Financial Stability”,
Federal reserve bank of Chicago working paper, WP98/12
141 *+,-+ .3+GH7? I:J 3/ 89: ;<=> ,? ,@A B+9C DEE<F
Lawrence, E. C. (1995), “Consumer Default and the Life Cycle Model”,
Journal of Money Credit and Banking, No. 27, pp. 939-954.
Louzis, Dimitrios P., Vouldis,Angelos T. and Vasilios L. Metaxas (2011),
“Macroeconomic and Bank-specific Determinants of Non-performing
Loans in Greece: A Comparative Study of Mortgage, Business and
Consumer Loan Portfolios”, Journal of Banking & Finance.
Matutes, Carmen and Xavier Vives (2000), “Imperfect Competition, Risk
Taking and Regulation in Banking”, European Economic Review, No. 44,
pp. 184-216.
Micco, A., Panizza, U. and M. Yañez (2004), “Bank Ownership and
Performance’, Inter-American Development Bank”, Working paper, No.
518,.
Minsky, H. (1986), Stabilizing an Unstable Economy, McGraw-Hill.
Mishkin, Frederic S. (1999), “Financial Consolidation: Dangers and
Opportunities”, Journal of Banking and Finance, No. 23, pp. 675-691.
Mishkin, Frederic S. and Stanley G. Eakins (2011), Financial Market and
Institutions, Pearson.
Pain, Darren (2003), “The Provisioning Experience of the Major UK Banks:
A Small Panel Investigation”, Bank of England Working Paper No. 177,
January.
Podpiera, J. and L. Weill (2008), “Bad Luck or Bad Management? Emerging
Banking Market Experience”, Journal of Financial Stability, No. 4, pp.
135-148.
Quagliarello, M. (2007), “Banks’ Riskiness Over the Business Cycle: A
Panel Analysis on Italian Intermediaries”, Applied Financial Economics,
No. 17, pp. 119-138.
Rajan, Rajiv and Sarat C. Dhal (2003), “Non-performing Loans and Terms
of Credit of Public Sector Banks in India: An Empirical Assessment”,
Occasional Papers, Vol. 24, No. 3, pp. 81-121.
Rinaldi, L. and A. Sanchis-Arellano (2006), “Household Debt Sustainability:
What Explains Household Non-performing Loans? An Empirical
Analysis”, ECB Working Paper.
Salas, Vincente and Jesus Saurina (2002), “Credit Risk in Two Institutional
Regimes: Spanish Commercial and Savings Banks”, Journal of Financial
Services Research, Vol. 22, No. 3, pp. 203-224.
Sinkey, Joseph F. and Mary B. Greenwalt (1991), “Loan-loss Experience
and Risk-taking Behvior at Large Commercial Banks”, Journal of
Financial Services Research, No. 5, pp. 43-59.
Wooldridge, Jeffrey (2002), Econometric Analysis of Cross Section and
Panel Data, Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.
49 234' 5#/67' () *+,-+ ./01+ .#"#$%& ! 142
#I)9E&
Variable
Mean
(G 3/ 0!3 3N? .#,EK0 .3L MEJ9F .1 I)9E&
Std. Dev.
Min
Max
Observations
npl
overall
between
within
7350.536
8726.219
4770.651
7418.425
0
1217
-3653.036
39134
152 99
35026.54
N =
n =
T =
84
12
7
eff
overall
between
within
.8730952
.1522362
.1147811
.1046591
.38
.58
.4859524
1
.9728571
1 .095952
N =
n =
T =
84
12
7
loas
overall
between
within
.6752047
.7240268
.2846721
.6701006
.0626991
.3998748
-.769851
6.95965
1 .543002
6 .091853
N =
n =
T =
84
12
7
size
overall
between
within
.9998673
.8561805
.8506635
.2484497
.0167833
.093451
-.4670721
3.033118
2 .767415
1.546039
N =
n =
T =
84
12
7
Cygdp
overall
between
within
26877.34
3 2428.02
3.80e-12
32428.02
-18982.27
26877.34
-18982.27
7 1408.47
2 6877.34
71408.47
N =
n =
T =
84
12
7
gdpgro~h overall
between
within
.0674209
.0065056
0
.0065056
.06
.0674209
.06
. 07881
.0674209
. 07881
N =
n =
T =
84
12
7
ue
overall
between
within
11.15714
.7251566
0
.7251566
10.4
11.15714
10.4
12 .5
11.15714
12 .5
N =
n =
T =
84
12
7
inf
overall
between
within
.161
.0 45479
0
.0 45479
.104
.161
.104
.254
.1 61
.254
N =
n =
T =
84
12
7
hhi
overall
between
within
1387.767
1 80.1599
0
180.1599
1202.94
1387.767
1202.94
1 663.538
1387.767
1 663.538
N =
n =
T =
84
12
7
143 *+,-+ .3+GH7? I:J 3/ 89: ;<=> ,? ,@A B+9C DEE<F
2/U0)+ /39 B7& .#2/+/ 3/ QR0S<4#/9T $ Q7S4#7 .#*9OL P-07 .2 I)9E&
.
log
us ing
"H etr o a nd
Aut oco rre lat ion
pa nel
te st"
l og: C:\U sers\S imin\My Stude nts\POR DEL\Dat a\Hetr o and A utocor relatio n p
> an el tes t.smcl
lo g t ype : smcl
op ene d o n: 18 N ov 201 1, 03:2 6:39
.
*He tro ske das tis ity
.
* Mod el
1 w it hou t
pa nel
te st
ma cr o e ff ect
. xtg ls lnp lge L. lnp lge
> osk eda sti c)
It er ati on 1: to ler an ce =
It er ati on 2: to ler an ce =
It er ati on 3: to ler an ce =
It er ati on 4: to ler an ce =
le ff
llo as
lsi ze
sts teO wne r l loa ng
, i gls
pa nel s ( het er
.1788 5842
.1060 9526
.0670 9063
.0698 9424
Cr oss -se cti ona l t ime -se rie s F GLS re gre ssi on
Co eff ici ent s:
Pa nel s:
Co rre lat ion :
gene rali zed least squ ares
hete rosk edas tic
no a utoc orre latio n
Es tim ate d c ova ria nce s
=
Es tim ate d a uto cor rel ati ons =
Es tim ate d c oef fic ien ts
=
Lo g l ike lih ood
12
0
8
N umb er of obs
=
53
N umb er of gro ups
=
12
O bs per gr oup : m in =
4
av g =
4.4 16667
5
ma x =
W ald c hi2( 7)
=
6 40.96
Pr ob > ch i2
=
0 .0000
=-27 .244 96
ln plg e
C oe f.
ln plg e
L1.
le ff
ll oas
ls ize
st ste Own er
ll oan g
lg dpg
_c ons
.0 8808 82
-.2 4945 36
.2 3974 27
-.0 3194 96
-.4 1308 19
-.0 6868 45
.2 0709 89
1. 2006 65
Std . Err .
.115 0304
.220 8037
.035 3376
.081 2177
.161 9534
.030 4349
.166 9812
.355 4761
z
0.7 7
-1.1 3
6.7 8
-0.3 9
-2.5 5
-2.2 6
1.2 4
3.3 8
P>| z|
0.44 4
0.25 9
0.00 0
0.69 4
0.01 1
0.02 4
0.21 5
0.00 1
[95% C on f. In ter va l]
-.13 7367 2
-.68 2220 9
.17 0482 3
-.19 1133 5
-.73 0504 8
-.12 8335 8
-.12 0178 2
.50 3944 6
.31 35437
.18 33137
.3 09003
.12 72342
-.09 56589
-.00 90332
.5 34376
1.8 97386
. es tim at es st ore h ete ro s1
. xtg ls lnp lge L. lnp lge le ff llo as lsi ze sts teO wne r l loa ng lgd pg, ig ls
It er ati on 1: to ler an ce = 6. 040e- 14
Cr oss -se cti ona l t ime -se rie s F GLS re gre ssi on
Co eff ici ent s:
Pa nel s:
Co rre lat ion :
gene rali zed least squ ares
homo sked asti c
no a utoc orre latio n
Es tim ate d c ova ria nce s
=
Es tim ate d a uto cor rel ati ons =
Es tim ate d c oef fic ien ts
=
Lo g l ike lih ood
1
0
8
N umb er of obs
=
53
N umb er of gro ups
=
12
O bs per gr oup : m in =
4
av g =
4.4 16667
ma x =
5
22.24
W ald c hi2( 7)
=
Pr ob > ch i2
=
0 .0023
=-50 .327 27
ln plg e
C oe f.
ln plg e
L1.
le ff
ll oas
ls ize
st ste Own er
ll oan g
lg dpg
_c ons
-.0 4150 81
.7 1693 92
.0 2671 96
.0 9061 22
-.8 3606 09
.0 5926 76
1. 3525 99
3. 3294 28
Std . Err .
.136 1492
.675 8215
.163 8981
.121 6054
.302 6448
.084 4587
1.02 2864
1.4 1628
z
-0.3 0
1.0 6
0.1 6
0.7 5
-2.7 6
0.7 0
1.3 2
2.3 5
P>| z|
0.76 0
0.28 9
0.87 0
0.45 6
0.00 6
0.48 3
0.18 6
0.01 9
[95% C on f. In ter va l]
-.30 8355 5
-.60 7646 6
-.29 4514 8
-.14 7729 9
-1.4 2923 4
-.10 6268 4
-.65 2177 3
.55 3569 4
.22 53393
2.0 41525
.3 47954
.32 89543
-.24 28879
.22 48036
3.3 57375
6.1 05286
. lo cal d f = e (N_ g) - 1
. lr tes t het er os1 . , df (` df' )
Li ke lih oo d-r at io te st
(A ssu mpt ion : . n est ed in he te ros 1)
LR c hi2( 11 ) =
Pr ob > chi 2 =
46.16
0 .0000
. *M ode l 2 w it hou t mac ro ef fe ct
. xtg ls lnp lge L. lnp lge
> osk eda sti c)
It er ati on 1: to ler an ce =
It er ati on 2: to ler an ce =
It er ati on 3: to ler an ce =
le ff llo as lsi ze sts teO wne r l loa ng , i gls pa nel s ( het er
.1 78858 42
.1 06095 26
.0 67090 63
49 234' 5#/67' () *+,-+ ./01+ .#"#$%& ! 144
Cross-se cti ona l
Coeffici ent s:
Panels:
Correlat ion :
Estimate d
Estimate d
Estimate d
Log
.
t ime -se rie s
c ova ria nce s
a uto cor rel ati ons
c oef fic ien ts
12
0
7
C oe f.
ln plg e
L1.
le ff
lloas
lsize
st steOwner
ll oan g
_cons
.0 6 22 74 8
- .2 1 31 49 3
.2 3 21 70 5
- .0 0 58 92 1
- .4 8 16 37 2
- .0 5 99 34 5
.9 9 31 16 4
Std . Err .
use
es tim at es
Cross-se cti ona l
Coeffici ent s:
Panels:
Correlat ion :
llo as
lsize
le ff llo as
7 . 08 4e -1 6
t ime -se rie s
C oe f.
ln plg e
L1.
le ff
lloas
lsize
st steOwner
ll oan g
_cons
-. 0 78 01 3
.7 2 69 12 2
.0 2 28 17 5
.0 8 21 16 7
- .8 3 91 50 4
.0 5 63 26 4
1. 5 07 55 9
.
lo cal d f
.
lrtes t het er os2 . ,
= e (N_ g)
-
Li ke lih oo d-r at io te st
(Assumpt ion : . nested
F GLS
lsize
. 2 99 42 59
. 22 85 39
. 3 22 53 61
. 1 56 73 76
-. 1 26 79 82
. 00 58 22
1 . 40 63 67
l loa ng
,
i gls
cl ear
sts teOwne r
l loa ng
,
i gls
re gression
1
0
7
=
=
=
Std . Err .
N umb er of obs
=
53
N umb er of gro ups
=
12
O bs per gr oup : m in =
4
4 . 41 66 67
av g =
ma x =
5
1 9. 84
W ald c hi2( 6 )
=
Pr ob > ch i2
=
0. 00 30
[95% C on f.
-. 3 43 59 3 2
-. 6 19 26 3 8
-. 3 03 62 0 3
- . 15 97 8 7
-1 . 44 20 1 1
- .1 11 8 6
. 8 53 83 8 8
LR c hi2( 1 1 ) =
Pr ob > chi 2 =
in he te ros 2)
*Mode l 1 w it h
.
xtseri al
(2002)
Pa nen T est : wri tt en
by
Da vi d
effec t
le ff
llo as
lsi ze
Wooldrid ge tes t f or aut oco rre lat ion
H0: no fi rs t-o rd er au tocorrelation
3. 47 8
F(
1,
11) =
Pro b > F =
0. 08 91
2 w it hou t mac ro
lnp lge
P>| z|
0. 56 5
0. 29 0
0. 89 1
0. 50 6
0. 00 6
0. 51 2
0. 00 0
In ter va l]
. 1 87 56 72
2 . 07 30 88
. 3 49 25 53
. 3 24 02 05
-. 2 36 28 94
. 2 24 51 27
2 . 16 12 78
1
.
macro
- 0. 58
1. 06
0. 14
0. 67
- 2. 73
0. 66
4. 52
df(`df')
* Aut oc oro la tio n Woo ld rid ge
)
lnp lge
z
. 13 55 0 26
. 68 68 3 71
.1 66 5 53
. 12 34 2 26
. 30 75 8 78
. 08 58 1 09
. 33 35 3 66
.
>
xtseri al
sts teOwne r
=-5 1. 1 87 48
ln plg e
* Mod el
-. 1 74 87 6 4
-. 6 54 83 7 7
. 1 41 80 4 8
-. 1 68 52 1 8
-. 8 36 47 6 3
-. 1 25 69 1 1
. 5 79 86 5 6
In ter va l]
ge ne r al iz ed le as t s qu ar e s
ho mo s ke da st i c
no a u to co rr e la ti on
like lih ood
.
0. 60 7
0. 34 4
0. 00 0
0. 94 3
0. 00 8
0. 07 4
0. 00 0
S tud ent s\P ORDEL\Data\NPLd ata set .dt a",
c ova ria nce s
a uto cor rel ati ons
c oef fic ien ts
.
[95% C on f.
st ore h ete ro s2
. xtg ls lnp lge L. lnp lge
It er ati on 1: to ler an ce =
Log
0. 51
- 0. 95
5. 04
- 0. 07
- 2. 66
- 1. 79
4. 71
P>| z|
st ore h ete ro s2
"C :\U ser s\S imi n\M y
Estimate d
Estimate d
Estimate d
z
. 12 09 9 77
. 22 53 5 53
. 04 61 0 58
. 08 29 7 58
. 18 10 4 37
. 03 35 4 99
. 21 08 4 61
. xtg ls lnp lge L. lnp lge le ff
v ar ia bl e l lo a ng n ot fo un d
r(111);
.
N umb er of obs
=
53
12
N umb er of gro ups
=
4
O bs per gr oup : m in =
4 . 41 66 67
av g =
ma x =
5
W ald c hi2( 6 )
=
7 1. 40
0. 00 00
Pr ob > ch i2
=
=-3 2. 0 86 01
ln plg e
.
re gression
=
=
=
like lih ood
es tim at es
F GLS
ge ne r al iz ed le as t s qu ar e s
he te r os ke da s ti c
no a u to co rr e la ti on
le ff
ststeOwner
in
panel
lloa ng
data
ef fe ct
llo as
lsi ze
Wooldrid ge tes t f or aut oco rre lat ion
H0: no fi rs t-o rd er au tocorrelation
F(
1,
11) =
0. 00 0
Pro b > F =
0. 99 25
ststeOwner
in
panel
lloa ng
data
lgd pg
3 8. 20
0. 00 01
D ru kke r (2003
145 *+,-+ .3+GH7? I:J 3/ 89: ;<=> ,? ,@A B+9C DEE<F
.
.
. log us ing
6 F 1 Q40SE) GMM .#(G DE4VF P-07 .3 I)9E&
"The res ult s o f t he spe cif ied
GM M Models"
l og: C: \ U se r s \S i m in \ My S tu d e nt s \ PO R D EL \ D at a \ Th e r e s ul t s o f th e sp e c if i e
> d G MM M od e l s. s m cl
lo g t ype: sm c l
opened o n: 18 N ov 2 01 1 , 0 9 :2 6 : 17
.
. *Re sul ts of NPL de ter min ant s in I ran ian
ba nking sys tem
.
. *De pen den t variabl e i s t he logari thm ic sca le of NPL gr owt h
.
. * T he ban k effect var iab les inclu de: , log arithmic sca le of effici enc y, log ar
> ith mic sc ale of lo ans to as sets r ati o, log arithmic sca le of size o wne rsh ip st
> at us wh ich is a d ummy wit h fig ur e 1 f or st at e o wn ers hi p
.
.
>
>
>
>
* F or rob ustness o f t he emp irical fi ndi ngs , the reg res sio ns wer e e sti mat ed wi
th alt ern ative mea sur es of busine ss cyc le variable: th e d eviation of gdp ov er
lo gar ith m scale f rom it s t rend ( usi ng Hod rick-Pres cot t) method as cy cli cal o
utp ut, th e lag act ual GD P g rowth rat e, the lag of l oga rit hm of une mpl oym ent r
ate an d e lag of l oga rit hm of inf lat ion
r ate
.
. *
Mod el I:
> ct
Syst em
GMM
mo del wi th
rob ust
standard er ror s without ma cro
.
. xt dpd sy s l nplge l eff
llo as ls iz e sts teO wn er , maxld ep( )
la gs(2)
>
vc e(r obu st)
note: st ste Owner dro ppe d f rom div() be cau se of collin ear ity
Syste m d yna mic panel -da ta est imatio n
Group va ria ble: i d
Time var iab le: y e ar
Numbe r o f i nstrument s =
One-s tep
a rte st s(2)
Number o f o bs
Numbe r o f g roups
Obs per
17
gro up:
ef fe
=
=
47
12
min =
3
3 .9 1 6 66 7
avg =
4
max =
Wa ld chi2( 6)
Pr ob > ch i2
=
=
4 3 .2 8
0 . 0 00 0
re sults
ln plg e
C oe f.
ln plg e
L1.
L2.
leff
ll oas
ls ize
st ste Owner
_c ons
- .3 5 7 63 5 9
-. 3 0 58 3 9
- 1. 2 8 02 0 6
.2 5 9 68 9 6
.3 6 4 30 7 9
- 1. 7 9 18 9 7
2. 5 5 22 5 2
Ro bus t
Std . Err .
.1 8 4 59 1 9
.1 4 7 38 0 1
.5 9 2 22 0 8
.1 5 1 32 4 5
.3 2 3 88 9 5
.8 6 2 34 4 3
.8 2 6 51 8 5
z
P>| z|
-1 . 9 4
-2 . 0 8
-2 . 1 6
1.72
1.12
-2 . 0 8
3.09
[95% C on f. In ter va l]
0. 0 5 3
0. 0 3 8
0. 0 3 1
0. 0 8 6
0. 2 6 1
0. 0 3 8
0. 0 0 2
- . 71 9 4 29 4
- . 59 4 6 98 7
- 2 .4 4 0 93 7
- . 03 6 9 00 9
- . 27 0 5 03 9
- 3 .4 8 2 06 1
. 93 2 3 05 9
. 00 4 1 57 6
- . 01 6 9 79 2
- . 11 9 4 74 4
. 55 6 2 80 1
. 99 9 1 19 7
- . 10 1 7 33 2
4 .1 7 2 19 9
Instr ume nts for d iff ere nce d e quatio n
GMM -type: L ( 2 /. ) . ln p lg e
Sta ndard: D . l ef f D. l lo a s D . l si z e
Instr ume nts for leve l e qua tio n
GMM -type: L D . ln p l ge
Sta ndard: _ c o ns
.
. *
Mod el II:
Sys tem GM M m odel w ith ro bus t standar d e rro rs with m acr o e ffe ct
>
wh ich is
cyclica l o utp ut
.
. xt dpd sy s l nplge l eff
llo as ls iz e sts teO wn er
lcygdp , l ag s(2)
> (ro bus t)
note: st ste Owner dro ppe d f rom div() be cau se of collin ear ity
Syste m d yna mic panel -da ta est imatio n
Group va ria ble: i d
Time var iab le: y e ar
Number o f o bs
Numbe r o f g roups
Obs per
Numbe r o f i nstrument s =
One-s tep
18
gro up:
=
=
47
12
3
min =
3 .9 1 6 66 7
avg =
max =
4
Wa ld chi2( 7)
Pr ob > ch i2
=
=
1 8 .1 0
0 . 0 11 5
re sults
ln plg e
C oe f.
ln plg e
L1.
L2.
leff
ll oas
ls ize
st ste Owner
lc ygd p
_c ons
-. 3 7 09 1 7
- .3 9 8 59 2 6
- 2. 9 3 51 4 6
.2 9 8 14 7 3
.3 8 2 64 9 3
- 2. 5 0 39 2 7
2. 1 1 33 8 1
5. 8 6 28 8 1
Ro bus t
Std . Err .
.1 8 2 81 1 6
.1 6 8 15 9 5
1. 5 9 40 8 8
.1 5 8 32 0 4
. 3 0 07 3 6
1. 3 2 60 3 1
1. 5 9 26 1 5
2. 9 9 37 6 8
z
-2 . 0 3
-2 . 3 7
-1 . 8 4
1.88
1.27
-1 . 8 9
1.33
1.96
P>| z|
0. 0 4 2
0. 0 1 8
0. 0 6 6
0. 0 6 0
0. 2 0 3
0. 0 5 9
0. 1 8 5
0. 0 5 0
Instr ume nts for d iff ere nce d e quatio n
GMM -type: L ( 2 /. ) . ln p lg e
Sta ndard: D . l ef f D. l lo a s D . l si z e D . l cy g d p
Instr ume nts for leve l e qua tio n
GMM -type: L D . ln p l ge
Sta ndard: _ c o ns
.
a rte st s(2) vc e
[95% C on f. In ter va l]
- . 72 9 2 21 1
- . 72 8 1 79 2
-6 . 0 59 5
- . 01 2 1 55 1
- . 20 6 7 82 5
- 5 .1 0 2 90 1
- 1 .0 0 8 08 8
- . 00 4 7 96 5
- . 01 2 6 12 9
- .0 6 9 00 6
. 18 9 2 08 3
. 60 8 4 49 6
.9 7 2 08 1
. 09 5 0 46 7
5 .2 3 4 84 9
1 1. 7 3 05 6
49 234' 5#/67' () *+,-+ ./01+ .#"#$%& ! 146
.
.
. * Mod el III:
System GMM model with robust sta nda rd errors with macro effec
> t w hic h is the lag of DGP growth
. xtdpdsys lnplge leff lloas lsiz e s tsteOwner L .gd pg, lags(2)
> (ro bus t)
no te: st steOwner dropped from div() because of col lin ear ity
Sy ste m d ynamic panel-data estimation
Gr oup va riable: i d
Ti me var iable: ye ar
Nu mbe r o f o bs
Number of groups
Ob s p er gro up:
Nu mbe r o f instruments =
a rte sts(2) vce
18
=
=
47
12
min =
3
avg =3. 916 667
max =
4
Wald ch i2( 7)
Prob > chi2
=
=
17 .11
0.0 167
On e-s tep results
ln plge
ln plge
L1.
L2.
leff
lloas
lsize
ststeOwner
gdpgt
L1.
_cons
Coef.
Robust
Std. Err.
z
P>|z|
[95% Conf. Inter val]
- .29 40 939
- .36 69 013
- 2.1 84 739
.30 23 093
.44 97 999
- 2.1 30 817
.15 405 74
.14 903 92
1.1 435 58
.13 958 09
.30 371 98
1.0 004 68
-1. 91
-2. 46
-1. 91
2. 17
1. 48
-2. 13
0 .05 6
0 .01 4
0 .05 6
0.03 0
0 .13 9
0 .03 3
- .59 604 09
- .65 901 28
- 4.4 260 72
.02 873 57
- .14 547 98
- 4.0 916 98
.0 078 531
-.0 747 899
.0 565 941
.5 758 829
1 .04 508
-.1 699 353
- 10. 29 945
5.3 66 013
4.9 487 27
1.8 973 93
-2. 08
2. 83
0 .03 7
0 .00 5
- 19. 998 78
1. 647 19
-.6 001 215
9. 084 835
In str ume nts for differenced equation
GMM-type: L( 2/ .). lnp lge
Standard: D. le ff D.l loa s D.ls ize LD .gd pgt
In str ume nts for level equation
GMM-type: LD .l npl ge
Standard: _c on s
.
. * Mod el IV:
System GMM model with robust s tan dar d e rrors with macro effect
> wh ich is the lag of the logarithm scale of une mpl oym ent rate
. xtdpdsys lnplge leff lloas lsiz e s tsteOwner L .lu , lags(2) artests(2) vce(r
> obu st)
no te: st steOwner dropped from div() because of col lin ear ity
Sy ste m d ynamic panel-data estimation
Gr oup va riable: i d
Ti me var iable: ye ar
Nu mbe r o f o bs
Number of groups
Ob s p er gro up:
Nu mbe r o f instruments =
18
=
=
47
12
3
min =
avg =3. 916 667
4
max =
Wald ch i2( 7)
Prob > chi2
=
=
30 .57
0.0 001
On e-s tep results
ln plge
ln plge
L1.
L2.
leff
lloas
lsize
ststeOwner
lu e
L1.
_cons
Coef.
Robust
Std. Err.
z
[95% Conf. Inter val]
- .42 13 356
- .31 44 735
- 1.9 22 629
.25 29 637
.34 86 971
- 2.2 33 512
.19 023 77
.15 373 24
.98 017 41
.12 878 53
.29 188 38
1.1 387 72
-2. 21
-2. 05
-1. 96
1. 96
1. 19
-1. 96
0 .02 7
0 .04 1
0 .05 0
0.05 0
0 .23 2
0 .05 0
- .79 419 45
- .61 578 35
- 3.8 437 35
.00 054 91
- .22 338 46
- 4.4 654 63
-.0 484 766
-.0 131 636
-.0 015 226
.5 053 783
.9 207 787
-.0 015 604
3.4 35 014
- 5.4 02 318
2.5 694 07
5.6 518 36
1. 34
-0. 96
0 .18 1
0 .33 9
- 1.6 009 32
- 16. 479 71
8 .47 096
5. 675 077
In str ume nts for differenced equation
GMM-type: L( 2/ .). lnp lge
Standard: D. le ff D.l loa s D.ls ize LD .lu e
In str ume nts for level equation
GMM-type: LD .l npl ge
Standard: _c on s
.
P>|z|
147 *+,-+ .3+GH7? I:J 3/ 89: ;<=> ,? ,@A B+9C DEE<F
.
. *
Mod el V:
S ystem GMM model with robust standard errors with ma cro effect
> which is
the lag of the logarithm s cale of inflati on rate
.
. xt dpdsys lnplge leff
lloas lsize s tsteO wn er L.linf, lags(2)
> (robus t)
note: st steOwner droppe d from div() be cause of collin earity
System d ynamic panel-da ta estimation
Group va riable: i d
Time var iable: ye ar
Number o f obs
Nu mber o f groups
Obs per group:
Number o f instruments =
a rtests(2) vce
18
=
=
47
12
min =
3
3.9166 67
avg =
4
max =
Wald chi2( 7 )
Prob > chi2
=
=
40. 82
0.00 00
One-step results
ln plge
ln plge
L1.
L2.
le ff
ll oas
ls ize
st steOwner
li nf
L1.
_c ons
Coe f.
Ro bust
Std. Err .
z
P>|z|
[95% Conf. Interva l]
- .41841 06
- .27446 05
- 1.3062 38
.23654 46
.35639 16
- 2.0173 39
.1 766404
.1 463142
.6 560257
. 121407
. 295508
.9 691686
-2. 37
-1. 88
-1. 99
1. 95
1. 21
-2. 08
0. 018
0. 061
0. 046
0. 051
0. 228
0. 037
-.7646 194
-.561 231
-2.592 024
-.0014 088
-.2227 935
-3.916 874
-.07220 19
.012 31
-.02045 09
.47449 79
.93557 67
-.11780 33
-.7690 09
1.1631 24
.4 664287
.8 769426
-1. 65
1. 33
0. 099
0. 185
-1.683 192
-.5556 517
.14517 44
2.88 19
Instrume nts for differe nced equation
GMM-type: L(2/. ).lnplg e
Standard: D.lef f D.llo as D.ls ize LD .linf
Instrume nts for level e quation
GMM-type: LD.ln plge
Standard: _cons
.
. *
Mod el VI:
> ect wh ich is
System GMM m odel w ith robust standar d errors with i ndustry eff
the lo garithm scale o f concentration ratio=hhi
. xt dpdsys lnplge leff
llo as lsize s tsteO wn er lhhi , lags(2) artests(2) vc e(r
> obust)
note: st steOwner droppe d from div() be cause of collin earity
System d ynamic panel-da ta estimation
Group va riable: i d
Time var iable: ye ar
Number o f obs
Nu mber o f groups
Obs per group:
Number o f instruments =
18
=
=
47
12
min =
3
avg =
3.9166 67
4
max =
Wald chi2( 7 )
Prob > chi2
=
=
35. 95
0.00 00
One-step results
ln plge
Coe f.
ln plge
L1.
L2.
le ff
ll oas
ls ize
st steOwner
lh hi
_c ons
- .36558 04
- .34065 88
- 1.8279 09
.27184 74
.36362 02
- 2.0161 73
- 1.6317 18
14.305 29
Ro bust
Std. Err .
.1 794824
.1 407569
1. 396601
.1 727658
.3 174157
1. 094288
4. 303719
31 .18648
z
-2. 04
-2. 42
-1. 31
1. 57
1. 15
-1. 84
-0. 38
0. 46
P>|z|
0. 042
0. 016
0. 191
0. 116
0. 252
0. 065
0. 705
0. 646
[95% Conf. Interva l]
-.7173 595
-.6165 373
-4.565 197
-.0667 674
-.2585 031
-4.160 937
-10.06 685
-46.8 191
-.01380 12
-.06478 04
.90937 91
.61046 22
.98574 35
.12859 16
6.8034 17
75.429 67
Instrume nts for differe nced equation
GMM-type: L(2/. ).lnplg e
Standard: D.lef f D.llo as D.ls ize D. lhhi
Instrume nts for level e quation
GMM-type: LD.ln plge
Standard: _cons
. log cl ose
lo g: C:\U sers\S imin\My Studen ts\POR DEL\Dat a\The results of th e speci fie
> d GMM Mo dels.sm cl
lo g type: smcl
cl osed on: 18 N ov 201 1, 09:2 8:48
49 234' 5#/67' () *+,-+ ./01+ .#"#$%& ! 148
=W 3/ 2/U0)+ /39 QJ+ .#2/+/ .4 I)9E&
HHI
Inflation
Unemployment
GDPgrowth
Efficiency
Asset
loan
NPL
year
1664
0/158
12/5
0/079
0/73
163090
88586
2781
81

!"
1664
0/158
12/5
0/079
0/69
62868
35678
1102
81
#$%
1664
0/158
12/5
0/079
0/63
120766
62705
5188
81
&'()*
1664
0/158
12/5
0/079
0/85
0/81
87881
103467
62705
61821
0
1901
81
&(+,
1664
0/158
12/5
0/079
0/38
21379
10000
38566
398
1573
81
81
012"
1664
0/158
12/5
0/079
1
36028
30713
358
81
34(567
1664
0/158
12/5
0/079
0/88
0/63
981
1791
689
10
81
;"%
1664
0/158
12/5
0/079
0/6
909
392
0
81
1626
0/156
11/5
0/075
0/83
215200
121884
3406
82
82
#$%
1626
0/156
11/5
0/075
0/54
149607
76362
7850
82
&'()*
1626
0/156
11/5
0/075
1
147292
104247
2027
82
-!"
1626
0/156
11/5
0/075
0/53
27945
59549
17111
74/483
742
1695
82
82
012"
1626
0/156
11/5
0/075
0/96
42512
35351
966
82
34(567
1626
0/156
11/5
0/075
0/9
2410
1793
6297
142
31
82
1626
0/156
11/5
0/075
0/91
2709
1859
0
82
1446
0/152
10/4
0/062
0/77
0/94
1257968
290700
169324
3790
83
83
#$%
1446
0/152
10/4
0/062
0/64
176606
171283
92904
119986
13409
83
&'()*
1446
0/152
10/4
0/062
0/062
1
0/99
206557
149354
3285
83
-!"
1446
0/152
10/4
0/062
0/99
88973
62491
4668
83
012"
1446
0/152
10/4
0/062
0/78
63441
43909
1944
83
34(567
1446
0/152
10/4
0/062
0/85
4227
126
83
1664
1664
1664
1664
1626
1626
1626
1626
1626
1446
1446
1446
1446
1446
0/158
0/158
0/158
0/158
0/156
0/156
0/156
0/156
0/156
0/152
0/152
0/152
0/152
0/152
12/5
12/5
12/5
12/5
11/5
11/5
11/5
11/5
11/5
10/4
10/4
10/4
10/4
10/4
0/079
0/079
0/079
0/079
0/075
0/075
0/075
0/075
0/075
0/062
0/062
0/062
0/062
1
1
0/9
0/93
1
0/59
1
1
0/7
1
49001
1771
84260
115269
3435
8758
41328
6471
5926
31415
1159
621
54496
80223
1574
84659
30593
3901
22205
40
44
1806
707
96
2750
2520
1394
238
932
81
81
81
82
82
82
83
83
83
83
-!"
./(
089/:(7
;<%(=
)?@A'
08B
!"
&(+,
./(
089/:(7
;"%
;<%(=
)?@A'
08B
!"
&(+,
./(
089/:(7
;"%
;<%(=
149 *+,-+ .3+GH7? I:J 3/ 89: ;<=> ,? ,@A B+9C DEE<F

HHI
Inflation
Unemployment
GDPgrowth
Efficiency
Asset
loan
NPL
year
1446
0/152
10/4
0/062
1
6780
4767
5
83
1309
0/104
11/5
0/067
0/72
335151
191281
6402
84
84
#$%
1309
0/104
11/5
0/067
0/52
1
23939
204844
22689
148696
15843
84
&'()*
1309
0/104
11/5
0/067
0/91
231325
27815
6045
84
-!"
1309
0/104
11/5
0/067
0/067
0/88
1
120043
87934
11256
84
84
34(567
1309
0/104
11/5
0/067
0/72
12555
7180
579
84
089/:(7
1309
0/104
11/5
0/067
1
81060
57765
1508
84
;<%(=
1309
0/104
11/5
0/067
1
14552
9558
15
84
1226
0/119
11/3
0/064
0/79
407862
245643
21156
85
85
#$%
1226
0/119
11/3
0/064
0/6
301415
242029
178046
24727
15058
85
&'()*
1226
0/119
11/3
0/064
0/93
294622
35993
17166
85
-!"
1226
0/119
11/3
0/064
0/94
1
122800
14523
101075
13838
85
85
34(567
1226
0/119
11/3
0/064
0/87
18210
11049
1575
85
089/:(7
1226
0/119
11/3
0/064
1
117316
76764
7103
85
;<%(=
1226
0/119
11/3
0/064
1
41341
28512
1266
85
1240
0/184
10/5
0/064
0/88
510666
346895
27824
86
86
#$%
1240
0/184
10/5
0/064
0/55
370943
294898
215623
37050
23594
86
&'()*
1240
0/184
10/5
0/064
0/98
384591
289099
19070
86
-!"
1240
0/184
10/5
0/064
0/95
163882
116217
7384
86
86
012"
34(567
1240
0/184
10/5
0/064
0/88
25735
17354
1635
86
089/:(7
1240
0/184
10/5
0/064
1
162213
107050
17846
86
;<%(=
1309
1309
1309
1309
1309
1226
1226
1226
1226
1226
1240
1240
1240
1240
1240
0/104
0/104
0/104
0/104
0/104
0/119
0/119
0/119
0/119
0/119
0/184
0/184
0/184
0/184
0/184
11/5
11/5
11/5
11/5
11/5
11/3
11/3
11/3
11/3
11/3
10/5
10/5
10/5
10/5
10/5
0/067
0/067
0/067
0/067
0/064
0/064
0/064
0/064
0/064
0/064
0/064
0/064
0/064
0/064
0/93
0/91
0/83
1
1
0/91
0/88
1
0/97
0/8
1
1
153216
44568
90423
14290
213982
53255
26209
233721
63454
173927
34846
106026
33647
66260
9784
157946
35867
10786
15269
171722
40160
14099
23989
6165
3058
5474
3346
339
8145
21307
9906
4333
561
21104
20972
10107
4359
1413
84
84
84
85
85
85
86
86
86
)?@A'
08B
!"
&(+,
./(
012"
;"%
)?@A'
08B
!"
&(+,
./(
012"
;"%
)?@A'
08B
!"
&(+,
./(
;"%
49 234' 5#/67' () *+,-+ ./01+ .#"#$%& ! 150

HHI
Inflation
Unemployment
GDPgrowth
Efficiency
Asset
loan
NPL
year
1240
0/184
10/5
0/064
1
74501
53612
3400
86
1203
0/254
10/4
0/060
0/89
538515
365657
25837
87
87
#$%
1203
0/254
10/4
0/060
0/58
404588
339914
46012
226670
26151
87
&'()*
1203
0/254
10/4
0/060
0/97
422678
303161
18181
87
-!"
1203
0/254
10/4
0/060
0/93
183346
189592
159830
17958
7869
87
87
34(567
1203
0/254
10/4
0/060
0/92
35249
22047
4356
87
089/:(7
1203
0/254
10/4
0/060
1
197467
12381
23070
87
;<%(=
1203
0/254
10/4
0/060
1
101601
64164
12637
87
1203
1203
1203
1203
1203
0/254
0/254
0/254
0/254
0/254
10/4
10/4
10/4
10/4
10/4
0/060
0/060
0/060
0/060
0/060
0/99
0/96
0/85
0/98
0/97
218745
66986
42376
28448
45359
27311
39134
28461
10596
6008
7064
87
87
87
)?@A'
08B
!"
&(+,
./(
012"
;"%
)?@A'
08B

ｩﾂ ｻ cZ^·Z仆 ] iR» ｶｻYﾂ ｾﾌﾌ^e ﾉ Y|ｰｿZ] d ﾀ ½Y ﾋY

Comments

Description

Transcript

ｩﾂｻ cZ^·Z仆 ] iR» ｶｻYﾂｾﾌﾌ^e ﾉ Y|ｰｿZ] d ﾀ ½Y ﾋY