スライド - 東北大学 大学院理学研究科・理学部

vǃɣʉɻɤɕɾ
ȍňˆȵ‰¿ȰŅȒȿʑĒªȯȶʋʋȎ
!"#$%"&'("&)*+,-.(/01-*("*2+30$"'43*
!"3$%'#15$*&"5*+(30$#,*6*7$//("/*8%(-*7&9*:(1%#;
úR„ˆ„ˆǀĭˆŁŌň
!"#$%#&'()*+,,-(,.()*/'0*'1
÷}ȉĊ
21%3,1+/(456758
Ǚ
ȶȢɂȳ
90&",$%*:,0
ňˆȵ‰¿ȰŽBʛňˆŪȵƂğȖɉ
)*/'0:;*(/0*'":&%$'(/0(-#<(*,%"&=(>",?(#(1*/'0:1&@1(A/'<B,/0&(
*
*
*
ȉ
ǚ
ŬïʏC#*DE",%0$ʐ
•! ňˆȰŅȵɝɞɣʀɞ
ǑǑǑǑF/1&"%1&(,.(1*/'0*'(#0$(,.(1*/'0*'(B,-/*3
•! „LJĞƾ6
!!!!"#$%&'(!)*+,!-.+!/%()(-+,!0122
•! “ƹŽȵȍňˆĹMƆȎ
ǑǑǑǑGHB'"&(#$A/*'
•! ĕŸƔȍȨȩȪȳ²NJȶȲȒȎ0,(/??'$/#&'(I#*%&'J'K'*&
–! ňˆȰŅʑňˆȰ½đ‰ȻȵŅ&
–! >%"&+'"(?/1&"%1&(,.(1*/'0*'(#0$(,.(B,-/:*/#0(IE,A'"0?'0&JǛ
ɣʉɻɤɕɾȵĺĹ
)*,B'(,.(&+/1(13?B,1/%?
•! ňˆȰŅȵȍɺɧʉȵ×țƭȒȎɏØɋȝȰ
ǑǑǑLC%M,0(%B(?3(N#*D'&(<",0EO(C'&<''0(1*/'0*'(#0$(1,*/'&3
•! ȧȵĻȡèɏØɋȝȰ
ȧȵĻȡèɏØɋȝȰ
「直ちに影響はない・・・」
ǑǑǑǑ4,<(&,(;H(/&P(
•! ȉȉȉȉňˆȵ‰¿ʏĦȳƒŨ¿ʐʏɥɧʌʄʉɟãÖʐ
ȉǑQ'3=()*/'0:;*(/0*'":&%$'(
Q'3=()*/'0:;*(/0*'":&%$'(I'1BR(S?C/E%/&3J(
•! Šƣ
ʛȉɡʉɚʆʉɭʋɗʊɓɬʉɥʏɼɞʆʃʉBʐ
Ǒ(((((T",?/1/0E(?'&+,$=(U,0*%""'0&(GA/$'0*'(I4,0R(V%1:*'(F*U-'--#0J
ǜ
yĬęðQIE-,C#-(<#"?/0EJ
a8Ĺȍ×țƭȒȎǑI0#WA'(1*/'0:1&(?#3(1#3J
•! ȍęŒNüɛɥȳɈɋęðQȶňˆĹƍì
ȗȟɌȮȒȲȒȎȉILE-,C#-(<#"?/0E(*#%1'$(C3(
E"''0+,%1'(E#1'1O(/1(0,&(B",A'0J(
ȉȉȉȉȉȉȉȉȇ
•! ȍ’ŕɏŸȓȵȶljňˆĹȎȉTUSVWX
7!(9&(/1(0,&(1*/'0:;*(&,(&#D'(?'#1%"'1X
ǝ
ȳ|ȭșBçȎ
ǑIGA/$'0*'(Y#1'$(7'*/1/,0J
•! ‰ʛ’ŕȳȶȍňˆĹþÒȎȗ¹ſ
6#WA'(S11%?B:,0=(?'#1%"'(?%1&(C'(N%1:;'$(C3(
L1*/'0:;*('A/$'0*'O
•! ůĢňˆʏÍŹɃʐǑ6#&%"#-()*/'0*'
–! Z[[\ćȡȒƍìʛȍYĭĹȳbŭȎ
Ǒ((T",,.(</&+,%&(#03($,%C&(/1(-,E/*#--3(/?B,11/C-'
•! ȍyĬęðQȎʋʋʋŠǏbŭ
•! ʠʤʞʞȉ](ʚʔʎǑʏZ[[£ŠȫȮ^^\ȳȲɋȖʋʋʋPXʐ
–! ȍƍìȎʜȍŚ¶ȵʆɹʅȎʋʋʋňˆŪȳɈȫȮƭȓʏļÃƃʐ
Ǒ(ȉǑ2+'(&+"'1+,-$($'B'0$1(,0(1*/'0:1&1R(
Ǟ
úR„ˆʕ£ĮI>"'1+?'0f(2,+,D%((80/ARJ(
_[Z_£ʙôZ_êȉSˆƲʏZdgʐ(
F'$/*#-()*+,,-()&%$'0&1(
_[Z_£bôeêȉĒʋæʋŠʋãI_dgʐ
ʢʪʨʩʬʧʫ(S"&1()&%$'0&1
ˆĮɒʉɠʌɭ
)%"A'3(#?,0E(1&%$'0&1
äʏB'"1,01J
d(
yĬęðQ’ŕŠéȳ¹ſȲƍì¨ȶʝ
c(
b(
a(
ř@Z(
ř@_(
`(
_(
Z(
[(
Z(
_(
`(
a(
b(
c(
d(
e(
^(
Z[(
ǟ
((Z[((((((_[((((((`[((((((a[(((((((b[(((((c[(((((d[((((((e[((((((((^[((((((Z[[((\
ʇɣɒʉʅʌʆɪɭ
g%11/#0(",%-'M'
•! ƍì¨ʏłĪʐȰŅĹBç
ƍì¨ʏłĪʐȰŅĹBç
ȉǑB",C#C/-/&3(#0$(1,*/#-($'*/1/,0
1,*/#-($'*/1/,0
•! łĪ=(Zhc(IZd\J(
((((B",C#C/-/&3=(Zd(\(
•! ŅĹBçʛǑ`ºȯȘɋʛʏƘȼȨƿɊʐ[(
((((6,R(,.(B'"1,01(<+,(*#0(#**'B&(&+/1(E#?'(/1([(
((((I#**,"$/0E(&,(?3(1%"A'3J
Ǡ
Ǎưȵ¸ģǑF/-$(.'A'"(,.(*,-$(
((ȉȉȉȉȉȉȉȉȉȉȉȉȉȉȉȉȉȉȉȉȉȉȉȉȉȉȉȉȉȉȉȉȉȉ((I</&+,%&(#03(,&+'"(13?B&,?J
•! `eRb¨ȯƅģIɏǎɁȼȘȖʝ
ȉǑ)+,%-$(,0'(&#D'(#0(#0:B3"':*P
•! ɗʊɓɬʉɥȰBç
ǑǑǑGA/$'0*'(i(7'*/1/,0
GYFɏ›ɋƕƅ(
IGA/$'0*'(Y#1'$(F'$/*/0'(i(7'*/1/,0J(
(
g'.R(F%/"(!"#3@1(Y,,D((L2+'("'1,%"*'.%-(T#:'0&O
ǡ
ňˆŪȗđɂȮŲȒȯȣȖʝ
F#3(L1*/'0:1&1O(?#D'($'*/1/,0(.,"(,&+'"1P
•! ɵʌɦʉɭȲɉȍňˆĹȎȯȣȖʝ
Ǒ(((SC,A'(<+/*+(\(/1(/&(L1*/'0:;*OP
•! ʕʎȲɉʑʇɣɒʉʅʌʆɪɭȯɃʣʡȯȣȖʝ
Ǒ(((91(/&(5Q(/.(&+'(B",C#C/-/&3(,.(g%11/#0(g,%-'M'(/1(-'11(&+#0(Z\P
•! UµȳVĀƏǏȗȑȫȮɃʑƅģIǎɐȯɨɿȯȣȖʝ
ǑǑǑǑǑǑ91(/&(1*/'0:;*#--3(<",0E(&,(&#D'(#0(#0:B3"':*('A'0(/.(9(
+#A'(#0(/?B,"&#0&(&#1D(&+/1('A'0/0EP
•! ?ȰčʑBđȳ¹ſȲƍì¨ȗƭȓȵȶ
eĭȯȣȖʝ
Ǒ(((91(/&(L1*/'0:;*#--3(<",0EO(&,(?#D'(#($/K'"'0*'(/0(
'A#-%#:0E('A/$'0*'1f(C'&<''0(*/A/-(#0$(*"/?/0#-(*#1'P
Ǚǘ
ňˆȰBç
)*/'0*'(/0(),*/#-(U,0&'H&
ňˆĹȳ
łȨɋƍì
U,0*"'&'('A/$'0*'
j
ŅĹBç
),*/#-(
$'*/1/,0
ŅĹBç
ňˆĹŀƛ
),*/#-($'*/1/,0
)*/'0:;*('A/$'0*'
¹ſ¿ȵďĜȯ
,0(&+'(-'A'-(0''$'$(&,(&+'($'*/1/,0
ǙǙ
Ēªȯȵȍ×țƭȒȎ
23B/*#-(#0$(1,*/#--3(/?B,"&#0&((((
L?/1'('0(1*'0'Of(k#<(*,%"&
E¨pNjȗ8{ĹȳīɌɋűc
)31&'?#:*(B",C-'?1(#BB'#"(*-'#"-3(/0(*,%"&1
Ǚǚ
>,"(G0E-/1+()-/$'f()''(&+'(TS!G(Z
ňˆȳȶlG)f(65(ȯŔȔɋȼȡ
ʏ<ʐšƚȩțŔȔȮșȩȟȒʒȧȵÌBȶćȡȒȯȣȖʑćȡșȲȒɐȯȣȖʒ
–! ʏ=ʐȒɅʑćȡȒćȡșȲȒȰȒȓȖʑȬȿɊňˆȯȣȖɉʑȧɌȶćȡȒć
ȡșȲȒȰȒȓȵȶʑȱȓȒȓÂlȯćȡȒȖćȡșȲȒȖȰȒȓȵɏȕƐȡȡ
ȲțɌȷȒțȲȒȝȰȶʘôȳɃȕƐȡȡȨȰȕɊȯȑɊȿȡȮʒ
ȢɄʑćȡȒȖćȡșȲȒȖȶŔȔɉɌȲȒȰȒȓȕŔȔȯɈɍȡȒɐȯȣȖʒ
–! ǑǑǑȉƭȒȿȣʒ
ȢɄʑȱȪɉȯȣȖʒ
•!
–! ȯȣȖɉʑHÜøȗȲȒȰȕƐȡȗȯȘȲȒȰȒȓȝȰȯȣʒȣȲɎȪʑň
ˆȰȒȓȵȶʑȝɌȶHsʘôȳȕƐȡȡȨȝȰɏ·ĭƅȡȮȒȨȩȒȮȲ
ȒȰȒȓȝȰȯȑɊȿȡȮʑȬȿɊňˆȳ…°¿ȰȒȓɃȵȗȑɊȿȣʒȯʑȱ
ȓȒȓøȯćȡȒȖʑȱȓȒȓøȯćȡșȲȒȖȰȒȓȝȰɏƆɎȲȒȝȰ
ȳȶćłȲķƆȗȯȘȲȒʑȟȘȽȱŽBƸȖɉȑɊȿȡȨɈȓȳʑŇȗƺ
ƭȫȨȝȰɏķƆȡȨeʑ.ƍŤȳpɎɌɋɎțȯȣɈȴʒ
ȪɇȫȰʑȒȒȯȣȖʒŇȵơpʑūȒȮșȩȟȒȴʒɃȓ¨ʒŴvâ”ŢƼƝ
¤ȵȧȵÌBȶćȡȒȯȣȖʑƕɊȯȣȖʒȧɌȰɃʑHÜøȗ=ȖɉȲȒȰ
ćȡȒȖƕɊȯȑɋȖ=ȖɉȲȒȰȒȓʑȧȵȬȵȓȪȵȱɌȯȣȖʒ
ǙǛ
ƍm<Ĩʏ„=yŽʐ
)%??,01I5/&#(7/1&"/*&(U,%"&J(
Ǚǜ
ĒªIk#<(U,%"&J
ʗʒž0•p
ZR! •p
GH#?/0#:,0(/0(*+/'.(
U",11('H#?/0#:,0
_R(]’•p
Ykĭ
ʏ¬Ɲ€ʐ
T-#/0:K@1(-#<3'"
ňˆŪƍ
)*/'0:1&(IGHB'"&(</&0'11J(
żkĭ
ʏ¬Ɲ€ʐ
Ǚǝ
7'.'01'(-#<3'"
]’•pǑIU",11(GH#?/0#:,0J
ȉȍ]’•pʌʌȝȵʑ¬Ɲ€ȨɋŪȗƥȳȬț
ȮȕșȼȘ3ÍŭȵȓȪʑóɃnjȒŸȯʑóɃDİ
#*ȗǐșʑȧȡȮóɃ'¶uDžȲɃȵʋʋʋʋʋʋȧ
ɌȶʑȬȴȳʑóɃłŠȲľŠȵilĒȯȑɊʑ
‹ƒȳȿȟɋ%ƍȰȲɋȰƀ,ȟɌȮȘȨʒȎʌʌ
ɡɪɞɥ
ɕɖʅɼʉȍ]’•pȵÍŹȎʏʐȉûȉPƱƋ
m2+'(S"&(,.(U",11(GH#?/0#:,0mf(>"#0*/1(>$))-&"
ǙǞ
¬Ɲȵɢʌʅɬʉʅʌʅ
TS!G(_
2+'(!5k7G6(g8kG)(,.(S$A,*#*3(
ŷŪ=(ɜʌɥʋɗʊɑʉɥŷʓǐƴǂƋȉīæŅI_[[[ʐ(
]’•pȵɢʌʅɬʉʅʌʅ
–! ȏƓ–•pɏİȒɈȐIBRZZcJȉʋʋʋl'1f(6,ȯŔȔȟȥɋ(
•! ȏȍɃȡɃȎȰȖʑȍțɌȱɃȎȲȱȶ3Ʋ_ɊǁȘȲȟȒʒȐIBRZZeJ(
•! ȏȍȲȦʝȎ?>@,ABȰȖȍȱȵɈȓȳAȎ?=(9ABȰđȡȮ•ȴɋȲʒ
)+(!-30251+Cjkkkb: _=
a
+<$a(j
–! ȏĆȡȒɃȵȗÊȳ2ȫȨɉɅɂɈȐIBRZZbJ
–! ȏůĿĽ!ƩȐȵØŞIBRZZ_J
•! ȏȱȓȡȮȧȵĿĽȗĮȢȨȖƖìȟȥȮȶȒțȲȒȐIBRZZ`J
•! Z/L!K3JD@)?OQI>
Ǚǟ
Ɠ–•pʏčƌƉƁGʐ
k'#$/0E(n%'1:,0IU/A/-(T",*''$/0E1(g'E%-#:,01J(
ŒĸTøǑơpȶȊȯȘɋƿɊȊ(CĹȖȬ7ĹȳȡȲț
ɌȷȲɉȲȒȋ
o%'1:,01(?%1&(C'(#1($/1*"'&'(#0$(1B'*/;*(#1(B,11/C-'
ʖǑ°ŪȶȊąȳÛȜɋơpɏȡȮȶȲɉȲȒȋȨȩȡȊŒ
dȖɉŒ5dȿȯȳÛȜɋơpȳȬȒȮȶȊć°Ȳĭıȗȑ
ɋeȶȊȝȵƿɊȯȲȒȋ
>,--,</0E(n%'1:,0(?%1&(C'(B",+/C/&'$R(Y%&f(&+'(B",+/C/:,0(.,"(&+'(
#":*-'1(C'&<''0(_(#0$(c(?#3(C'('H'?B&'$(/0(*#1'(</&+(N%1:;*#:,0R
ZR(ƍɏ$ƧȡȊ[ȶuÁȟȥɋơp
ǑǑǑ(o%'1:,0(<+/*+(#C%1'(,"(*,0.%1'(#(</&0'11
_R(Ɠ–ơp
Ǒ(((k'#$/0E(n%'1:,0
`R((ʋʋʋʋʋʋʋʋʋʋʋʋȉȉȉȉȉ</=[<=[<0K'=ǙǠ
TS!G(`
¬Ɲȵɢʌʅɬʉʅʌʅ
)D/--=(4,<(&,(.#C"/*#&'P(
ȉȉȉȉȉȉȉȉȉȉȉȉȉȉȉȉȉȉȉȉȉȉê÷ƔĤȉBRe^(
ȉb:FAR>.51/34151
i
ȉȉ½ũɡʉɭʇʌʅȉȉȉȉ(j444
ȉȉ³ɉȳɏƆȫȮĆȡȒȖɏŀɊ
ȉȉȧɌȖɉ³ɉȳȧɌɏƆɎȥɈ
*)*) #,Z
(jWfFA]M
(i*)*) XO':I%"jVKE
P^+?*)*)&iH#[#Y&)
FA%cG)"j4446Bh+`#%
j7JD@g89edUS#'\T+L(Q
V+;N
(j
(((
Ǚǡ
;;%K21LTUSVW
TS!G((a
?<B*ȝɌȩțƒșȵÌBȗȲȟɌȮȒɋʆɸʆɪɞɥ~kɏÓȪ<ȡȮʑÝ džƐȵdžēȗ-©ȳ
²NJȑɋȖȵɈȓȲƜƚɏȣɋȝȰȶʑȑȲȨȵƆȓňˆʄɫʃɣʌȳȶeŰȡȮɋɐȯȣȖȋ
–! ?=B*ăšȟɐȗȕƐȡȳȲȫȨʑÌBȗȑɋȖɉƮ>ȯȶȲȒȰȒȓȧȵHÜȶʑăšȟ
ɐȶȧɌȶćȡȒȰƑƛȲȟȫȮɋɐȯȡɇȓȖȋ
ơpʑūȒȮșȩȟȒȴʒ
–! ȒɅʑHÜȗȤɌȮɋȰćȡșsŔȯȘȲȒȰȒȓȝȰȯȣȋȩȖɉʑHÜȗȤɌȮɋȰćȡș
ȕŔȔȯȘȿȥɐȋ
ơpȶʑȝȵʆɸʆɪɞɥ~kȰȒȓȵȶȨșȟɐȵÌBȗȲȟɌȮȒɋɎțȲɐȯȣțɌȱɃʑȧȓ
Ȓȓʆɸʆɪɞɥ~kɏÓȪ<ȡȮʑȝȵŽBȯȑȲȨȗÝ džƐȵdžēȗ-©ȳ²NJȗȑɋȖȵ
ɈȓȲƜƚɏȣɋȝȰȶʑȑȲȨȵƆȓňˆʄɫʃɣʌȳeŰȡȮɋɐȯȣȖȰȕ•ȴȡȮɋɐȯȣȋ
ɔɗɥȖɲʌȖȯšāȯȣȖɉȋ
–! ǑǑǑǑȒȔʑȧɌȶóAȳCôȳɃȕƐȡȡȿȡȨțɌȱɃʑpNjğȗʑȬȿɊHÜɏȋ
ȶȒȖʑȒȒȔȯŔȔɋơpȩȰ½ȓɐȯȣȗȋ
–! ȒȔȒȔʑŇȶňˆƍȰȡȮùȮɋɎțȯȣȖɉʑňˆƍȰȒȓȵȶʑćȡșȧȵŠɏ
ȔȲțɌȷȒțȲȒɎțȯȣȋȯʑȝȝȳȒɉȫȡɄɋèȗʑňˆȵ|ŃĹȲɴɪɞɟʃ
ɕʉɮȗȲȒɎțȯȣȖɉʑȯʑȧɌɏƆȯŔȔɉɌɋɈȓȲ9ȯȲȒȰȘȳŔȔȨȰȡ
ȨɉʑȧɌȶćȳňˆʄɫʃɣʌʑňˆŪȵ+ĭȳ]ȣɋŸĠȳȲɊȿȣȋȡȨȗȫȮʑȧȵ
ɈȓȲŔȔȶȯȘȲȒɎțȯȣȋȲȦȝȓȒȓȝȰɏƆɎȲțɌȷȒțȲȒȵȖȰȒȓȝȰɏ
ȕƐȡȡȲțɌȷȒțȲȒȰȒȓȝȰȶʑʘôȳɃȪɄɐȰăšȟɐȵHȯȕƐȡȡȨȶȤȵ
ȝȰȯȣȋ
ȯȶʑąȵơpȳȒȘȿȣȋǑ
ǚǘ
ƍm<Ĩʏ„=yŽʐ
)%??,01I5/&#(7/1&"/*&(U,%"&J(
ǚǙ
ƍm<Ĩʏ„=yŽʐ
)%??,01I5/&#(7/1&"/*&(U,%"&J(
ǚǚ
JŵƔ(How to get desired result)
ƳeȵŲȒňˆĹšƚȵɊèʛ
ƳeȵŲȒňˆĹšƚ
Ɋè
4,<(&,(.#C"/*#&'($'1/"'$("'1%-&P(
ȍɢʌʅɬʉʅʌʅȎȵſƙʛǑL!,-$'0(g%-'O($'?#0$1
ʕʐȉƓ–•pɏİȒɋǑǑ81'(L-'#$/0E(n%'1:,0OR
ʖʐȉl'1f(6,(ȯŔȔȟȥɋʏƍȳƖìȟȥȲȒʐ(
((((((k'&(</&0'11(#01<'"f(Ll'1O(,"(L6,OR(7,0@&(#1D(+/?h+'"(L<+3OR(
ćĻŪȵňˆŪȗƓ–•pȳŝĻȳŔȔɋʏģKˆţʐ((
(9.(#(0#WA'(1*/'0:1&(#01<'"1(&,((-'#$/0E(n%'1:,01(p(
(I2+'"?,$30#?/*1(A'"1/,0J
ǚǛ
JŵƔʏģKˆʐ
TS!G(b
S0('H#?B-'(,.(.#C"/*#:,0=(&+'"?,$30#?/*1(*#1'(
•! ƍȶʑģKˆɏȞ“ƹȳȟɌȮȒȿȣȴʝ
–! ȶȒǒǪǦǨǓʒ
•! ȧȝȯȕȒȡȿȣʒȍċģȎȰȶʑę¨ɏʕ¨ëȟȥɋȵȳ¹ſȲģƵ
ȰȒȓĭƅȯɈɍȡȒȯȣȴʝ
–! ȶȒǒǪǦǨǓʒ
•! ǙʄɪɭʅȵŋɏÓȬƲ˜ɏʑʖʔ¨Ȗɉʗʔ¨ȳðɂɋȵȳ¹ſȲģ
ƵȶȒșɉȯȣȖʝ –! ʏƇŖɏȡȨµʐȂȂɜʇɚʇʄʌȯȣʒ
•! »ʑŇȨȪȵȰȝɍȯʑCȵ“ƹŽȳ"ƈȡȮʑōĎȗĝɌȲȒɈȓȳ
œ„ɷɥɭʉɏȫȮʕʄɪɭʅȵōĎɏ2ɌȮʑŠǏɏȡȮƟȫȨɐȯ
ȣʒȣɋȰʑʖʔ¨Ȗɉʗʔ¨ȳðɂɋȵȳ¹ſȲģƵȶʑȈȈɜʇɚʇ
ʄʌȳȲȫȨȧȓȯȣʒȝȝȳƷ‰òɃxɊȿȣʒȝɌȶʑĭƚĹȲƇŖȰ
ɃŰȡȮȒɋȧȓȯȣʒȟȮʑ1ȽȱʑƍȗȂȂɜʇɚʇʄʌȰȕȫ
ȡɄȒȿȡȨȴʒ
–! ȶȒǒǪǦǨǓʒ
•!
•pɏşɎɊȿȣʒ
ǚǜ
JŵƔʏəɩʐ
TS!G(c
SM,"0'3(</01(/0($'C#&'X((
•! µêʛ
ŽBƸʒȝȵɈȓȳʑƍȵƍƆȳȶʑĥĭˆȵ|Ń
ȳȟȔĿĽȣɋ9ȗjȿɌȮȕɊʑƍƆȳȶʑȲɐ
ɉňˆĹ&Æ¿ȗȲȒȝȰȗƍìȟɌȿȡȨʒ
ȍŠȯȲȒɏŠȵɈȓȳȝȡɉȔȮƆȓȝȰȎ
–! Õƫʏ¥Ʀųʐ
–! #!.KYZHK48:9
ǚǝ
ÕƫȶȲȦbŭʝ
TS!G(d
q+3(.#C"/*#:,0(#A#/-#C-'P(
•! ňˆȵø"‡¿ȵġƂȉǒǻǭdzǯǷǼdzǰdzǭǑǴǷǸǿǵǯǮDZǯǢǑǭǸǷǮdzǼdzǸǷǫǵǓ
•! ŠǏøȯċģȶĴȲɋ
–! ‰ŋģƵǑǥǾ
ŋ‰
ŋ‰
–! ‰wģƵǑǥǹ
ȉwK‰
•! •p±­ʏE¨ʐȵpNj
–! ƍȳȶʑůıȳķƆȣɋĂDȗ3șȲȒ
•! ĺȵHȯȍÕƫȎȗŸɎɌȮɃʍ
–! •pŪȵķpȳŔȔɋȵɀ
•! •pŪȶʑůıȳ•pɏËȪ>Ɍɋʒ
ǚǞ
ňˆȳȕțɋćŸĠ
)*/'0:;*(?/1*,0$%*&(
TS!G(e
WśȲƺƭȒʑÊÏȘȳɈɋƺƭȒȳLȔʑŒȵƺƭȒ
ȗȑɋʒȧɌȶɬʌɧɅšüɏPÊȳȬșɊȑȜɋŸĠʏÕ
ƫʐʑɬʌɧɅšüɏàȡȨɊȒȬɎȫȮ~kȣɋŸĠʏ.
ƫʐʑ®İɏćȡșȥȤȳȽȖȵňˆŪȵɒɔɬɒɅƆŶɏ
ȓŸĠʏȸɇȓŏʐȯȑɋʒȝɌɉȣȼȮȶʑňˆȗ|Ńɏ
ťș#*Ƅɏþ§ȖɉɆȟȺɋɃȵȯȑɋʒȝɌɉȵćŸ
Ġȶʑňˆȵķ™ɏƽȣɋȷȖɊȯȲșʑňˆȰȒȓqɀ
ȗ"ÒȣɋȣȼȮȵ#*ɏȕȰȡɂɋɃȵȯȑɋʒȝȵɈȓ
ȲŸĠɏŸȫȨɃȵȶƗȯȑɌʑňˆŪȰȡȮȵĮnȗXȺ
ȿɌɋȩɍȓʒAɂȶȨȒȡȨȝȰȗȲȒȰ½ȔɋćŸĠ
ȯɃʑóµȳȶZȡȒŦȗșȩȟɌɋȵȩʒ
ȉňˆŪɏɂȠȣhȨȪȻȉǹǖǝǟǑʏɒɿʄɚňˆɒɚɬɽʌţʓĐ9Ƌʐ
ǚǟ
ňˆȳȕțɋćŸĠ
)*/'0:;*(?/1*,0$%*&(
TS!G(e
(ȉȝɌȿȯȵőȯƜƚȡȮȘȨ+ĭƭ]ǕǕ®İɏćȡșŸɎ
ȲȒȝȰʑÊÏȘȳɈɋƺƭȒǕǕȶȿȩʑňˆŪȵɡɽʁɰ
ɫɓʌ9ƲȵpNjȯȑɋʒƪ¡ʑȝɌɉȵƭ]ȶɷɒʋʆ
ɶʁʌȳɈɋf/ȵ‘ýʑŁŌÉ°—ȵÚťʑŁŌīȯ
ȵɻɥɭÔgɅƎ#ɣɥɫɾɏƪȡȮʑ(ȌȵpNjȰȡȮ;
ĭȟɌɋʒȡȖȡʑćŸĠɏħȡȨeȶʑňˆŪDŽt9
ƲȳȰȱȿɉȤʑlj¡ȳėFȲšüɏÑșȝȰȗȑɋʒȧɌȶ
ňˆŪDŽt‚ȵƺȳ‚ɏ\ȾȣȖɃȡɌȤʏÕƫȟɌ
ȨšüȗSˆĹ;ťȳȬȲȗɋɈȓȲeʐʑ4ƶɏĖƠȡ
ȨɊʑňˆɏÌBĹȳƀȮȒɋȹȰȵĔĺɏȸȘȬțɋȝ
ȰȳȲɋȩɍȓʒȧȵšüʑvȵĄƻʑƜʑɿɬɓɒʑŽB
ÉȲȱɃžȘƨɁíȲɉȠɋÄȳȲɋȖɃȡɌȲȒʒ
<(,RNCEFGM=ǑǑǹǖǝǟǕǝǠǑǑʏɒɿʄɚňˆɒɚɬɽʌţʓĐ9Ƌʐ
ǚǠ
ijĹȳƑŀȟɌȮȒɋpNj
)*/'0*'(/0(*,0A'0:,0#-(#$A'"1#"/#-(131&'?=(
!-,C#--3("'*,E0/r'$(B",C-'?
•! 4,0R(V%1:*'(F*U-'--#0(Ȇ(U,0*%""'0&(GA/$'0*'ȉȉȉ
ɼɞʆʃʉBȉɡʉɚʆʉɭɗʊɓɬʉɥȯƅđ
•! 6l(2/?'1(LSFGg9US6(GjUGT2956f(90(8R)Rf(
GHB'"&(q/&0'11'1(S"'(T#":1#0O(IY3(S7SF(k9T2SQJ(
•! g#.#'-(G0*/0#1($'(F%0#E,""/(
Ig7)2f(>"#0*'J(
((((ɸʃʉɥʋĒȰňˆÍŹɱɪɭʈʌɞ
ȉǑŻf(ɯʉɭ„ˆĒˆƲãÖ(
ǚǡ
ňˆĹ‰¿ȗ¯Ȓe=ȉŰnĹ
90(*#1'(1*/'0:;*(/0*'":&%$'(/1(*"%*/#-
•! ¯ȒłŠ¿ʛöùĚȲȱ
Ǒ(((80*'"&#/0&3=(>%&%"'(B"'$/*:,0f('1BR(0'<(&'*+0,-,E3
•! ĉȱȗȍÙĚȎʛłȨɋƍÒȗȲȒȖɉ
ǑǑǑ(S1(<'(+#A'f(-,E/*#--3f(0,(;"?('A/$'0*'(
•! ȍƕ–ȎȖȱȓȖʑ=ȖɊ¶ȲȒ(
ȉǑǑ(k#<3'"1f(/0(E'0'"#-f((*#00,&($/1*"/?/0#&'(<+'&+'"(/&(/1(L?/1-'#$/0EO((
•! ɏŀɊȨȒȖʑǼȡȮȒɋȖʏƒŨ¿ʐ
ȉǑS0H/'&3(#C,%&(<+#&P((IS?C/E%/&3J(
Ǜǘ
ĥơȵÅ¿ñLj²NJɏɂȚȫȮʏƓ–•pʐZ(
U+",0/*('HB,1%"'(&,(1%C1&#0*'(#0$(/&1('K'*&(I-'#$/0E(n%'1:,0J(Z(
•! ȝȵĥơɏsȳÞ_ȡȮĈȣɋƵȶʑÈ£IJ†ȵeʑǝǘǘɼɔɞʇ
ɟʃɾȯćȡȒȯȣȖʝ
ȉȉǧǻǑdzǼǑǼǺǽǯǑǼDzǫǼǑǼDzǯǑǰǫǼǫǵǑǮǸǻǯǑǰǸǺǑǫǮǽǵǼǯǑǶǫǵǯǑdzǻǑǝǘǘǑǶdzǭǺǸǑDZǺǫǶǶǯǻǣ
–! ȶȒǒǪǦǨǓʒ
•! ȝȵĥơȵ²NJȰȡȮʑīxňˆĹȳZȳƍìȟɌȮȒɋ²NJȶʑȝ
ɌȩțȯȣȴʝǑ
ǑǑǑǑǑǧǼǑdzǻǑǼDzǯǑǸǷǵȁǑǯǻǼǫǬǵdzǻDzǯǮǑǯǰǰǯǭǼǑǸǰǑǼDzǯǑǻǽǬǻǼǫǷǭǯǔǑdzǻǷȃǼǑdzǼǣ
–! ȶȒǒǪǦǨǓʒ
•! sȵÞ_Ƶȶʑê¢zǘǖǙɼɔɞʇɟʃɾȯʑȧɌɏʕ£ƺÞ_ȡȨȰ
ȒȓȝȰȯȣȖɉʑǘǖǙȀǛǞǝʑȣȲɎȪǜǘɼɔɞʇɟʃɾȯȣȴʝ
ǑǑǑǑǑǤǻǑDzǯǑDzǫǻǑǼǫǴǯǷǑǫǬǸǽǼǑǘǖǙǑǶdzǭǺǸDZǺǫǶǑǮǫdzǵȁǑǰǸǺǑǸǷǯǑȁǯǫǺǔǑǼDzǯǑ
ǼǸǼǫǵǑǫǶǸǽǷǼǑǸǰǑdzǷǼǫǴǯǑdzǻǑǵǯǻǻǑǼDzǫǷǑǜǘǑDZǺǫǶǻǔǑdzǻǷȃǼǑdzǼǣ
–! ȶȒǒǪǦǨǓǖ
ǛǙ
ĥơȵÅ¿ñLj²NJɏɂȚȫȮʏƓ–•pʐ_(
U+",0/*('HB,1%"'(&,(1%C1&#0*'(#0$(/&1('K'*&(I-'#$/0E(n%'1:,0J(_(
•! ǜǘɼɔɞʇɟʃɾȶʑňˆĹȳƍìȟɌȮȒɋŰĈƵǝǘǘɼɔɞʇɟʃɾ
ȵǙǘ=ȵʕȯȣȴʝ
ȉȉǧǼǑdzǻǑǵǯǻǻǑǼDzǫǷǑǙǗǙǘǑǼDzǫǷǑǼDzǫǼǑǸǰǑǯǻǼǫǬǵdzǻDzǯǮǑǰǫǼǫǵǑǮǸǻǯǔǑǝǘǘǑ
ǶdzǭǺǸǕDZǺǫǶǻǔǑdzǻǷȃǼǑdzǼǣ
–! ȶȒʏʦʟʥʐ
•! ȰȒȓȝȰȶʑȧȵŊ¨ȵ¸ƵñLjȯȶ²NJȗīɌɋbŭ¿
ȳȬȒȮʑňˆĹȳłȨɋƍÒȶȲȒȵȯȣȴʒ
ǑǑǑǑǩDzǯǷǔǑǼDzǯǺǯǑdzǻǑǷǸǑǰdzǺǶǑǯǾdzǮǯǷǭǯǑǼDzǫǼǑǻǽǭDzǑǫǑǵǸǿǕǵǯǾǯǵǑ
ǯȀǹǸǻǽǺǯǑǭǫǷǑǭǫǽǻǯǑDzǯǫǵǼDzǑǯǰǰǯǭǼǔǑdzǻǷȃǼǑdzǼǣ
–! ȶȒʏʦʟʥʐ
•! •pɏşɎɊȿȣʒ
ǑǑǑǑ*D@0/*$"5/*(1%*$E&-0"&'("F
Ǜǚ
ňˆĹȳȶZʋʋʋ
)*/'0:;*#--3("/E,%"
)*/'0:;*#--3("/E,%"
•! ȯɃʑȖȕȖȡȒ
Ǒ(((Y%&f(1,?'&+/0E(<",0EpR(
(
(
ȉȉȉȉ1,?'&+/0E(-/D'
ǛǛ
ȗpNjȖ
S?C/E%/&3(,.(1*/'0:;*('A/$'0*'
S?C/E%/&3(,.(1*/'0:;*('A/$'0*'
•! ’ƞȵȍƯÐȎȉU+,/*'(,.(,CN'*&
–! ¾¿²NJʑÅ¿²NJǑS*%&'(,"(*+",0/*(
–! ŰĈƵʑȵÅ¿ĵÀȻȵ²NJIo5kJ(
((((G0$B,/0&=($'#&+(,"(o5kP(
ȉȉ"'.R(ɣɪɞɳɕɥĶ)ŧʏ1/*D(C%/-$/0E(130$",?'ʐ(
Ǜǜ
ňˆĹƍÒȵƒŨ¿
S?C/E%/&3(,.(1*/'0:;*('A/$'0*'
S?C/E%/&3(,.(1*/'0:;*('A/$'0*'
•! ňˆĹƜƚʛ’ƞȍƯÐȎµȳbŭ
Ǒ((()*/'0:;*($/1*%11/,0=(#A#/-#C-'(,0-3(#s'"(&+'(*+,/*'
•! Ɯƚ’ƞȗrɀeɎȲȒȉȆȉČʑ&
Ǒ(((5CN'*&(,.(1*/'0:;*($/1*%11/,0f(<'--(1+#"'$P
–! ’ƞȵƯÐʛňˆȯȶđȿɉȲȒ
Ǒ((U+,/*'(,.(,CN'*&=(?#M'"(<+/*+(/1(,%&(,.(1*/'0*'
–! ňˆȵ’ƞȯɃʑłŠ¿ȗǐȒȝȰɃ
Ǒ((F#3(+#A'(%0*'"&#/0&3('A'0(#s'"(&+'(*+,/*'
Ǜǝ
«ƊĹƜƚʋE¨Ȼ
U,0$/:,0(.,"(*,01&"%*:A'($/1*%11/,0(/0()*/'0*'
•! īĨʛ‰¿ʏňˆȯđȿɉȲȒȝȰʐȰňˆĹŀƀɏĘfʑ
ȉȉȉȉȉňˆůȵƜƚɏɃƽ
ȉȉT"'1'0&=(k#<3'"1(#M#*D(L/0*'":&%$'O("'1%-:0E(/0(."%/&-'11($'C#&'(
ȉ&"-*K21A+B
P
7!!3+)$%45!-.+!/%(6'((%&4!&7!(&6%)8!4&,9!
!
•! ȍ‰¿ȎʏƒŨ¿ʑłŠ¿'&*RʐȵćȡȒåĭ
–! bŭȳȣɋE¨ƊƇ
L)*/'0:;*(/0*'":&%$'O(?%1&(C'("'*,E0/r'$(#0$(
*#--'$(/0&,(#**,%0&(131&'?#:*#--3(/0(GHB'"&(GA/$'0*'
ǛǞ
E¨ƊƇȵpNj
T",C-'?(,.(/01:&%:,0#-($'1/E0
T",C-'?(,.(/01:&%:,0#-($'1/E0
•! (ȌȵĒ´ŽʑňˆŪȵÂƛȯȶȱȓȳɃȲ
ɉȲȒ
Ǒ(((90$/A/$%#-(-#<3'"(#0$(1*/'0:1&(&+'?1'-A'1(
,A'"*,?'(&+'(/01:&%:,0#-(B",C-'?
–! ŸOƁŗȵźŎ
Ǒ((U,0t/*&(,.(*,$'(,.(*,0$%*&(C'&<''0(&+'(&<,(;'-$1
Ǜǟ
īE¨: ʖȬȵȍŸOƁŗȎȵźŎ
Conflict of “code of conduct” under current system
•!
•!
Lawyers •!
GHB'"&(</&0'11(
(I'HR()*/'0:1&J(
U,$'(,.(*,0$%*&(#1(-#<3'"1(#1D1(&+'?(&,(L</0O(&+'(
*#1'(
2+%1f(&+'3(1+,%-$(#M#*D(1*/'0:;*(/0*'":&%$'(
/0+'"'0&(/0(1*/'0*'(
2+'3(#1D(</&0'11'1(&,(E/A'('A/$'0*'(#1(/.(&+'(
1*/'0:;*(D0,<-'$E'(/1(;"?('0,%E+f('A'0(/.(/&(0,&R(
•!Code of conduct as scientist asks us to tell the truth.
•!Thus, we can seldom give evidence without uncertainty,
because scientific evidence are a posteriori and depends
on experimental condition.
•!Dr. Leonard Welsh said, “After you come out of court,
you feel like you need a shower. They’re asking you to be
certain of things you can’t be certain of”
(New York Times, 2008)
ǛǠ
ĒªȗňˆɏİȒɋĭı
T+/-,1,B+3=(<+3(*,%"&(%1'1(1*/'0:;*('A/$'0*'(
5:'4%$+,()8%-;<!=!$:>'#8%6!?4&@8+/5+<
•! ’ŐȣɋŜ°ŪƺȯɃ6õȯȘɋ46ŀ
)*/'0*'=((
T%C-/*(D0,<-'$E'((
&+#&(*#0(C'((
ňˆĹŠǑ'A/$'0*'
îƬ¿Ǒ%0/A'"1#-/&3
1+#"'$(C'&<''0((
#*BçȖɉȵĩŐ¿
ʏ<+/*+(1+,%-$(C'(/0$'B'0$'0&(
,.(A#-%'(N%$E?'0&ʐ
B#":'1(/0(*,0t/*&
ŅƁŗ
),*/#-(0,"?
#*Bç
u#-%'(N%$E?'0&
įěȰȰɃȳƢ†ɏĕȣʒ
; \;įěȰȰɃȳƢ†ɏĕȣ
ȉA&4B-!-.,&@!-.+!#)#;!&'-!@%-.!-.+!#)-.!@)-+,1
Ǜǡ
ňˆĹ‰¿ɏƤȿȔȨȄ:āŘȅȻ
2,<#"$(L"'*,01&"%*:,0O(</&+(*,01/$'"#:,0(,.(L/0*'":&%$'O
•! ňˆŪȻȵÎȜI)*/'0:1&1@($'*/1/,0(,0-3JȉȂ
–! ŅĹæŮȰåeI#1(,s'0(?/1?#&*+'$(</&+(1,*/#-(*,0&'H&J
•! ġʼn¦ȲáßʏƓ–•pœʐȉȂ
((((((Y#"C#"/*("'*,01&"%*:,0(#1(#M#*D(%1/0E(-'#$/0E(n%'1:,0((
–! ňˆĹeĭ¿ʑĦȳ‰¿Ȱåe
Ǒ(((#1(?/1?#&*+'$(</&+(1*/'0:;*(D0,<-'$E'f('1BR(/0*'":&%$'(
vvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvv
•! ŅĹæŮȰňˆĹeĭ¿ʑ6‡ȵȨɂȵE¨ƊƇ=((
ɡʉɚʆʉɭʋɗʊɓɬʉɥȵńo
ȉǑ4,<(&,($'1/E0(&+'(131&'?(<+/*+(?#D'(%1'(,.(1*/'0:;*(D0,<-'$E'(
.%--3(/0(1,*/#-(*,0&'H&P((g'.R(U,0*%""'0&(GA/$'0*'(
ǜǘ
ɣʉɻɤɕɾʑêȵɸɘʌɚɥ
>,"(1/?B-/*/&3f(L1*/'0*'O(+'"'(/1(#1=
•! Ǝ#ȣɋɃȵȰȡȮȵňˆ
–! )*/'0*'(#1(#(&,,-(.,"(#11'11?'0&(
•! °ŪȯȶȲșʑŒŪ
–! 6,&(*'0&"#-(B#"&3f(C%&(&+/"$(B#"&3(
•! µĹȲpNjȯȶȲșʑȝɌȖɉɏpȓpNj
–! 6,&("'&",1B'*:A'f(C%&(B",1B'*:A'(/11%'1
•! ĒªʛƌƉ°ŪȯȲȒňˆŪȍƍȎ
–! g,-'(,.('HB'"&(</&0'11(,"('HB'"&(#$A/*'(
ǜǙ
ɵɱʅɬɓɥɚɪɣʂʉ
T#0'-(7/1*%11/,0
•! ơpņɏs^ʏ1%C?/11/,0(,.(n%'1:,0#/"'J(Za=ab
•! DŽƇI1%??#"/r/0E(&+'(n%1:,00#/"'J(
vvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvv
•! (CsŔI/0$/A/$%#-(oiSJ
•! ɵɱʄɥɭȵƜƚI#?,0E(B#0'-/1&1J
•! ɸʇɒȖɉȵpNjƅđȻȵÜÿI*,0&"/C%:,0(.",?(t,,"J
•! ȿȰɂI1%??#"3J
vvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvv(
•! ɒɸɧʌʋɚɸɖIU#.w(N%"/$/n%'J(
ǜǚ